Conspiracy to steal the vote again in 2008

Your links are evidence of some strong opinions, and the interesting problem of how you can show proof of who you are. The problem of fraud, and its spread, is that the need to prove who you are increases over time in order to reign in abuse of loopholes.

To equate proving who you are equivalent to poll tax about stretches my patience. Twenty dollars over five years is a burden? The appeal to victim status is noted, as is the problem of the small group of people who fit into the odd category the lady in Mr Beene's article are.

What is the magnitude of this population, among citizens? Compare that to the magnitude of this among illegal residents?

Problem is, even with better ID and control and the registration end, that does not address skullduggery with how votes are handled, "sampled" and tabulated. It isn't a matter of fixing one problem, or the other, it is of fixing them all.

Put another way, why should a state ID cost anything for those without a DL? It is to the state's benefit that you have one, why should it cost anything at all for the lady in Beene's article? Has anyone addressed that?

DR

My strongest opinion is that a false claim is being made that significant numbers of illegal aliens voted. Where is the evidence this happened? So far all that's been posted is the dislike of the fact ballots are printed in more than one language and foreign language speakers were overheard at the voting polls. That smacks more of prejudice than evidence.

In addition, I think those who believe $20 is not a burden for some to vote need to take a trip to the rural south and Appalachia and maybe a few Indian reservations that don't have casinos. You might also visit some of the poorest elderly among us. You may just find you've been living in a sheltered world.

As I said above, I'd agree with the IDs if there was evidence of a problem that the IDs are intended to address, if the IDs will effectively address the problem and if they are the best way to address it, and if there are unintended consequences the ID solution will create, then those should be addressed with the ID requirement laws.


Where's the evidence for the problem and this solution?
 
Citizenship is best confirmed during the registration process because there is time to verify address and citizenship. So send out registration confirmation and require the person bring it or vote with a provisional ballot. If your confirmation is lost or stolen, you can report that and the thief would be caught when they went in to vote. That alone would discourage voter impersonation.


I would support that also- perhaps even in place of an ID requirement, provided that it was not a one- time requirement that could be open to abuse (say- after some died). But aside from you and me, it would be interesting to see how many of the people currently against ID's would also be against that plan (just so you're not confused "that plan" being the plan covered in your quote above).

Because my theory is that many of the people who are against ID requirements for voters are against it because they think it's an avenue of illegal extra votes that support that side. Naturally I could be wrong, but I've shown as much evidence for that as you have for the opposing view.
 
Are I dense? The avenue of walking into a polling place and claiming to be someone you're not so you can vote. That avenue. The avenue about which I also said "That avenue would be eliminated whether it's currently being used or not." Considering that's the topic of discussion I assumed that would be clear several posts ago.

That's as clear as I can make it.

I didn't realize your attention span was so short that the topic of the discussion had to be re-explained with every post.
Finally! It has nothing to do with attention span. It has to do with you assuming a problem when there is no evidence it exists.

What evidence do you have people voted in significant numbers (in other words more than a handful of cases) pretending to be someone else?

And if they did, is the problem that they registered under false names or that they stole someone else's vote? Wouldn't that person whose vote was stolen have noticed when they went to vote, someone had already voted for them? How would the vote stealer know they were going to get to the polls before the voter?

This is just not a logical way to cheat at the polls.

A few people could be voting for a deceased relative. So make sure death certificates result in voter registration cancellation. That makes more sense than requiring ID at the polls.

No, we use driver's licenses to show that the state has determined that you meet the legal requirements to drive. Just as a photo ID could show that you meet (at least one) of the legal requirements to vote.
Except if you have an ID that doesn't require being a citizen. You can also have more than one address on different IDs.

You take a test to get your driver's license. Are you claiming that my son, for example, has to prove he is a citizen to get his college photo ID? He's 18, did he need to prove he was a citizen to get his school picture ASB card? My Costco card has my picture on it. Our season passes to Wild Waves had our pictures on them.

As to your claim I have opinions while claiming I don't care... You don't understand, if there is evidence the IDs are needed, I don't object to the IDs. But there is no evidence they solve anything, let alone evidence there were significant numbers of people impersonating other voters.
 
My strongest opinion is that a false claim is being made that significant numbers of illegal aliens voted. Where is the evidence this happened? So far all that's been posted is the dislike of the fact ballots are printed in more than one language and foreign language speakers were overheard at the voting polls. That smacks more of prejudice than evidence.

In addition, I think those who believe $20 is not a burden for some to vote need to take a trip to the rural south and Appalachia and maybe a few Indian reservations that don't have casinos. You might also visit some of the poorest elderly among us. You may just find you've been living in a sheltered world.

As I said above, I'd agree with the IDs if there was evidence of a problem that the IDs are intended to address, if the IDs will effectively address the problem and if they are the best way to address it, and if there are unintended consequences the ID solution will create, then those should be addressed with the ID requirement laws.


Where's the evidence for the problem and this solution?

Let's apply a modicum of reason, SG.

Jim Wells county is not too far from where I live. It is the infamous site of Lyndon Johnson's well told tale of success in getting ballot boxes stuffed, dead people voting, etc.

An ID check mitigates the risk of that recurring. Risk management. That voting fraud happened is reason enough to believe that it can, and will, happen again.

So, prudent steps can and should be taken to reduce the risk.

If you find that other than rational, how can we have a conversation?

Twenty dollars over four years, a burden? Nope. Not in 2007.

However, I contend that it is in the state's interest to provide the ID and process of verification for the rare persons in the "don't drive/have a license" category without charge, as it is in the State's interest for all to be verifiable as legal and registered voters.

Mitigate/reduce risk of voting fraud. It is that important, a hell of a lot more important than crap like CPS.

DR
 
Finally! It has nothing to do with attention span. It has to do with you assuming a problem when there is no evidence it exists.

I haven't assumed there's a problem. I've said there is the potential for one.

What evidence do you have people voted in significant numbers (in other words more than a handful of cases) pretending to be someone else?

That assumes I've made a claim I didn't make. It also fails to define "significant numbers". How many phony votes are required to make it significant? In 2000, 300 to 500 votes in Florida would have been pretty significant since that's the number it would have taken to put Gore the White House.

And if they did, is the problem that they registered under false names or that they stole someone else's vote?

Makes no difference- there should be measures in place to prevent both.

Wouldn't that person whose vote was stolen have noticed when they went to vote, someone had already voted for them? How would the vote stealer know they were going to get to the polls before the voter?

In most elections there's less than a 50-50 chance that the person whose vote was stolen would know since it's rare for even a 50% turnout in an election. And if the stolen vote was in place of a dead person it's unlikely the dead person would show up and find out.

A few people could be voting for a deceased relative. So make sure death certificates result in voter registration cancellation. That makes more sense than requiring ID at the polls.

Or do both.

Except if you have an ID that doesn't require being a citizen.

Which is why proof of citizenship should be required at registration.

You take a test to get your driver's license. Are you claiming that my son, for example, has to prove he is a citizen to get his college photo ID? He's 18, did he need to prove he was a citizen to get his school picture ASB card? My Costco card has my picture on it. Our season passes to Wild Waves had our pictures on them.

Photo ID is not proof of citizenship. Photo ID is proof (or evidence since fake IDs do exist) that you are really you and not someone else pretending to be you. Citizenship is not shown by photo ID which is why that should be shown when registering.

As to your claim I have opinions while claiming I don't care...

I don't recall making that claim and can't seem to find it in any of my posts.
 
So far, the Goodling testimony does not have the revelations the committee is looking for, but some additional ones nonetheless.

Goodling admits violating civil service laws in her role firing career prosecutors and putting the 150 inexperienced lawyers from Pat Robertson's law school in their place. She admitted it was "against the rules" (her wording when asked twice if she knew it was "illegal").

But oh what a tangled web is weaved..... Goodling claims to have been less involved in the federal attorney firings, which is interesting for a couple other things she said. One, apparently McNulty (guy under Gonzales who resigned and has become Gonzales' scape goat {after contradictory statements, of course by Gonzales earlier}) blamed Goodling in his testimony for not being properly briefed by Goodling. So Goodling refuted that and we have a, 'he said she said' now. Apparently not everyone believes Ms Goodling is too Christian to be above lying. OTOH, it's seems to me more like everyone has a version of reality where they are the good guy. Goodling was likely steamed hearing what sounded like McNulty blaming her for his actions.

The second issue here besides all these Christians blaming each other (someone has to be "bearing false witness"), is the thing Goodling says McNulty falsely testified about. That is, the White House involvement in the attorney firings. So I await more details about this area of inquiry. I haven't seen a clear picture arise yet just what Goodling briefed McNulty on that he claimed to be ignorant of. Now I need to go back and look at McNulty's testimony where he speaks about Goodling.


As usual, of course, the Bush supporters (you'd think they would be getting a clue by now) are spewing the talking point, there is nothing here but some politics as usual in the attorney firings. In other words, because Goodling's testimony has failed to reveal what the federal attorneys were fired for, there is no evidence anything bad happened. Of course that position continues to ignore the fact no one is saying really why these attorneys were fired. If it isn't a big deal, what's with the cover up?
 
Let's apply a modicum of reason, SG.

Jim Wells county is not too far from where I live. It is the infamous site of Lyndon Johnson's well told tale of success in getting ballot boxes stuffed, dead people voting, etc.

An ID check mitigates the risk of that recurring. Risk management. That voting fraud happened is reason enough to believe that it can, and will, happen again.

So, prudent steps can and should be taken to reduce the risk.

If you find that other than rational, how can we have a conversation?

Twenty dollars over four years, a burden? Nope. Not in 2007.

However, I contend that it is in the state's interest to provide the ID and process of verification for the rare persons in the "don't drive/have a license" category without charge, as it is in the State's interest for all to be verifiable as legal and registered voters.

Mitigate/reduce risk of voting fraud. It is that important, a hell of a lot more important than crap like CPS.

DR
If you define "burden" as one which causes someone not to vote, it is unconstitutional.
24th Amendment
Amendment Text | Annotations

Section 1. The right of citizens of the United States to vote in any primary or other election for President or Vice President, for electors for President or Vice President, or for Senator or Representative in Congress, shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or any State by reason of failure to pay any poll tax or other tax.

Section 2. The Congress shall have power to enforce this article by appropriate legislation.
Calling it a fee doesn't negate the violation of this amendment.

I understand you are of the opinion, if it isn't worth $5/yr to you to vote, tough luck. But the reality is, the 24th amendment says you should be able to vote without having any fee be part of your decision.

As to the dead people impersonations, doesn't it make more sense to use death certificate files to purge voter registration rolls? Wouldn't most votes by the deceased have come in via absentee ballot anyway? Not to mention if ID is required, absentee ballot is an easy way around the problem?

I still say voter ID accomplishes nothing.
 
Last edited:
I haven't assumed there's a problem. I've said there is the potential for one.

That assumes I've made a claim I didn't make. It also fails to define "significant numbers". How many phony votes are required to make it significant? In 2000, 300 to 500 votes in Florida would have been pretty significant since that's the number it would have taken to put Gore the White House.

Makes no difference- there should be measures in place to prevent both.
So we should enact legislation and pay for implementing the law and any legal challenges that are sure to follow when there is no actual problem, only a possible problem, and absentee ballots are an easy way around the ID requirement?

You really want your tax dollars wasted on this?

In most elections there's less than a 50-50 chance that the person whose vote was stolen would know since it's rare for even a 50% turnout in an election. And if the stolen vote was in place of a dead person it's unlikely the dead person would show up and find out.
Bob, show me this actually happens and I'll be more sympathetic to your view. I can imagine all sorts of problems and solutions to spend money on.

If wide scale voter impersonation were going to actually take place, then someone is going to used the names of people that didn't show up to vote to stuff the ballot box some place in the vote procedure. How many people are going to say, "Gee, my neighbor didn't vote, I think I'll go vote for them?" There can't be more than a handful of cases! If I want to vote for my Mom who is registered and not going out to vote, I'm not going to go to the polls where in my case my neighbors who know me are working anyway. I'm going to mail in an absentee ballot.

This idea of all these people out there voting multiple times and voter ID is going to change that is ludicrous. I still think people who think IDs are needed have an inaccurate view of how you vote. You don't just saunter into the voting booth and vote. You register ahead of time and when you vote your name is there, OR YOU CAN'T VOTE! If you want to cheat, you'd just need to register fake names and send in absentee ballots.

What is wrong here is people seem to think I'm advocating no one should have to prove anything to vote. That's nonsense, of course they should. But voter IDs addresses one problem there is no evidence occurs in any significant way, and is easily avoided with absentee ballots. In other words all voter ID does is stop people physically claiming to be someone else who is registered to vote at the polls. There is no evidence people show up at the polls impersonating voters. If they did, the 50 50 chance as you say still means a lot of people would go to vote and find someone already voted under the real voter's name. THERE WOULD BE AT LEAST SOME, IF NOT LOTS OF CASES. Where are the cases? Anyone voting for dead people would mail in their ballots.


I don't recall making that claim and can't seem to find it in any of my posts.
This is what you said, post 189:
In one paragraph you claim that you're not making any arguments and ask for research (evidence). In the very next paragraph you contradict yourself and you do make an argument. So do you agree with the arguments you're presenting? I assume that if you didn't you wouldn't present them. Therefore (unless my assumption is wrong) you are "presenting" them rather than "making" them simply because using the term "present" absolves you of having to support them.
I don't agree or disagree. I would need evidence before drawing a conclusion.
 
Last edited:
So we should enact legislation and pay for implementing the law and any legal challenges that are sure to follow when there is no actual problem, only a possible problem, and absentee ballots are an easy way around the ID requirement?

You really want your tax dollars wasted on this?

I don't like my tax dollars wasted on anything. But with the billions that are wasted to accomplish absolutely nothing (such as bridges to nowhere), this would be an insignificant speck of money that might actually accomplish something.

And if the stolen vote was in place of a dead person it's unlikely the dead person would show up and find out.

Bob, show me this actually happens and I'll be more sympathetic to your view. I can imagine all sorts of problems and solutions to spend money on.

It may (or may not) have happened last year or in 2000, I don't think there's much dispute that it has happened in the past. And you can pick any spending bill in congress and find items where the money would be better spent on other problems and solutions. The first problem is that even if you eliminate the waste the money is likely to be spent on other waste.

And even if voter ID is a complete waste of money, if that's your biggest argument against it then your time would be better spent fighting some of the waste that actually costs a significant amount.

This idea of all these people out there voting multiple times and voter ID is going to change that is ludicrous.

I don't know how ludicrous it is- I don't know how often it happens. But it's like other crimes- just because it doesn't happen a lot doesn't mean it should be ignored.


As to your claim I have opinions while claiming I don't care...

This is what you said, post 189:

I didn't say you "didn't care" there.
 
I don't like my tax dollars wasted on anything. But with the billions that are wasted to accomplish absolutely nothing (such as bridges to nowhere), this would be an insignificant speck of money that might actually accomplish something.

It may (or may not) have happened last year or in 2000, I don't think there's much dispute that it has happened in the past. And you can pick any spending bill in congress and find items where the money would be better spent on other problems and solutions. The first problem is that even if you eliminate the waste the money is likely to be spent on other waste.

And even if voter ID is a complete waste of money, if that's your biggest argument against it then your time would be better spent fighting some of the waste that actually costs a significant amount.

I don't know how ludicrous it is- I don't know how often it happens. But it's like other crimes- just because it doesn't happen a lot doesn't mean it should be ignored.
So let's spend money on a problem that may not exist and let's spend it on a solution that is not the best solution if the problem did exist. How hard is it to understand my position here?

Where are your critical thinking skills. Look for evidence of the problem. Determine if the solution is the best one. Then invest in the solution. That's how intelligent people deal with problems.

What do manipulators do? They stir up fear and loathing and distract you from the real cheating that is benefiting them currently. Much better to cry, "illegal immigrants are stealing the vote. The vote cheating you are hearing about, that is people voting more than once, we care too. We need voter ID, we need voter ID." And without thinking about the "evidence" both for the problem actually existing, and for the solution actually working, the masses follow the piper.

What does the evidence show? More people were unable to vote because the availability of voting machines were manipulated. That was well documented in Ohio. People were purged from voter roles that shouldn't have been and it was done by Republicans in official positions where they had charge over the voting process. That was well documented. "Caging" occurred by Republicans in official positions sending out letters which if they weren't replied to resulted in more voter purging from the registration roles, again purging more Democratic Party voters than Republicans. That was well documented.

Did other cheating go on? Yes. Tires were slashed by Democrats to stop vans from driving Republicans to the polls. Phone systems were jammed by Republicans to stop get out the vote calling by Democrats on election day. Republicans also called Democratic voters telling them to go to the wrong polling place or that they could vote Tuesday and Wednesday. Those actions were well documented.

None of those well documented voter problems are the least bit corrected by implementing voter ID requirements. So why are you letting the Republicans who don't want cheating corrected to distract you with voter ID issues?

I didn't say you "didn't care" there.
You said I contradicted myself. I didn't. I don't care specifically about the ID requirement. I care about using evidence to identify problems, to identify the best solutions and to identify unintended consequences that the solutions might result in.

I posted the evidence of those unintended consequences. If you or anyone has any contradictory evidence about the unintended consequences, produce it. I have only seen so far, opinions the unintended consequences are not significant.

Obviously many people have opinions about the significance the cost of voter ID will be. Those opinions differ. I have no reason to accept the opinions here that the cost of the ID is insignificant, because no evidence has been presented actually evaluating the impact voter ID has on impeding certain voters.

There is evidence poll taxes, even small ones disenfranchise certain voters. That evidence led to a Constitutional Amendment. I'd say that was pretty significant.


I have followed the voting issues from both the 00 and 04 elections. I have seen no evidence people impersonated voters nor that illegal aliens voted in significant numbers. A few cases were documented, especially voting for deceased relatives. I saw no evidence that occurred more by one party over the other, nor that it affected any election outcome.

There were allegations such illegal votes affected the outcome of the governor's election in WA State, my state. The Republican, Christian, Bush appointed federal attorney, McCay, elected not to pursue the issue because the Republicans sought out such illegal votes only in King County, a Democratic leaning county. Those same Republicans did not look at the illegal votes in any other part of the state. The Republican, Christian, Bush appointed, federal prosecutor after weighing all the evidence in this important matter, determined there was not sufficient evidence to pursue a case.

McCay also testified before the Oversight Committee on these attorney firings that he received a call from one Republican Congressman which McCay interpreted as an illegal attempt to influence the investigation and possible prosecution over the WA State election.

That is what the evidence shows. I have seen no evidence that problems occurred which voter ID will address.

Skeptics should be asking about the evidence, not about which party is at fault or which will benefit. I do not take the position, they all do it. I don't care. That is a red herring. I care about the evidence. And I care about political manipulation of the masses of people who are suckered by the unsupported claims that we should focus on voter IDs.


"How fortunate for leaders that men do not think." Adolf Hitler.

-
 
Where are your critical thinking skills. Look for evidence of the problem. Determine if the solution is the best one. Then invest in the solution. That's how intelligent people deal with problems.

Well that's a whole different ball game. I thought w were talking about how congress should deal with the problem. I'd say the intelligent thing is to pass a voter ID act, make the ID free and move on to the real problems.

That was well documented. "Caging" occurred by Republicans in official positions sending out letters which if they weren't replied to resulted in more voter purging from the registration roles, again purging more Democratic Party voters than Republicans. That was well documented.

If you're talking about the claims in those 500 unverified emails, that's hardly "well documented". And (as Darth has pointed out several times- as stated it's a fairly stupid method of attempting to purge the votes you want to purge).

You said I contradicted myself. I didn't.

You said:
I only present the arguments being made. I am not making the arguments.
And then:
But I am making the argument voter ID is a waste of time

You said you were not making the arguments. Then you made an argument. That stuck me as a contradiction. (But I still see nothing I wrote claiming that you "don't care", and that's what you said that I claimed).

I don't care specifically about the ID requirement.

Neither do I really. I'd much rather see proof of citizenship required before registering to vote. But for the piddling cost of providing free ID to all voters who don't have ID, I'd rather just do it and then spend the time on fixing bigger problems. The democrats (and anti-ID supporters like you) will spent all your time and energy fighting the ID requirement and when it's all done the other problems will be forgotten.

There is evidence poll taxes, even small ones disenfranchise certain voters. That evidence led to a Constitutional Amendment. I'd say that was pretty significant.

Not significant if the ID is provided at no cost.

And I care about political manipulation of the masses of people who are suckered by the unsupported claims that we should focus on voter IDs.

I think it's just as much about political manipulation to spend all your time focused against voter IDs while bigger problems continue to be ignored by both sides.


Strength lies not in defence but in attack.

Humanitarianism is the expression of stupidity and cowardice. Adolf Hitler

"Success is the sole earthly judge of right and wrong." Adolf Hitler

The day of individual happiness has passed.

Sometimes Hitler is like the bible- you can cherry pick quotes to support all kinds of things you like.
 
Last edited:
Is there anything new in this post over at Bradblog? They're making it out as some kind of Greg Palast exclusive, but from what I can see, it's much of the same stuff that's been rehashed in this thread. Not entirely relevant, but I felt I should mention that Bradblog is one of the very few major lefty/liberal blogs that has promoted the 9-11 Denier nonsense.
 
There's no free lunch, Bob Klase. If the voter IDs are productive, then they should be free to the voters. But someone is still paying, IE the taxpayer. Do voter ID requirements actually serve any purpose? Not as far as the evidence presented so far indicates.

We both agree on citizenship verification. It's better done during the registration process. Voter ID is adequate when the voter signs in as registered. If people are voting for dead people then purge the registration roles with death certificates. If people are impersonating voters, then show me the evidence before using my tax dollars to fix a problem that doesn't exist.

I, for one, think the voter ID issue is a purposeful distraction and I'd like skeptics to expect to see the evidence before being distracted by marketing talking points.
 
I, for one, think the voter ID issue is a purposeful distraction and I'd like skeptics to expect to see the evidence before being distracted by marketing talking points.

Maybe- pretty muc all politics (at least by politicians trying to get elected) are purposeful distraction. Why do you suppose so few of those against vote ID are trying to get proof of citizenship required when registering to vote?
 
Maybe- pretty muc all politics (at least by politicians trying to get elected) are purposeful distraction. Why do you suppose so few of those against vote ID are trying to get proof of citizenship required when registering to vote?
Who says they are or aren't? The problem is the news media along with the talking points being inserted in the news are controlling the dialog.
 
Pomeroo, the issue is not verifying only citizens vote. The issue is what is the best way to do so, how many cases of non-citizens voting have actually been detected so how much time and money should we invest in the solutions, and is this all just a distraction from the real voting problems?

I see nothing in that opinion piece addressing those issues.
 
Pomeroo, the issue is not verifying only citizens vote. The issue is what is the best way to do so, how many cases of non-citizens voting have actually been detected so how much time and money should we invest in the solutions, and is this all just a distraction from the real voting problems?

I see nothing in that opinion piece addressing those issues.


But, skeptigirl, the author of the WSJ piece, John Fund, has written a book about vote fraud, Stealing Elections. Shouldn't you take a look at it?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom