Chopper 5 Velocity Study Proves Video Composite, Reveals Sloppy Photoshopping

What I just can't comprehend is the value of this photo's validity to the overall conspiracy theory. Suppose for a moment that we have unassailable proof that the photo is fake. Suppose Val herself came forward and explained exactly how and why she did it.

So what? In what way does this help show that the events in Shanksville on 9/11 played out any differently than the official version says?

If I were to digitally manipulate an image to show that I was present when Lincoln was inaugaurated, would that confirm that he never really became President?

I just don't get what all the hubbub is about.
It's a form of argumentum ad logicam. They think that the 9/11 evidence is a house of cards and if they can show one piece, in this case Val's photo, to be false, then all the evidence must be false and the house comes tumbling down. They have two major problems with this. First being, the photo (to my knowledge) hasn't been used as any form of evidence to support the EBC. Second is what you pointed out, if the photo is falsified it doesn't mean anything beyond the fact that the photo is falsified.
 
What I just can't comprehend is the value of this photo's validity to the overall conspiracy theory. Suppose for a moment that we have unassailable proof that the photo is fake. Suppose Val herself came forward and explained exactly how and why she did it.

So what? In what way does this help show that the events in Shanksville on 9/11 played out any differently than the official version says?

If I were to digitally manipulate an image to show that I was present when Lincoln was inaugaurated, would that confirm that he never really became President?

I just don't get what all the hubbub is about.
It goes like this:
The Truthers believe (some of them) that no plane crashed at Shanksville. The whole crash site was faked. If they disprove Ms. McClatchey's photo, then they (in their minds) have proved the point that no plane crashed there.

This ignores, of course, the remains of people and machines found at the crash site. But then, what do Truthers care about reality?
 
ETA: Using both is good, but not in the same sentence. Français and English, not Franglais, please.

Mais de quoi are you talking about ? Le Franglais est le best thing de l'histoire! To mélange deux languages de manière and confuse those qui sont présents is une expérience awesome!
 
It goes like this:
The Truthers believe (some of them) that no plane crashed at Shanksville. The whole crash site was faked. If they disprove Ms. McClatchey's photo, then they (in their minds) have proved the point that no plane crashed there.


Not so much, I think. They're not trying to prove anything, in my opinion, because they know they can't prove anything. They're just trying to plant doubt.

They seem to view reality of some sort of elected official with a popularity rating. They're still in the mudslinging phase of their campaign. They've positioned themselves as the opposition to the "official story", and are attempting to cast enough doubt on the incumbent. They hope that the voters will eventually scramble for something "better"... even though they've never explained how or why they are actually better. But at that point, it won't matter.

To them, truth is politics. And they've learned their politicking from the very politicians they hate.
 
Originally Posted by Swing Dangler View Post
Yes, this is true. I'm not interested in the paper and inks appearance. I can buy the paper and ink from Val if I so choose. I am interested in the analysis of the digital file itself.

Yes, Swing, you've said that before. Nonetheless, your argument is based upon this:

Originally Posted by Swing Dangler View Post
I don't consider the thoughts of those who were there speculation. If people who saw the event and the photo and state the photo is a fraud and it does not match the event, then I accept their statements as fact.
And those statements were based, at best, on the "paper and ink appearance." So, by your own standard, this is irrelevant.
Notice I did not question the authenticity of the witness statements. I stated the paper and photo are meaningless.
Considering it is the photo that is being described as a fake, their statements are completely relevant to the paper and ink. To prove conclusively the authenticity of the photo, the digital file would need to be examined. However since no one to my knowledge in the public domain has access to the file, the multiple witnesses to the event are the best evidence to validate the premise that the photo is a fake.

BTW, you never did answer if you thought Purabaugh was lying about the plane crash and scene afterwards or the photo. Will you be addressing that?


Originally Posted by Swing Dangler View Post
Quote:
Rmackey-You yourself admitted that the photo could only be invalidated through forensic analysis of the underlying digital information.
No, I said it could be validated through analysis of the digital information as I don't believe it to be a valid photo. There is no need to restate this misstatement again as you have already done so before as I addressed it already. Remember the reminder about credibility
?
So, you're saying I'm wrong, but you then restate precisely the same thing? What in the world is wrong with you?
No you lied about what I said.

Originally Posted by Swing Dangler View Post
The premise remains as valid if not more so than the opposing premise. This would not be an issue if everyone agreed or even somewhat agreed the photo matched what actually happened.
Once again, Swing, the transcripts that you typed yourself do not indicate any criticism of the photograph itself -- except one. Ms. Leverknight said the photo was fake because it contained "no mushroom cloud."

But the photo does contain a "mushroom cloud." You yourself drew the parallel to a "mushroom cloud" in this post. Even Killtown states that the photo contains a "mushroom cloud." I would call it a "smoke ring," but to a moderate level of precision, I agree with that description.
I'm sorry you level of reading comprehension surrounding the Levernknight statements does not match your level of knowledge of statistics.


Originally Posted by Swing Dangler View Post
Yep, it was a real piece of paper with ink on it. You can buy a piece of paper as well.
Well they [the FBI] stated the photo appeared to be authentic, but no mention of the digital file composed of 1's and 0's.
Condition unsatisfied.
In case you missed it, FBI agents Hacker, Brown, and Lewzander took the memory card, not just a paper copy. (Source)
Yep, I did read that. And still no mention of the digital file's authenticity.
Were you ever to reconcile how Val described the image prior to the FBI's confiscation and the what it now displays?

Anyway, unless you show some ability to comprehend your gross, irreconcilable contradictions, then we're done here. If you can't follow the most basic logical reasoning, then you are not ready to learn.
Nice send off with a character attack. I thought you were done several comments ago.

You questioning my logical reasoning when I pointed out your outright lies, misstatements, and your own logical fallacies, especially in your own quote you referred me to? That is comical. If I wanted to learn how to lie in support of a position, then I have certainly learned how to do that thanks to your comments.

What I just can't comprehend is the value of this photo's validity to the overall conspiracy theory. Suppose for a moment that we have unassailable proof that the photo is fake. Suppose Val herself came forward and explained exactly how and why she did it.So what? In what way does this help show that the events in Shanksville on 9/11 played out any differently than the official version says?If I were to digitally manipulate an image to show that I was present when Lincoln was inaugaurated, would that confirm that he never really became President?I just don't get what all the hubbub is about.
One, many private individuals bought the photo in belief that it was authentic. The press published the photos in the belief that it was authentic Two, it is promoted as a historical document, when it appears that it is not authentic. The historical record should reflect the facts and that is IMHO, what the hubbub is about.
It's a form of argumentum ad logicam. They think that the 9/11 evidence is a house of cards and if they can show one piece, in this case Val's photo, to be false, then all the evidence must be false and the house comes tumbling down. They have two major problems with this. First being, the photo (to my knowledge) hasn't been used as any form of evidence to support the EBC. Second is what you pointed out, if the photo is falsified it doesn't mean anything beyond the fact that the photo is falsified.
This maybe true for some people, but not in my case. I agree that this photo really has nothing to do with a house of cards scenario. In fact, one of the people who claim the photo is a fraud is very damming to the No Plane At Shanksville theory.
 
SD, I hope you are as passionate about every other photo or document throughout history--important or unimportant.
 
What I just can't comprehend is the value of this photo's validity to the overall conspiracy theory. [...]

One, many private individuals bought the photo in belief that it was authentic. The press published the photos in the belief that it was authentic Two, it is promoted as a historical document, when it appears that it is not authentic. The historical record should reflect the facts and that is IMHO, what the hubbub is about.

In other words, it DOESN'T mean a thing about the 9/11 conspiracy claims.
 
Last edited:
I think its value to the CTs, if it is fake, is that it is one of the few photos, allegedly taken just after the official crash time, that does show what appear to be a cloud of smoke from a crash or explosion.

By proving it fake, it takes away another piece of evidence from the "OCT" as they call it.

TAM:)
 
Look, Swing, I showed you where you contradicted yourself three times in one post. If you can't figure that out, you need a new hobby.

BTW, you never did answer if you thought Purabaugh was lying about the plane crash and scene afterwards or the photo. Will you be addressing that?
Specify. Not sure what you're interested in.

No you lied about what I said.
Show me.

I'm sorry you level of reading comprehension surrounding the Levernknight statements does not match your level of knowledge of statistics.
Dude, it's pretty simple.

Yep, I did read that. And still no mention of the digital file's authenticity.
Were you ever to reconcile how Val described the image prior to the FBI's confiscation and the what it now displays?
The burden of proof is on you to show it isn't authentic. I've told you that at least three times.


Nice send off with a character attack. I thought you were done several comments ago.

You questioning my logical reasoning when I pointed out your outright lies, misstatements, and your own logical fallacies, especially in your own quote you referred me to? That is comical. If I wanted to learn how to lie in support of a position, then I have certainly learned how to do that thanks to your comments.

Your confusion level is staggering. Let me try something simple.

You say she faked the photo. Fine. Tell me how she faked it.

That should be easy, right? Go for it.
 
One, many private individuals bought the photo in belief that it was authentic. The press published the photos in the belief that it was authentic Two, it is promoted as a historical document, when it appears that it is not authentic. The historical record should reflect the facts and that is IMHO, what the hubbub is about.

....

This maybe true for some people, but not in my case. I agree that this photo really has nothing to do with a house of cards scenario. In fact, one of the people who claim the photo is a fraud is very damming to the No Plane At Shanksville theory.


Ok, so if we are all agreed that it doesn't make one whit of difference whether the photo is a fake or not, why are we arguing the point at all?

If on the other hand, your point is that you are morally outraged by the idea of this woman making money from a potentially fake photo, well, all I can say is there are plenty of other things to better spend your time being outraged by.

Like, say, Dylan Avery making money from a fake video......
 
SwingDangler: Nice work documenting the tactics of our favorite resident NASA spook.

Mackey: Any chance you'd like to retract your lie about my velocity study? You said that my hypothesis does not generate falsifiable predictions. Of course it does. It predicts that legitimate videos of similar quality will produce smooth graph lines. You are a NASA scientist. You'd have to know this.

(By the way, I've now studied one legitimate video with similar quality, and it has a very stable apparent velocity, almost ruler flat. It never varies by more than one pixel, which would be 1/2 pixel at original size. Will update study and post here within a week).

So not only does my hypothesis generate falsifiable predictions, I've now run the test, and the test confirms my prediction, and supports the hypothesis. I'll study my camera shake video over the next few days, and let you all know.
 
SwingDangler: Nice work documenting the tactics of our favorite resident NASA spook.

Mackey: Any chance you'd like to retract your lie about my velocity study? You said that my hypothesis does not generate falsifiable predictions. Of course it does. It predicts that legitimate videos of similar quality will produce smooth graph lines. You are a NASA scientist. You'd have to know this.

(By the way, I've now studied one legitimate video with similar quality, and it has a very stable apparent velocity, almost ruler flat. It never varies by more than one pixel, which would be 1/2 pixel at original size. Will update study and post here within a week).

So not only does my hypothesis generate falsifiable predictions, I've now run the test, and the test confirms my prediction, and supports the hypothesis. I'll study my camera shake video over the next few days, and let you all know.



I predict that your "study" will confirm your deranged falsehoods.
 
Version 2 of Chopper 5 Velocity Study

You have been infracted and warned regarding breaching Rule 6, this is your final warning. Further breaches will result in further Moderation action which may include suspension or banning.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Darat


Here is the updated version of the Chopper 5 velocity study.

http://www.acebaker.com/9-11/ABPlaneStudy/Chopper5Velocity2.html

I've added two control cases - a steady camera shot, and a shaky one. These control cases serve to validate the analysis technique generally, and to establish that the margin of error is too small to account for the variations in UA175 velocity.

Thanks to Dave Rogers for insightful comments on version one, I believe this study now constitutes robust proof of video fakery.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hey Ace,

I have a new theory. I call it the "No-Tower" theory. The Twin Towers never existed, and were edited in to the video of that day.

Disprove it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom