I don't like my tax dollars wasted on anything. But with the billions that are wasted to accomplish absolutely nothing (such as bridges to nowhere), this would be an insignificant speck of money that might actually accomplish something.
It may (or may not) have happened last year or in 2000, I don't think there's much dispute that it has happened in the past. And you can pick any spending bill in congress and find items where the money would be better spent on other problems and solutions. The first problem is that even if you eliminate the waste the money is likely to be spent on other waste.
And even if voter ID is a complete waste of money, if that's your biggest argument against it then your time would be better spent fighting some of the waste that actually costs a significant amount.
I don't know how ludicrous it is- I don't know how often it happens. But it's like other crimes- just because it doesn't happen a lot doesn't mean it should be ignored.
So let's spend money on a problem that may not exist and let's spend it on a solution that is not the best solution if the problem did exist. How hard is it to understand my position here?
Where are your critical thinking skills. Look for evidence of the problem. Determine if the solution is the best one. Then invest in the solution. That's how intelligent people deal with problems.
What do manipulators do? They stir up fear and loathing and distract you from the real cheating that is benefiting them currently. Much better to cry, "illegal immigrants are stealing the vote. The vote cheating you are hearing about, that is people voting more than once, we care too. We need voter ID, we need voter ID." And without thinking about the "evidence" both for the problem actually existing, and for the solution actually working, the masses follow the piper.
What does the evidence show? More people were unable to vote because the availability of voting machines were manipulated. That was well documented in Ohio. People were purged from voter roles that shouldn't have been and it was done by Republicans in official positions where they had charge over the voting process. That was well documented. "Caging" occurred by Republicans in official positions sending out letters which if they weren't replied to resulted in more voter purging from the registration roles, again purging more Democratic Party voters than Republicans. That was well documented.
Did other cheating go on? Yes. Tires were slashed by Democrats to stop vans from driving Republicans to the polls. Phone systems were jammed by Republicans to stop get out the vote calling by Democrats on election day. Republicans also called Democratic voters telling them to go to the wrong polling place or that they could vote Tuesday and Wednesday. Those actions were well documented.
None of those well documented voter problems are the least bit corrected by implementing voter ID requirements. So why are you letting the Republicans who don't want cheating corrected to distract you with voter ID issues?
I didn't say you "didn't care" there.
You said I contradicted myself. I didn't.
I don't care specifically about the ID requirement. I care about using evidence to identify problems, to identify the best solutions and to identify unintended consequences that the solutions might result in.
I posted the evidence of those unintended consequences. If you or anyone has any contradictory evidence about the unintended consequences, produce it. I have only seen so far, opinions the unintended consequences are not significant.
Obviously many people have opinions about the significance the cost of voter ID will be. Those opinions differ.
I have no reason to accept the opinions here that the cost of the ID is insignificant, because no evidence has been presented actually evaluating the impact voter ID has on impeding certain voters.
There is evidence poll taxes, even small ones disenfranchise certain voters. That evidence led to a Constitutional Amendment. I'd say that was pretty significant.
I have followed the voting issues from both the 00 and 04 elections. I have seen no evidence people impersonated voters nor that illegal aliens voted in significant numbers. A few cases were documented, especially voting for deceased relatives. I saw no evidence that occurred more by one party over the other, nor that it affected any election outcome.
There were allegations such illegal votes affected the outcome of the governor's election in WA State, my state. The Republican, Christian, Bush appointed federal attorney, McCay, elected not to pursue the issue because the Republicans sought out such illegal votes only in King County, a Democratic leaning county. Those same Republicans did not look at the illegal votes in any other part of the state. The Republican, Christian, Bush appointed, federal prosecutor after weighing all the evidence in this important matter, determined there was not sufficient evidence to pursue a case.
McCay also testified before the Oversight Committee on these attorney firings that he received a call from one Republican Congressman which McCay interpreted as an illegal attempt to influence the investigation and possible prosecution over the WA State election.
That is what the
evidence shows. I have seen no evidence that problems occurred which voter ID will address.
Skeptics should be asking about the evidence, not about which party is at fault or which will benefit. I do not take the position, they all do it. I don't care. That is a red herring. I care about the evidence.
And I care about political manipulation of the masses of people who are suckered by the unsupported claims that we should focus on voter IDs.
"How fortunate for leaders that men do not think." Adolf Hitler.
-