Chopper 5 Velocity Study Proves Video Composite, Reveals Sloppy Photoshopping

Dude, you have completely failed to notice the so called nose of the plane coming out the other side of the building is a different shape than before it went in.

And you CANNOT, increase the brightness and contrast of a video to prove anything! This isn't ****ing CSI with their magical computers. Have you ever heard of compression artefacts??

Movies today even have a hard time with convincing Blue/Green Screen work, this is extremely realistic looking and done LIVE, in 2001!

You should be ashamed of yourself, the fact you're even willing to change properties (brightness and contrast of a highly compressed video) of a video to prove anything completely discredits your argument.
 
Last edited:
Ace, I only skimmed your article so forgive me if I missed something important. I notice you talk alot about video compression, and how it could not do this thing or that thing. From that I assume that your source is compressed.

Do you have any idea what a video compression algorithm does? In basic terms, it removes huge amounts of visual data, easily of the order of 99% of the data captured by the camera, and replaces it with computer generated content, which is determined to be 'close enough' to the original source for viewing purposes. The smart part is just removing the parts the viewer probably won't notice, or in extreme compression just removing the data the viewer doesn't need in order to understand the image. You also state you increased the image size by 200%. You must realise that this doesn't add extra data, it just adds more interpolation! If your video was only 10% genuine data, your enlargement process has reduced it to 2.5% genuine data! The idea of doing frame by frame scientific analysis on such data is just laughable. I hope you can understand why.

If you suppy the actual video source you used, it might be possible to determine how much of it is actual data captured by the camera, and how much is just a computer generated guess.

Secondly, stabilising camera footage does not 'effectively remove camera movement' it only appears to do so, again, such that it may, or may not fool a human viewer. The effectiveness is dependent on the accuracy of the track, the amount of parallax, and lens distortion.

Thirdly tracking a shape through a video frame by hand will produce masses of human induced error, especially if that human is hoping to find such errors. You should use automated tracking solutions to get a more scientifically accurate and unbiased result. These will analyse the picture and find, mathematically, the best fit. They also do not match pixel by pixel or on half-pixels as you seem to be doing, as this introduces quantization errors. A good, accurate track often requires tracking at the 1/64th of a pixel level. This is beyond the skill of a manual (and untrained) tracker.

About this author. I'm a visual effects supervisor with 6 years experience and a further ten years CGI and digital video exerience before that. Stabilising shots and tracking moving objects across video frames is part of my daily routine. We absolutely do not ever recommend any kind of tracking on significantly compressed video material because it produces erratic results. We do not track objects by hand unless it is absolutely necessary because it is very, very difficult to get it right. I have also done video analysis for law enforcement agencies, and believe me, it's nothing like your CSI fantasy world.
 
Last edited:
I think nearly all was said, but one thing: TS1234 claims that separate footage of a plane was comehow copied into the video. His evidence is apparant speed fluctuations in the movement of the plane, which would be impossible in reality. He fails to mention how they then occured in the plane footage that was allegedly copied in. If they are not possible for the plane approaching the tower, how are they possible for a copied in plane? If they are possible (presumably due to some artefact) for a copied in plane, then they are also possible in an original video.

There is a lack of internal logic in your argument, TS1234.

Anyhow, seeing that the alleged fluctuations are quite cyclic, I suggest they are an artefact of the frame-rate. The frame division is simply not equidistant.

Hans
 
Ace,

As far as I see it, your analysis can be boiled down to two anomalies that you claim to be able to see. I would like to know how much effort you have made to analyse your own conclusions critically with a view to determining their falsifiability; in other words, have you considered alternative explanations, or are you simply trying to "save the hypothesis"?

The two main issues, and my comments on them, are:

(1) The so-called "digital halo" around the plane. Other posters have suggested that these may be due to video compression artefacts. Have you studied the edges of the towers to see whether they show similar artefacts, or looked at compressed videos where you know no compositing has taken place, to compare effects and see whether what you observe is unique to digital compositing? Your analysis of this point suffers from the absence of a control sample, a basic principle of scientific analysis, and at present you have yet to prove that your explanation is superior to the alternatives that have been advanced.

(2) The variations in apparent aircraft speed. I accept that your normalisation technique is valid - measuring the difference in position between the aircraft and the edge of the tower is an effective way to eliminate camera movement. What you have failed to address is any kind of analysis of the random errors in your measurement of the airliner position. This is first year university course material. Your graph of speed against frame number looks very much like a horizontal line at 23 pixels/frame with a random error of +/- 4 pixels/frame, so your argument rests entirely on the unstated premise that you can measure the airliner position to an accuracy of significantly less than this. Given your own comments about the blurring of the edges of the airliner, and the clear grading of the edge in the stills you have posted, it appears to me that +/- 4 pixels is quite a reasonable measurement error, in which case your data would fall below the level of statistical significance. If you want to do some further work on this area, I would suggest you study the apparent movement of the tower side in the video and look for correlations between that and the velocity variation. If the video was truly composited as you suggest, there should be a very clear and strong anticorrelation between apparent movements of the tower (i.e. changes in camera angle) and velocity variations of the airliner, as in your scenario both arise from camera movement. Another possibility is to look at the movement of different parts of the airliner and see how well correlated are the velocity variations; strong correlation would help your argument.

As for the emergence of the nose, your suggestion as to how the video was composited is simply not plausible. Let us assume for the sake of argument that your hypothesis is correct, and a video of an airliner flying at constant velocity across a clear background was selected in advance of the events of 9/11 to produce a fake video. Given that the organisers of the attack had ample time to plan the events, and ample access to areas where airliners could be seen from the right angle and distance (I hope you are not trying to argue that either of these was not the case), what possible motivation could they have had for deliberately selecting a video in which the airliner appears to slow by a factor of four part way through the shot? To do so would then require that the camera angle from the helicopter be precisely set so that the airliner would enter the tower at exactly the right point on the screen, and any inadvertant camera movement would necessarily produce an unrealistic slowing of the airliner that would be obvious to a casual observer. It also makes no sense that the prepared video would have been taken from a helicopter, when a fixed ground-based camera would produce a video lacking any variations in camera angle or position, so that the manipulation of the video could start with a clip in which the airliner position was known precisely at all times.

So, to summarise, you've made a good effort, but your lack of a control experiment and the absence of any analysis of random measurement errors mean that your conclusions cannot be said to follow from your premises. I suggest you address these points and see what you find out.

Dave
 
And Ace, which is the case:
a) The sky was removed from the original video of the plane and the result was composited into this video.
b) The sky was removed from the WTC video and the full video of the plane was put in the background.

A would give a better comp I'd imagine but the plane going behind the building makes ZERO sense.

B would put the plane behind the buildings but the supposed artefacts of the compositing would also appear around the buildings, but I can't see them and you don't identify them. Also for B compositing the smoke onto the sky from another video of the plane would be VERY noticiable given the low quality of the video and the lack of a blue/green screen (calibrated to a correct colour), ESPECIALLY if done Live.
 
Last edited:
And, the formatting of your web page overlaps several of the paragraphs and paragraph section headings.

OMFG his site has been artifactated and dustionified! run ace run!
roger wilco tally-ho over and out beep etti etti a shrubbery a shrubbery. you shall not pass.

BV
 
You know what the funniest thing about all of this is?

His analysis clearly indicates significant deceleration during impact with the building - the debris exiting is travelling at less than half the speed of the aircraft at impact.

He has successfully managed to totally disprove one of his own earlier claims.

Bravo Ace!

-Gumboot
 
Ace, I only skimmed your article so forgive me if I missed something important. I notice you talk alot about video compression, and how it could not do this thing or that thing. From that I assume that your source is compressed.

Do you have any idea what a video compression algorithm does? In basic terms, it removes huge amounts of visual data, easily of the order of 99% of the data captured by the camera, and replaces it with computer generated content, which is determined to be 'close enough' to the original source for viewing purposes. The smart part is just removing the parts the viewer probably won't notice, or in extreme compression just removing the data the viewer doesn't need in order to understand the image. You also state you increased the image size by 200%. You must realise that this doesn't add extra data, it just adds more interpolation! If your video was only 10% genuine data, your enlargement process has reduced it to 2.5% genuine data! The idea of doing frame by frame scientific analysis on such data is just laughable. I hope you can understand why.

If you suppy the actual video source you used, it might be possible to determine how much of it is actual data captured by the camera, and how much is just a computer generated guess.

Secondly, stabilising camera footage does not 'effectively remove camera movement' it only appears to do so, again, such that it may, or may not fool a human viewer. The effectiveness is dependent on the accuracy of the track, the amount of parallax, and lens distortion.

Thirdly tracking a shape through a video frame by hand will produce masses of human induced error, especially if that human is hoping to find such errors. You should use automated tracking solutions to get a more scientifically accurate and unbiased result. These will analyse the picture and find, mathematically, the best fit. They also do not match pixel by pixel or on half-pixels as you seem to be doing, as this introduces quantization errors. A good, accurate track often requires tracking at the 1/64th of a pixel level. This is beyond the skill of a manual (and untrained) tracker.

About this author. I'm a visual effects supervisor with 6 years experience and a further ten years CGI and digital video exerience before that. Stabilising shots and tracking moving objects across video frames is part of my daily routine. We absolutely do not ever recommend any kind of tracking on significantly compressed video material because it produces erratic results. We do not track objects by hand unless it is absolutely necessary because it is very, very difficult to get it right. I have also done video analysis for law enforcement agencies, and believe me, it's nothing like your CSI fantasy world.

Thanks Shrinker for your professional input. Very informative and easy to understand post.

-Gumboot
 
It seems quite obvoius that the jaggedness of the curve is due to Ace's own measurement error, expecially since there is absolutely no mention of this magnitude of this in the "paper". Looking at his screenshots I wouldn't be surprised if this could be several pixels. And magnifying the image 200% would of course magnify this error 200% as well.

And claiming the halo is evidence of cuting and pasting? Thats just stupid, it looks like a sharpening artefact to me or could be a compression artefact however I se not mention of the type or amount of comression used.
 
Ace, did you know that real image analysts exist?

If I were one and saw your 'analysis' I would be pissed that you were embarrassing my profession.

Then, I would realize just how many videos and images would have to be faked, and how many eye witnesses there were, I'd stop being pissed and just feel sorry for you.

Then, I'd read all your posts on this forum and I'd be pissed at myself for feeling sorry for you.
 
Accoring to Newton's first law of motion, an approaching airliner flying through air will "keep on doing what it's doing". That is, the airplane is either travelling a constant speed, accelerating or decelerating. It cannot speed up and slow down repeatedly.

:dl:
Wow, third sentence of the whole paper. Well done, Ace!

First Law

If no external force acts on a particle, then it is possible to select a set of reference frames, called inertial reference frames, observed from which the particle moves without any change in velocity.
 
Accoring to Newton's first law of motion, an approaching airliner flying through air will "keep on doing what it's doing". That is, the airplane is either travelling a constant speed, accelerating or decelerating. It cannot speed up and slow down repeatedly.


Grade Report

Student name: Baker, Ace

Course: Physics 101

Grade: F
 
once again...not reading...title of op says it all.

Take your fakery BS and go home, or to a psychiatrist.

TAM;)
 
The WNYW "Chopper 5" video of UA flight 175 crashing into the World Trade Center which aired live on 9/11 must be a video composite. The moving plane image must have been recorded separately from the image of the twin towers.

Live, of course.

Accoring to Newton's first law of motion, an approaching airliner flying through air will "keep on doing what it's doing".

Yes, that is EXACTLY what Newton said.

That is, the airplane is either travelling a constant speed, accelerating or decelerating. It cannot speed up and slow down repeatedly.

They don't have throttles on planes ?

Plotting velocity as a function of time, the approaching airplane must present a smooth line on the graph. Constant velocity would be a straight horizontal line.

Assuming your video is an adequate means of analysis.

The apparent velocity of a jetliner on video can be contaminated by various noise factors including atmospheric interference, video compression artifacts, and, most importantly, camera motion. Simply moving the camera while recording can cause any object to appear to speed up, slow down, stop, go backwards, etc. Being on a helicopter, and also being controlled by an operator, the chopper 5 camera is never still. Rather it moves around, mostly to the left, but also up, down, and to the right. The camera movements appear to be quite smooth, however.

Translation: "A whole lot of problems can falsify my analysis, but I choose to ignore them."

The raw video

...captured from Youtube...

depicts rapid increases and decreases in velocity of up to 186 mph (a jagged line on the graph), which is assumed to be caused by some combination of noise factors, especially including camera movement, because atmospheric disturbances and video compression artifacts do not appear sufficient to explain the magnitude of such deviations.

I think Gumboot will tear this to shreds. EDIT: Nope, Shrinker got it covered.

The line on the graph becomes even more jagged. Other noise factors are judged to be insignificant, so these data are explained by camera motion on the plane, camera motion not present on the twin towers, thus not removed during the stabilization process.

You'd think that their CGI composition would be a little smoother than that. Damn NWO and their ridiculously incompetent stormtroopers... I mean... shills.

After a 0.3 second disappearance inside the tower, what appears to be the nose of the aircraft exits the building, apparently now coming from behind the tower.

Key word: apparently.

Frame #7 shows a very evident "pixel halo" around the nose of the aircraft, indicative of a "cut and paste".

Honest researchers would also point out that video compression might have something to do with it.

The planes of 9/11 remain a hotly controversial topic within the 9/11 truth movement.

Of course. Truth is VERY controversial within the movement.

Other researchers in the 9/11 truth movement have argued in favor of real planes.

Gee, I wonder why. It may have something to do with thousands of people on site seeing that plane crash into the building. From the comfort of your basement, Ace, it may not be so obvious.

The chopper 5 video is a composite.

That also means pretty much EVERY video ever made is a composite.
 
Last edited:
Accelerate = speed up over time
Decelerate = slow down over time.

So what exactly are you trying to say about Newtons law and an airliner ACE?

lol

TAM:)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom