Chopper 5 Velocity Study Proves Video Composite, Reveals Sloppy Photoshopping

If it's well done, a fake is indistinguishable from authentic.
Experts who do that kind of work all the time most certainly could.

The reason I am able to prove that Chopper 5 is fake is that they didn't get the velocity right, plus they let the nose cone come out the back side.
Both of those are assumptions on your part and are far from definitely proven. These eyes of mine see nothing wrong in any of the numerous videos of the WTC impacts and collapses, they all look exactly like they should. And I was home on 9/11, and spent that day and the next two doing little else but watching the news all day.

For example, Corsair, tell me if this video is authentic or fake:

http://www.acebaker.com/9-11/ABPlaneStudy/Plane2RealOrFake.mov
I would, but I don't do QuickTime movies, I hate the format. Make it compatible with Media Player, or if you hate Windows, then make it compatible with VLC media player.
 
I call it the nose cone, because it is visually not distinguishable from the nose cone.

I call my refrigerator a horse because you can't tell one from the other in a camcorder video taken from 2,000 metres away and shrunk to postage stamp size for upload to youtube.com.

Perhaps you could get some schoolchildren to address this point scientifically.

Or how about a washed up studio musician who can't even score a gig playing the "donk donk" on Law & Order?
 
I find it hilarious that Ace thinks we care.

When I saw the thread title on the main CT forum Page I had a good chuckle and thats the first thing I thought. He has actually run off and spent hours compiling this! hahaha!

Everytime I read his posts I picture that 'Zugabe' guy on the penn and teller Miracles episode with his half cross in the basement. *chuckling*

Ace - You should put this much work into getting laid!
 
why has ace again ignored the the thousands of those who were there that day, live in person, within a few feet of the towers, who claim to have seen nthe plane?

why is so stuck in channel 5 video, when he has yet to tackled the private video tapes of the event, the CNN videos, the TNN videos, the BBC videos, the other media channels


Unti ACE can give a reason why the thousands of people saw a real plane that day, and could identify that planes as united airlines craft,

his spamming of his analysis of ONE video, proves that he has nothing at all to answer


I say stop replying to this cretin until he can answer how eyewitnesses saw, what he claims to be fake
 
If it's well done, a fake is indistinguishable from authentic. The reason I am able to prove that Chopper 5 is fake is that they didn't get the velocity right, plus they let the nose cone come out the back side.

But don't you claim that the plane we see in the Chopper 5 video is a real plane, filmed on a different day and inserted into the footage?

So why would this real plane have such a variable velocity?

Oh, and you never properly reconciled this theory with the fact that the 'nose' exits the tower with only 25% of the velocity of the plane, as shown by Dave Rogers. Obviously your theory cannot account for this.
 
Fictional? What, you don't believe that Chopper 5 video actually went on the air?

It did.

If there are any errors in the paper, either in premise or execution, please point them out. With the previous version, the only valid criticism to emerge was the lack of control cases, and margin of error. I've now addressed that.

Bah. Even Clancy novels have a tidbit of truth scattered about the story. It's still classified as fiction, just as I've correctly classified your website. FICTION.

You just need a better opening line to your fictional tale like "Call me Mohammad Ishmael".
 
But don't you claim that the plane we see in the Chopper 5 video is a real plane, filmed on a different day and inserted into the footage?

So why would this real plane have such a variable velocity?

Oh, and you never properly reconciled this theory with the fact that the 'nose' exits the tower with only 25% of the velocity of the plane, as shown by Dave Rogers. Obviously your theory cannot account for this.

You obviously did not read the paper. Version 2 is out. Here it is.

http://www.acebaker.com/9-11/ABPlaneStudy/Chopper5Velocity2.html

The real plane would appear to have a variable velocity because of camera shake. This also explains the apparent velocity of the "nose". Whether it is debris, or the nose, or anything else, you lack a mechanical explanation for why it would speed up and slow down repeatedly upon exiting the building.
 
And nothing posted by people here who know vastly than you do about this subject has taught you anything? You didn't absorb a single bit of information?

Crazy people don't know that they're crazy.

They also don't "absorb" information in the same manner that sane people do.;)
 
You obviously did not read the paper. Version 2 is out. Here it is.

http://www.acebaker.com/9-11/ABPlaneStudy/Chopper5Velocity2.html

The real plane would appear to have a variable velocity because of camera shake. This also explains the apparent velocity of the "nose". Whether it is debris, or the nose, or anything else, you lack a mechanical explanation for why it would speed up and slow down repeatedly upon exiting the building.

So why not use a fixed camera?
 
You obviously did not read the paper. Version 2 is out. Here it is.

http://www.acebaker.com/9-11/ABPlaneStudy/Chopper5Velocity2.html

The real plane would appear to have a variable velocity because of camera shake. This also explains the apparent velocity of the "nose". Whether it is debris, or the nose, or anything else, you lack a mechanical explanation for why it would speed up and slow down repeatedly upon exiting the building.
Except, of course, if the apparant speed fluctuations are an artefact. Then they would apply equally.

ACE, your own analysis shows that what you call the nose moves at only slightly over half the speed of the plane before entry. Based on your copied in plane thesis, can you explain the reason for that?

Hans
 
Here is another possible way to attack this error margin. Perhaps one of the video experts here can suggest some series of conversions and compressions that they think would introduce a margin of error of 4-5 pixels in an otherwise stable motion.

It doesn't take a video expert to answer that; it just takes some common sense, so I'll be glad to help you out.

First, there isn't any "error of 4-5 pixels" to be explained. When you increased the size of your images by 200%, you also increased your errors by 200%. Duh.

Second, the "error" in the original images is not really 2 to 2.5 pixels, either, even if your measurements were precise. The 2 to 2.5 original pixels would be the total difference you got between your largest and smallest per-frame travel distance, with the mean falling very close to half way between, so your measurement error from the plane's probable real position is plus or minus a little more than 1 pixel to either side of the mean.

When I use the original images (enlarged enough to see individual pixels clearly, but without any resizing interpolation), and I try to measure the number of pixels between the edge of the building and the nose of the plane (which is a much easier and more accurate way to do the same thing you tried to do with your stabilization), for the seven frames before the plane's nose disappears behind the logo, I get per-frame travel of 13, 12, 12, 13, 11, and 11 -- one pixel to either side of the mean of 12.

But anyone who tries to duplicate those measurements will easily see where the plus-or-minus-1-pixel errors are coming from: It's completely impossible to determine the exact pixel that marks the edge of the building or the nose of the plane; you have to guess at both. Starting with imaging errors in the camera (noise, differences in CCD pixel sensitivity, and edge artifacts), compression artifacts were introduced in the original digitization of that image, and then more were added when it was converted to QuickTime.

Given that the error is just about what should be expected, it's absurd to suggest that those images prove that the plane is not moving at a constant speed. The incontrovertible proof that the images won't support any greater accuracy is to simply look at the edge of the building and note that the imaging and compression errors make what we know is a straight edge appear very ragged within a band about 3 pixels wide and changing from one frame to the next!

The only thing you have produced here is a very nice graph of the measurement errors. Since those errors are just about what should be expected, your study actually lends support to the theory that it's a real image of a real plane moving at a constant velocity. ("No-planers" will hate you for that if they ever understand it, but that's probably not a problem.)

(Edit to add: The thing that really cracks me up about the video analysis done by "no-planers" is that they persistently take video flaws and artifacts that should be there in real videos, and claim that those flaws prove that the videos are bad fakes. The irony, of course, is that if these really were bad fakes they would probably look a lot more like the "no-planers" think real videos ought to!)
 
Last edited:
I call it the nose cone, because it is visually not distinguishable from the nose cone.

However, this is irrelevant to the major point of the paper. Whatever it is exiting the building, nosecone, debris or anything else, we lack a mechanism to explain why it would speed up and then slow down, then speed up and then slow down.


You call it nosecone because you want it to be the nosecone. In the real world debris and flame exited the side of the south tower as did one engine of the aircraft. So you can call it 'nosecone' simply because you want it to be a nosecone but I for one, will call it impact debris because I KNOW that impact debris exited the building.

Now I have not been following this thread too much for quite a while and I see that WS has educated all here on the lack or anything unusual in the video , however in TS's post quoted here he seems to suggest that the debris exiting the building also sped up and slowed down. Previously I thought he had concentrated solely on the plane approaching the building.
 
Unless I missed something, the only complaint about my velocity study is possible margin of error. I've now provided two control cases which show that the margin of error is too small to account for these variations in speed. Does anyone have any substantive critique?
 
Unless I missed something, the only complaint about my velocity study is possible margin of error. I've now provided two control cases which show that the margin of error is too small to account for these variations in speed. Does anyone have any substantive critique?
You missed thousands of eyewitnesses who saw what you said was fake.

You have wasted time on lies, when you could be doing something else. What a waste on making up lies. (you have to account for the motion of the helo, that means you need to know the position of the helo every frame, good luck) Next time listen to the people who saw what happen live with their eyes.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom