Debunk-liners

modem = moulator-demodulator

Even in the cable/dsl world it still does change the incoming signal(demod) into something it can use, and change the outgoing data (modulator) into something that can be transmitted over a long distance.

No it doesn't. A modem modulates a digital signal into an analogue one so that it can be sent over an ordinary phone line and via an analogue exchange (and demodulates the analogue signal it receives). Cable and DSL connections are entirely digital.

However, because the function is the same (ie it's a box that connects you to The Internet) the name has carried over to the newer devices. Technically most of them are routers, but the distinction isn't really important.
 
No it doesn't. A modem modulates a digital signal into an analogue one so that it can be sent over an ordinary phone line and via an analogue exchange (and demodulates the analogue signal it receives). Cable and DSL connections are entirely digital.

However, because the function is the same (ie it's a box that connects you to The Internet) the name has carried over to the newer devices. Technically most of them are routers, but the distinction isn't really important.

This is incorrect - previous post is correct. Do a little research on DSL Modulation and you will see why.

There aren't 1s and 0s going out your DSL modem.
 
Would you say that WTC7 looked like a CD?

Any reasonable person would say YES...
That really should depend on how many controlled demolitions the person has seen, either in person or on video. It also depends on how much similiarity one wants to establish as being the threshold for "looking like a CD."

I would argue that, given the lack on any videos of the WTC7 collapse of the distinctive and very loud sounds and the bright flashes of light which occur when demolition chargers are detonated, this makes WTC7 rather different from a CD.
 
This is incorrect - previous post is correct. Do a little research on DSL Modulation and you will see why.

There aren't 1s and 0s going out your DSL modem.

I stand corrected.

I didn't realise there was digital as well as analogue modulation.

Which is probably far enough off topic...
 
Start a thread up in another subforum if you want to continue maccy. Or not. :)

We are a bit off topic.

I may well do, but I'm going to bed now - so it'll have to wait for another time.
 
Rubbish.

As for the WTC7, there's no credible explanation for the collapse mechanism , except CD.
If you know of one, write to NIST, because they don't know of one that has any more than a 'low probabitity'

This is incorrect.

R.Mackey said:
<snip>The "low order of probability" comment comes from the FEMA investigation of WTC 7. NIST has never said any such thing. The FEMA report was completed years ago, and is quite cursory. The NIST report, as most are aware, has been repeatedly delayed as its scope has grown, and is now anticipated towards the end of this year.

FEMA did indeed state that their proposed collapse hypothesis was of "a low probability of occurrence." However, the report needs to be read in order to understand what that statement means. FEMA's words, in context, are as follows:

Please see the complete post by R.Mackey where he explains this in terrific detail.
 
No, you commited the affirming the consequent fallacy.

If P then Q.
Q.
Therefore P

If it was a controlled demolition, it would have looked like a controlled demotion.
It looked like a controlled demolition.
Therefore it was a controlled demolition.

Further, the burden of proof is still on you.


No, I have not "commited the affirming the consequent fallacy" as you put it.

How about :
all known P are Q
therefor P is probably Q

IOW, all known collapses that look like the WTC7 collapse are CDs, therefor WTC7 was probably a CD, OK?

I believe that if there's a chance that it could have been caused by something else, it certainly wasn't fire and debris damage.

Why don't you try to make 'reasonable' arguments Par, instead of being preoccupied by P, Q, and this or that fallacy?
 
Terry, you might want to inquire about a beginner's logic course at your local university to find out why you can't do what you just did.

ETA: To help illuminate your logical fallacy, allow me the following illustration:

Suppose every dog you ever saw was brown.
Suppose I have a dog that you have never seen.
Based on those two suppositions, my dog is probably what color?
 
Last edited:
So, you want to change the subject. Sure. Show me where NIST said this.

FEMA said that.

NIST has obviously not yet been able to come up with an answer, at least not one that will pass the simplest examination.
Give them more time, it's only what, nearly 6 years?
 
And yet the world's top CD experts can and have explained exactly why it wasn't and couldn't have possibly been one.

<snide remarks snipped>



Please show the evidence for this.

I don't believe anyone could prove "it couldn't possibly have been a CD" , as you put it.
 
FEMA said that.

NIST has obviously not yet been able to come up with an answer, at least not one that will pass the simplest examination.
Give them more time, it's only what, nearly 6 years?

You realize, of course, that the collapse of WTC7 holds absolutely no significance or mystery to anyone other than conspiracy fantasists, right? There is no rush to determine the cause of a relatively mundane phenomenon.
 
FEMA said that.

NIST has obviously not yet been able to come up with an answer, at least not one that will pass the simplest examination.
Give them more time, it's only what, nearly 6 years?
theyve been working on WTC7 less than 2 years, they started working on it after the final report for WTC1+2 was published
 
Would you say that WTC7 looked like a CD?

Any reasonable person would say YES - but OT JREFers say NO

Boneheads ?

There is no other way for such a building to fall.

Please post a video of a similarly constructed building that fell in a manner that did not look like a cd, or at the very least, please describe how, in your expert opinion, it should have looked as it fell.

Or is it easier to just call us boneheads and get yourself banned?
 
Please show the evidence for this.

I don't believe anyone could prove "it couldn't possibly have been a CD" , as you put it.

Actually maccy provided this list of proofs against a CD theory in an earlier post:

1. why there were no sounds of explosions;
2. why there is no seismic data to indicate explosions;
3. why the penthouses collapsed before the rest of the building;
4. how the building was rigged without anybody noticing;
5. how the conspirators knew it would be hit by debris and set on fire;
6. how the explosive survived several hours of fire;
7. why the building needed to be demolished at all;
8. why so many members of the FDNY insist that building was going to fall due to the fires; and
9. why the conspirators didn't wait until it was dark before demolishing the building.
 
Terry, you might want to inquire about a beginner's logic course at your local university to find out why you can't do what you just did.

ETA: To help illuminate your logical fallacy, allow me the following illustration:

Suppose every dog you ever saw was brown.
Suppose I have a dog that you have never seen.
Based on those two suppositions, my dog is probably what color?

Brown, obviously :D

If every dog I'd ever seen was brown, the probability of your dog being brown is very high...
Assuming I've seen a lot of dogs, and also everyone I know has never seen any dog other than a brown dog, your dog is very probably brown, OK
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom