Conspiracy to steal the vote again in 2008

I put this information in because it has to do with the voter disenfranchisement which is part of the conspiracy charge.
Do you think that proof of citizenship should be required to be able to register to vote? And by "proof" I don't mean you check a box that says you're a citizen, which is all they do here. I mean show a birth certificate, or an official state ID (drivers license or ID card) that is verifiably legitimate.
 
According to the link you provided, 21 states require voters to show ID every time they vote. (Only 2 require photo ID):

Is there evidence that the ID requirement has discouraged low income, minority or elderly voters from voting in any of those 21 states? If there is evidence, I've never seen it.
Right, the federal law only affect federal elections. Time will tell whether the fear is legit or not. All this ID stuff is new. But in the past, poll taxes were used to disenfranchise voters.
 
I agree, the whole voting system is a mess. And I guarantee you that had the Democrats won the election the Republicans would have accused them of stealing it.

Yup. And shouldn't we, as a nation, be embrassed about that? Our voting system should be so robust and corruption-free that a close defeat should not fall into question.

To be fair, not every close race is challenged. But the 2000 election betrayed a really ugly side of our supposedly representative government.
 
How do you know that? You have to register. Illegal registrations can be challenged.
Here you simply check a box saying you're a citizen.

There shouldn't be any need to print ballots or polling place information in any language but English, since proficiency in English is a requirement for citizenship.
 
Wiki on poll taxes
Tax on Voting

A poll tax, on the sense of a discriminatory tax which was a pre-condition of the exercise of the right to vote, emerged in some US states between the mid-19th to mid-20th centuries. After the right to vote was extended to all races by the enactment of the 15th Amendment, many Southern states enacted poll tax laws which often included a grandfather clause that allowed any adult male whose father or grandfather had voted in a specific year prior to the abolition of slavery to vote without paying the tax. These laws achieved the desired effect of disenfranchising African and Native Americans, as well as poor whites who immigrated after the year specified.

Wiki on voter suppression, (a neutrality disputed entry, what a surprise :rolleyes:)
Voter suppression by governmental power

In the United States, voter suppression was used extensively in some Southern states until the Voting Rights Act (1965) made most disenfranchisement and voting qualifications illegal. Traditional voter suppression tactics included the institution of poll taxes and literacy tests, aimed at suppressing the votes of African Americans and working class white voters.

Measures in place in seven U.S. states ban released felons from voting; some allege that this is a tactic aimed at suppressing voter turnout. Occasionally, as in Florida in the 2000 presidential election, some non-felons are banned due to record-keeping errors and are not warned of their disqualification before they have the right to contest it.

In the U.S. presidential election of 2004, Ohio officials allegedly mis-allocated voting machines to reduce Democratic turnout. (With too few voting machines per registered voter, in areas heavily populated by African Americans who were Democratic, had to wait in line for hours. Republican districts received many more voting machines per capita.) [1]

Regarding the voter ID and conspiracies, here's an interesting link from the Brennan Center for Justice at the NYU School of Law.
Much of the hue and cry about voter fraud is accompanied by calls for restrictive ID requirements. Some of this may be a sincere, if mistaken, belief in the need for restrictive ID measures. But this clip from a May 17, 2007, Houston Chronicle article suggests another rationale:

Among Republicans it is an 'article of religious faith that voter fraud is causing us to lose elections,' [Royal] Masset[, former political director of the Republican Party of Texas,] said. He doesn't agree with that, but does believe that requiring photo IDs could cause enough of a dropoff in legitimate Democratic voting to add 3 percent to the Republican vote.

The political cartoon on the page comments on the claims of voter fraud by the people pushing the voter ID legislation.
 
Last edited:
Here you simply check a box saying you're a citizen.

There shouldn't be any need to print ballots or polling place information in any language but English, since proficiency in English is a requirement for citizenship.
I meant how do you know what the voter registration office checks? Maybe they do random audits, maybe they check registrations that are challenged.

Re the language, reading is different from speaking.
 
I meant how do you know what the voter registration office checks? Maybe they do random audits, maybe they check registrations that are challenged.
I eagerly await for you to present the hundreds of prosecutions for illegally registering to vote in Cook County that must exist if these audits take place.

Re the language, reading is different from speaking.
Anecdotal I know, but the folks I've seen at my polling place didn't speak it either.
 
Do you think that proof of citizenship should be required to be able to register to vote? And by "proof" I don't mean you check a box that says you're a citizen, which is all they do here. I mean show a birth certificate, or an official state ID (drivers license or ID card) that is verifiably legitimate.
I have no problem with some system of verifying voter registrations. How much you verify and what states spend doing it should be based on the actual need. If there was evidence those X million illegal workers were voting, then proof of citizenship should be checked in some way. Showing ID at the polls is silly. Proving you are legit when you register is not. Doing it through registration allows time to check, challenge, provide missing proof and so on. Signing your name when you vote allows one vote per registrant and a way to check for fraud if challenged. And if I wanted to cheat and didn't have ID, I could just mail in my ballot. Not to mention fake ID doesn't seem to be too hard for all these illegal workers.
 
Right, the federal law only affect federal elections.


In the absence of evidence I think it's reasonable to assume that if any voters are going to be discouraged from voting by an ID requirement then very few of those people will discriminate between federal and local elections.

Time will tell whether the fear is legit or not. All this ID stuff is new.


My mistake. I interpreted it as a statement of fact earlier when you wrote:

Requiring voter ID with pictures is one way to discourage low income, minority and elderly voters.


But in the past, poll taxes were used to disenfranchise voters.


Are you equating poll taxes with ID requirements? Should we also do away with registration altogether and just let anyone who shows up vote because poll taxes were used to disenfranchise voters?

And when we get right down to it- if requiring ID does disenfranchise voters, shouldn't we (the federal government) prohibit states from requiring ID just like we prohibited poll taxes?

ETA: I doubt that massive voter fraud exists due to the lack of ID. But I also fail to see why an ID requirement is such a problem for so many people.
 
Last edited:
Showing ID at the polls is silly.
How so? What's to prevent me from walking into a polling place, look down at the voter list and tell the judge that I'm whatever name I choose that isn't crossed off yet?
 
Not to mention fake ID doesn't seem to be too hard for all these illegal workers.
That's why I said a "verifiable". An employer has no way to verify, say, a driver's license. But a cop can find out in a few seconds whether or not the DL you presented to him is not legitimate.
 
I eagerly await for you to present the hundreds of prosecutions for illegally registering to vote in Cook County that must exist if these audits take place.


Anecdotal I know, but the folks I've seen at my polling place didn't speak it either.
Have you looked for the actual evidence large numbers of non-citizens voted where you live?

The Republican Bush appointed attorney here in WA State was on that firing list and had been asked by one of our Republican Congressman to investigate and charge fraudulent voters. Our Democratic governor only won by ~120 votes and it was on the third count. But McCay did not believe there was evidence that there was anything significant to pursue. Why? I have to assume he would have if there had been.

This is all part of this alleged conspiracy. Why go after a handful of fraudulent voters? According to Palast and others the reason isn't because there was any widespread voter fraud. The reason is to eliminate a small but decisive number of Democratic voters in 08 by intimidation.
 
Have you looked for the actual evidence large numbers of non-citizens voted where you live?
Since there seems to be no effort at all made to prevent it I'm assuming it is happening.

The Republican Bush appointed attorney here in WA State was on that firing list and had been asked by one of our Republican Congressman to investigate and charge fraudulent voters. Our Democratic governor only won by ~120 votes and it was on the third count. But McCay did not believe there was evidence that there was anything significant to pursue. Why? I have to assume he would have if there had been.
There's a world of difference between verifying the voter during the registration process and fishing for the fraudulent applications after the fact. The latter is expensive, time consuming, and inefficient.

This is all part of this alleged conspiracy. Why go after a handful of fraudulent voters? According to Palast and others the reason isn't because there was any widespread voter fraud. The reason is to eliminate a small but decisive number of Democratic voters in 08 by intimidation.
I really don't see how anyone is intimidated by the ID requirement. It certainly doesn't seem to keep customers out of the bars on Saturday nights...
 
What you are missing would fill a canyon.

You haven't been in the military, Ron, and so therefore it becomes terribly easy for you to think in terms of using unique human beings as pawns in military adventures. I've been in, and so have many, many, many Democrats. Does it affect one's perspective on war? Yes it does.


Who likes war? It was the judgment of many analysts, most prominently Kenneth Pollack, that we would have to fight Saddam at some point. We had the option of waiting until he was stronger. Why that was necessarily the better choice remains unclear to me.


What you are missing is this: Starting an offensive war against a nation that did not attack us is always the LAST option to be considered.


What is the relevance of this platitude to the geopolitical reality? We were attacked by jihadists on 9/11/01. Osama's appeal to the oppressed and backward peoples of the Middle East lay in his identification of the cause of all their misery: the Great Satan--the United States. He offered a vision, one that could only be countered by a competing vision. The neocons thought that dangling the promise of political freedom would defuse the hatred and resentment of the downtrodden for the prosperous West. Was that a bad idea?


Regardless of political bent. Once the dogs of war are loosed - anything follows. As we've seen. Babies are going to be turned into red mist. Women are going to be burned to cinders. Men are going to be blown to pieces. Families - perhaps complete family lines, front to back - are going to be wiped out of existence. Entire villages, towns, destroyed. Unexploded ordnance in the fields, waters, cities for decades. Depleted uranium expelling its remaining radioactivity for years. It is the greatest sin of mankind, as General Douglas MacArthur so eloquently stated.


The U.S. didn't provoke Saddam to attack three of his neighbors. When we've suffered a devastating blow from terrorists, should we ignore an implacable enemy who seeks WMD? If Bush had done nothing about Saddam, and America was dealt another crippling blow in, say, 2006, by weapons that were traced back to Iraq, what would the consequences have been? Conceivably 100,000 of our fellow citizens would be dead; congressional Democrats would be demanding Bush's impeachment for criminal negligence of his duty to protect us (I would agree with them); and the lunatic-left would be screaming that we had attacked ourselves.
If I had been elected President in 2000, I would have regarded my term as a failure if I allowed Saddam to remain in power.



Stupid-Boy, Quick-Draw Dick and Der Oberfuhrer Rove came through the door after the disputed election of 2000 - spoiling for war with Iraq! They WANTED it! They sought it every way they could. If they had to lie, steal, cheat to begin the slaughter - so be it. Just so long as they got their way.


Bubba wanted the credit for removing Saddam, but he called off the invasion when polling data failed to show overwhelming support for the venture. Some cans shouldn't be kicked down the road indefinitely.


And this bit about putting a murderous tyrant out of business? Freeing an oppressed people? Hogwash. Why don't you go over to Saudi Arabia, Ron, and get educated on the concept of oppression. We didn't invade them. Nor North Korea. Nor Russia. Nor China. Nor a hundred other countries or more in the world that suffer from an overdose of oppression, meted out by a greedy, gluttonous government.


You keep pretending that it's hogwash because you must besmirch everything Bush attempts. You are completely wrong, however. Setting up a democratic Iraq was the whole idea--the long-term alternative to the vision of radical Islam. The status quo that Democrats support so fervently hasn't worked out too well for us.


We had a Civil War. And the Brits did a bit to intervene with their Confederate shipbuilding operations. We really did not like that at all, angrily demanded reparations after war. It's a no-win situation for the country butting into a nation's civil war. And that is what your boy - Stupid-Boy Extraordinaire - got us into. We got involved in a civil war in Vietnam, didn't we? And that turned out how?


It's no longer the seventies. We now know that North Vietnam's war of conquest was no civil war. Some of us understood that all along. The insurgent and terrorist violence in Iraq is no civil war, either.
 
Last edited:
That's why I said a "verifiable". An employer has no way to verify, say, a driver's license. But a cop can find out in a few seconds whether or not the DL you presented to him is not legitimate.
I don't want this thread derailed too far here so keep that in mind if/when you reply. My son's SSN doesn't match his name because his name was changed a few years ago. So his passport and his license have one name and his SSN has another. He got a job, no trouble. But he couldn't get a bank account. The bank had an instant SSN check as he sat there filling out the forms. So it isn't just cops who can easily check and the mechanics of an instant check is obviously not a barrier.

To tie this back to the thread, it was clear to me when that happened that politics, and not simple legitimacy in the voting public is the rule here. If there were a lot of non-citizens voting, and the Republicans thought such votes went more heavily Democratic, show me the evidence, I'll be on your side for requiring proof of citizenship to register to vote.

Hearing a foreign language spoken at the voting booth is not evidence. Being unhappy about immigrants being granted citizenship is not relevant to this issue. Why, given the obvious benefit to Republicans disclosing widespread non-citizens voting would have, have the Republicans only been able to produce rumors of such illegal voting? Why are the Republicans pursuing voter ID when to check citizenship all they need to do is ask for that SSN and run the same instant check the bank ran on my son? Is the voter ID proof of citizenship?
 
I don't want this thread derailed too far here so keep that in mind if/when you reply. My son's SSN doesn't match his name because his name was changed a few years ago. So his passport and his license have one name and his SSN has another. He got a job, no trouble. But he couldn't get a bank account. The bank had an instant SSN check as he sat there filling out the forms. So it isn't just cops who can easily check and the mechanics of an instant check is obviously not a barrier.

To tie this back to the thread, it was clear to me when that happened that politics, and not simple legitimacy in the voting public is the rule here. If there were a lot of non-citizens voting, and the Republicans thought such votes went more heavily Democratic, show me the evidence, I'll be on your side for requiring proof of citizenship to register to vote.

Hearing a foreign language spoken at the voting booth is not evidence. Being unhappy about immigrants being granted citizenship is not relevant to this issue. Why, given the obvious benefit to Republicans disclosing widespread non-citizens voting would have, have the Republicans only been able to produce rumors of such illegal voting? Why are the Republicans pursuing voter ID when to check citizenship all they need to do is ask for that SSN and run the same instant check the bank ran on my son? Is the voter ID proof of citizenship?
First off, there are no Republicans in my area*.
Secondly, I'm dumbfounded by the list of requirements that must be true before you'll accept proof of citizenship in the registration process.



*Actually, there are a few. Kerry only carried 97.47% of the vote here in 2004.
 
...I really don't see how anyone is intimidated by the ID requirement. It certainly doesn't seem to keep customers out of the bars on Saturday nights...
Why do you want an ID check if illegal voters can simply mail in ballots or have fake IDs?

As a Democrat, I plan to campaign for any voter without an ID to mail in their ballot.

Whether or not voter ID requirements actually do disenfranchise low income, minority, and elderly voters and whether or not such a requirement keeps 3% of Democratic voters from the polls may be speculation. Or the evidence may be stronger if to a social scientist, I don't know. What I do see evidence of, however, is that voter ID doesn't prevent non-citizen voters, nor voter fraud, nor is there any evidence either of those problems contributed to actual election outcomes being changed in past national elections.

But there is evidence the Republicans are pursuing voter ID requirements, and some Republicans have suggested they believe voter IDs will disenfranchise some Democratic voters. I believe there was evidence of voter disenfranchisement in 00, some purposeful (by Harris' actions), some accidental (the chads), that might have been a lucky break for the Republicans. I think in 04 the Republicans made a more sophisticated effort to disenfranchise Democratic voters both in Ohio and Florida. It's my belief based on the evidence I have seen.

I have no desire to convince anyone here in this thread that my conclusions are correct, that stuff has been hashed and rehashed in previous threads. I doubt many of us are going to change our conclusions at this point. But I would like to know what these attorney firings were all about, and if there is any evidence Rove is involved with plans to systematically disenfranchise voters in 08 in key states that are possibly going to be close calls between Red and Blue.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom