Chopper 5 Velocity Study Proves Video Composite, Reveals Sloppy Photoshopping

William Seger is playing semantics. Increasing the size of a picture does not create any more data, but it does allow greater precision in stabilizing, and greater precision in placing wireframes, thus greater precision in measurement. Essentially it allows us to move things by what would have been 1/2 pixel at the original size. Increasing the image size does indeed serve to reduce margin of measurement error.


The error in my controls is <6%, in Chopper 5 it is>35%.

If Seger is correct, how does he explain the stability of my control cases?
I know very little about video so I tried like he said to count the pixels between the plane and the building. I to found it very difficult to do with any margin of accuracy. The buildings edge and the planes nose are almost impossible to track. My understanding of this is a compression artifact. How can you be sure this isn't the case in the video from chopper5 without the original.
 
he refuses to address that DGM. he rather use pixelated bad quality video instead of being honest and obtain the REAL raw footage from that day
 
I used the highest quality Chopper 5 available, that is 640x480. I'm in close contact with the person who recorded and digitized it, who is a video engineer.

I'd LOVE to get my hands on any and all significant 9/11 videos, I'll will pay money for any copies that are of better quality than is commonly available.

You still haven't addressed the point:

If the quality is too low to make these measurements, then why are my controls so stable? They are similar quality, from a similar distance, and actually a bit worse.
 
Actually, many of the videos show conflicting data, different paths, colors, etc. My study is only about this one video, however.

Basic error: You cant pick and choose which part of reality to address. It is all there.

My study is only about Chopper 5, but there are more and more witnesses being discovered who said there were no planes.
False. Lie, in fact, because you know this. A number of witnesses did not see the plane because they only looked up after it hit. This is moot, however: Address the withessese who DID see the plane.

False. It is explained by camera motion on the original plane recording. Discussed here.

No. Whatever explanation you have for the apparant speed movements, will apply equally to a possible fake and the real thing.

I provide control case data which show the margin of error to be too small. Upon what data do you base your assertion?

The control case is not THE case. Address the case at hand: Where did the artefact come form?

Yes, and artifact of camera motion. That's what the paper is all about.
Applies to the real video as well.


No, the variations cannot exist on a stabilized video. Either you didn't read, or do not understand the paper.

There is no difference in the conditions, whether it is the actual vidoe or an alleged fake.

Face it, you have been debunked. Again.

Hans
 
I used the highest quality Chopper 5 available, that is 640x480. I'm in close contact with the person who recorded and digitized it, who is a video engineer.


so you do have contact with Chopper 5? please provide us with teh contact information of whom you spoke to to obtain that footage.



btw, 640 x 480 video? nope, that's not even high quality. that's WEB quality and it would have to be given to you in RAW format (uncompressed avi or similar)
 
Until someone points out errors in the paper, either in premise or methodology, the paper stands. With version one, the only complaint was margin of error. I have addressed that in version two. I have data to back my claim that the margin of error is too low. The claim that margin of error is too high is backed by nothing at this point.

Can anyone link me to any data or study which provides any intellectual foundation for the assertion that the margin of error in Chopper 5 is too high to make the kinds of measurements that I make?

Thank you.
Yes, until someone points out errors, your paper stands. Unfortunatley, it doesn't stand as long as you ignore the errors pointed out. Address the errors pointed out, or your paper has fallen. Start with the supporting evidence of dozens of other videos and thousands of eye witnesses.

Hans
 
If the quality is too low to make these measurements, then why are my controls so stable? They are similar quality, from a similar distance, and actually a bit worse.
Ace;
It seems to me that you are basing all your research on somewhat of an unknown. This will always cast a doubt on your research and before you can accurately make your conclusion this would need to be better addressed.

If push came to shove and the original was analyzed and found to be stable then all your research is down the toilet. This does not sound to me like competent research.
 
Regnad, your comment has nothing to do with the premise of my paper. Strictly speaking, there could have fake video AND a real plane witnessed by thousands. From a scientific perspective, the two are not necessarily mutually exclusive. This is about science and the scientific method. I have a science paper that purports to prove that Chopper 5 is a video composite.

Is anyone here willing and able to address the scientific merits of the paper? If there are errors in either premise or methodology, please point them out.

You guys must know that the more you avoid and try to change the subject, the more it convinces me that I am absolutely right.

What's wrong with my paper?

It seems to me that you have been shown many times, by people far more experienced in the fields of videography, special effects, matchmoving and even aviation than you are, that your methods are at best flawed, at worst dishonest. Extraordinary claims demand extraordinary evidence, and this study is in no way convincing of what you are claiming.

The source material is not of sufficient quality to make any dramatic, conclusive statements about video fakery, and even then one is not taking into account the margin of human error inherent in your method of measurement. You seem to have been shown this many times, yet are unable to accept it. Science is not a conspiracy. If you were to provide solid proof of your claims, we would accept it. You have not done so. Should you continue to seek evidence of your beliefs, I would ask: Are you doing so to seek confirmation of them, or to test them?
 
Here is your error:

You are speaking categorically about something which fundamentally a matter of degree.

All photos and videos, of any quality, will have limitations on how accurately things can be measured. All photos. All videos.

The question, then, for any video, is what is the margin of error for this video? It isn't zero, nor is it infinity. The idea is to attempt to quantify it. This is done by the use of control cases. I have provided my data. Thusfar, the claims that the margin of error is too large are based on absolutely nothing.

Sorry guys. You're making assertions with no support whatsoever. Try again.
 
Ace;
I a little curious, Why do you care what we think? We all have told you what we think of your research, you have a different opinion. I for one couldn't care less if you publish this paper. You don't need our blessing its your work.

Good luck with it.
 
Im still waiting for you to cover the eye witnesses. please give us a detailed analysis on exactly what you think they saw
 
Ace;
I a little curious, Why do you care what we think?

It is a form of review. If there were legitimate scientific complaints about my Chopper 5 velocity paper, then posters would voice them. I know that the people here are not inclined to agree with me, so it is a rigorous test. I could easily just post on no-planer boards and have everyone tell me what a great job I did.

I ignore the irrelevancies, and look for any complaints with scientific merit.

Still looking.
 
It is a form of review. If there were legitimate scientific complaints about my Chopper 5 velocity paper, then posters would voice them. I know that the people here are not inclined to agree with me, so it is a rigorous test. I could easily just post on no-planer boards and have everyone tell me what a great job I did.

I ignore the irrelevancies, and look for any complaints with scientific merit.

Still looking.
Fair enough.

You can log my concern about the quality of the source and the lack of real effort to obtain the original.

Hows that?
DGM
 
Ace, the reason people here aren't really interested in finding legitimate complaints about your paper is because there are literally thousands of people who watched the second plane hit the South Tower with their own eye's backing up all the video you are trying to say is fake.

Do you understand?
 
Fair enough.

You can log my concern about the quality of the source and the lack of real effort to obtain the original.

Hows that?
DGM

The quality of the source should have errors of <1 pixel, at the enlargement used, as shown. If you have any data to support your "concern", please bring them.

I have tried everything I can think of to obtain broadcast quality 9/11 videos, including offering money.

8den says he can get them, and I offered to pay the fee plus pay him for his effort.

Do you know how I might obtain broadcast quality 9/11 videos?

Thank you.
 
Ace, the reason people here aren't really interested in finding legitimate complaints about your paper is because there are literally thousands of people who watched the second plane hit the South Tower with their own eye's backing up all the video you are trying to say is fake.

Do you understand?

Strictly speaking, fake videos are not mutually exclusive to real planes. However, it is reasonable to think that if there were real planes, fake video would be unnecessary.

Making the assumption that real planes invalidates video fakery, then if you are correct, logically there must be some error with my paper. What is the error?
 
Do you know how I might obtain broadcast quality 9/11 videos?

Thank you.

Well I would first file a complaint in a NY court alleging fraud. Maybe this is something the FCC might get involved with. Just off the top of my head.

I have no desire to argue with you about my concern. I believe others have this same view. If you want to dismiss this go for it. Like I said I couldn't care less.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom