TruthSeeker1234
Banned
- Joined
- Sep 9, 2006
- Messages
- 1,756
Yes but the footage you used is not the original recording. It is a digital media file of unknown origin. Thus you cannot know if the frame rate is consistent.
How a computer plays back the frames of a video file is not relevant for this particular analysis. All that matters is the frame rate on the original recording. Then, as long as no frames are missing, the analysis can proceed. I go through this in the paper.
See, you see the motion of the aircraft as being evidence of a fake. I see it as evidence that the video does not have a stable frame rate. And no, I am not confusing recording and playback. Digital media files are notoriously bad at preserving frame fidelity.
Thank you for confirming that the motion is not stable. The fidelity has nothing to do with the frame rate of the original recording.
You have allowed no margin of error in your study. Here's a few factors that contribute significantly to margin of error:
1) The camera is in motion
Did you even read the paper? Camera motion is what the paper is ABOUT!
2) The object is in motion
3) The object is moving at high speed
Right.
4) The object is not moving parallel to the X-axis of the camera.
Irrelevant. This could not possibly cause the apparent velocity to increase and decrease repeatedly.
5) The footage being used is not the original footage
The original footage is presumably a 3/4 inch video tape in a vault at WNYW. I repeat my plea and offer to the world. If anyone can provide any higher quality copy of any significant 9/11 video than is commonly available, I will pay money for it. Standing offer.
6) The image has been enlarged
That's for good reason. Enlarging will not increase the amount of data in the original. But it will allow greater precision when stabilizing and placing wireframes. Effectively it allows you to move the frame by 1/2 pixel if need be.
7) Measurement of the object's movement has been measured manually
Yes. If software more sophisticated can stabilize and track the airplane, I'm all for it. This is the best we have so far.
Your raw data graph shows a margin of error of +/- 3 pixels. Allowing for an enlargement of the image 2x, this means a margin of error of +/- 1.5 pixels.
I don't agree. I've agreed to a margin of error of 1 px, maybe 2. That would reduce to 1/2 or 1.
Each of the factors listed above could easily on its own account for this degree of margin of error. Your research indicates the footage in question is genuine.
I've debunked your points. You are flat wrong about frame rate. The footage is the highest quality copy I could find. It was digitized originally at NTSC standard 640 x 480. I invite anyone to repeat the analysis, and see if you can get a straighter line.
Your best point is that the positioning of video was done by hand. If it turns out that the motion of the plane is stable after all, it does not refute the video composite conclusion, it simply might mean they used a stable video to overlay.
The more interesting thing I've discovered is the cut-and-paste artifacts. Watch for a complete study of that.