Chopper 5 Velocity Study Proves Video Composite, Reveals Sloppy Photoshopping

I clearly explained this about 4 times in the article. However, the article has now been deleted by the moderators. Dave, if you were unintelligent, I would chalk it up to poor reading comprehension. You're not unintelligent.

For anyone who does have reading comprehension problems, I'll rephrase it, and try to spell it out even more than in my article. Pay careful attention. I'll add step numbers, maybe that will help.

1. The video of the airplane was recorded prior to 9/11. The plane was flying north, at around 9 am, on a clear day, a day where the sky was more pink than on 9/11.
2. The background from this airplane video was removed, leaving a plane flying against a transparency. They could have spent days, months or years doing this.
3. They needed to leave sky color around the perimeter of the plane, to get it to blend. They needed to leave intact the area behind the engines, so that it would show the distortions caused by jet exhaust. Unfortunately, the sky was a different color on 9/11, so you can tell.
4. Overall, they did a pretty good job, except on frame 7. On frame 7, it looks exactly like "sky color" was painted around the nose. It matches the more pink color of the sky color behind the engines, and around the plane. It does not match the sky color from the overall video. It also shows the 2 round areas of digital "paint" where the "brushstroke" began and ended.
5. In case I forgot to mention it, THIS WAS DONE PRIOR TO 9/11.
6. On 9/11, the live video from Chopper 5 was split into two copies, with only the towers remaining in one copy, as explained in the article. This is done in real time, as explained.
7. The PRE-EXISTING airplane video, on an otherwise transparent layer, is sandwiched in between the two video layers in step6.


Did I mention that the airplane video was edited BEFORE (i.e. prior to, i.e. in advance of, i.e. at an earlier point in time than, i.e. pre-dating, i.e. previous to, i.e. anticipating) 9/11?

[URL]http://www.acebaker.com/9-11/PinocchioStudy/PastedPlane-Contrast.jpg[/URL]

So how were they able to construct a supposed special effect days, weeks, months, or perhaps years in advance of what real live witnesses in the tens of thousands witnessed that day live with their very own eyes?
You appear to suffer from a mental illness in that you perceive the world around you is conspiring against you. In the Hollywood film Truman the lead character played out his life but in the reality of the show it was all a big movie set and Ace baker was the focus of the televised worldwide grand delusion. Yes Ace we are all watching you. We are laughing, We log in here every day to watch You, Lyte Trip, PDoh, Stundie, And the like make fools of yourselves. Flaunting your delusions and mental illness. Don't you think there is a cognitive problem when no one in this world believes the events happened as you do? Keep posting. With every post it chips away at your credibility with the fence sitters. And when you get a chance. Answer the posts I quoted below.

Ace, TS, or whatever you call yourself,

Could you please explain to me how the NWO, Government, or whoever you think made these videos also somehow implanted the images of 2 planes hitting the WTC in to my EYEBALLS!

See, I was there, and I personally witnessed both planes hitting the buildings.

I saw everything, EVERYTHING!

I saw it firsthand, not on video, not by description after the fact. I saw BOTH PLANES HIT THE BUILDINGS!!!

Please explain how I saw what you say didn't happen.

Please, this I gotta hear.

Forget that, he can't be asked to explain what people didn't see. I just want him to explain what I did see.

I was a few hundred yards from WTC1 walking towards it when the first plane hit. I looked up when I heard an incredibly loud jet engine sound a second or two before the plane hit. It was so loud that the ground was vibrating and I actually felt the sound. Of course the crash and resulting explosion was even louder, but I'll never forget the sound of the jet. Its what made me look up. Then there it was, an American Airlines jet flying full speed in to the north tower.

So please tell me Ace, how did the big bad NWO not only implant images in to my eyeball, but also have the accompanying sound effects so perfectly staged?
 
You have every right to feel as you do and express those feelings. But is that the best way to act on those feelings, from a point of view of strategy and style? Pointing out the immorality of the truthters' unjustified allegations is a reasonable response to such allegations. But ultimately this is an argument from emotion, and using it turns the whole debate into an emotional contest, which plays into the truthers' hands. If the winner is the side that can express the strongest sense of outrage, then the contest has become equal. You've discarded your superior weapons (evidence and reason) and offered to settle it with an emotional fistfight instead. I can't stop you from doing that, but I can express my own opinion that it's a poor strategy.
It's a poor strategy for you, Myriad, and therefore you have every right to commend Baker's "analysis" and encourage his pointless and futile activities.

But it's a terrific strategy for me, which is exactly why I employ it. Evidence and reason are as effective at blunting Baker's stupidity as spraying a medical hypodermic full of water at a raging California wildfire. He doesn't listen to or acknowledge the concepts of reason, evidence, proof and so forth. Therefore, presenting only those to parry Baker's blindingly foolish conclusions borders on insanity. Other pathways must be forged and attempted.

The time-honored art of scorn-heaping is one such pathway.

Which is why I insist that Baker begin looking at the real possibility that the two airliners were really experimental "jump jets" that hovered in the air that September day. The entire island of Manhattan was then slid into the stationary jets. This has not been exhaustively explored, and Ace Baker is just the man to do it! I want pictures!
 
Other pathways must be forged and attempted.

The time-honored art of scorn-heaping is one such pathway.

Fair enough!

If it proves effective (particularly, at persuading fence-sitters), I'll have to change my position.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Fair enough!

If it proves effective (particularly, at persuading fence-sitters), I'll have to change my position.

Respectfully,
Myriad
You, sir, are an exceedingly honorable gentleman and schooner! Er, scholar.

As long as you promise not to change your position on my account. :)
 
TrushSeeker, given the first plane strike alone - be it real or faked - was likely to be one of the biggest news stories in American history; and hundreds or thousands of cameras and camcorders were likely to be trained on the towers:

a) Would it not be incredibly risky of conspirators to fake a plane strike in the way you propose?
b) Can you think of a reasonable explanation of how they've prevented any smoking-gun photos or videos from surfacing?
 
I clearly explained this about 4 times in the article. However, the article has now been deleted by the moderators. Dave, if you were unintelligent, I would chalk it up to poor reading comprehension. You're not unintelligent.

For anyone who does have reading comprehension problems, I'll rephrase it, and try to spell it out even more than in my article. Pay careful attention. I'll add step numbers, maybe that will help.

1. The video of the airplane was recorded prior to 9/11. The plane was flying north, at around 9 am, on a clear day, a day where the sky was more pink than on 9/11.


No, you're lying. Not a word of this true. You made it up.


2. The background from this airplane video was removed, leaving a plane flying against a transparency. They could have spent days, months or years doing this.


You're lying. Not a word of this is true. You made it up.


3. They needed to leave sky color around the perimeter of the plane, to get it to blend. They needed to leave intact the area behind the engines, so that it would show the distortions caused by jet exhaust. Unfortunately, the sky was a different color on 9/11, so you can tell.
4. Overall, they did a pretty good job, except on frame 7. On frame 7, it looks exactly like "sky color" was painted around the nose. It matches the more pink color of the sky color behind the engines, and around the plane. It does not match the sky color from the overall video. It also shows the 2 round areas of digital "paint" where the "brushstroke" began and ended.


There is no "they." The people you refer to are imaginary. You're lying again.



5. In case I forgot to mention it, THIS WAS DONE PRIOR TO 9/11.


No, it wasn't. The videos were shot live. You're lying again.


6. On 9/11, the live video from Chopper 5 was split into two copies, with only the towers remaining in one copy, as explained in the article. This is done in real time, as explained.
7. The PRE-EXISTING airplane video, on an otherwise transparent layer, is sandwiched in between the two video layers in step6.



I am tired of reading explanations correcting your idiocy by people competent to discuss the subject. You are a mentally-disturbed liar. You are incompetent to make judgments about matters you know nothing about. Your act is a bore.


Did I mention that the airplane video was edited BEFORE (i.e. prior to, i.e. in advance of, i.e. at an earlier point in time than, i.e. pre-dating, i.e. previous to, i.e. anticipating) 9/11?

http://www.acebaker.com/9-11/PinocchioStudy/PastedPlane-Contrast.jpg


Newcomers wading through your gibberish are curious to know how much of it may be attributed to your manifest mental illness and how much to your dishonesty. I would argue that your dishonesty is forced upon you by your illness. What people here don't understand is where you're coming from.

The question in most minds is the obvious one: Why would media outlets, overwhelmingly liberal and implacably hostile to the Bush administration, participate in a fantastic crime to line the pockets of Dick Cheney, a man they despise? For almost all of us, your imaginary conspiracy collapses at this point. I have met other anarcho-libertarians and I understand that you are incapable of distinguishing George Bush from Barack Obama. To you, both are evil statists (a term you are clueless about). The man who responded belatedly to the jihadist threat is no different from the man who believes that the threat is bogus.

Those of us who inhabit the real world understand perfectly well that the networks hate Bush and do everything in their power to undermine "his" war on terror. The idea that they faked video of planes crashing into the Twin Towers is preposterous nonsense on several levels. Your often-demonstrated technical incompetence masks your fundamental inability to comprehend basic political realities. For your imaginary, mathematically-impossible conspiracy to exist, all that we know about the world must be an illusion. Republicans and Democrats who seem to loathe each other must secretly be allies in a gigantic imperialist venture that, oddly enough, comes to an abrupt halt whenever a Democrat enters the White House.

Mindless fantasists have even tried to enlist John Kerry, of all people, into the Impossibly Vast Conspiracy, citing his confused and uninformed comments on WTC 7. Like you, they are not inconvenienced by the fact that by blowing the whistle, he could have gotten himself elected Presdient of the United States.

Seek help, Ace. Seriously. You are ill.
 
TrushSeeker, given the first plane strike alone - be it real or faked - was likely to be one of the biggest news stories in American history; and hundreds or thousands of cameras and camcorders were likely to be trained on the towers:

a) Would it not be incredibly risky of conspirators to fake a plane strike in the way you propose?
b) Can you think of a reasonable explanation of how they've prevented any smoking-gun photos or videos from surfacing?

Bingo!

Bullseye!!

Ace is totally crushed by these obvious questions. But--he DOESN'T CARE.

He dismisses them as he dismisses the THOUSANDS of eyewitnesses who SAW the crash of Flight 175 from the street and their office windows.

He is insane.
 
If there was nothing incoming, no missile, no anything, then it's not so risky for the perps. How can someone take a picture of nothing?

If there was, say, a missile, that's riskier. What if a citizen happens to get a video of it coming in? I bet the plan was to come out with a boatload of plane videos and eyewitnesses, and if the citizen videographer doesn't want to "cooperate", then you launch the smear campaign, claim the missile video is a fake, etc. Overwhelm the situation with quantity.

There was a live network video that appeared to show something very small, like a missile, coming in at a steep angle. Then the same video appeared later with a much larger plane in it.

You might want to talk to "Bob and Bri". Their video cuts out right before the south tower strike. A lot of us find that a bit suspicious.
 
Who Are "They"?

Tell us, Ace, who "they" are. If it turns out that "they" are the Bush administration AND its avowed enemies, you will have been exposed--again--as an incoherent extremist.
 
If there was nothing incoming, no missile, no anything, then it's not so risky for the perps. How can someone take a picture of nothing?

Two hijacked commercial airliners hit the Twin Towers, Ace. There were no missiles.


If there was, say, a missile, that's riskier. What if a citizen happens to get a video of it coming in? I bet the plan was to come out with a boatload of plane videos and eyewitnesses, and if the citizen videographer doesn't want to "cooperate", then you launch the smear campaign, claim the missile video is a fake, etc.


WHOSE plan was it, Ace? You are aligning your evil imperialist neocons with media liberals who hate them and oppose everything they do.


Overwhelm the situation with quantity.

There was a live network video that appeared to show something very small, like a missile, coming in at a steep angle. Then the same video appeared later with a much larger plane in it.


You're lying again. THOUSANDS of eyewitnesses SAW Flight 175 crash.



You might want to talk to "Bob and Bri". Their video cuts out right before the south tower strike. A lot of us find that a bit suspicious.

Only lunatics find anything suspicious. Where did the plane go, Ace? Oh, wait--there was no plane. What did all the eyewitnesses see?

They're all in on the conspiracy--the conspiracy that combines Bush and his worst enemies: the conspiracy to achieve aims that WILL BE ABANDONED AS SOON AS A DEMOCRAT TAKES OFFICE, YOU NITWIT!!
 
If there was nothing incoming, no missile, no anything, then it's not so risky for the perps. How can someone take a picture of nothing?

If there was, say, a missile, that's riskier. What if a citizen happens to get a video of it coming in? I bet the plan was to come out with a boatload of plane videos and eyewitnesses, and if the citizen videographer doesn't want to "cooperate", then you launch the smear campaign, claim the missile video is a fake, etc. Overwhelm the situation with quantity.

There was a live network video that appeared to show something very small, like a missile, coming in at a steep angle. Then the same video appeared later with a much larger plane in it.

You might want to talk to "Bob and Bri". Their video cuts out right before the south tower strike. A lot of us find that a bit suspicious.

Who is this "us'" ?? are you now wearing cargo pants with mice in every pocket? I was absolutely correct. You do see yourself as the lead in the movie Truman.

and you never addressed my repost of jujigatamis questions
 
Why would media outlets, overwhelmingly liberal and implacably hostile to the Bush administration, participate in a fantastic crime to line the pockets of Dick Cheney, a man they despise?
And it wasn't just American media outlets which covered the events that day, lots of foreign news agencies did as well. So does that mean CBC, CTV, Global, to name three networks in Canada, are also part of the cover-up?

Their video cuts out right before the south tower strike. A lot of us find that a bit suspicious.
And what the at least forty other camera angles of the impact? What about all the still photos? What about the thousands of eyewitnesses?
 
You might want to talk to "Bob and Bri". Their video cuts out right before the south tower strike. A lot of us find that a bit suspicious.


No it doesn't, unless they waited about 7 minutes after the first tower hit to start recording. The south tower strike's fireball is seen a little over 11 minutes into the video (not counting the opening crawl) but it was more than 15 minutes between the two tower hits, indicating to me that she shut the camera off for several minutes, thinking things were over for now, but then grabbed it and hit "record" again after hearing the second crash. It's the same as for the south tower collapse -- there's a bunch of minutes of time missing and then you see the immediate aftermath because she grabbed the camera and hit "record" again after hearing noise.
 
Last edited:
Tell us, Ace, who "they" are. If it turns out that "they" are the Bush administration AND its avowed enemies, you will have been exposed--again--as an incoherent extremist.
"They" are Bob and Bri, as he teased us with. I like how, as a good professor will do, the Bakester lets YOU discover the complete picture by unveiling just enough of the mosaic. We got a clever brain workin' here, Ron.

Bob is obviously the lock-stepping Bush supporter and Bri is the Marxist-Leninist-Leftist-Liberal-Whale-Hugging Democrat. Bri was innocently filming the horror when Bob, realizing what was coming to WTC2 and when, showed her something that was even more interesting. Well - to Bri anyway.

And since theirs was the only video of the alleged "Flight 175" strike upon WTC2, the fly - I mean door - was open for widespread speculation as to "what really happened".

Darned politicians. They beat us poor folks every time, just becuz they're smarter. I wish I was a politician so's I could be smart. Or be like Ace - smart with no politicking and no plane.
 
You're confusing recording with playback. The frame rate on recording must be stable, or my velocity study is dismissed, as I state in the article. After that, the only issue is whether or not any frames are missing. Even consumer video recorders are are very stable, recording at 29.97 fps.

Here is the source I used:

http://www.questionsquestions.net/WTC/summaryimages/fox11secondhitexcerpt.mov

If anyone has any sources of any significant 9/11 videos that are higher quality than is commonly available, I'll pay money for them.


Yes but the footage you used is not the original recording. It is a digital media file of unknown origin. Thus you cannot know if the frame rate is consistent.

See, you see the motion of the aircraft as being evidence of a fake. I see it as evidence that the video does not have a stable frame rate. And no, I am not confusing recording and playback. Digital media files are notoriously bad at preserving frame fidelity.

You have allowed no margin of error in your study. Here's a few factors that contribute significantly to margin of error:

1) The camera is in motion
2) The object is in motion
3) The object is moving at high speed
4) The object is not moving parallel to the X-axis of the camera.
5) The footage being used is not the original footage
6) The image has been enlarged
7) Measurement of the object's movement has been measured manually

Your raw data graph shows a margin of error of +/- 3 pixels. Allowing for an enlargement of the image 2x, this means a margin of error of +/- 1.5 pixels.

Each of the factors listed above could easily on its own account for this degree of margin of error. Your research indicates the footage in question is genuine.

-Gumboot
 
Ron Wieck wonders how it is possible for a conspiracy to be consummated between the "conservative" administration and their "enemies" the "liberal" media. I'll write you a nice essay.

To Ron Wieck:

Newsflash. The whole charade is a false choice. In logic we might say false dichotomy, or insufficient options. The case of the Soviet experiment is instructive. The Soviets admittedly controlled the news media, and admittedly only allowed one political party. The result was that no one in the U.S.S.R believed a word "their" government said in the news.

In the U.S., the thugs are smarter. They present what appears to be choices. Democrat or Republican? Liberal or Conservative? CNN or Fox News?

To be sure, CNN presents vastly different propaganda than Fox News. Fox sells the war, CNN sells environmentalism. Guess what? The NWO wants both! They don't care who wins the election, they own both parties. They don't care which news channel you watch. I predict that the next president will be a Democrat, or perhaps a "moderate" Republican. The big word on the news will be "change".

The war will go mostly off the front page, and the focus will be on "global warming". The solution to which will be more government crackdowns. Have you noticed a pattern? We elect Democrats, and government gets bigger. We elect Republicans, and government gets bigger. In 1994, the American people clearly, unambiguously voted for smaller government. We got huge government. In 1964, the American people voted for peace. We got Viet Nam.

So to directly answer you question: Who are "they"? "They" are the class of net tax consumers. As we learn from Calhoun and Rothbard, there is no such thing as a fair tax. Any tax, of any kind, applied in any fashion, must have the effect of dividing society into two distinct classes: net tax payers, and net tax consumers.

The top of the perpetrator pyramid is the international banking cartel, and the executive branch of the U.S. government. Who could possibly rule the world besides those with the monopoly privilege to create unlimited money? Right below them are all of the swine feeding on the gravy train, which is anyone who derives all or most of their income from government contracts. Prominent among those are the war contractors, of course, and also scientists of all stripes at practically every university.

The sad but inescapable truth is that a significant minority of people have entrenched themselves, greedily slurping off the government nozzle. They support the global domination project. They are all for it. They know where their bread is buttered. They are willing to do what it takes to keep the gravy train rolling down the tracks. That includes looking the other way when the big boys blow up the World Trade Center and cook up a ludicrous fairy tale about 19 party-animal-kamikazee-fundamentalist-hijackers who hate our freedom.

Disrespectfully,

Ace Baker
 
The top of the perpetrator pyramid is the international banking cartel, and the executive branch of the U.S. government. Who could possibly rule the world besides those with the monopoly privilege to create unlimited money?


Newsflash: there are plenty of other sovereign states in the world besides the United States of America and the use of fiat currency is widespread, so all of their central banks would also have to be involved.
 
To be sure, CNN presents vastly different propaganda than Fox News. Fox sells the war, CNN sells environmentalism. Guess what? The NWO wants both! They don't care who wins the election, they own both parties.
Okay. So what's the NWO's opinion on CTV? The CBC? How about Citytv? How about Global? Do the own the Liberal Party of Canada? What about the NDP? Where does the BQ fit into their schemes?

Or is the NWO some sort of American-only enterprise? (If so, then they really ought to remove the "W" from their name.)
 
<snipped above>

So to directly answer you question: Who are "they"? "They" are the class of net tax consumers. As we learn from Calhoun and Rothbard, there is no such thing as a fair tax. Any tax, of any kind, applied in any fashion, must have the effect of dividing society into two distinct classes: net tax payers, and net tax consumers.
But WHY?!? And where are they? Is this why tennis is not so terribly popular here in the States - too many net consumers? I drove by an apartment complex on Tuesday and sure enough - tennis court, no net. Or is it the scoring? "Forty-Love". I mean honestly. Give me touchdown, safety, extra point, field goal or conversion any day of the week (except Tuesday).

So we eliminate the net consumers and then we can get the planes to run on time - those planes, that is, which can be proven to be airborne.

Oh wait. Net tax consumers.

Never mind. :boxedin:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom