Debunk-liners

why do truthers fail to do any research?

I don't know what the official line is on the FDR.

So fire doesn't spread or compromise the steel as fast. Some fires go for hour’s even whole days. The trade centers fell in about an hour.
The FDR was even decoded by idiot truthers, who found all 24-25 hours of flight on the plane known as flight 77. Oops, proof it is flight 77. FDR is easy stuff, you should know this, what is your problem doing research?

Fire destroys the strength of steel very quickly. There are many dead firemen because steel fails quickly in fire. Sorry, but if this is your best or your worse research showing, you are not going to do well in school.

So far you are just asking questions that make you look research challenged.
 
this can be solved very easily -just provide us a video of a building collapsing - not as a result of CD- and we can compare the massive differences.
If only it was that easy... I guess most of them are CDs
I've seen videos of a building falling over, I've seen one which collapsed in a non symertic fashion, i.e. with some 'shearing' - meaning one part is trying to fall, but the ajacent parts stay up.
 
Look, I don't personally know much about CD, and I don't pretend to be a structural engineer.

I do believe that WTC7 looked like a CD and I don't believe anyone has - so far - shown any other building of [similar constuction type] collapsing like #7 did , unless it was by means of CD.
Also, the Dutch CD expert that people here have quoted is adamant that it was CD...
WTC7 is the main 'sticking point' for me in the whole 9/11 thing

Certainly 7 WTC "looked" a lot like a CD especially when viewed casually, like when I first saw that. I thought to myself, now THAT is what I would think a CD would look like. Certainly much more like a CD than the collapses of the two towers.

I have read, though skimpily, about the analysis that has been done on 7 WTC which postulated where the initiating event was and one thing you can say is that the engineers were making a guess about exactly what happened based on external characteristics of the collapse. That's what experts are expected to do when something is not subject to direct observation -- like what is happening to the interior.

Mr. Jowenko is certainly entitled to his opinion. Since he's not been required to testify (in a court or under oath) or has not presented a paper in a peer-reviewed journal on the collapse, he does not have to back up with calculations or a line of reasoning what he concluded. Despite his apparent confidence in his conclusion, if he were to be required to back up his opinion, it might change or at least lose a lot of certainty.
 
How many of those buildings were tubed design or struck by an aircraft?
The question was about fire-proofing not design. So if it fell in just an hour with the fire-proofing supposedly sheared off just a few floors how long would it have taken with the fire-proofing intact? Is it the fire-proofing or the design?
 
I'm not much for the no plane theories I just don't know without the transponder code except for process of elimination how did they ID the planes that hit the towers? Plus the only multiple footage they would need to have is the 2nd WTC hit. There wouldn’t be any need for a bunch of cameras catching the first hit of anything.
You didn't answer the question


On google video I think the guys name is bregistration has two videos from the same camera or same angle but different stations at the same time with one showing the plane and the other just showing something you can barely see come in and make the second WTC hit. I don't necessarily know that fake video means no plane. Couldn't it just mean some news stations embellished the shot they had just to have an exclusive video?
You didn't answer the question.


How about WTC7 wasn't part of the original plan but once it was damaged it was an unsecured building that house agencies like the Secret Service thus a security breach and had to be destroyed? Or maybe it was suppose to be hit by the third plane flying around the city that the emergency responders were warned about but never came in. How about everything didn’t go exactly as planned?
Well, if you maintain that WTC7 was brought down with CD, then the above statement means it would have to have been set up on the fly that very same morning without a single person witnessing anything suspicious. Please explain how that is even remotely possible.


So fire doesn't spread or compromise the steel as fast. Some fires go for hour’s even whole days. The trade centers fell in about an hour after being struck by giant airplanes traveling at 500 mph.
Fixed


They can't kill everyone besides they have the Government Counter-Misinformation Team to combat that stuff.
So wait, this imaginary agency you just made up... they counter misinformation? That's kind of confusing. In the future, please name your imaginary government agencies something a little more straight forward. KTHX!
 
Last edited:
The question was about fire-proofing not design. So if it fell in just an hour with the fire-proofing supposedly sheared off just a few floors how long would it have taken with the fire-proofing intact? Is it the fire-proofing or the design?

Well the design and fire proofing. As I quote James Quintiere from the email I have received from him, though it was not much here you go:

From: "James Quintiere" <[email protected]>
Subject: Re: Question about NIST WTC Report

I believe the trusses were to blame and they did not have sufficient
insulation.
---
James G. Quintiere
The John L. Bryan Professor
Fire Protection Engineering
University of Maryland
1137D Glenn L. Martin Hall
College Park, MD 20742-3031
301 405 3993 fax 9383
cell 240 472 2016
New Book
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/t...ding=UTF8&no=283155&me=ATVPDKIKX0DER&st=books


Now even if there was sufficient fire proofing and only a small amount was removed from the steel would have been weakened and failed.


ETA: "how long would it have taken with the fire-proofing intact?"

I can only speculate because no fire is ever the same. The Sight and Sound Theater's steel members were sprayed with fire resistance material and still collapsed. That building was not damaged prior the fire, so it can range. Thats real world conditions.
 
Last edited:
Please!
You must know that if it was CD, they can't actually publish that conclusion...

Why not? Because it would void Larry's insurance policy? Because it would reveal the existence of supersonic invisible demolition ninjas? Why?
 
Please!
You must know that if it was CD, they can't actually publish that conclusion...
and why not? just because they are associated with the government means everyone must automatically be "in on it"

do you know how many engineers names are on the NIST report? do yo uknow how many more had input? are you saying that ALL of these people are covering up for the government?

besides, if its obviously a demolition why does only 1 CD expert in the entire world say so? what reason do all these people have to cover up for the US governmetn?
 
What is your evidence to back up that claim?

I've seen the same thing in several institutions in various fields.

For example, even recently, an investigation into abuse in 'old folks homes' (care homes) - More than 50% of staff admitted they didn't report abuse when they witnessed it, saying they didn't want to risk repercussions..
 
I've seen the same thing in several institutions in various fields.

For example, even recently, an investigation into abuse in 'old folks homes' (care homes) - More than 50% of staff admitted they didn't report abuse when they witnessed it, saying they didn't want to risk repercussions..
more than 50% eh, so what about the other less than 50%? do they report it? wouldnt that mean we should see just under half of all engineers siding with the truthers?
 
Why not? Because it would void Larry's insurance policy? Because it would reveal the existence of supersonic invisible demolition ninjas? Why?

I don't have any opinion about any involvement of Larry S.
 
Last edited:
more than 50% eh, so what about the other less than 50%? do they report it? wouldnt that mean we should see just under half of all engineers siding with the truthers?

Following your logic, yes of course exactly 50% - so you must have a strange logic.
 
Following your logic, yes of course exactly 50% - so you must have a strange logic.
well, you said that over 50% of healthcare workers (lets call it 60%) dont report abuse, this must mean that 40% of them DO report abuse

to apply these same number to the engineering community, we shoudl expect to see 40% of engineers to be speaking out against the NIST report, correct?

or was that not your point? if not, WTH is your point?
 
Just because you think there are only two choices?

I did ask you why they couldn't report a CD and offered two silly suggestions. You chose to mention one of them in your reply, but you still haven't said why NIST couldn't report CD if that was what the evidence suggested.
 
I've seen the same thing in several institutions in various fields.

For example, even recently, an investigation into abuse in 'old folks homes' (care homes) - More than 50% of staff admitted they didn't report abuse when they witnessed it, saying they didn't want to risk repercussions..

And of course that's the same thing as people who witness what is tantamount to complicity in murder of 3000 innocent people, right?
 
Well the design and fire proofing. As I quote James Quintiere from the email I have received from him, though it was not much here you go:

From: "James Quintiere" <[email protected]>
Subject: Re: Question about NIST WTC Report

I believe the trusses were to blame and they did not have sufficient
insulation.
---
James G. Quintiere
The John L. Bryan Professor
Fire Protection Engineering
University of Maryland
1137D Glenn L. Martin Hall
College Park, MD 20742-3031
301 405 3993 fax 9383
cell 240 472 2016
New Book
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/t...ding=UTF8&no=283155&me=ATVPDKIKX0DER&st=books


Now even if there was sufficient fire proofing and only a small amount was removed from the steel would have been weakened and failed.


ETA: "how long would it have taken with the fire-proofing intact?"

I can only speculate because no fire is ever the same. The Sight and Sound Theater's steel members were sprayed with fire resistance material and still collapsed. That building was not damaged prior the fire, so it can range. Thats real world conditions.

So I gather from this Quintiere feels the trusses failed because of insufficient fireproofing not from the plane crash but just insufficient to begin with as in when it was installed? And if it was sufficient you believe its possible it would have collapse anyway eventually? What about if it had the same asbestos fire-proofing of the lower floors what do you think then?
 
<<Originally Posted by ref:
- How did the NWO know beforehand, that the north tower would collapse into WTC7, so the debris could be blamed for the damage and starting fires?>>
How about WTC7 wasn't part of the original plan but once it was damaged it was an unsecured building that house agencies like the Secret Service thus a security breach and had to be destroyed? Or maybe it was suppose to be hit by the third plane flying around the city that the emergency responders were warned about but never came in. How about everything didn’t go exactly as planned?

Maybe WTC7 was part of the plan, i.e. to destroy all the buildings, so it was 'rigged' beforehand like 1 & 2.

The third plane was supposed to hit #7 but didn't make it.

Things don't always go as planned. :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom