Conspiracy to steal the vote again in 2008

That isn't how disenfranchisement works.

Less machines for many more Democrats vs more voting machines for less Republicans. Have you ever had to wait 8 or more hours to vote like Democrats did in Ohio? Dumping of legit names from voter roles by various means. Moving polling places so voters go to the wrong place to vote. Sending out false notices or making phone calls telling people they have an extra day to send in absentee ballots. Those are some of the means of voter disenfranchisement.

Requiring voter ID with pictures is one way to discourage low income, minority and elderly voters.[/QUOTE]

I've never understood this argument. This is an argument of contradictions.
I've never been a minority or old(yet) but I have been low income.
I lived for the most part then around those groups cited in that statement that I've heard numerous times from dems. What I dont get is this.

Most people that I knew including myself lived very much week to week,even day to day. Most of the business transactions,rent,utilities etc were paid with money orders. They use cash much more than bank cards or checks from my experience with the exception of the elderly people maybe who I dont really know why they get throw in there except scaring the elderly people is a long used democrat talking point.

So most of those people need to carry ID's more than lets say the middle class much less the upper class because most get paid with checks they have to cash.Whether it's social security,welfare,unemployment,pay checks etc.

And when they say minority what they must mean is illegals who are'nt supposed to vote anyway right?

I mean if they mean all black folks or legal mexican americans, and other legal immigrants etc dont carry ID's thats such a slap to those people. Just because someone is black or mexican or pick a minority race here and to assume they are poor and dont carry ID's is to me a much more racist remark than other topics going on this board right now involving racism. If you think about that statement for a minute how does that really sound?

How do the democrats get away with this crap?


You must be watching too much Fox News.

09/21/06

HB29 in Alabama is for statewide voter ID and is sponsored by Republican State Senator Allen.

Not being facetious here, I rarely watch TV news period, it's much too tabloid oriented for me. I get most of my news off the internet.
So just curious, what does Fox news have to do with what I said?




Edited for spelling
 
Last edited:
First off, there are no Republicans in my area*.
Secondly, I'm dumbfounded by the list of requirements that must be true before you'll accept proof of citizenship in the registration process.



*Actually, there are a few. Kerry only carried 97.47% of the vote here in 2004.
You lost me here? I said proving citizenship was reasonable.

If you want to waste time and money on doing it there should be evidence it is needed.

And ID at the polls would do nothing to prevent non-citizen voters from voting.
 
This whole issue is extremely simple.

Republicans want to diminish vote fraud because they get hurt by it.

Democrats resist any attempt to reform the voting system because they profit from illegally-cast votes.

If the effects were reversed, the parties' positions would be reversed.

Neither side gives a damn about clean elections, per se.
 
Your [/b] mucked with the quote function there Drys.
That isn't how disenfranchisement works.

Less machines for many more Democrats vs more voting machines for less Republicans. Have you ever had to wait 8 or more hours to vote like Democrats did in Ohio? Dumping of legit names from voter roles by various means. Moving polling places so voters go to the wrong place to vote. Sending out false notices or making phone calls telling people they have an extra day to send in absentee ballots. Those are some of the means of voter disenfranchisement.

Requiring voter ID with pictures is one way to discourage low income, minority and elderly voters.

I've never understood this argument. This is an argument of contradictions.
I've never been a minority or old(yet) but I have been low income.
I lived for the most part then around those groups cited in that statement that I've heard numerous times from dems. What I dont get is this.

Most people that I knew including myself lived very much week to week,even day to day. Most of the business transactions,rent,utilities etc were paid with money orders. They use cash much more than bank cards or checks from my experience with the exception of the elderly people maybe who I dont really know why they get throw in there except scaring the elderly people is a long used democrat talking point.

So most of those people need to carry ID's more than lets say the middle class much less the upper class because most get paid with checks they have to cash.Whether it's social security,welfare,unemployment,pay checks etc.

And when they say minority what they must mean is illegals who are'nt supposed to vote anyway right?

I mean if they mean all black folks or legal mexican americans, and other legal immigrants etc dont carry ID's thats such a slap to those people. Just because someone is black or mexican or pick a minority race here and to assume they are poor and dont carry ID's is to me a much more racist remark than other topics going on this board right now involving racism. If you think about that statement for a minute how does that really sound?

How do the democrats get away with this crap?
Get away with what? Believing voter ID requirements prevent some people from voting? Or believing some minority voters are affected equals the claim all minority voters are and they are therefore racist?

You are also quite confused about why Republican leaders want voter ID requirements. You are buying the reason they are selling, but that isn't the reason they are discussing in top Party meetings as I noted in at least one link above.

Why don't you read the links discussing why voter ID intimidates some voters if you don't understand the rationale?

Not being facetious here, I rarely watch TV news period, it's much too tabloid oriented for me. I get most of my news off the internet.
So just curious, what does Fox news have to do with what I said?...
Because you posted your facts backward. Republicans want ID, Dems don't and you insisted the opposite was true. People who watch Fox News are statistically more likely to believe falsehoods like that.
 
This whole issue is extremely simple.

Republicans want to diminish vote fraud because they get hurt by it.

Democrats resist any attempt to reform the voting system because they profit from illegally-cast votes.

If the effects were reversed, the parties' positions would be reversed.

Neither side gives a damn about clean elections, per se.
Is that the vote fraud the Republicans can't seem to find any evidence of, pommy? And with the correction that won't correct the concocted vote fraud?
 
Last edited:
You lost me here? I said proving citizenship was reasonable.
But then you said:
If there were a lot of non-citizens voting, and the Republicans thought such votes went more heavily Democratic, show me the evidence, I'll be on your side for requiring proof of citizenship to register to vote.
Which makes me think you're hedging quite a bit.

If you want to waste time and money on doing it there should be evidence it is needed.
It would be a waste of time and money to check for this after the fact, far easier and cheaper to do it at the application stage - could be as simple as swiping a DL.

And ID at the polls would do nothing to prevent non-citizen voters from voting.
ID at the polls is to make sure the person voting is who they say they are in order to keep people from voting "early and often", not to keep non-citizens from voting.
 
But then you said:

Which makes me think you're hedging quite a bit.
I'm not hedging, but I am not supporting correcting a problem that there is no evidence occurred or is occurring.


It would be a waste of time and money to check for this after the fact, far easier and cheaper to do it at the application stage - could be as simple as swiping a DL.
I'm saying is there evidence this occurred? Because for something so important to the Republicans, they haven't found evidence of any more than a handful of cases of illegal voting.


ID at the polls is to make sure the person voting is who they say they are in order to keep people from voting "early and often", not to keep non-citizens from voting.
How do you vote early and often if you aren't registered in multiple places? And so what if John Smith has an ID. What stops him from registering in multiple addresses and still voting more than once?

More importantly here is how do you coordinate enough people doing this to affect an election outcome? How do you conspire to manipulate the vote using individuals voting more than once?
 
Is that the vote fraud the Republicans can't seem to find any evidence of, pommy? And with the correction that won't correct the concocted vote fraud?


Do you think there was no evidence of fraud in the Washington State election? Or in Palm Beach County in 2000?

Read Baehr's article and the relevant chapter in John Fund's book.

The Dems have a good scam going. The Republicans scream and the Dems call them racists. Works like a charm.

One of my favorite Al Sharpton moments came on Election night 1993, after David Dinkins had conceded defeat to Rudy. The rotund Rev seized the mike and thundered about Republican attempts to intimidate illegal immigrants at the polls. He demanded that Janet Reno get involved. An aide whispered in his ear. Reno did not get involved. Like that old ad said, You can't make this stuff up.
 
I didn't intend to post about and I don't have time to provide the research about the 00 and 04 voter disenfranchisement for all you rightwing ad homers who ignore half the evidence anyway.

Like the fact that Bush won Florida in 2000. Including the recounts, and the recounts of the recounts, and the media recounts of the recounts?

The Democrats lost because they ran a poor campaign. Get over it already.


Getting back OT, I want to honestly look at this information. If you have nothing to support your automatic dismissal of the presented facts other than to whine, "Palast is a left wing journalist", then you are just wasting time and thread space.

Um....no. Questioning the source is certainly something a skeptic should do. If Sylvia Browne were to come out with email evidence that Randi had awarded her the prize we would all certainly put her through the ringer.

If they are legit

And that's the sticky part, isn't it? If you can get the original emails you might be able to trace the headers back to a point of origin. But in this electronic age you need more than X number of emails to launch an investigation. I could whip up 500 emails with people in my city (using publicly available records) in a very short amount of time.

What is needed is a bit of computer forensics, something to say "these may be legitimate". As opposed to someone with an obvious bias saying "Oh, look, I just happen to have come across these incredibly incriminating emails...."

I'm not going to dismiss anything out of hand. By the same token I'm not going to accept it, unquestioningly, at face value. No free rides.

Why would even a left wing journalist be so stupid as to fake 500 emails? One or two maybe, but why 500? Could turn out Palast was duped but allow me to request in advance, don' t waste our time with Dan Rather distractions either.

Request all you want. As I said, no free rides. Scrutiny of these emails should most certainly include the possibility they have been faked.

Why would a journalist (left or right) fake 500 emails? Perhaps we could ask Jayson Blair.


What does anyone know about these emails? It could also be they are really from a whistle blower source. Monica Goodling's testimony should also shed some more light on this.

What do we know about the emails? That a journalist claims they exist. That the journalist claims they were sent by Rove. That the journalist claims they came to him by mistake.

In short, we know absolutely nothing about these emails other than what an obviously biased source has decided to tell us. We have no data.

If these emails are real, once they're released I'm certain the folks on the forum will be able to dissect them rather quickly and efficiently. But at this point we have our choice of two conspiracies to debate: The firings & voter disenfranchisement spoken of in the emails...or the faking of 500 emails and the involvement / deception of the reporter.
 
Get away with what? Believing voter ID requirements prevent some people from voting? Or believing some minority voters are affected equals the claim all minority voters are and they are therefore racist?

You are also quite confused about why Republican leaders want voter ID requirements. You are buying the reason they are selling, but that isn't the reason they are discussing in top Party meetings as I noted in at least one link above.

Why don't you read the links discussing why voter ID intimidates some voters if you don't understand the rationale?

Because you posted your facts backward. Republicans want ID, Dems don't and you insisted the opposite was true. People who watch Fox News are statistically more likely to believe falsehoods like that.

No, thats exactly what I said if you'll reread it. I said the dems cry about voter fraud the loudest yet try and stop any attempt at voter ID's.

And directly from that link it says minority not some minorities. If they meant some why did'nt they say some?
 
Will you guys making the claim voter ID will prevent the voter fraud we disagree there is evidence for address the question, How will requiring voter ID stop illegal voters from mailing in their ballots?

Will you guys making the claim voter ID will prevent the voter fraud we disagree there is evidence for address the question, How will requiring voter ID stop illegal aliens from voting?

Will you guys making the claim voter ID will prevent the voter fraud we disagree there is evidence for address the question, How will requiring voter ID stop illegal voters from registering in multiple voter districts and voting multiple times or registering and using fake IDs?

Will you guys making the claim voter ID will prevent the voter fraud we disagree there is evidence for address the question, How many illegal voters does it take to swing an election and how does one Party conspire to get enough cheaters to make a difference?
 
No, thats exactly what I said if you'll reread it. I said the dems cry about voter fraud the loudest yet try and stop any attempt at voter ID's.

And directly from that link it says minority not some minorities. If they meant some why did'nt they say some?
You are confusing two types of voter fraud.

Voter disenfranchisement.

Illegal individual voting.

The attorney firings and Karl Rove conspiracy theory involves only voter disenfranchisement.

To facilitate getting this thread back on topic, I'll support your desire to prevent illegal individual voting if you suggest a method other than voter ID which won't prevent individual voter fraud anyway.
 
Why would even a left wing journalist be so stupid as to fake 500 emails? One or two maybe, but why 500?


I have no idea if they're fake or not. Neither does anyone else since apparently no one has been allowed to see enough of them to even make a guess as to the authenticity. But even a left wing journalist might be smart enough to know that if they only fake one or two then many people would say "those could be fake", while if they fake 500 then there will be many people who will say "why would he be stupid enough to fake 500 emails?". So to many people, faking 500 hundred would make it believable.
 
Like the fact that Bush won Florida in 2000. Including the recounts, and the recounts of the recounts, and the media recounts of the recounts?

The Democrats lost because they ran a poor campaign. Get over it already.
Since the thread is about the 08 campaign, I suggest you take your own cliche' advice.

Um....no. Questioning the source is certainly something a skeptic should do. If Sylvia Browne were to come out with email evidence that Randi had awarded her the prize we would all certainly put her through the ringer.
Questioning the source is legit, just throwing out an ad hom or unsupported personal opinion is not. I have no issue if someone wants to provide evidence that Palast has made up stories in the past.

We have enough evidence in his parody web page he probably has a liberal bias, though he could have other parody web pages of the Democratic Party site or he could be like some comedians and simply be parodying the party in office. But I think it's been established Palast and Robert Kennedy Jr run in the same circles.

And that's the sticky part, isn't it? If you can get the original emails you might be able to trace the headers back to a point of origin. .....
Validity of the emails aside, the evidence is mounting that the attorney firings did have an 08 election motive for some of them. But even if you don't accept that evidence, what is your explanation or possible explanations for Gonzales being unable or more likely unwilling to explain the reason behind the 8 attorney firings? It's obvious they couldn't prove any real performance deficits. A couple might have had something to do with prosecuting an individual influential Republican. But then what about the rest?
 
Will you guys making the claim voter ID will prevent the voter fraud we disagree there is evidence for address the question, How will requiring voter ID stop illegal voters from mailing in their ballots?

I didn't claim it would prevent it. I'm not convinced that it would eliminate any fraud although it would certainly eliminate one avenue of voter fraud I'm not convinced it would disenfranchise anyone either. And I'm not convinced that those who oppose it aren't doing so only because they think they benefit from illegal voters ballots.

But to answer the question- it won't. Just like requiring a driver's license doesn't keep illegal aliens from driving without a license. Would you suggest we stop requiring driver's licenses too since it doesn't stop every violator?

How will requiring voter ID stop illegal aliens from voting?

You're right- just requiring an ID isn't enough. Proof of citizenship should be required when you register to vote and photo ID required when you actually vote.

b]How will requiring voter ID stop illegal voters from registering in multiple voter districts and voting multiple times or registering and using fake IDs?[/b]

The same way that requirements for a drivers license stop illegal drivers from getting multiple fake licenses. So again, I suppose we should eliminate the require to have a driver license with you when you drive because it's easy to get a fake license and the requirement doesn't stop all forms of driving violations.

How many illegal voters does it take to swing an election and how does one Party conspire to get enough cheaters to make a difference?[/b]

Maybe just one if the election is close enough.

And if you're that worried about voters being disenfranchised, one illegal vote could wipe out the effect of my legal vote. Am I not disenfranchised by that?
 
You are confusing two types of voter fraud.

Voter disenfranchisement.

Illegal individual voting.

The attorney firings and Karl Rove conspiracy theory involves only voter disenfranchisement.

To facilitate getting this thread back on topic, I'll support your desire to prevent illegal individual voting if you suggest a method other than voter ID which won't prevent individual voter fraud anyway.

I'll need to do some research in order to answer this completely. But for now isnt that what registering to vote is supposed to prevent? I dont know the exact protocol state to state and I'm not a polling expert by no means
so if I'm wrong correct me here. .

You are allowed to vote in only one polling location correct?

If you cant vote in that polling place then you need to vote absentee in which case you cant vote there after absentee vote?

So for now though the picture voter ID system isnt perfect should'nt it at least make a flawed system better anyway?


What are you talking about specifically being disenfranchised?
I know the military angle in 2000 but Gore was primarily the candidate fighting to keep those out not Bush. What other types of disenfranchisement are you talking about?


What other sources are you using for the 8 attorney firings being connected to the 08 election? I haven't heard that one.
 
...although it would certainly eliminate one avenue of voter fraud
WHAT AVENUE????????? you say it won't help here several times then throw that in.

...But to answer the question- it won't. Just like requiring a driver's license doesn't keep illegal aliens from driving without a license. Would you suggest we stop requiring driver's licenses too since it doesn't stop every violator?
Could you find a more irrelevant straw man? Driver's test!! D'uh. And people do have more than one license. Change states and just claim you lost your old one and you have two.

...You're right- just requiring an ID isn't enough. Proof of citizenship should be required when you register to vote.....
Which is not what the voter ID law is all about now is it?

...and photo ID required when you actually vote
Why? to prevent someone from stealing your vote? Did hundreds of people go to vote and find someone had already signed in as them?

...The same way that requirements for a drivers license stop illegal drivers from getting multiple fake licenses. So again, I suppose we should eliminate the require to have a driver license with you when you drive because it's easy to get a fake license and the requirement doesn't stop all forms of driving violations.
Have you guys actually ever voted? Because you have to wonder why it is you don't know that you go in, someone finds your registration on a page, you sign next to the line and you get a ballot. How does an ID matter if your name is not on the list? You don't just walk in and vote.

...
Maybe just one if the election is close enough.

And if you're that worried about voters being disenfranchised, one illegal vote could wipe out the effect of my legal vote. Am I not disenfranchised by that?
Depends, have you ever actually voted?
 
I'll need to do some research in order to answer this completely. But for now isnt that what registering to vote is supposed to prevent? I dont know the exact protocol state to state and I'm not a polling expert by no means
so if I'm wrong correct me here. .

You are allowed to vote in only one polling location correct?

If you cant vote in that polling place then you need to vote absentee in which case you cant vote there after absentee vote?

So for now though the picture voter ID system isnt perfect should'nt it at least make a flawed system better anyway?


What are you talking about specifically being disenfranchised?
I know the military angle in 2000 but Gore was primarily the candidate fighting to keep those out not Bush. What other types of disenfranchisement are you talking about?


What other sources are you using for the 8 attorney firings being connected to the 08 election? I haven't heard that one.
I'l tell you what is going on and what this thread is about if you make an effort to read what I post? First, say you will.
 
I'l tell you what is going on and what this thread is about if you make an effort to read what I post? First, say you will.

You being sarcastic or serious?

If you post links to sources I'll read it. I hope it's more than just Palast though.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom