Chopper 5 Velocity Study Proves Video Composite, Reveals Sloppy Photoshopping

Conclusions and Discussion

Conclusion: it's easier to ram planes into buildings than to fake them.

In a real crash, a plane could not possibly accelerate while entering the tower. Yet in this video, the plane appears to do just that.

Key word: appears.

Frame #7 reveals tell-tale signs of having been "cut-and-pasted". The area around the nose of the aircraft is a different color than the sky, more pink, and pixels under the nose appear to have been erased in what looks to me like the swipe of a digital paintbrush.

You really know nothing about video compression, do you ?

Perhaps this was an inadvertant mistake, perhaps it was a deliberate clue.

Or perhaps you're just way out of your league.

Due to the camera motion, the realistic blending of the airplane into the sky, and the sloppy photoshopping

Yeah, that's right. Photoshopping live videos is a killer.

Multiple videos were made from multiple cameras by multiple camera operators, capturing the flight from a great number of different angles and distances, including helicopter shots from above. The backgrounds from these videos were removed, leaving just a plane flying against a transparency. These multiple videos became overlays for the many "amateur" videos which emerged later.

Speculation.

A careful examination of the the exiting nose cone provides further evidence that this is a composite video, and does not depict an actual real life event.

If you had paid ANY attention to the posters here, which you never have, you'd know that that was NOT a nose cone. It's part of the explosion. The mere fact that it has a similar shape does not mean it's a nose cone.

Computer software was used to model the twin tower, and mask it off dynamically in real time.

Boy, you just keep inventing more and more non-existent technology, do you ?

I can't wait for you guys to bring your various "theories" to court and see them shot down, one after another.

I am a music composer and producer by profession.

Why don't you just go on writing tunes and let the grown ups do the investigations, m'kay ?

In my opinion, based on other studies by other authors, the evidence and scientific reasoning support the idea that no planes crashed at any of the 4 "crash locations" on 9/11.

I just love it when woo-woos use the word "scientific" as though it meant something to them.
 
TS - just the link and an "interesting" is enough for me.

Kitten Launcher no.3 crew load Death Ray Eye Kittens.

Sir, DRE Kittens already loaded!

Kitten Launcher no.3 crew - Fire!
 

Attachments

  • deathrays.jpg
    deathrays.jpg
    23.4 KB · Views: 323
Last edited:
Shrinker said:
You also state you increased the image size by 200%. You must realise that this doesn't add extra data

IT DOESN'T ??? But they do it all the time in Star Trek !!!!

Plus, they have BEAM weapons in Star Trek. And life-like HOLOGRAMS!!!
 
Grade Report

Student name: Baker, Ace

Course: Physics 101

Grade: F

To be fair to Ace - and believe me, I'm trying very hard to be fair to Ace, because I feel rather responsible for this mess he's put together - his total misunderstanding of Newton's laws is no more than tangential to the reason why his analysis is meaningless. The statement that the airliner's speed should not show large fluctuations over a timescale of less than a second (I'm paraphrasing Ace's argument to make it comprehensible) is quite reasonable. What isn't reasonable, and what would also have him failing a first year physics course, is a total failure to appreciate the concept of random measurement errors. On the halo analysis I'm happy to defer to those with more experience.

BTW, I agree about the Spitfire IX as a dogfighter - as did most of its pilots, from what I've read - but I have a photo of a MkIIB seen in plan view while banking in a 1941 aircraft spotter's guide at home that is simply the most beautiful picture of an aeroplane ever taken. IMO the Merlin 60 nose just doesn't quite look as good. I just wanted to say that without posting in the Flight 175 thread, which I've vowed never to do.

Dave
 
:dl:
Wow, third sentence of the whole paper. Well done, Ace!

First Law

If no external force acts on a particle, then it is possible to select a set of reference frames, called inertial reference frames, observed from which the particle moves without any change in velocity.


To be fair, I think he's talking about the airplane's motion through the air before it hits the building.

The conjecture that the plane's velocity through the air should be smooth on a short time scale (before impact) is reasonable. However, a control study is needed to establish that an airplane that is smoothly moving through the air, videotaped at the same distance and angle under similar conditions by similar equipment, with the video then compressed, magnified, etc. in the same way, and then analyzed using the same procedure (preferably blind, that is with the people doing the analysis unaware of whether they're analyzing the control video or the suspected false video), yields any significant difference between the two.

Respectfully,
Myriad

ETA: Scopped by Dave Rogers. The control study I suggest would be one way to establish the magnitude of the measurement error.
 
Last edited:
chopper5graphbothsj9.jpg
 
Ace, I don't really mind having to ignore your idiotic "research" and I don't think you should be banned....but just promise me something.

Promise me that you will one day seek medical help and that you will not buy a gun a go postal on some innocent people.

OK, Ace? Can you do that?
 
My neighbor took photos of the second plane as it hit the tower. Is he an agent for the NWO?

I'm sure you can do a web search of people's photos of the planes. Are they ALL NWO agents?
 
My neighbor took photos of the second plane as it hit the tower. Is he an agent for the NWO?

I'm sure you can do a web search of people's photos of the planes. Are they ALL NWO agents?



I think the idea is there are only about six eyewitnesses, master sloof Ace Baker has personally proven five of those to be liars and the sixth one ran off.
 
Alright before I go back and start to read this entire thread could somebody please tell me if it's worth it? Or should I just continue to do what I have been and check out the pictures of the kittens and ignore the rest?
 
Alright before I go back and start to read this entire thread could somebody please tell me if it's worth it? Or should I just continue to do what I have been and check out the pictures of the kittens and ignore the rest?


My own snide remark about using ImageReady for this sort of editing notwithstanding, I thought that several of the longer posts by members of this forum were interesting and worth reading, most notably Shrinker's post about actual video manipulation - though there were several which were right up there. Dave Rogers had a nice one as well.
 
Ace: What if the pilot of Chopper 5 had somebody else in the cockpit whom he and/or she was trying to initiate into the Mile High Club? Wouldn't that alter the camera image and account for the Pinocchio Effect?

Pinocchio Effect = Woody (get it?)

Otherwise, everything else makes sense, especially the Clear Sky Rule as endorsed by Judy Wood. Good show!
 
Dave Rogers - thank you for a reasonable reply.

Ace,

The two main issues, and my comments on them, are:

(1) The so-called "digital halo" around the plane. Other posters have suggested that these may be due to video compression artefacts. Have you studied the edges of the towers to see whether they show similar artefacts, or looked at compressed videos where you know no compositing has taken place, to compare effects and see whether what you observe is unique to digital compositing? Your analysis of this point suffers from the absence of a control sample, a basic principle of scientific analysis, and at present you have yet to prove that your explanation is superior to the alternatives that have been advanced.

Adding control samples is a great idea. I'm quite sure that planes don't leave trails of pink pixels behind them. I'm quite sure that noses of airplanes don't ever look like a swipe with a digital paintbrush.

(2) The variations in apparent aircraft speed. I accept that your normalisation technique is valid - measuring the difference in position between the aircraft and the edge of the tower is an effective way to eliminate camera movement. What you have failed to address is any kind of analysis of the random errors in your measurement of the airliner position. This is first year university course material. Your graph of speed against frame number looks very much like a horizontal line at 23 pixels/frame with a random error of +/- 4 pixels/frame, so your argument rests entirely on the unstated premise that you can measure the airliner position to an accuracy of significantly less than this. Given your own comments about the blurring of the edges of the airliner, and the clear grading of the edge in the stills you have posted, it appears to me that +/- 4 pixels is quite a reasonable measurement error, in which case your data would fall below the level of statistical significance.

I have certainly considered measurement accuracy. This is why I chose to track the outline of the entire plane. Shifting the outline even 1 or 2 pixels causes an obvious misplacement. To say that the placement of the outline could be off by 4 pixels in either direction, is simply not plausible to me. 1 pixel, quite possibly. 2 pixels, I doubt it but maybe. 3 pixels, no. 4, certainly not.

If you want to do some further work on this area, I would suggest you study the apparent movement of the tower side in the video and look for correlations between that and the velocity variation. If the video was truly composited as you suggest, there should be a very clear and strong anticorrelation between apparent movements of the tower (i.e. changes in camera angle) and velocity variations of the airliner, as in your scenario both arise from camera movement.

There would be strong anti-correlation between tower movement and velocity variations ONLY if the camera movement was significant, compared to the camera movement on the plane. It isn't. The chopper 5 camera movement is quite smooth. It was the camera movement on the original plane video that was unsteady.

As for the emergence of the nose, your suggestion as to how the video was composited is simply not plausible. Let us assume for the sake of argument that your hypothesis is correct, and a video of an airliner flying at constant velocity across a clear background was selected in advance of the events of 9/11 to produce a fake video.

Stop right there Dave. I clearly state that the airplane video is NOT at a constant velocity, rather that it has unstable velocity due to camera motion.

Given that the organisers of the attack had ample time to plan the events, and ample access to areas where airliners could be seen from the right angle and distance (I hope you are not trying to argue that either of these was not the case), what possible motivation could they have had for deliberately selecting a video in which the airliner appears to slow by a factor of four part way through the shot? To do so would then require that the camera angle from the helicopter be precisely set so that the airliner would enter the tower at exactly the right point on the screen, and any inadvertant camera movement would necessarily produce an unrealistic slowing of the airliner that would be obvious to a casual observer. It also makes no sense that the prepared video would have been taken from a helicopter, when a fixed ground-based camera would produce a video lacking any variations in camera angle or position, so that the manipulation of the video could start with a clip in which the airliner position was known precisely at all times.

It makes sense to have an unstable airplane video, knowing that the live shot will be from a helicopter. If the airplane flew at a steady apparent velocity, while the Chopper 5 camera moved, this would be a dead giveaway.

They chose a video where the plane appears to slow down in the middle of the frame, because they wanted it to disappear inside the tower. They did everything pretty much right, except, the chopper drifted to the left during the shot just enough to screw up their masking by that amount. That's why the darn nose appeared to come out the other side.

OOPS.
 
Doing such an analysis on a previously compressed video, then expanding its frames thus garnering more interpolation by the computer, and thinking you can make a determination of anything within a few pixel widths, is the height of pure ignorance.

IF one wished to do a study of this video clip it would only be possible to get any meaningful conclusions by having a direct, uncompressed copy of the original raw video. Just the very fact that the banner is displayed on the video means that it ran through a processor to insert that banner. Such CG machines can alter the entire frame.

We also do not know if the camera was set on auto focus or auto iris, both of which will change the data recorded, especially on moving objects or scenes in which the amount of light changes. Such changes are not noticable to the naked eye but on a minute pixel by pixel examination they would be.

then there is just the fact that so many people actually SAW the plane hit the building and that many other cameras recorded the event.

To that point, this;
The "Chopper 5" video aired live on 9/11. It is the live shot which came the closest to actually showing the impact of the plane into the tower, although it did not. In actuality, all of the live "plane impact" videos showed the plane disappearing behind the tower.
is a particularily odd thing to say since Morgan Reynolds also argues that the shot that actually shows the plane going into the building illustrates that the building just swallowed up the plane and must be fake. Either no videos show the plane actually hitting the tower or there is one that shows the plane hitting the tower. Which is it Ace? Try not to answer with anything resembling circular reasoning.

"Photoshopping" is a generic term for "digital photography manipulation".

Actually Photoshoppe is a proprietery name, not a generic term.
It is only "generic" in the same sense that "Kleenex" is generic for facial tissue.
 
They chose a video where the plane appears to slow down in the middle of the frame, because they wanted it to disappear inside the tower. They did everything pretty much right, except, the chopper drifted to the left during the shot just enough to screw up their masking by that amount. That's why the darn nose appeared to come out the other side.

Whoa, that implies that this fakery was done live! That isn't any photoshoppe program I know of.
 
Whoa, that implies that this fakery was done live! That isn't any photoshoppe program I know of.

Hey, these are the folks who run Area 51. Reverse-engineered alien live video editing technology is child's play.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom