Chopper 5 Velocity Study Proves Video Composite, Reveals Sloppy Photoshopping

Another Spit fan here. I have a similar photo of a V doing the same "pose" and you still have all those original Mitchell curves largely intact; that variant's always been my personal favourite. But then when you see the IX or a Griffon-engined job blatting along at high speed and low level, it has a beauty all its own. The low-backs, not so much, but I bet they saved a few lives with the increased visibility.

OK, back to the kitten pics!



The Mark IX still had the malcolm hood and the higher tail.

The Mark IX was just a Mark V airframe fitted with a Merlin 61 engine instead of a Merlin 45.

That's what makes them so great, they had the look of the Mark V, but with the extra grunt of a more powerful engine.

Personally I think the Spitfire was the Queen of the skies and the Mustang was the king... :)

The Corsair was their highly talented deformed cousin :p

-Gumboot
 
[*]In the WNYW "Chopper 5" video, a wide angle shot fails to depict flight 175, at a time and place when flight 175 should be in the picture. (see StillDiggin 2006)

Thought I'd take a crask at this one, as it can be debunked with only one image. That analysis assumes a straight approach, and claims "Any other path would result in the "plane" being even closer to WTC than I have presented.". This is true but he fails to mention that if you took a more realistic approach - of the final turn Flight 175 made and not a straight line, the plane can be closer to the WTC and out of the shot.
53juv6f.jpg


He states that the plane would have to be travelling at 632mph to be out of shot 6.1 seconds before impact. This is all based on the 1.07 mile distance to the edge of the shot, perpendicular to the towers. However, due to the angle of the view the plane could be as close as 0.99 miles, and thus need a velocity of (0.99*6.1)*3600 = 584mph. Which is within estimates by FEMA and the FAA, and close to an RAF estimate. My own estimate from that video was 592mph.

And of course my entire post is moot anyway, the plane would never be visible on zoomed out shot from 4 miles, which has been compressed to hell.
 
And of course my entire post is moot anyway, the plane would never be visible on zoomed out shot from 4 miles, which has been compressed to hell.

Unless you used Photoshop.
 
The Mark IX still had the malcolm hood and the higher tail.


Forget the Spitfire. Let's argue about what the tail markings were on the Enola Gay when it dropped the bomb. I say it was the 509th's "circle arrow" marking.
 
Alright before I go back and start to read this entire thread could somebody please tell me if it's worth it? Or should I just continue to do what I have been and check out the pictures of the kittens and ignore the rest?

It's kittens all the way down.
 
Forget the Spitfire. Let's argue about what the tail markings were on the Enola Gay when it dropped the bomb. I say it was the 509th's "circle arrow" marking.


This is the Enola Gay landing at Tinian after dropping the atomic bomb on Hiroshima.

-Gumboot
 
So near.... yet so far

A cat.... a chipmunk.... a screen door.
 

Attachments

  • Cat.jpg
    Cat.jpg
    38.6 KB · Views: 6
Doing such an analysis on a previously compressed video, then expanding its frames thus garnering more interpolation by the computer, and thinking you can make a determination of anything within a few pixel widths, is the height of pure ignorance.

IF one wished to do a study of this video clip it would only be possible to get any meaningful conclusions by having a direct, uncompressed copy of the original raw video. Just the very fact that the banner is displayed on the video means that it ran through a processor to insert that banner. Such CG machines can alter the entire frame.

We also do not know if the camera was set on auto focus or auto iris, both of which will change the data recorded, especially on moving objects or scenes in which the amount of light changes. Such changes are not noticable to the naked eye but on a minute pixel by pixel examination they would be.

then there is just the fact that so many people actually SAW the plane hit the building and that many other cameras recorded the event.

To that point, this;

is a particularily odd thing to say since Morgan Reynolds also argues that the shot that actually shows the plane going into the building illustrates that the building just swallowed up the plane and must be fake. Either no videos show the plane actually hitting the tower or there is one that shows the plane hitting the tower. Which is it Ace? Try not to answer with anything resembling circular reasoning.



Actually Photoshoppe is a proprietery name, not a generic term.
It is only "generic" in the same sense that "Kleenex" is generic for facial tissue.

He's using the homeopathic method of data analysis.

Take compressed data, add ignorance to proper dilution.
Serve to fools.
 
#Enola gay, you should have stayed at home yesterday#

...but, in the end, you probably saved more lives than if you had.

/peep show
 
My 10 year-old nephew sent me this link just today. Take a look, it's only 90 seconds.

Stop! (not really)

If I see too much more of that nonsense I may have to acquire some felines. Then I'll be my own worst stereotype: Single guy with 2 cats. :eek:
 
Forget the Spitfire. Let's argue about what the tail markings were on the Enola Gay when it dropped the bomb. I say it was the 509th's "circle arrow" marking.


Here ya go:

The group was assigned tail markings of a circle outline around an arrowhead pointing forward, but at the beginning of August, after it began flying combat missions, its fifteen B-29's were given the tail markings of other XXI Bomber Command groups as a security measure. The victor numbers previously assigned the aircraft were changed to avoid confusion with B-29s of the groups from whom the tail identifiers were borrowed.[19]

Victor numbers 82, 89, 90, and 91 (including the Enola Gay) carried the markings of the 6th Bomb Group (Circle R); victors 71, 72, 73, and 84 those of the 497th Bomb Group (large "A"); victors 77, 85, 86, and 88 those of the 444th Bomb Group (triangle N); and victors 83, 94, and 95 those of the 39th Bomb Group (square P).[20]

Source

-Gumboot
 
Ace;
Technical aspects aside, What about the thousands of eyewitnesses. I know you don't like the question but you have to answer it eventually.

The sum total of eyewitnesses who are willing to talk to me is, thusfar, zero. Alt+F4 insists that she saw UA175 hit the south tower, yet she admits that she was a couple miles north of the towers. Considering UA175 is alleged to have hit the south face, this would imply that Alt+F4 has Xray vision.

You all have a choice:

1. Call out Alt+f4 as a liar
2. Admit that you believe in Xray vision
 
The sum total of eyewitnesses who are willing to talk to me is, thusfar, zero. Alt+F4 insists that she saw UA175 hit the south tower, yet she admits that she was a couple miles north of the towers. Considering UA175 is alleged to have hit the south face, this would imply that Alt+F4 has Xray vision.

You all have a choice:

1. Call out Alt+f4 as a liar
2. Admit that you believe in Xray vision
.... 3. Make you explain how the Pinocchio Effect in the late Pleistocene brought us the admirable yet enigmatic aardvark.

I'm a gonna go fer that 3rd one, ya think?
 
Last edited:
The sum total of eyewitnesses who are willing to talk to me is, thusfar, zero. Alt+F4 insists that she saw UA175 hit the south tower, yet she admits that she was a couple miles north of the towers. Considering UA175 is alleged to have hit the south face, this would imply that Alt+F4 has Xray vision.

You all have a choice:

1. Call out Alt+f4 as a liar
2. Admit that you believe in Xray vision

Picture put under spoiler for dial-up users.
Connection.gif
 
Last edited:
The sum total of eyewitnesses who are willing to talk to me is, thusfar, zero. Alt+F4 insists that she saw UA175 hit the south tower, yet she admits that she was a couple miles north of the towers. Considering UA175 is alleged to have hit the south face, this would imply that Alt+F4 has Xray vision.

You all have a choice:

1. Call out Alt+f4 as a liar
2. Admit that you believe in Xray vision

I choose pomegranate!
 
The sum total of eyewitnesses who are willing to talk to me is, thusfar, zero. Alt+F4 insists that she saw UA175 hit the south tower, yet she admits that she was a couple miles north of the towers. Considering UA175 is alleged to have hit the south face, this would imply that Alt+F4 has Xray vision.

You all have a choice:

1. Call out Alt+f4 as a liar
2. Admit that you believe in Xray vision

We were about 20 blocks north, so about a mile.

I couldn't give a [rule 8] if you or anyone else thinks I'm a liar.

I'm still in contact with a few of those kids, now in college (yikes!) and I'm going to ask a few of them to visit my classes around 9/11 and talk to the kids about what we all saw that day, the terrible loss, and what it means now.

You have no influence with your disrespectful, delusional Internet postings. I'll be teaching Social Studies for the next 15-20 years and will influence thousands of teenagers to become critical thinkers regarding 9/11.

Thanks Ace, you've made it even easier for teenagers to realize that 9/11 conspiracies are garbage. While a typical 16 year-old might not know how a controlled demolition works, your BS is obvious even to kids in my Special Education class.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom