Debunk-liners

I believe that if there's a chance that it could have been caused by something else, it certainly wasn't fire and debris damage.

Why don't you try to make 'reasonable' arguments Par, instead of being preoccupied by P, Q, and this or that fallacy?

It certainly wasn't fire and debris? Please explain how this could not have been the cause. And what are your credentials and experience in engineering and/or demolition?
 
Actually maccy provided this list of proofs against a CD theory in an earlier post:

1. why there were no sounds of explosions;
2. why there is no seismic data to indicate explosions;
3. why the penthouses collapsed before the rest of the building;
4. how the building was rigged without anybody noticing;
5. how the conspirators knew it would be hit by debris and set on fire;
6. how the explosive survived several hours of fire;
7. why the building needed to be demolished at all;
8. why so many members of the FDNY insist that building was going to fall due to the fires; and
9. why the conspirators didn't wait until it was dark before demolishing the building.
Just to add:
Why did no one see the unmistakable signs of explosive cut steel. I'm in construction and have witnessed this and it's unmistakable and obvious.
 
No, I have not "commited the affirming the consequent fallacy" as you put it.

How about :
all known P are Q
therefor P is probably Q

IOW, all known collapses that look like the WTC7 collapse are CDs, therefor WTC7 was probably a CD, OK?

No, that is not okay.

What you are saying is, "All Ps that I personally know of look to me like Qs, therefore this P is probably a Q."

That is so wrong on so many levels, it isn't even funny.
 
theyve been working on WTC7 less than 2 years, they started working on it after the final report for WTC1+2 was published

Yes I know that, but if it was obviously caused by fire and debris damage, they wouldn't need two years to come up with something that can pass simple scrutiny.
 
No, that is not okay.

What you are saying is, "All Ps that I personally know of look to me like Qs, therefore this P is probably a Q."

That is so wrong on so many levels, it isn't even funny.

No it's not wrong.

All examples of 'P' that any reasonable person knows of, just happen to be 'Q'

Therefor P is probably Q

OK?
 
Rubbish. As for the WTC7, there's no credible explanation for the collapse mechanism , except CD. If you know of one, write to NIST, because they don't know of one that has any more than a 'low probabitity'
Show me where NIST said this.
FEMA said that.

Oh, so it was FEMA and not NIST – just as you said all along.

NIST has obviously not yet been able to come up with an answer, at least not one that will pass the simplest examination.

Why don’t you explain what NIST get wrong.
 
Last edited:
Yes I know that, but if it was obviously caused by fire and debris damage, they wouldn't need two years to come up with something that can pass simple scrutiny.
Either that or they're doing their job and trying to revise building codes to prevent similar collapses. For that they need to know the exact progression. A little more difficult than disproving silly CT theories.
 
Brown, obviously :D

If every dog I'd ever seen was brown, the probability of your dog being brown is very high...
Assuming I've seen a lot of dogs, and also everyone I know has never seen any dog other than a brown dog, your dog is very probably brown, OK

So nice when they debunk themselves.

Ergo, you've seen a lot of massive buildings collapse - all by CD - and thus the probability of this one being CD is very high, correct?

Just how many dogs have you seen? And how many buildings of this size have you seen collapse?

The problem with troofers and the CD theory is that you're looking at video of the RESULT of the CD, and ignoring the CD itself. Show me the footage of WTC 7 (or 1 or 2) collapsing and all the horrendously loud explosions. Show me the seismograph data. What's on those videos is a building falling. You haven't seen a building fall that wasn't CD (because when a building falls there are generally not a lot of cameras around - it happens kind of unexpected like in most cases, e.g. Pakistan, e.g. South Korea).

BTW if every dog you've ever seen is brown, the natural conclusion to any "thinking person" (troofers fave terminology) is that you haven't seen many dogs or that you have blinded yourself to reality because we've all seen many many dogs of many different colors.
 
No it's not wrong.

All examples of 'P' that any reasonable person knows of, just happen to be 'Q'

Therefor P is probably Q

OK?

Terry, Terry, Terry.

I guess you need it explained to you directly.

All buildings of this design collapse in a manner that resembles cds. There is no other way for them to collapse. Please let me know what part of that you do not understand so I can clarify it.
 
How about :
all known P are Q
therefor P is probably Q

IOW, all known collapses that look like the WTC7 collapse are CDs, therefor WTC7 was probably a CD, OK?

No, that doesn’t work either. It doesn’t make even a lick of sense. We do not have an example of a similar kind of building collapsing due to widespread fires and severe debris damage to compare it to. You cannot, for instance, point to a red and spherical object and say “That is a red ball and not an X” before knowing whether or not X’s are red and spherical.

I believe that if there's a chance that it could have been caused by something else, it certainly wasn't fire and debris damage.

Argument from incredulity fallacy.

Why don't you try to make 'reasonable' arguments Par, instead of being preoccupied by P, Q, and this or that fallacy?

So, you want me to make “reasonable” arguments – something that includes ignoring your straightforward errors of logic. Regardless, as I’ve already pointed out, the burden of proof is on you.
 
There is no other way for such a building to fall.

Please post a video of a similarly constructed building that fell in a manner that did not look like a cd, or at the very least, please describe how, in your expert opinion, it should have looked as it fell.

Or is it easier to just call us boneheads and get yourself banned?

It fell symetrically, i.e. no separating or shearing vertically - you know like when a building falls due to some non-CD structural failure, you'll see the facade break unevenly. This WTC7 collapse was very symetric.
It means that all the supports failed ~ simultaneously
...
 
It fell symetrically, i.e. no separating or shearing vertically - you know like when a building falls due to some non-CD structural failure, you'll see the facade break unevenly. This WTC7 collapse was very symetric.
It means that all the supports failed ~ simultaneously
...


Nope.
 
It fell symetrically, i.e. no separating or shearing vertically - you know like when a building falls due to some non-CD structural failure, you'll see the facade break unevenly. This WTC7 collapse was very symetric.
It means that all the supports failed ~ simultaneously
...
Do you know what "curtain wall" construction is? By your statement I believe you don't.
 
It certainly wasn't fire and debris? Please explain how this could not have been the cause. And what are your credentials and experience in engineering and/or demolition?

If it was fire/debris damage, common sense tells you the fire and damage would not weaken all supports the full length and breadth of the building.
It would be localised to a smaller area.
The idea that the fire managed to weaken the entire support structure to the same degree, simultaneously doesn't make sense.
 
If it was fire/debris damage, common sense tells you the fire and damage would not weaken all supports the full length and breadth of the building.
It would be localised to a smaller area.
The idea that the fire managed to weaken the entire support structure to the same degree, simultaneously doesn't make sense.

Argument from incredulity fallacy. Straw man fallacy.

Evidence?
 
If it was fire/debris damage, common sense tells you the fire and damage would not weaken all supports the full length and breadth of the building.
It would be localised to a smaller area.
The idea that the fire managed to weaken the entire support structure to the same degree, simultaneously doesn't make sense.
You don't understand how buildings distribute and transfer loads do you?
 
No, that doesn’t work either. It doesn’t make even a lick of sense. We do not have an example of a similar kind of building collapsing due to widespread fires and severe debris damage to compare it to. You cannot, for instance, point to a red and spherical object and say “That is a red ball and not an X” before knowing whether or not X’s are red and spherical.

You're not making sense.





So, you want me to make “reasonable” arguments – something that includes ignoring your straightforward errors of logic.

I've not made any "errors of logic". Show me one if you can.
( make it simple)
 
Everybody seems to be missing the extraodinary question at the pentagon. How does an FDR from flight 77 found in the pentagon serve as proof flight 77 didn't hit the pentagon? This question is really for CIT and their sister group Guides Who Lie™.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom