Debunk-liners

Argument from incredulity fallacy. Straw man fallacy.

Evidence?

Please stop talking about "straw man" fallacies and such.

It's very unlikely that the weakening was present all across the entire support structure at the same time. Steel regains it's strength when it cool down below, what, 300C. Fire moves.

Any heating was local.
 
If it was fire/debris damage, common sense tells you the fire and damage would not weaken all supports the full length and breadth of the building.
Well then I guess all those people who go to university to study engineering for years are wasting their time if all you need is common sense to solve engineering questions.

It would be localised to a smaller area.
The idea that the fire managed to weaken the entire support structure to the same degree, simultaneously doesn't make sense.

So your common sense doesn't tell you how one collumn after another can fail until the remaining collumns are no longer able to support the building?

I've seen people use the example of jenga blocks and other things like stretching a rubber band until it snaps, but it never seems to sink in. I would try to think up another demonstration, but I'm no engineer, so I'll leave it to the experts...
 
Please stop talking about "straw man" fallacies and such.

It's very unlikely that the weakening was present all across the entire support structure at the same time. Steel regains it's strength when it cool down below, what, 300C. Fire moves.



Perhaps you should simply learn what the term means.

PS: Do you know a guy called Malcolm Kirkman?
 
Do you know what "curtain wall" construction is? By your statement I believe you don't.

I think I know what "curtain wall" construction is.

I think you going to say what we 'saw' wasn't what was happening internally right?
 
It fell symetrically, i.e. no separating or shearing vertically - you know like when a building falls due to some non-CD structural failure, you'll see the facade break unevenly. This WTC7 collapse was very symetric.
It means that all the supports failed ~ simultaneously
...

Tell you what; in 3 years or so, when you decide to go to college how about getting a degree in either architecture or structural engineering, then get back to us so we can have an intelligent conversation.
 
No it's not wrong.

All examples of 'P' that any reasonable person knows of, just happen to be 'Q'

Therefor P is probably Q

OK?

No, it is not okay.

Because it is untrue in these circumstances to say "all examples of P that any reasonable person know of just happen to be Q".

Thus your poor attempt to construct a logical argument is based upon a faulty premise from the beginning. Therefore, it fails.

And on the point about "the low probability" and the fact that NIST never said that, I really wanted you to read the entire post that I linked to, not to simply take that one line out of it. You really should read it, as R. Mackey did a great job of explaining it. It isn't that long and it won't take you too long to read it, so please do. Once again, you can find it here.
 
Last edited:
I'm still waiting for an explanation as to how the demolition charges which allegedly brought down WTC7 made no discernable noises nor discernable flashes of light...
 
PLEASE STOP!


STOP WITH YOUR THEORY OF FIRE BACKED BY YOUR OBVIOUS LACK OF KNOWLEDGE ON FIRE BEHAVIOR!

Hey, it's OK... I don't pretend to have any special knowledge about fire.
Don't get upset.
( and before you mention it - no, I'm not implicating any firefighters in anything at all, ok? )
 
If it was fire/debris damage, common sense tells you the fire and damage would not weaken all supports the full length and breadth of the building.
It would be localised to a smaller area.
The idea that the fire managed to weaken the entire support structure to the same degree, simultaneously doesn't make sense.

So you are saying that pretty much the world body of structural engineers have no common sense. Again, how is it these guys are professionals when someone with no expertise in the field says that everything they know goes against common sense?

Perhaps you would care to teach structural engineering so that structural engineers can learn common sense instead of the laws of physics and engineering?
 
No, it is not okay.

Because it is untrue in these circumstances to say "all examples of P that any reasonable person know of just happen to be Q".

Yes but, it no good just saying "it's untrue" - you OT JREFers always demand evidence from "truthers" don't you?
 
Only in truther-ville do you get someone cheerfully admitting to a total ignorance of the requisite science whilst equally cheerfully making absolute claims about how building collapses must have and can’t have happened.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom