Debunk-liners

You didn't answer the question


You didn't answer the question.


Well, if you maintain that WTC7 was brought down with CD, then the above statement means it would have to have been set up on the fly that very same morning without a single person witnessing anything suspicious. Please explain how that is even remotely possible.


Fixed


So wait, this imaginary agency you just made up... they counter misinformation? That's kind of confusing. In the future, please name your imaginary government agencies something a little more straight forward. KTHX!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Counter_Misinformation_Team
 
<<Originally Posted by ref:
- How did the NWO know beforehand, that the north tower would collapse into WTC7, so the debris could be blamed for the damage and starting fires?>>


Maybe WTC7 was part of the plan, i.e. to destroy all the buildings, so it was 'rigged' beforehand like 1 & 2.

The third plane was supposed to hit #7 but didn't make it.

Things don't always go as planned. :)
so the plane didnt make it, they decide to blow it up anyway, instead of, oh i dont know, cordoning off the area and removing the demo charges

i mean, if they could get them in there while people were in and out of th ebuilding every day certainly they could get them back out, no?
 
I did ask you why they couldn't report a CD and offered two silly suggestions. You chose to mention one of them in your reply, but you still haven't said why NIST couldn't report CD if that was what the evidence suggested.

I mentioned Larry S. because he's a player in some "truthers" theories.

As to why NIST couldn't report CD, let's just say it would be quite a 'bombshell' to say the least, so I assume there would be some pressure brought to bear, although I don't believe it would even get to that stage...
 
No questions.

I think I can stand by anything I've written here - I don't think I have to read it back.

I am not surprised you didn't understand what I wrote. I'm asking you to back up what you have written with evidence.


It might be you are reading something else into what I actually said.
No, I noticed right off that you provided no evidence for your assertions but made reference to your "common sense" as apparently the sole thing you need.

If you disagree with anything, just point it out.
If I'm wrong, I'll accept that
I want your evidence for your claims. Simple, no?


"It looks like a CD. It does not look like a building falling down without CD. It you can come up with evidence showing a "building falling down" which looks like that but without CD, you will have a new convert."
Where is your evidence that CD brought down WTC7?


"As for the WTC7, there's no credible explanation for the collapse mechanism , except CD."
Says who? Where is your evidence?

"IOW, all known collapses that look like the WTC7 collapse are CDs, therefor WTC7 was probably a CD, OK?"
Says who? Where is your evidence?


"I believe that if there's a chance that it could have been caused by something else, it certainly wasn't fire and debris damage."
Who says it could not have been from the fire and damage? Who is your authority for your unsupported claim?

"NIST has obviously not yet been able to come up with an answer, at least not one that will pass the simplest examination."
It hasn't completed the report but you haven't bothered to refute its working hypothesis much less support any claim that it has not passed the simplest examination. Where is your evidence for your claim?

"I don't believe anyone could prove "it couldn't possibly have been a CD" , as you put it."
Then you would agree that no one could prove that it was a CD. Your logic just bit you on the derriere.


"If every dog I'd ever seen was brown, the probability of your dog being brown is very high... Assuming I've seen a lot of dogs, and also everyone I know has never seen any dog other than a brown dog, your dog is very probably brown, OK"
Do you also believe there are no black swans? In the Middle Ages people had only seen white swans. They, like you, believed there were no black swans. Therefore, there must have been no black swans, correct? Even though black swans have been seen since, you would continue to assert there are no black swans because YOU haven't seen one.


"...but if it was obviously caused by fire and debris damage, they wouldn't need two years to come up with something that can pass simple scrutiny."
Says who? Are you an expert in conducting investigations? Please explain.


"If it was fire/debris damage, common sense tells you the fire and damage would not weaken all supports the full length and breadth of the building. It would be localised to a smaller area. The idea that the fire managed to weaken the entire support structure to the same degree, simultaneously doesn't make sense."
Tell us in detail the source for your assertion and all evidence that fire and damage weakened "all supports the full length and breadth of the building" as well as your assertion that "the fire managed to weaken the entire support structure to the same degree, simultaneously."

Obviously, since you are not an expert in any of the relevant fields, you need to provide evidence and not just your imagined "common sense."

"It's very unlikely that the weakening was present all across the entire support structure at the same time."
Please supply evidence that weakening across the entire structure is a necessary condition for the collapse. What and who is the source for your assertion?



Now do you understand why we ask questions?
 
so the plane didnt make it, they decide to blow it up anyway, instead of, oh i dont know, cordoning off the area and removing the demo charges

i mean, if they could get them in there while people were in and out of th ebuilding every day certainly they could get them back out, no?

You'll have to ask 'them', how woud I know?

All I'm saying is it's one theory amongst others.
 
So I gather from this Quintiere feels the trusses failed because of insufficient fireproofing not from the plane crash but just insufficient to begin with as in when it was installed? And if it was sufficient you believe its possible it would have collapse anyway eventually? What about if it had the same asbestos fire-proofing of the lower floors what do you think then?

I don't disagree with Quintiere's statement, though it is very brief I am trying get his thoughts about behind it. It is very possible that the fire proofing could have been insufficient, but it is very possible that the plane removed the fire proofing whether it was sufficient or not. Either situation would have resulted in failure of the trusses.

It may have been the same fire-proofing as the lower floor, but it may have not have been sufficient throughout the whole building, but there was no fire in the lower floors so it wouldn't have mattered.
 
I mentioned Larry S. because he's a player in some "truthers" theories.

As to why NIST couldn't report CD, let's just say it would be quite a 'bombshell' to say the least, so I assume there would be some pressure brought to bear, although I don't believe it would even get to that stage...


So, as a scientist, you discover government complicity in the greatest act of domestic terrorism in the US, and you decide that because your boss does not want you to publish it, you'll just keep your mouth shut?

I think your opinions are based upon an extremely low opinion on the moral fiber of a group of researchers and people whom you've never met. Do you not find that logic a bit self serving?
 
so the plane didnt make it, they decide to blow it up anyway, instead of, oh i dont know, cordoning off the area and removing the demo charges

i mean, if they could get them in there while people were in and out of th ebuilding every day certainly they could get them back out, no?

The fires were already going and they weren’t going to be able to secure the building sufficiently any longer.
 
I'm asking you to back up what you have written with evidence.

I don't have written evidence.

But I think I said that WTC7 "looks like a CD" - do you disagree?

Look at the visual evidence (video)

I think I said that it appears that nobody has come up with examples of building collapse looking like CD but which were not CD.
Maybe there is such evidence - I can't prove the non-existence of something like that.

Just like your black swans/ brown dogs - I never said they did/didn't exist.

I said certain things are improbable, OK?
 
I don't disagree with Quintiere's statement, though it is very brief I am trying get his thoughts about behind it. It is very possible that the fire proofing could have been insufficient, but it is very possible that the plane removed the fire proofing whether it was sufficient or not. Either situation would have resulted in failure of the trusses.

It may have been the same fire-proofing as the lower floor, but it may have not have been sufficient throughout the whole building, but there was no fire in the lower floors so it wouldn't have mattered.
The first building while it was being built had different fire-proofing on the first 38 floors. Then they were told they had to switch to something that wasn't asbestos. Some have claimed this original fire-proofing would have faired better.

http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,244698,00.html
 
So, as a scientist, you discover government complicity in the greatest act of domestic terrorism in the US, and you decide that because your boss does not want you to publish it, you'll just keep your mouth shut?

I think your opinions are based upon an extremely low opinion on the moral fiber of a group of researchers and people whom you've never met. Do you not find that logic a bit self serving?

I don't know who is involved, I don't know the way the organisation is structured, I don't know who's been given control etc.

In an ideal world, everyone would do the 'right' thing, but unfortunately we don't have that luxury... I'm not passing moral judgement on anybody, I just know by experience that people - understandably - do not necessarily do the morally 'right' thing.

Evidently, the 19 hijackers/terrorists were human beings with no "moral fibre"
but that's perfectly acceptable to us, is it not?
In their own culture, they may be considered as 'heroes' , which of course is reprehensible to us.
 
Last edited:
I've seen the same thing in several institutions in various fields.

For example, even recently, an investigation into abuse in 'old folks homes' (care homes) - More than 50% of staff admitted they didn't report abuse when they witnessed it, saying they didn't want to risk repercussions..


So your evidence that all the worlds experts are all keeping quit because they are being paid off or afraid is that you have seen some abuse in an old folks home? Just how well do you think that would hold up in a court of law.

ARE YOU SERIOUS?
 
I don't have written evidence.

But I think I said that WTC7 "looks like a CD" - do you disagree?

Look at the visual evidence (video)

I think I said that it appears that nobody has come up with examples of building collapse looking like CD but which were not CD.
Maybe there is such evidence - I can't prove the non-existence of something like that.

Just like your black swans/ brown dogs - I never said they did/didn't exist.

I said certain things are improbable, OK?

You know people used to think the earth was flat because when ships ailed far enough they would disappear. They would ask "did the ship disappear or not?" to which the only answer could be 'yes'.

Luckily science came along and explained this phenomenon by showing the world was round and that simply because it looked like the ships fell of the edge didn't mean they really did. So just because to your uneducated eyes it looks like a CD is not evidence o a CD.

Try using that in court. "Your honor, we would like to bring in expert testimony from someone who has no expertise who says it looks like a controlled demolition".

If I said I thought it looked like a giant dildo, would that make it true too?

And the reason no one can provide you with an example of what you want is because never before in the history of man has such an incident occurred. And what you are arguing is that if something has never happened before, it's impossible. Which means that a building burning is impossible because at some point it had never happened before.

This is simply ignorance at it's best.
 
I don't know who is involved, I don't know the way the organisation is structured, I don't know who's been given control etc.

In an ideal world, everyone would do the 'right' thing, but unfortunately we don't have that luxury... I'm not passing moral judgement on anybody, I just know by experience that people - understandably - do not necessarily do the morally 'right' thing.

Evidently, the 19 hijackers/terrorists were human beings with no "moral fibre"
but that's perfectly acceptable to us, is it not?
In their own culture, they may be considered as 'heroes' , which of course is reprehensible to us.

The thing is I can understand why an Islamist terrorist would feel motivated to launch a suicide attack. I don't think they're right, but I can see how it would make sense to them.

I don't see how it is plausible for the NIST scientists to cover up evidence and then for the whole scientific community of the world to not say anything. Are you saying that all these people are scared and/or paid off?

Here are some engineers that you would assume are in no way beholden to the US government:

The Engineering Faculty of the Central University of Venezuela
The Iran University of Science and Technology College of Civil Engineering

And that's just a couple of Universities among many in those countries. And that's without mentioning France, Germany, Russia, I could go on...

Here's a TV station that would love to have a story that incriminated the US Government in a cover up:

http://english.aljazeera.net

although every news outlet in the world would love to break the story, if there was evidence.

So, why is almost everybody in the world silent about this?

Why is it only a few people on the Internet pointing at a video clip and telling us its obvious?
 
The first building while it was being built had different fire-proofing on the first 38 floors. Then they were told they had to switch to something that wasn't asbestos. Some have claimed this original fire-proofing would have faired better.

http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,244698,00.html

Thank you for the article.



This actually brings Quintiere's statement into a better light. I am not going to assume anything until I receive his answer on what he feels insufficient.
 
But I think I said that WTC7 "looks like a CD" - do you disagree?

Yes I disagree, things that don't look like a CD:

1. No flashes
2. The collapse of the penthouses
3. The debris pile.

That's before you get onto the lack of audio and seismic evidence.
 
I don't know who is involved, I don't know the way the organisation is structured, I don't know who's been given control etc.

In an ideal world, everyone would do the 'right' thing, but unfortunately we don't have that luxury... I'm not passing moral judgement on anybody, I just know by experience that people - understandably - do not necessarily do the morally 'right' thing.

Evidently, the 19 hijackers/terrorists were human beings with no "moral fibre"
but that's perfectly acceptable to us, is it not?
In their own culture, they may be considered as 'heroes' , which of course is reprehensible to us.

Actually their beliefs were different from ours. We are considered the enemy in the jihad and becoming a martyr for your religion gives 70 or so virgins. Thats why there were so many Suicide Bombers in Israel.


To our beliefs they had no "moral fiber", to them that was the most Holy thing they could have done.
 
... And what you are arguing is that if something has never happened before, it's impossible....

This is simply ignorance at it's best.

See, this is where you go wrong... I have not said "impossible" at all - I think you'll find that I said "improbable" which would be appropriate.

So please learn to differentiate between 'impossible' and 'improbable' - there's a big difference.

As to "experts" and in a court of law you said "Try using that in court. "Your honor, we would like to bring in expert testimony from someone who has no expertise who says it looks like a controlled demolition".
I believe I mentioned earlier the Dutch guy who's a pofessional in the field of CD - well he says it was "definitely" a CD... (he's even more definite than me - I only say it's most likely)
So how would he do in court?

As for me being 'uneducated' - if that's what you think, too bad... nobody is forcing you to post.

Anyway, I must log off for now.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom