Chopper 5 Velocity Study Proves Video Composite, Reveals Sloppy Photoshopping

Yes but the footage you used is not the original recording. It is a digital media file of unknown origin. Thus you cannot know if the frame rate is consistent.

How a computer plays back the frames of a video file is not relevant for this particular analysis. All that matters is the frame rate on the original recording. Then, as long as no frames are missing, the analysis can proceed. I go through this in the paper.

See, you see the motion of the aircraft as being evidence of a fake. I see it as evidence that the video does not have a stable frame rate. And no, I am not confusing recording and playback. Digital media files are notoriously bad at preserving frame fidelity.

Thank you for confirming that the motion is not stable. The fidelity has nothing to do with the frame rate of the original recording.

You have allowed no margin of error in your study. Here's a few factors that contribute significantly to margin of error:

1) The camera is in motion

Did you even read the paper? Camera motion is what the paper is ABOUT!

2) The object is in motion
3) The object is moving at high speed

Right.

4) The object is not moving parallel to the X-axis of the camera.

Irrelevant. This could not possibly cause the apparent velocity to increase and decrease repeatedly.

5) The footage being used is not the original footage

The original footage is presumably a 3/4 inch video tape in a vault at WNYW. I repeat my plea and offer to the world. If anyone can provide any higher quality copy of any significant 9/11 video than is commonly available, I will pay money for it. Standing offer.

6) The image has been enlarged

That's for good reason. Enlarging will not increase the amount of data in the original. But it will allow greater precision when stabilizing and placing wireframes. Effectively it allows you to move the frame by 1/2 pixel if need be.

7) Measurement of the object's movement has been measured manually

Yes. If software more sophisticated can stabilize and track the airplane, I'm all for it. This is the best we have so far.

Your raw data graph shows a margin of error of +/- 3 pixels. Allowing for an enlargement of the image 2x, this means a margin of error of +/- 1.5 pixels.

I don't agree. I've agreed to a margin of error of 1 px, maybe 2. That would reduce to 1/2 or 1.
Each of the factors listed above could easily on its own account for this degree of margin of error. Your research indicates the footage in question is genuine.

I've debunked your points. You are flat wrong about frame rate. The footage is the highest quality copy I could find. It was digitized originally at NTSC standard 640 x 480. I invite anyone to repeat the analysis, and see if you can get a straighter line.

Your best point is that the positioning of video was done by hand. If it turns out that the motion of the plane is stable after all, it does not refute the video composite conclusion, it simply might mean they used a stable video to overlay.

The more interesting thing I've discovered is the cut-and-paste artifacts. Watch for a complete study of that.
 
How a computer plays back the frames of a video file is not relevant for this particular analysis. All that matters is the frame rate on the original recording. Then, as long as no frames are missing, the analysis can proceed. I go through this in the paper.


Frame rate on the original recording is irrelevant. You are not using the original recording. You are using a digitised copy of unspecified origin. You have no idea how many times this footage was recorded in a different format before arriving at the version you used. Ergo, you cannot guarantee frame fidelity.

Playback is, of course, vitally relevant to the study, however I am currently working on the assumption that your playback software is maintaining fidelity with the digital file.



Thank you for confirming that the motion is not stable. The fidelity has nothing to do with the frame rate of the original recording.

Fidelity has everything to do with the frame rate of the original recording (actually, the original capture, not the original recording).



Did you even read the paper? Camera motion is what the paper is ABOUT!


Your stabilising techniques do not sufficiently address camera motion to completely disregard any margin of error relating to camera motion.



Irrelevant. This could not possibly cause the apparent velocity to increase and decrease repeatedly.


We are talking about margin of error. Distance to the CCD affects scale as well as apparant speed. Both of these introduce margins of error into the calculations.



The original footage is presumably a 3/4 inch video tape in a vault at WNYW. I repeat my plea and offer to the world. If anyone can provide any higher quality copy of any significant 9/11 video than is commonly available, I will pay money for it. Standing offer.


This is very admirable of you. However your assertion that your current research is conclusive demonstratively refutes the authenticity of your above position.

A good researcher acquires the necessary data before making any determinations. They do not make determinations regardless. At worst, they acknowledge the serious flaws in their determinations due to poor data. You do not do this. Thus your study is worthless.



That's for good reason. Enlarging will not increase the amount of data in the original. But it will allow greater precision when stabilizing and placing wireframes. Effectively it allows you to move the frame by 1/2 pixel if need be.


Enlarging the image by 100% doubles the perceived variation in velocity, and doubles the margin of error.



Yes. If software more sophisticated can stabilize and track the airplane, I'm all for it. This is the best we have so far.

If your resources are insufficient for accurate analysis, you must either acknowledge that you cannot perform the analysis, or factor an appropriate margin of error into the analysis. You do neither. Thus your analysis is worthless.



I don't agree. I've agreed to a margin of error of 1 px, maybe 2. That would reduce to 1/2 or 1.

The raw data range of your data is 6 pixels. Ergo, by definition the variance is +/- 3 pixels. Enlarging the image by 100% doubles the margin of error, thus your variance is in fact +/- 1.5 pixels. Your assertion can only be correct if your analysis is more accurate than the variance. It cannot be that accurate, for the reasons stated.



I've debunked your points.


You have done nothing of the sort, and are quite obviously grossly out of your depth.



You are flat wrong about frame rate. The footage is the highest quality copy I could find.


Which is irrelevant. You cannot determine fidelity to the original footage. Thus your copy has a very large margin of error.



Your best point is that the positioning of video was done by hand. If it turns out that the motion of the plane is stable after all, it does not refute the video composite conclusion, it simply might mean they used a stable video to overlay.


It refutes your hypothesis.



The more interesting thing I've discovered is the cut-and-paste artifacts. Watch for a complete study of that.

In regard to your "cut and paste" artefacts, you are simply delving even further into territory of which you know nothing.

You clearly understand nothing of video compression, and how if affects motion in the frame. Raw DV is about 4GB a minute. Thus we can determine immediately that the .mov file you used is highly compressed.

-Gumboot
 
[
quote=TruthSeeker1234;2677448]Ron Wieck wonders how it is possible for a conspiracy to be consummated between the "conservative" administration and their "enemies" the "liberal" media. I'll write you a nice essay.


No, as I am an intelligent person, I don't "wonder" about it at all. I understand that the Bush administration and the liberal (no dishonest scare-quotes) media are genuine enemies.



To Ron Wieck:

Newsflash. The whole charade is a false choice.


Nonsense. Conservatives and liberals differ significantly.



In logic we might say false dichotomy, or insufficient options.


Logic is terra incognita for you. Your critical thinking skills are nonexistent.



The case of the Soviet experiment is instructive. The Soviets admittedly controlled the news media, and admittedly only allowed one political party. The result was that no one in the U.S.S.R believed a word "their" government said in the news.

In the U.S., the thugs are smarter. They present what appears to be choices. Democrat or Republican? Liberal or Conservative? CNN or Fox News?



You are insane. There are no "thugs." These imaginary creatures are symptoms of your illness and nothing more.




To be sure, CNN presents vastly different propaganda than Fox News. Fox sells the war, CNN sells environmentalism. Guess what? The NWO wants both!



Guess what? The NWO doesn't exist. You are insane.



They don't care who wins the election, they own both parties. They don't care which news channel you watch. I predict that the next president will be a Democrat, or perhaps a "moderate" Republican. The big word on the news will be "change".


Who are "they"? Why doesn't it matter to "them" if policies reverse and contradict one another? Why doesn't matter if one party favors greater involvement in the Middle East and the other favors a complete pull-out?



The war will go mostly off the front page, and the focus will be on "global warming". The solution to which will be more government crackdowns. Have you noticed a pattern?


Yes, I notice a pattern of mentally-ill people like yourself raving about imaginary "crackdowns." These "crackdowns" exist nowhere but in your mind. None of my freedoms have been abridged.


We elect Democrats, and government gets bigger. We elect Republicans, and government gets bigger. In 1994, the American people clearly, unambiguously voted for smaller government.
We got huge government. In 1964, the American people voted for peace. We got Viet Nam.



Yes, Bush has disappointed many conservatives who deplore his runaway spending. In 1964, the American people were frightened by a cyncial caricature of Goldwater. The public did not want to abandon South Vietnam to the communists. Where were "they" in all of this?



So to directly answer you question: Who are "they"? "They" are the class of net tax consumers. As we learn from Calhoun and Rothbard, there is no such thing as a fair tax. Any tax, of any kind, applied in any fashion, must have the effect of dividing society into two distinct classes: net tax payers, and net tax consumers.


Always the artist who hasn't learned his craft. Your ignorance of economics is abysmal. Why not read Thomas Sowell's Basic Economics before parroting Murray Rothbard?



The top of the perpetrator pyramid is the international banking cartel, and the executive branch of the U.S. government. Who could possibly rule the world besides those with the monopoly privilege to create unlimited money? Right below them are all of the swine feeding on the gravy train, which is anyone who derives all or most of their income from government contracts. Prominent among those are the war contractors, of course, and also scientists of all stripes at practically every university.


Nonsensical drivel.



The sad but inescapable truth is that a significant minority of people have entrenched themselves, greedily slurping off the government nozzle. They support the global domination project. They are all for it. They know where their bread is buttered. They are willing to do what it takes to keep the gravy train rolling down the tracks. That includes looking the other way when the big boys blow up the World Trade Center and cook up a ludicrous fairy tale about 19 party-animal-kamikazee-fundamentalist-hijackers who hate our freedom.



There are no "big boys." The jihadists are very real and your stupidity/insanity won't protect you. Your imaginary conspiracy is mathematically impossible. It is fantastic nonsense unsupported by even a shred of evidence.



Disrespectfully,

Ace Baker


You are a liar and a fool.
 
Last edited:
The war will go mostly off the front page, and the focus will be on "global warming". The solution to which will be more government crackdowns. Have you noticed a pattern? We elect Democrats, and government gets bigger. We elect Republicans, and government gets bigger. In 1994, the American people clearly, unambiguously voted for smaller government. We got huge government. In 1964, the American people voted for peace. We got Viet Nam.
(emphasis mine)

Uhh, Ace - you aren't seriously suggesting that as time passes, the government shouldn't be getting "bigger"? You do realize that our population is growing, and that our society is increasingly complicated? You cannot run a country with the same size government when you have a population of 280 million that you did when the country was a whopping 4 million people (1790, the first U.S. census) - New York City has more people than that!
 
Ron, I was a huge fan of Sowell's before I got into the Austrians. I believe I've read everything he's written. The Green cover of "Basic Economics" is staring at me from my bookshelf now. A fantastic writer. "Vision of the Anointed" rocked my world when it came out. I wore that book out. Back then I was a conservative, leaning libertarian. "Knowledge and Decisions" is a brilliant book, only later did I realize that Sowell plagiar . . ., er, was influenced heavily on that by Frederick Hayek. "Road to Serfdom" also rocked my world.

As great as Sowell is, he tends to sort of ignore some controversial topics that might upset his colleagues at the Hoover Institute. He just doesn't carry his analysis through to its logical conclusions.

It's Mises, Hoppe and Rothbard who do. "Man, Economy, and State" with "Power and Market" is basically a retelling and extension of "Human Action". It is highly recommended.

http://www.mises.org/rothbard/mes.asp

I can also regurgitate mainstream BS Neo-Keyensian claptrap they teach in school. It's just that it's false. It has no predictive or explanatory power at all. The Money Multiplier? Fiction.

Now. If you want to talk about the Austrian Business Cycle Theory, that's a great topic. The ABCT rocks my world even harder than Sowell did, and that's saying something.

(pssst. Mises and Hayek predicted the great depression. The Austrians also predicted the dotcom bust.)
 
(emphasis mine)

Uhh, Ace - you aren't seriously suggesting that as time passes, the government shouldn't be getting "bigger"? You do realize that our population is growing, and that our society is increasingly complicated? You cannot run a country with the same size government when you have a population of 280 million that you did when the country was a whopping 4 million people (1790, the first U.S. census) - New York City has more people than that!

Uhh, AZCat - I'm seriously suggesting a completely voluntary society, as in Rothbardian Anarcho-capitalism.

If you want to accept the notion of a nation-state for purposes of argument, then it should obey the written Constitution. Nothing could be more obvious than that "they" don't obey it. At all. Ron brought up Thomas Sowell. Sowell has done a very nice job of debunking the idea that government should grow with population. Go look it up.

So you should begin by admitting that the Constitution is null and void, and progress your "government ought to grow" argument from there. Is there any level of taxation or inflation that you would find extreme? What is that level? Do you agree that as taxation approaches 100%, citizens approach slavery?

Or not?
 
Ron, I was a huge fan of Sowell's before I got into the Austrians. I believe I've read everything he's written. The Green cover of "Basic Economics" is staring at me from my bookshelf now. A fantastic writer. "Vision of the Anointed" rocked my world when it came out.


A Conflict of Visions and The Vision of the Anointed are classics, and I don't toss around that term loosely. Ace, do you understand why you make people so angry? You have a way of framing your opinions--and some of them are outlandish--as absolute truth. You have never struck me as a bad guy. You frustrate--no, infuriate me by your refusal to listen to the people here who are experts in technical fields and have much to teach anyone willing to display a modicum of humility.



I wore that book out. Back then I was a conservative, leaning libertarian. "Knowledge and Decisions" is a brilliant book, only later did I realize that Sowell plagiar . . ., er, was influenced heavily on that by Frederick Hayek. "Road to Serfdom" also rocked my world.



See, that's what I'm talking about. Sowell acknowledges a debt to Hayek, but he didn't plagiarize him. Really. Nobody thinks he did.


As great as Sowell is, he tends to sort of ignore some controversial topics that might upset his colleagues at the Hoover Institute. He just doesn't carry his analysis through to its logical conclusions.



Why that crazy mindset, even where it is so obviously inappropriate? Sowell is a national treasure. He is one of the clearest thinkers alive, with a well-earned reputation for calling 'em as he sees 'em. He is not worried about upsetting anybody. You people way out on the fringe suffer from a delusion that nobody does any real work. Everything has to be some sort of mad scheme to suppress something or other.


It's Mises, Hoppe and Rothbard who do. "Man, Economy, and State" with "Power and Market" is basically a retelling and extension of "Human Action". It is highly recommended.


I struggled through Human Action in an economics course and was profoundly affected by the incisiveness of Mises's thought. Rothbard lost me when he couldn't bring himself to take sides in the Cold War. He never grasped the simple point that freedom cannot exist without order. The free market can't function properly outside the framework of a liberal democracy.




http://www.mises.org/rothbard/mes.asp


Well, I retract my statement accusing you of abysmal ignorance about economics. Still, you said some silly things about FDR and the gold standard. Sowell, as you must know, explains very clearly why linking paper money to a precious metal doesn't "back" the currency in any meaningful sense; it merely limits the amount that can be printed.
 
Uhh, AZCat - I'm seriously suggesting a completely voluntary society, as in Rothbardian Anarcho-capitalism.

If you want to accept the notion of a nation-state for purposes of argument, then it should obey the written Constitution. Nothing could be more obvious than that "they" don't obey it. At all. Ron brought up Thomas Sowell. Sowell has done a very nice job of debunking the idea that government should grow with population. Go look it up.

So you should begin by admitting that the Constitution is null and void, and progress your "government ought to grow" argument from there. Is there any level of taxation or inflation that you would find extreme? What is that level? Do you agree that as taxation approaches 100%, citizens approach slavery?

Or not?

If Sowell claims that a government should not grow in size as the population increases, then he's an idiot. The public services provided by our government are necessarily required to increase as population increases, just as any organization serves a population has to increase the number of workers as demand for services increases. Fire fighters, for example, are not blessed with infinite capacity for fighting fires. Each fireman has a limited capacity for work, and as the demand for fighting fires increases (because of a larger population) the demand for firemen increases. Since firefighting is one of the public services provided by our government, it is stupid to claim that government does not grow in size as population increases.

Please describe how our government doesn't obey the "written" Constitution. Links to nutty websites (such as tax avoidance scammers) are not appreciated.
 
Is taxation approaching 100%? I think that's an answerable question.

Federal, State and Local taxes add up to around 50% of income last I checked. Inflation is equivalent to a tax, but it is incalculable, since money creation is tippy-top secret. But you'd add that in to the study. Government regulation is also like a tax, in that it makes the economy less efficient, thus reducing standard of living.

I don't think 60% is an unreasonable estimate. Of course, many people benefit greatly from taxation, and that's the problem.

The real way to get a handle on the question is to look at government spending,, because once the government spends, the productive citizens are on the hook for it, one way or another.

Anybody want to answer the question. Where would you draw the line and say government is big enough?
 
:dl:
Wow, third sentence of the whole paper. Well done, Ace!

First Law

If no external force acts on a particle, then it is possible to select a set of reference frames, called inertial reference frames, observed from which the particle moves without any change in velocity.
Good grief, I knew these people were incompetant, ignorant and pathetic - but if that is how Truthfreaker interprets Newton ( a self-propelled object with a variable engine and in a non-vacuum cannot change its' speed) it explains pretty much all that is wrong with the CTers in one little para. That is unbelievable!!!
 
If I'm not mistaken, Hayek is not in the bibliography of "Knowledge and Decisions". I seem to recall a discussion where the Austrians were in a fit about that. If wrong, I will stand corrected. I've loaned my copy to my brother so I can't check on that tonight.

In any case, I 100% agree that Thomas Sowell is fantastic. Brilliant. He is a better pure writer than any of the Austrians. He is clear, clever, his works are always chock full of real-world examples. And he is right. As far as he goes, I am totally on board with Sowell. He was the one who really turned me on to economics. A talk show host in LA once said Sowell belongs on Mt. Rushmore. I agree.
 
:p I can't believe y'all are still arguing with our would-be Dread Pirate Danneskjold. Let him have his paper-hat fantasies already.
 
ace why have you ignored for the last 5 pages about how the thousands of witnesses and the thousands of people who saw the planes hit, LIVE, in person!?

have you even offered an answer to this question?


remember
thousands of people saw the two planes hit the buildings from various angles, from right in front of the WTC towers, up to miles away

many people, including tourists were in new york that day, and once the north tower was hit, those tourists were probably turning their cameras to the buildings as well.


you cannot create a 3d illusion no matter how you think its possible. OUR technology doesn't exist to handle the kind of crap you're proposing.

people live saw those planes hit. when are you going to explain what they saw?
 
Good grief, I knew these people were incompetant, ignorant and pathetic - but if that is how Truthfreaker interprets Newton ( a self-propelled object with a variable engine and in a non-vacuum cannot change its' speed) it explains pretty much all that is wrong with the CTers in one little para. That is unbelievable!!!

Fuelair, if you will read the paper, I say that the aircraft must be doing one of 3 things:
  • holding a constant velocity (most likely)
  • accelerating
  • decelerating
All three of these would present a smooth line on a graph, either a straight line, or perhaps a very gentle curve. Newton's first law is that an object in motion will remain in motion unless acted upon by a net force. The engines can impart a changing net force on the plane, but not in such a short time span. In other words, the plane can not be speeding up, and then slowing down, and then speeding up, and then slowing down.

I'm glad you raise this point, because you seem to be admitting that the video reveals an unstable motion. You can see it, and stabilizing the video only makes it worse. That's the key.

Fuelair evidently thinks the plane is actually speeding up and slowing down in reality. Anybody on board with that?
 
Eyewitnesses are outside the scope of this paper, but I'll touch on some points.

Logically, if even one person really saw a 767 crash into the south tower, that would invalidate the no plane theory. But there are reasons that eyewitness testimony is less valued than physical evidence. People lie. People are mistaken. People are suggestible. Etc.

Ningen has posted some interesting research tonight. We seem to have a number of firefighters saying they saw the south tower explode, and did not see or hear a plane.

http://911researchers.com/node/570
 
The Naudet film shows firefighters actually witnessing the first plane hit. Why should we consider this to be anything but fact?
 
But WHY?!? And where are they? Is this why tennis is not so terribly popular here in the States - too many net consumers? I drove by an apartment complex on Tuesday and sure enough - tennis court, no net. Or is it the scoring? "Forty-Love". I mean honestly. Give me touchdown, safety, extra point, field goal or conversion any day of the week (except Tuesday).

So we eliminate the net consumers and then we can get the planes to run on time - those planes, that is, which can be proven to be airborne.

Oh wait. Net tax consumers.

Never mind. :boxedin:

If we flood the trolls with bridges.

Ten only fools cross rivers
 
How a computer plays back the frames of a video file is not relevant for this particular analysis. All that matters is the frame rate on the original recording. Then, as long as no frames are missing, the analysis can proceed. I go through this in the paper.



Thank you for confirming that the motion is not stable. The fidelity has nothing to do with the frame rate of the original recording.



Did you even read the paper? Camera motion is what the paper is ABOUT!



Right.



Irrelevant. This could not possibly cause the apparent velocity to increase and decrease repeatedly.



The original footage is presumably a 3/4 inch video tape in a vault at WNYW. I repeat my plea and offer to the world. If anyone can provide any higher quality copy of any significant 9/11 video than is commonly available, I will pay money for it. Standing offer.



That's for good reason. Enlarging will not increase the amount of data in the original. But it will allow greater precision when stabilizing and placing wireframes. Effectively it allows you to move the frame by 1/2 pixel if need be.



Yes. If software more sophisticated can stabilize and track the airplane, I'm all for it. This is the best we have so far.



I don't agree. I've agreed to a margin of error of 1 px, maybe 2. That would reduce to 1/2 or 1.


I've debunked your points. You are flat wrong about frame rate. The footage is the highest quality copy I could find. It was digitized originally at NTSC standard 640 x 480. I invite anyone to repeat the analysis, and see if you can get a straighter line.

Your best point is that the positioning of video was done by hand. If it turns out that the motion of the plane is stable after all, it does not refute the video composite conclusion, it simply might mean they used a stable video to overlay.

The more interesting thing I've discovered is the cut-and-paste artifacts. Watch for a complete study of that.

The frame rate is flat'

Your best work was done by hand Hee Hee

A soft hand overlaying a stable video.

We've all been there.
 
My point about "approaching 100%" is that your statement implies a measurable movement of the increase in taxes such that the rate of 100% is actually being "approached."

For example, a population goes from no taxes to 50% tax in a year. The next year the tax is raised to 80%. The next year, it's raised to 92%. The next year, to 97%. The next year, to 99%.

This is a tax rate that is approaching 100%. Can you demonstrate an similar curve in the American tax rate to justify your statement that our tax rate is approaching 100%? Please show your work.

ETA: I live in Texas where we have no state income tax. We have a regressive sales tax, though - but I'd say that my personal cut I give to the government is 28%, not 50%. Perhaps California is different.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom