Skeptic Ginger
Nasty Woman
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2005
- Messages
- 96,955
Evidence or a conspiracy?No - they are either supported by evidence or they are not. Got some?
Evidence or a conspiracy?No - they are either supported by evidence or they are not. Got some?
I'm sorry, Drys but I was being serious. After posting several tidbits you reveal you don't know what voter disenfranchisement is and that's what the thread is about.You being sarcastic or serious?
If you post links to sources I'll read it. I hope it's more than just Palast though.
I'm sorry, Drys but I was being serious. After posting several tidbits you reveal you don't know what voter disenfranchisement is and that's what the thread is about.
Voter disenfranchisement is when you prevent large (or small, but usually large) groups of people from voting by various means.
You require picture ID knowing some people don't have picture IDs and that will cause some of them to not vote.
You require a "poll tax" or a fee to vote, knowing some voters can't pay the fee and won't vote.
You require a literacy test knowing people who can't read then can't vote.
You send out letters to some people and if they don't return the request, you erase them from the voter roles but you don't send the letters to everyone.
You erase all the people from the voter registration in some districts that have the same name as any convicted felon. But you don't do that in every district.
You make sure there aren't enough voting machines in some districts and make sure there are more than enough in others.
Those are examples of voter disenfranchisement. There are many more ways to do it. If the election is close you only have to prevent a few % of people from voting and you can change the winner.
Illegal voting by individuals who weren't legally allowed to vote or who supposedly voted twice is what the Republicans hope you believe when you hear the words, "voter fraud". So when the news reports of voter disenfranchisement come out, people who aren't paying close attention think they are news reports of individual voters cheating.
The conspiracy is to distract people with this red herring of voter ID, make it sound like the news reports are about individual voters cheating and pull it off again in 08.
I'm sorry, Drys but I was being serious. After posting several tidbits you reveal you don't know what voter disenfranchisement is and that's what the thread is about.
Voter disenfranchisement is when you prevent large (or small, but usually large) groups of people from voting by various means.
You require picture ID knowing some people don't have picture IDs and that will cause some of them to not vote.
You require a "poll tax" or a fee to vote, knowing some voters can't pay the fee and won't vote.
You require a literacy test knowing people who can't read then can't vote.
You send out letters to some people and if they don't return the request, you erase them from the voter roles but you don't send the letters to everyone.
You erase all the people from the voter registration in some districts that have the same name as any convicted felon. But you don't do that in every district.
You make sure there aren't enough voting machines in some districts and make sure there are more than enough in others.
Those are examples of voter disenfranchisement. There are many more ways to do it. If the election is close you only have to prevent a few % of people from voting and you can change the winner.
Illegal voting by individuals who weren't legally allowed to vote or who supposedly voted twice is what the Republicans hope you believe when you hear the words, "voter fraud". So when the news reports of voter disenfranchisement come out, people who aren't paying close attention think they are news reports of individual voters cheating.
The conspiracy is to distract people with this red herring of voter ID, make it sound like the news reports are about individual voters cheating and pull it off again in 08.
I'm sorry, Drys but I was being serious. After posting several tidbits you reveal you don't know what voter disenfranchisement is and that's what the thread is about.
Voter disenfranchisement is when you prevent large (or small, but usually large) groups of people from voting by various means.
Should I start the thread over?Can I ask how you came by this knowledge of what the republicans intend to do and their motivations for it?
And only the republicans are guilty of these?
Thats your belief?
Is there any proof of any of this stuff are is it just a bunch of accusations thrown against the wall hoping some will stick?
One thing though. I know you are aware that it's not just republicans in charge of voting correct?
What makes you so sure they are the only ones attempting to disenfranchise voters?
You cannot be that naive surely?
For Pete's sake, Brainst, I was giving examples after Drys posted he didn't know the difference between voter disenfranchisement and individual voter fraud. Read the post.And once again, the part you have to deal with is the enormous increases in people voting for the Democratic candidates in 2000 and 2004. You may claim this thread is about 2008, but your sources and you have already claimed the Republicans did this in the prior elections.
However, in 1996, 47.4 million people voted for Bill Clinton. In 2000, 51 million voted for Al Gore. And in 2004, an incredible 59 million voted for John Kerry. So in the course of two elections, the Democrats got almost 25% more votes. It seems abundantly obvious that the problem is not that the Republicans are preventing the Democrats from getting new voters, it is that Republicans thus far have gotten more of the benefit of new voters.
This thread is about a very specific conspiracy by one political party: the federal attorney firings, why was it done, what's Rove's involvement, is there a connection to the 08 election.
Should I start the thread over?
Those were examples, not what Republicans are trying to do. And while I'm at it let me address this nonsense,
I have made no claims the Democrats are without sin. Why is it when the discussion is about a specific event: the federal attorney firings, why was it done, what's Rove's involvement, is there a connection to the 08 election, does someone get his/her (mostly his in this thread I think) feelings hurt and insist on making the discussion either about, "Well nayh nayh you did it too" or "I know you are but what am I?"
Who cares who else did what? Start a thread about the evil Dems, I'll take a look. This thread is about a very specific conspiracy by one political party: the federal attorney firings, why was it done, what's Rove's involvement, is there a connection to the 08 election.
I think you and I can forget all about voter fraud making any kind of a diff in 2008. The Dems are going to win, and win big. My being a liberal Democrat finds me grinning profusely in anticipation.
You require a literacy test knowing people who can't read then can't vote.
Here's a shortened version of the stuff I have already posted:Can I ask how you came by this knowledge of what was done by the republicans and why they did it?
...georgewbush.org is "A chicken head production parody web site". Take a look. Click on "contact us".
While, "GOP.com | Republican National Committee :: Home
GOP.com. WEDNESDAY | MAY 09, 2007. Sign up for news and information, Submit · Issues · Social Security · Nominations · Jobs & Economy · Safety & Security ...
www.georgebush.com/ -" , the Google listing, actually forwards you to GOP.com when you try to go to the latter address.
This part of the story checks out when you consider it has been revealed these guys were sending a lot of emails via the Republican Party website to avoid the requirement official emails be saved for review. Both of those web pages have "contact us" options. I'd like to see just how these emails were addressed that they would have been going through a web site instead of to a specific email address.
But it is plausible.
I am waiting for the emails to be verified as well. But I don't put it past Rove to have sent something like them. Another possibility is they were leaked or hacked by someone then ended up in Palast's hands and the mis-mailed story is to cover the trail.
On Palast's web site (same link from Pardalis above) he covers the email topic in an interview with Dollars and Sense. On their web site, they published part of the interview but left out the part on the emails, unless it is on a page I didn't find.
Despite the validity of the emails, the voter fraud prosecution theme is emerging without them. U.S. Attorneys Investigation; Voter-Fraud Complaints by GOP Drove DismissalsSource Watch, Congresspedia on the fired attorney matterBy Dan Eggen and Amy Goldstein
Washington Post Staff Writers
Monday, May 14, 2007; Page A04
Nearly half the U.S. attorneys slated for removal by the administration last year were targets of Republican complaints that they were lax on voter fraud, including efforts by presidential adviser Karl Rove to encourage more prosecutions of election- law violations, according to new documents and interviews.
Of the 12 U.S. attorneys known to have been dismissed or considered for removal last year, five were identified by Rove or other administration officials as working in districts that were trouble spots for voter fraud -- Kansas City, Mo.; Milwaukee; New Mexico; Nevada; and Washington state. Four of the five prosecutors in those districts were dismissed.
It has been clear for months that the administration's eagerness to launch voter-fraud prosecutions played a role in some of the firings, but recent testimony, documents and interviews show the issue was more central than previously known. The new details include the names of additional prosecutors who were targeted and other districts that were of concern, as well as previously unknown information about the White House's role....Shifting explanations by White House and Gonzales
On March 14, the White House responded to increasing criticism by offering an additional reason for the forced resignations, namely, "Lax Voter-Fraud Investigations". Counselor to the President Dan Bartlett, cited complaints about U.S. Attorneys in New Mexico, Wisconsin and Pennsylvania. [6]
[snip]
Voter-fraud complaints
According to a May 14, 2007, report by the Washington Post based off of newly released Department of Justice documents and interviews, nearly half of the attorneys who were slated for removal were targets of Republican complaints that they were lax on voter fraud, including efforts by presidential adviser Karl Rove to encourage more prosecutions of election. [76]
It's obvious there is more than meets the eye here.
Justice Official Says He Was Directed To Call Fired ProsecutorsSo on the one hand there are specious emails, on the other, there's clearly obstruction of 'coming clean' about the reason for wanting to fire the attorneys and who was involved.By Murray Waas, National Journal
© National Journal Group Inc.
Thursday, May 3, 2007
The chief of staff to Deputy Attorney General Paul McNulty has told congressional investigators that phone calls he placed to four fired U.S. attorneys -- calls that three of the prosecutors say involved threats about testifying before Congress -- were made at McNulty's direction.
Michael Elston, the chief of staff, told congressional investigators in a closed-door session on March 30 that McNulty specifically instructed him to make the phone calls after the Justice Department's No. 2 official learned that the fired prosecutors might testify before Congress about their dismissals.
A transcript of Elston's confidential interview with the congressional investigators was made available to National Journal.
The U.S. attorneys have said that Elston, in effect, told them that if they kept quiet about their dismissals, the Justice Department would not suggest that they had been forced to resign because of poor performance.
At least one member of Congress has questioned whether the phone calls might constitute obstruction of justice.
So if not the Rove '08 election influence plan, what other possibilities make more sense? And I am keeping in mind there could have been different reasons for each or some of the firings.
Gonzales hearing long on theatricsMiss Sanchez asked Mr. Gonzales why Debra Yang resigned from her U.S. attorney post in Los Angeles while her office reportedly was investigating Mr. Lewis on reports of political corruption. Miss Yang reportedly took a $1.5 million signing bonus to join Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP, the same private law firm that is representing Mr. Lewis.
Mr. Gonzales said nothing untoward happened, as cases do not end when a U.S. attorney resigns. He added that he "is not confirming that Mr. Lewis is a target," a formal legal term for a person who has been officially notified that prosecutors are investigating him.
But that wasn't enough for Rep. Dan Lungren, California Republican, who talked heatedly with four other Republicans and then objected to Miss Sanchez's words, which he said "besmirched" Mr. Lewis.
"As anybody knows, there's a huge difference between an investigation and a target," said Mr. Lungren, a former attorney general of California.
Miss Sanchez withdrew her use of the word "target" to apply to Mr. Lewis.
Less than an hour later, Rep. Chris Cannon, Utah Republican, approached Mr. Lewis in a hallway, put his arm around his shoulder and informed him of what had happened.
"Thank you," Mr. Lewis said repeatedly, before declining to speak about the matter with The Washington Times.
There's some kind of conspiracy going on here. How can anyone not think that?
Did you miss the actual story here?The soldiers weren't the target, the neighborhoods were. And the absentee ballots were targeted for rejection, not targeted to not be sent out. Surely all soldiers don't uniformly vote Republican. Apparently those dogs do hunt, but Palast just got the details wrong in the interview.They did this by an illegal process called “caging” — they sent address verification letters to primarily African-American voters, many of them soldiers serving in Iraq. Because they were in Iraq and planning to vote by absentee ballot, they were not home to reply to the verification letters. Then, when they sent in their absentee ballots, their votes were challenged and disqualified.
Regarding the voter ID and conspiracies, here's an interesting link from the Brennan Center for Justice at the NYU School of Law.Much of the hue and cry about voter fraud is accompanied by calls for restrictive ID requirements. Some of this may be a sincere, if mistaken, belief in the need for restrictive ID measures. But this clip from a May 17, 2007, Houston Chronicle article suggests another rationale:
Among Republicans it is an 'article of religious faith that voter fraud is causing us to lose elections,' [Royal] Masset[, former political director of the Republican Party of Texas,] said. He doesn't agree with that, but does believe that requiring photo IDs could cause enough of a dropoff in legitimate Democratic voting to add 3 percent to the Republican vote.
Some objections to the federal voter ID law:
Vote Trust USAThe American Association of Retired People has actively opposed voter identification legislation in several states wrote in a letter submitted into the record at last week's mark-up "On behalf of older Americans who have largely shaped the values of our democracy, we urge great care to ensure that the basic right to vote is not trampled in an effort to address unproven allegations of voting issues."
Similarly, the League of Women Voters has argued against photo ID legislation stating in the field hearing held in Phoenix, "any proposal that restricts voter registration or raises barriers to voting in order to deal with the supposed problem of non-citizen voting is a fear-based approach instead of a fact-based solution. We simply have not seen the facts that would justify restricting the franchise." These sentiments are echoed in statements from dozens of public interest and civil rights organizations.
That was May 2nd and they haven't been turned over. Here are some emails that were turned over in March. They don't help the Bush admin case....Their scathing chorus of opinion is especially striking when one considers that all of the federal prosecutors were appointed by President Bush.
Some of the most vivid stories come from Bud Cummins of Arkansas. Cummins describes his replacement, former White House aide Tim Griffin, bragging, "They are going to use the Patriot Act to appoint me."
Cummins wrote, "He said that there was a provision in the Patriot Act that nobody knew about that would enable them to appoint him in a way he could stay in place throughout President Bush's administration with or without Senate confirmation." ...
...To the question "Did you ever receive a warning from the Justice Department that your office's priorities would result in your being asked to resign?" all of the six replied, "No."
The correspondence came out from the House Judiciary Committee, which asked the fired prosecutors written questions after their live testimony earlier this year.
Also Wednesday, Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Patrick Leahy sent out a subpoena demanding that Attorney General Alberto Gonzales hand over any e-mails from White House political adviser Karl Rove about the U.S. attorney firings.
The White House says some of those e-mails may have been deleted, but the Justice Department might have them from an earlier investigation of White House aide Lewis "scooter" Libby.
The subpoena, the first that Leahy has issued in the controversy, gives the attorney general two weeks to deliver the documents.
Bush is stupid, and there's no way Carter is worse than this bunch of crooks and liars, (to borrow a quote).I don't understand why you care who is President? Since you use a term like 'stupid boy' to describe the current President you obviously have no respect for the office. I think J.Carter was the worst President of my lifetime, but I never call him by anything other than his proper name or title.
This whole issue is extremely simple.
Republicans want to diminish vote fraud because they get hurt by it.
Democrats resist any attempt to reform the voting system because they profit from illegally-cast votes.
If the effects were reversed, the parties' positions would be reversed.
Neither side gives a damn about clean elections, per se.
You forget these were all Republican Bush appointed attorneys. So now you aren't talking political philosophy, it is more likely you are talking professional integrity. If it were merely sentiments, why would the attorneys in question not be amenable to shifting positions?One thing I don't understand about this attorney-firing hubbub..
What laws allegedly were broken? As I understand it, these attorneys can be (and are) frequently fired when the administration changes for no other reason than that they were appointed by the new President's predecessor.
Patronage is deeply ingrained in American political life. Always has been, always will be. You may not like it (I certainly don't) but that's the way it is. I can only take comfort in the fact that Bush only has a year and a half to go.
Show me where I said this conspiracy was a fact.Apparently I wasn't specific enough so I need to ask again; Where did you find the sinister secret republican plan to steal the '08 election? Where and in wich documents do the ebil republicans clearly state their knowledge that they are engaging in illegal activities?
EDIT: Having read and re-read your post and the accompanying links again, I still see no proof of some vast conspiracy to hijack elections.
The only thing approaching proof I saw was Palasts claim of having 500 e-mails. Except he doesn't appear interested in posting them.
I find it hypocritical that there are good people bleeding for American democracy in Iraq and Afghanistan but Mr. Palast can't be bothered to reveal his evidence of the biggest threat to american democracy since Al Gore tried to steal the 2000 election.