Disagree entirely with your premise, Myriad.
His work deserves even more mockery and scorn. It's the least that can be expected, considering the fact that he is PURPOSELY ignoring so many detractions from his crazed mindset. The level of dishonor Ace does to so many of his fellow human beings in his egotistical crusade to be "right" is off the scale. In a sense - it's monstrous. So many are dishonored and trivialized by his sick assertions. How does Robert Shaler feel about this? The guy - and his team - who had to sift through parts and pieces of human beings over a 3-year period just to provide some answers to the loved ones of those who were gruesomely murdered. Including Flight 175 passengers, some of whom Shaler's team identified.
You have every right to feel as you do and express those feelings. But is that the best way to act on those feelings, from a point of view of strategy and style? Pointing out the immorality of the truthters' unjustified allegations is a reasonable response to such allegations. But ultimately this is an argument from emotion, and using it turns the whole debate into an emotional contest, which plays into the truthers' hands. If the winner is the side that can express the strongest sense of outrage, then the contest has become equal. You've discarded your superior weapons (evidence and reason) and offered to settle it with an emotional fistfight instead. I can't stop you from doing that, but I can express my own opinion that it's a poor strategy.
Hurrah. Ace Baker made an effort at applying the scientific method. Brownie points for that.
Those points are completely overwhelmed by the subject he applied it to, and his implicit assumption that thousands of witnesses to the event must have lied or been completely wrong about what happened - not to mention his assumption that hundreds if not thousands of his fellow Americans would have to be involved with the conspiracy, and that not one of them would come forward and tell the truth.
Again, is Ace's analsysis such strong evidence that the best way to counter it is to point out the objectionable implications of his conclusions? I've seen that technique used to argue against evolution, too: "If humans just evolved by accident, then life would have no meaning, so evolution can't be right." (They're also fond of arguing that evolution is based on the "implicit assumption" of atheism so its conclusions are automatically invalid.) It's a poor type of argument there and it's a poor type of argument here. Creationists have to argue that way because the evidence is against them. You have the evidence on your side.
Myriad's post is interesting. The problem with the analogy is that Ace is not investigating an algebra problem which is somewhat subtle, which involves a principle over which no one died.
9/11 is not a high school science project, not by a long shot.
That's a bit of a strawman. My analogy was between Ace's analysis of the video and a high school science project.
Cancer is not a high school science project, and millions die from it. Yet I've seen many high school science projects investigating cancer (some conducted well, most typically amateurish). Is that offensive?
As an exercise, it's absurd in the same way that it would be to follow a Cartesian line of questioning from first principles, but to come to the opposite conclusion: "Descartes was wrong, I'm not "thinking", so I must not exist, so neither does anybody else!"
Ace makes a big show of arguing from first principles. This is only a pretense of reason.
His doubt is unreasonable. He has a track-record of other unreasonable behaviour.
If he won't believe all the people here on this forum who saw the planes hit, he has numerous other videos to choose from. He is willfully ignoring overwhelming evidence in favor of a narrow focus, which always seems to come down to an absurd way of stating his problems:
1. Call out Alt+f4 as a liar
2. Admit that you believe in Xray vision.
Again, people in my extended family lived in Tribecca and saw the second plane hit. Thousands of others did, too.
then there's this:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ThPTduiA5jI&mode=related&search=
I want to suggest that we are doing more than evaluating his findings and analysis, and that is a
good thing. To do other than what the people here are doing--mocking him--would be nerdy and, in a sense, morally wrong. It would be to ignore what we already well know.
There's a time to question, a time to doubt, and a time to mock.
And there are plenty of threads to mock in. Why this one, where he's at least shown a glimmer of rationality? Even if it's a put-on, why discourage it? How can I explain the greater belligerence and more concerted derailment efforts in this thread in particular compared to the ones where he just posts claims with no attempt to back them up, other than an attitude of "you're supposed to act like a lunatic for our enjoyment, how dare you pretend to be rational?"
I disagree agree with your claim that "Ace did very well for an amateur" for 3 reasons:
1) the question he was investigating is trivial. Even if that particular video had been tampered with, it would not change the conclusion that 2 airliners crashed into the WTC;
This is relevant in the context of evaluating Ace's overall body of arguments, but not for the question of the validity of this particular analysis. Trivial stuff, for which prevailing theory already clearly predicts the results, gets investigated all the time.
2) he didn't have sufficient understanding of the subject matter (e.g., the capabilities of PhotoShop) and failed to do background research or consult with experts;
This is a valid criticism of his methodology. Why didn't you bring it up before?
3) he failed to consider contrary evidence.
This is also relevant to Ace's overall beliefs and conclusions but not to this analysis, whose results stand or fall on their own. Science is reductionistic; the results of an experiment show what they show, generating evidence independently of what other evidence obtained in a different way shows. Eventually, findings with the overall weight of evidence against them are discarded and the flaws in them are revealed, but ignoring the results (or not doing the investigation)
a priori because contrary evidence exists is jumping the gun.
Sure, if this had been done by a 15 year-old, you could say that it was a good learning experience. But Ace isn't a 15 year-old.
And only 15-year-olds can have good learning experiences? What's the cut-off age? I was under the impression that adults learned things at this site.
Look, I don't think Ace's investigation shows anything of value or makes an even remotely convincing case for his no-planes conjecture. I have no interest in promoting or defending Ace's case in general, especially because he's shown no interest in defending it himself in this thread. But I do think there are better ways to argue the issue than appeals to emotion, ridicule, berating amateurs for not meeting professional standards, and arguing from the consequences. If this forum turns into a whose-outrage-is-bigger p***ing match, what useful purpose can it serve?
Respectfully,
Myriad