Conspiracy to steal the vote again in 2008

Requiring voter ID with pictures is one way to discourage low income, minority and elderly voters.
Why do you claim that? How is having to have an ID discouraging voting? How is proving that you are who you say you are discouraging lawful voting?

ETA: Yes, things can be faked, and multiple voting identities are possible to the motivated crook. How widespread do you think this is?

Elderly people are discouraged by having to show an ID? Where do you come up with this?

Anyone poor and "minority" with an ID is discouraged from voting by having an ID?

ETA

Some months ago, I raised a question that I still don't have an answer to: how the hell do homeless people vote? My experience with voting is based on one having an address in a district/precinct, which puts you on the rolls. How does someone homeless deal with that? I have no idea.

Do you agree that an ID check is a good way to shore up the validity of a vote, of an election, if not 100% foolproof? (See above)

I show my ID each time, with my voter reg card, and the local officials (in this predominantly Democratic and Hispanic district) check to make sure I am who I claim I am, and that I am registered. I am a minority in this town: Anglo and not a Democrat.

How does any of this discourage the vote?

DR
 
Last edited:
Where did I say it "won't" help? If you're going to misquote me to disagree then it makes no difference what I write.
You wrote:
I didn't claim it would prevent it. I'm not convinced that it would eliminate any fraud although it would certainly eliminate one avenue of voter fraud ...
I asked what Avenue? You say right there, "it won't prevent it". By it I assume you mean voter fraud since that is what we are discussing. Then you go on to say the voter ID will prevent something. What specifically would voter ID accomplish that the current system of registering and going to vote and signing in on the line listing your registration doesn't? And I don't see where you think I misquoted you.

Where did I say anything about a "test"?
What I'm saying is you are comparing a simple ID card with a card that represents having at least passed a test.

Exactly! Driver license requirements don't stop people from having 2 licenses, don't stop people from driving without one. If you apply your reasoning about a voting ID requirement to driver licenses then we shouldn't require driver licenses either.
But the driver's license means you at least passed a test. Are you just ignoring that fact?

... As far as I know, the requirement to show an ID has not disfranchised anyone in Florida.
It would be a good place to do a study of the effect then. I'm for a study to see if it does or doesn't disenfranchise voters. I only present the arguments being made. I am not making the arguments. Show me the research any time.

But I am making the argument voter ID is a waste of time, money, and is meant to distract from the real issues interfering with valid elections.
 
Last edited:
Provided requiring voter ID accomplishes something, then some of these arguments may have merit. But I haven't seen much evidence validating that ID at the polls will have the desired effect. So I ask you all for that evidence, rather than just complaints of what's the big deal.

In the mean time, the waste of resources on this issue is one thing, heres a bit more. We have these reports on who doesn't have these documents for those of you who think everyone in the country must be just like you, there is the legal costs of all the lawsuits, and there are the unintended consequences.

Missouri Voter ID Requirement Burdens the Elderly; by Bill Beene

These individuals are less likely to have a car, therefore a driver's license, not to mention affording the fees for the necessary "feeder documents" required to get a license, such as a birth certificate or a passport.

September 19, 2005; Voting Rights Advocates Challenge Georgia Photo ID Law in Federal Court; Measure Decried as "New Poll Tax," Violates State, Federal Constitutions
The $20 fee that is required to obtain a five year state ID card is an unconstitutional poll tax that violates the Twenty-Fourth Amendment," said Neil Bradley, associate director of the American Civil Liberties Union Voting Rights Project in Atlanta. In addition, lawyers for the plaintiffs say H.B. 244:

Are you a citizen? Prove it; By Kavan Peterson, Stateline.org Staff Writer
When Colorado state Sen. Andy McElhany (R) championed adoption of the strictest identification requirements in the country, his aim was to keep illegal immigrants off state welfare rolls. He didn’t anticipate making it harder for his 15-year-old daughter to get a learner’s permit.

But that’s what happened when his wife and daughter showed up at the Division of Motor Vehicles office in Colorado Springs in September. They brought the teen’s passport, only to discover DMV had changed the rules and a passport was no longer a sufficient form of identification.

“There's no reason to believe a 15-year-old girl is going to be running around with a fake passport just to get a driver's permit," a chagrined McElhany said.
Going to the DMV never has been a walk in the park, but it’s likely to get even more difficult as states across the country begin to comply with stringent federal identification rules required by the 2005 Real ID Act.

Americans by the tens of millions will have to dig out documents such as Social Security cards and birth certificates, or go to the expense of getting new ones, to renew their driver’s licenses. Fears of terrorism and the uproar over illegal immigration are behind the new rules. The Real ID Act is a response to the fact that four of the 19 foreign hijackers on Sept. 11 had obtained valid U.S. driver’s licenses.

Again, I'll go with the evidence here. I'm not ranting about any cause. So far my son has been unable to correct his name with the Social Security Administration even though he took in his passport, original birth certificate, and a signed original court order showing his name was changed. They wanted a corrected birth certificate along with the original one. We are waiting for that document.

But as I said in another thread, he had no trouble getting a job even though his SSN and name don't match. But he couldn't get a bank account, they had an instant check at the bank. Even there with the signed court order they didn't care. The SSN had to match the name. So he can get an account in the wrong name.

Needless to say, none of this makes me feel any safer, it's obvious the rich and powerful don't want to discourage illegal workers, there is no evidence large numbers of illegal aliens voted, nor is there evidence voter ID will impact that anyway.
 
Most photo ID's are not free. Requiring a photo ID frequently amounts to a poll tax. This is why Georgia's voter id law was overturned. Note that many of the lawyers in the US Attorney's voter fraud office said the law would be overturned and recommended the US Attorney not support Georgia's law. He did anyway.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/10/27/AR2005102702171.html

Some states have setup systems where voter id cards can be obtained for free. I believe the argument against these is that the mere requirement of being forced to stand before a person, not a member of the voter board, and be denied the right to vote (by refusing to issue a card) is illegal. Not sure this has been tested in court yet.

Note, most poor people do not have photo id's. They live on a cash basis, they cash pay checks (if not paid in cash) at check cashing places (usually no photo id required for a pay check), and don't have bank accounts. I got my bank account when I started High School. I had no photo id to when I got the account and in the years since I've never presented them with a photo id.

BTW, here is an analysis of the New Jersey state Attorney General to purge voting rolls in 2005.
The analysts found serious methodological problems with the report, echoing the problems with the notoriously flawed “suspected felon” purge lists in Florida in 2000 and 2004. They cautioned election officials not to rely on the flawed report and urged the Attorney General to follow the normal statutory procedures for maintaining the state’s voter registration rolls.

http://www.brennancenter.org/press_detail.asp?key=100&subkey=35619
 
It's unfortunate that a skeptic would believe that red herring. It's been thrown out there by the Bush team to try to cover up what is going on here.

The actions are not in any way equivalent. In one case you have a changing of the guard. Bush and Clinton both changed all the federal attorneys under the Attorney General, just like they changed Attorney Generals. But once you appoint those attorneys, they are independent. They are not, as I said in another post, the President's henchmen. If it were merely more normal staff changes, business as usual, then Gonzales should have been able to explain. The only reason he cannot explain why these attorneys were fired is the explanation isn't good. And these guys are going to great lengths to cover up the reason. So the reason must really not be good.

It's a red herring to you because...why? The federal attorneys are an appointed position and can be released at any time by the President. If they're not doing what he wants them to do he can let them go. Is it unusual, odd...possibly a bit slimy? Yup. It's politics. But until we get some actual evidence (and not trying to extrapolate that "the reason must really not be good" because they haven;t come up with a reason viable to you) we've got nothing to go on.

Right now there's no evidence of any conspiracy. Just the 500 phantom emails that you want us to take at face value until they're proven false...which is backwards. It's unfortunate that a skeptic would forget that "Extraordinary claims require extraoprdinary evidence", and this certainly falls into the realm of "extraordinary claim".
 
Note, most poor people do not have photo id's. They live on a cash basis, they cash pay checks (if not paid in cash) at check cashing places (usually no photo id required for a pay check), and don't have bank accounts.

Where do you live? I've lived in a few different states and never have I seen a check cashing place cash paychecks when you dont have an ID.

At least not legally.
 
why would be illegal to cash a check without a photo id?

To prevent theft?

If it's that easy to cash checks I think there'd be a lot more paycheck fraud than there is. There's a reason thugs watch people coming out of check cashing establishments and banks and follow them instead of mugging them after work or mail is delivered on paydays or days when they get their welfare or social security checks.

I cant say it's impossible that there's a check cashing business that does'nt require some type of ID, but I've never heard of one if there is.
 
You wrote:I asked what Avenue? You say right there, "it won't prevent it". By it I assume you mean voter fraud since that is what we are discussing. Then you go on to say the voter ID will prevent something.

So you're saying that in your understanding of the english language that if action #1 prevents action #2- that means that doing action #1 would keep action #2 from ever happening. In other words, speed limits don't "prevent" accidents because we have speed limits yet accidents still happen. Or having laws against bank robbery don't prevent people from robbing banks because we have those laws and people still rob banks?

Or is it maybe possible to take steps to prevent something and yet still have that something happen although possibly with less frequency?

What I did say was:

I'm not convinced that it would eliminate any fraud although it would certainly eliminate one avenue of voter fraud ...

That avenue would be eliminated whether it's currently being used or not. If it's not happening then it will continue to not happen with one difference- it will be prevented in the future should people decide to do that.

What I'm saying is you are comparing a simple ID card with a card that represents having at least passed a test.

Only because we can't require people to pass a test before letting them vote. Personally I think that might not be a bad idea either- make everyone pass a test on the constitution, current events and a few other subjects before allowing them to vote.

But the driver's license means you at least passed a test. Are you just ignoring that fact?

Yes, I'm ignoring that fact because it's not relevant to this topic (although if someone gets a fake license they probably didn't pass a test). And there are many 85 year old drivers who haven't passed a test in 65 years- making the passing of a test even less relevant.

I only present the arguments being made. I am not making the arguments. Show me the research any time.

But I am making the argument voter ID is a waste of time, money, and is meant to distract from the real issues interfering with valid elections.

In one paragraph you claim that you're not making any arguments and ask for research (evidence). In the very next paragraph you contradict yourself and you do make an argument. So do you agree with the arguments you're presenting? I assume that if you didn't you wouldn't present them. Therefore (unless my assumption is wrong) you are "presenting" them rather than "making" them simply because using the term "present" absolves you of having to support them.
 
Right now there's no evidence of any conspiracy. Just the 500 phantom emails that you want us to take at face value until they're proven false...which is backwards.

There's no evidence of conspiracy- but Gonzalez alone (his varying testimony) are evidence that either something is being covered up and/or that he's the most incompetent AG in history.

I think it's up to congress to find out what is being covered up and Gonzalez should resign because he's either incompetent and/or involved in a cover-up.

I don't buy the 500 phantom emails though.
 
It's a red herring to you because...why? The federal attorneys are an appointed position and can be released at any time by the President. If they're not doing what he wants them to do he can let them go. Is it unusual, odd...possibly a bit slimy? Yup. It's politics. But until we get some actual evidence (and not trying to extrapolate that "the reason must really not be good" because they haven;t come up with a reason viable to you) we've got nothing to go on.

Right now there's no evidence of any conspiracy. Just the 500 phantom emails that you want us to take at face value until they're proven false...which is backwards. It's unfortunate that a skeptic would forget that "Extraordinary claims require extraoprdinary evidence", and this certainly falls into the realm of "extraordinary claim".
So the obvious cover up going on isn't evidence? Is that your position? Is your head in the sand? Seriously.

I am assuming you didn't watch the pitiful Gonzales on the witness stand making statements like, "I don't know who put the attorney's names on the list." "I don't know why they were fired." "I don't know who to ask to find out." "I can't give you the rest of the emails because I recused myself from involvement since I'm being investigated." I kid you not on the last one. Gonzales told the committee he couldn't release the emails, not he wouldn't. Did he put someone else in charge of that decision after recusing himself? Nope.

The reason firing all attorneys when taking office and appointing new ones is a red herring is because it clearly isn't the same thing going on here. When you change attorneys normally, you don't have to cover up the reason. You don't have staff PLEADING the 5th.

You can believe your fairy tale a few more days. At least until Ms 'plead the 5th' Goodling testifies with her granted immunity on the 23rd.
 
So you're saying that in your understanding of the english language that if action #1 prevents action #2- that means that doing action #1 would keep action #2 from ever happening. In other words, speed limits don't "prevent" accidents because we have speed limits yet accidents still happen. Or having laws against bank robbery don't prevent people from robbing banks because we have those laws and people still rob banks?

Or is it maybe possible to take steps to prevent something and yet still have that something happen although possibly with less frequency?

What I did say was:

That avenue would be eliminated whether it's currently being used or not. If it's not happening then it will continue to not happen with one difference- it will be prevented in the future should people decide to do that.
Bob, are you dense or what? I am simply asking you what avenue are you talking about? You say the ID's will accomplish something. WHAT will they accomplish? I'm just asking you to clarify what you mean by the following sentence you said, "although it would certainly eliminate one avenue of voter fraud". What avenue of voter fraud????????????? This is the third time I am asking you to just clarify what you mean. All that other stuff about action #1 and 2, good grief! "That avenue" 'That' is a pronoun. What do you mean when you say, "That avenue"????


Only because we can't require people to pass a test before letting them vote. Personally I think that might not be a bad idea either- make everyone pass a test on the constitution, current events and a few other subjects before allowing them to vote.
You are completely off on a tangent here. This has nothing to do with your statement, "If you apply your reasoning about a voting ID requirement to driver licenses then we shouldn't require driver licenses either." We require drivers to prove they can drive. Your statement about applying my reasoning is wrong because voter ID and driver's licenses are not equal examples.

In one paragraph you claim that you're not making any arguments and ask for research (evidence). In the very next paragraph you contradict yourself and you do make an argument. So do you agree with the arguments you're presenting? I assume that if you didn't you wouldn't present them. Therefore (unless my assumption is wrong) you are "presenting" them rather than "making" them simply because using the term "present" absolves you of having to support them.
It's really hard to discuss this with you because you don't understand what I've said. I don't see how else to explain it to you right now. I'll try again tomorrow.
 
You know, if you just want to get rid of Gonzales because of your political ideology just say so.

I dont like the guy either but for a different reason. He's letting the border patrol agents get shot at from drug dealers crossing borders and if they return fire they're prosecuted. They basically have to run away .
He's not letting them do their jobs. He stinks!!

But quit with the steal the vote conspiracy BS. Not one of those links have anything substantial to them.

And you bring up the point well Clinton fired them all so that was'nt political rhetoric. There is a train of thought that Clinton fired them all in order to not be accused of firing the one investigating Whitewater.

Was he sneakier yea. But dont throw him out there as an example.
 
It is however, true. Attorneys in the Justice Department may be fired or hired at will. As others have said, it is really the possible coverup that Gonzales is in hot water for.


(Incidently, while ID does cost some money, I believe there are ways to get one without any money being required. I'm not quite sure about that, though.)
 
Drysdale, you continue to ignore the cover-up here. What is being covered up?

Changing attorneys for political philosophy is the current way the Dept of Justice is set up and currently legal. Firing attorneys to manipulate their actions, which are independent for critical reasons, (you know, that little balance of powers thing in the Constitution, :rolleyes: ), is not legal.
 
It is however, true. Attorneys in the Justice Department may be fired or hired at will. As others have said, it is really the possible coverup that Gonzales is in hot water for.
The cover up, the reason for the cover up and who else is involved in the reason for the cover up are indeed what is at issue here.

(Incidently, while ID does cost some money, I believe there are ways to get one without any money being required. I'm not quite sure about that, though.)

The skeptical steps here are, first, is there a problem that the IDs are intended to address; second, will the IDs effectively address the problem and are they the best way to address it; and third, are there unintended consequences the ID solution will create?

I see no evidence there was massive voter impersonation (IDs would address that). If there were significant numbers of non-citizens voting (no evidence but assuming there was), then picture ID is not an efficient way of confirming citizenship. Citizenship is best confirmed during the registration process because there is time to verify address and citizenship. So send out registration confirmation and require the person bring it or vote with a provisional ballot. If your confirmation is lost or stolen, you can report that and the thief would be caught when they went in to vote. That alone would discourage voter impersonation.

Seems more logical to me to actually identify the problem and connect the solution to it rather than drumming the sound bite that illegal immigrants are voting and implying voter ID would somehow prevent that travesty.
 
Provided requiring voter ID accomplishes something, then some of these arguments may have merit. But I haven't seen much evidence validating that ID at the polls will have the desired effect. So I ask you all for that evidence, rather than just complaints of what's the big deal.

In the mean time, the waste of resources on this issue is one thing, heres a bit more. We have these reports on who doesn't have these documents for those of you who think everyone in the country must be just like you, there is the legal costs of all the lawsuits, and there are the unintended consequences.

Missouri Voter ID Requirement Burdens the Elderly; by Bill Beene

These individuals are less likely to have a car, therefore a driver's license, not to mention affording the fees for the necessary "feeder documents" required to get a license, such as a birth certificate or a passport.

September 19, 2005; Voting Rights Advocates Challenge Georgia Photo ID Law in Federal Court; Measure Decried as "New Poll Tax," Violates State, Federal Constitutions

Are you a citizen? Prove it; By Kavan Peterson, Stateline.org Staff Writer

Again, I'll go with the evidence here. I'm not ranting about any cause. So far my son has been unable to correct his name with the Social Security Administration even though he took in his passport, original birth certificate, and a signed original court order showing his name was changed. They wanted a corrected birth certificate along with the original one. We are waiting for that document.

But as I said in another thread, he had no trouble getting a job even though his SSN and name don't match. But he couldn't get a bank account, they had an instant check at the bank. Even there with the signed court order they didn't care. The SSN had to match the name. So he can get an account in the wrong name.

Needless to say, none of this makes me feel any safer, it's obvious the rich and powerful don't want to discourage illegal workers, there is no evidence large numbers of illegal aliens voted, nor is there evidence voter ID will impact that anyway.
Your links are evidence of some strong opinions, and the interesting problem of how you can show proof of who you are. The problem of fraud, and its spread, is that the need to prove who you are increases over time in order to reign in abuse of loopholes.

To equate proving who you are equivalent to poll tax about stretches my patience. Twenty dollars over five years is a burden? The appeal to victim status is noted, as is the problem of the small group of people who fit into the odd category the lady in Mr Beene's article are.

What is the magnitude of this population, among citizens? Compare that to the magnitude of this among illegal residents?

Problem is, even with better ID and control and the registration end, that does not address skullduggery with how votes are handled, "sampled" and tabulated. It isn't a matter of fixing one problem, or the other, it is of fixing them all.

Put another way, why should a state ID cost anything for those without a DL? It is to the state's benefit that you have one, why should it cost anything at all for the lady in Beene's article? Has anyone addressed that?

DR
 
Bob, are you dense or what? I am simply asking you what avenue are you talking about? You say the ID's will accomplish something. WHAT will they accomplish? I'm just asking you to clarify what you mean by the following sentence you said, "although it would certainly eliminate one avenue of voter fraud". What avenue of voter fraud?????????????


Are I dense? The avenue of walking into a polling place and claiming to be someone you're not so you can vote. That avenue. The avenue about which I also said "That avenue would be eliminated whether it's currently being used or not." Considering that's the topic of discussion I assumed that would be clear several posts ago.

That's as clear as I can make it.

"That avenue" 'That' is a pronoun. What do you mean when you say, "That avenue"????


I didn't realize your attention span was so short that the topic of the discussion had to be re-explained with every post.

You are completely off on a tangent here. This has nothing to do with your statement, "If you apply your reasoning about a voting ID requirement to driver licenses then we shouldn't require driver licenses either." We require drivers to prove they can drive.


No, we use driver's licenses to show that the state has determined that you meet the legal requirements to drive. Just as a photo ID could show that you meet (at least one) of the legal requirements to vote.

Your statement about applying my reasoning is wrong because voter ID and driver's licenses are not equal examples.


Analogies are never exactly equal examples. That doesn't automatically invalidate them.

It's really hard to discuss this with you because you don't understand what I've said. I don't see how else to explain it to you right now. I'll try again tomorrow.


Apparently I don't understand what you've said- except for the part of what you said that I addressed in my last post- the paragraph you didn't answer.

In one paragraph you claim that you're not making any arguments and ask for research (evidence). In the very next paragraph you contradict yourself and you do make an argument. So do you agree with the arguments you're presenting? I assume that if you didn't you wouldn't present them. Therefore (unless my assumption is wrong) you are "presenting" them rather than "making" them simply because using the term "present" absolves you of having to support them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom