Debunk-liners

You're right, #1 is at least twice as ludicrous.

Of course, that's like saying believing in sasquatch is twice as ludicrous as believing in the loch ness monster, but still... :p

I did not know that ludicrousness could be quantified.

Is there a scale of ludicrousness?

If so, which is more ludicrous:

1) JFK was killed by a massive, military-industrial complex-sponsored, conspiracy

2) We never went to the moon

3) 9/11 was an inside job

4) The Holocaust never occurred

5) Hitler is alive and living in Argentina

6) Mark Roberts is really a CIA disinformation agent :)
 
Would you say that WTC7 looked like a CD?

Any reasonable person would say YES - but OT JREFers say NO

Boneheads ?
i never said 7 didnt look like a demolition, but a question the CTers never seem to want to answer is "is that appearance chracteristic of a CD or of a building falling down"

remember, the same force does all the work in both cases
 
Would you say that WTC7 looked like a CD?

Any reasonable person would say YES
Oh, so we've changed it from "was" to "looked like" now?

Stupid JREFers, actually looking the evidence and science behind things. No wonder the aliens never probe us, we keep denying their existence even though there are pictures that look like UFOs out there. :rolleyes:
 
but a question the CTers never seem to want to answer is "is that appearance chracteristic of a CD or of a building falling down"

It looks like a CD. It does not look like a building falling down without CD.
It you can come up with evidence showing a "building falling down" which looks like that but without CD, you will have a new convert.
 
Would you say that WTC7 looked like a CD?

Any reasonable person would say YES - but OT JREFers say NO

Boneheads ?
I don't see explosions before the collapse started and part of the penthouse fell before the rest of the building. I'll answer no.

Back to the OP; why did Silverstein confess under light questioning?
 
It looks like a CD. It does not look like a building falling down without CD.
It you can come up with evidence showing a "building falling down" which looks like that but without CD, you will have a new convert.
Sorry, computer's running slow. I'll get back to you when google search finds matches for "building" "skyscraper falling on" "plane falling on" "fires."
 
It looks like a CD. It does not look like a building falling down without CD.
It you can come up with evidence showing a "building falling down" which looks like that but without CD, you will have a new convert.


Affirming the consequent fallacy. Further, find me an example of a similar kind of building collapsing due to widespread fires and severe debris damage that didn’t look like WTC7. The burden of proof is on you, after all.
 
Last edited:
It looks like a CD. It does not look like a building falling down without CD.
It you can come up with evidence showing a "building falling down" which looks like that but without CD, you will have a new convert.
no buildings that large have collapsed save for the ones on 9/11 (and before you make the obvious reply, no buildings that large have ever been demo'd either)

which is why i ask, is it chrateristic of demolition, or chracteristic of the building faslling down? you seem to have answered the question based on nothing at all
 
I did not know that ludicrousness could be quantified.

Is there a scale of ludicrousness?

If so, which is more ludicrous:

1) JFK was killed by a massive, military-industrial complex-sponsored, conspiracy

2) We never went to the moon

3) 9/11 was an inside job

4) The Holocaust never occurred

5) Hitler is alive and living in Argentina

6) Mark Roberts is really a CIA disinformation agent :)

All are pretty equally ludicrous except #5, which is true because Mad Magazine referenced it in an All In the Family parody once.
eng101.gif
 
Affirming the consequent fallacy.

Rubbish.

As for the WTC7, there's no credible explanation for the collapse mechanism , except CD.
If you know of one, write to NIST, because they don't know of one that has any more than a 'low probabitity'
 
Rubbish.

As for the WTC7, there's no credible explanation for the collapse mechanism , except CD.
If you know of one, write to NIST, because they don't know of one that has any more than a 'low probabitity'
too bad CD has no credibility

BTW, while NIST says their best hypothesis has low probability of occurance, NIST also said they took explosive demolition into consideration for their hypothesis, which means it must have an ever LOWER probability (otherwise it would be the best hypothesis) so youve just debunked yourself there buddy
 
It looks like a CD. It does not look like a building falling down without CD.
It you can come up with evidence showing a "building falling down" which looks like that but without CD, you will have a new convert.
Affirming the consequent fallacy.

No, you commited the affirming the consequent fallacy.

If P then Q.
Q.
Therefore P

If it was a controlled demolition, it would have looked like a controlled demotion.
It looked like a controlled demolition.
Therefore it was a controlled demolition.

Further, the burden of proof is still on you.
 
As for the WTC7, there's no credible explanation for the collapse mechanism , except CD.
If you know of one, write to NIST, because they don't know of one that has any more than a 'low probabitity'


So, you want to change the subject. Sure. Show me where NIST said this.
 
Rubbish.

As for the WTC7, there's no credible explanation for the collapse mechanism , except CD.
And yet the world's top CD experts can and have explained exactly why it wasn't and couldn't have possibly been one.

Granted they wouldn't know as much as someone with a PhD in Theology or college kids, but hey, that's all our side has. :(









...well, except the top physicists, structural engineers, and the other elite smarties in the private and public sectors whose only explanation for CD is "paranoid delusion."
 
Rubbish.

As for the WTC7, there's no credible explanation for the collapse mechanism, except CD.

I'm absolutely speechless. Could you please lay out your theory and evidence of a CD rather then a simple argument from personal incredulity. Is that a fair request?

All of the structural engineers in my company do not see anything wrong with the combination of the debri damage and fires theory being plausible, but what do they know, they only design skyscrapers? They are eagerly waiting for the NIST report. Once they are availble to digest this I will report back if they believe the reported collapse mechanism is rubbish.

As an avid skier, I've seen many an avalanche and to this day I can never tell which have occured naturally and which have occured intentionally from explosives. They have all looked the same to me. Once gravity acts......
 
Would you say that WTC7 looked like a CD?

Any reasonable person would say YES - but OT JREFers say NO

Boneheads ?

It looks bit like a CD if you start the clip from after the Penthouses collapse into the building. However there are none of explosive flashes that you would expect to see. Also the fact that you can only see the top half of the building in the clip is somewhat confusing. The building certainly didn't fall into its own footprint - so it wasn't a controlled demolition in the controlled sense.

It certainly doesn't sound like a CD (no loud bangs immediately before the collapse) and there were no seismic readings to indicate explosives.

Neither were there any remnants of explosives found in the wreckage.

As far as the plausibility of hypotheses go, the NIST working hypothesis makes sense and explains how the building could have fallen in the way it did. The conspiracy hypothesis, by contrast, doesn't come up with a plausible explanation for:

1. why there were no sounds of explosions;
2. why there is no seismic data to indicate explosions;
3. why the penthouses collapsed before the rest of the building;
4. how the building was rigged without anybody noticing;
5. how the conspirators knew it would be hit by debris and set on fire;
6. how the explosive survived several hours of fire;
7. why the building needed to be demolished at all;
8. why so many members of the FDNY insist that building was going to fall due to the fires; and
9. why the conspirators didn't wait until it was dark before demolishing the building.

The most important thing is the evidence: and there is none to suggest a CD. But, on top of that, it doesn't make sense even as a hypothesis.
 
Last edited:
Two of the link units are shattered. The buildings either side are still standing, which is quite peculiar structurally. Were the collapsed units properly integrated into the main structure?

Hmm...sounds suspiciously like another conspiracy
 
why do people insist on calling a cable/dsl modem a modem?

modem = moulator-demodulator

Even in the cable/dsl world it still does change the incoming signal(demod) into something it can use, and change the outgoing data (modulator) into something that can be transmitted over a long distance.

My question (if not asked yet)
-if the whole idea was to get the USA into invading Afghanistan and Iraq then why were none of the hijackers 'discovered' to be Afghani or Iraqi, and instead most of them are Saudi(a country ostensibly friendly to the USA and which was not invaded)?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom