Did you miss
the actual story here?The soldiers weren't the target, the neighborhoods were. And the absentee ballots were targeted for rejection, not targeted to not be sent out. Surely all soldiers don't uniformly vote Republican. Apparently those dogs do hunt, but Palast just got the details wrong in the interview.
I read the entire wheeze on Democracy Now.
Note: The road to nowhere was regarding this thread. Also, I addressed only the NAS Jax matter, not the rest as the rest is filled with assertion, little supporting evidence, until I can see what is in those 500 emails. I'll await until I see how that plays out before I consider futher, but when I see how badly he gets NAS JAX wrong, I am skeptical about the claims. Not dismissive of, skeptical of.
Soldiers and NAS Jax DO NOT FIT. Did you see my post on who gets deployed from NAS Jax?
Also, yes, soldiers and sailors do not uniformly vote Republican. It may be that the 2008 election is being looked at, and the discontent of a lot of those who have been deployed (with the civilian leadership) is being measured and a backlash is being planned against. THAT might be a motive for Rove to try and hijack the military vote, and would actually fit the scenario Palast is trying to paint. What Palast doesn't do, however, is tie that together with any coherence. He appeals to spin and anxiety. If he has facts to back this up, in his emails, I would love to see them.
On the other bit, for clarity: if you are in Iraq, you aren't in nor from the barracks on the NAS, in your thousands and multitudes, given how most of the folk there don't live on the NAS Jacksonville base, nor use its zip code, as I pointed out. The people on and in NAS don't tend to be
in Iraq. If I have to underline that yet again, I will.
If you live on base housing, with your family, and are deployed, guess who gets your mail? Your wife/husband. Contact is an email/letter away to unscrew it. So, caging game exposed, in the micro, but in deference to Palast, only if someone cares enough to pursue it.
I understand what you mean by caging, and I am glad to see this being discussed. I would love to see the emails, since Palast does not inspire confidence, nor does the format of that link.
As to the mechanics of what is being tried, and this "he must hate the troops," he put together two disparate thoughts that don't fit very well. If you note the spin, where 1/2 million of absentee ballots are targeted, and the focus of the piece is all of a sudden "Blacks and Hispanic" votes when the demographics of the military are not skewed that way. Sorry, can't shake the suspiscion of the man's grasp of fact versus fantasy. That does not kill his story, no, but it costs it credibility.
What is clear is that not enough facts are used to support the number of claims he was making, but what also seems clear is that Rove was (hell, is) up to something. Something seamy.
Yes.
Given the zip code targeted, there is more to support "get out the vote" than "stifle the vote," the latter of which is a self-inflicted wound based on the small amount of facts. However, if the projections within RNC are as I noted above, a backlash from the ranks, then it makes far more sense, with this caveat:
Illegally supressing the vote is more difficult than getting out the vote, in that you have to cover more stuff up. What I sense in your theme, and in Palasts, is that the effort is being targeted in a few critical states, which tactically (conservation of finite resources) sound if one is trying to swing an election.
"Neighborhoods" and "NAS Jacksonville" is a non-sequitur.
SG, if the caging is in fact being applied to anyone, and this can be shown rather than asserted, it is indeed an egregious foul, and someone needs to go to jail for a good long time.
DR