Chopper 5 Velocity Study Proves Video Composite, Reveals Sloppy Photoshopping

Unless I missed something, the only complaint about my velocity study is possible margin of error.

You missed the dozen of other videos and Ed knows how many stills of the same event, that show the same.

You missed the thousands of eyewitnesses who support the video.

You forgot to explain how the alleged fake plane could reduce its speed with almost 50% while "behind" the building.

You missed the fact that the margin of error dismantles your evidence.

I've now provided two control cases which show that the margin of error is too small to account for these variations in speed. Does anyone have any substantive critique?

Allready presented. Your control cases don't change anything.

You are missing the central point that no matter HOW you claim the video was created, the variations must be an artefact.

IF a video of a passing plane had been copied in, this plane also could not change its speed in this way, so you would still have to explain the apparant variations as an artefact.

And since you will have to acknowledge that the artefact can exist in a faked video, you will also have to acknowledge that it can exist in a real video. Thus, the presense of this phenomenon does not provide evidence of fakery.

We don't even have to analyse the possible reasons for your observation. Simple logic does it.

Hans
 
You missed the dozen of other videos and Ed knows how many stills of the same event, that show the same.

Actually, many of the videos show conflicting data, different paths, colors, etc. My study is only about this one video, however.

You missed the thousands of eyewitnesses who support the video.

My study is only about Chopper 5, but there are more and more witnesses being discovered who said there were no planes.

You forgot to explain how the alleged fake plane could reduce its speed with almost 50% while "behind" the building.

False. It is explained by camera motion on the original plane recording. Discussed here.

You missed the fact that the margin of error dismantles your evidence.

I provide control case data which show the margin of error to be too small. Upon what data do you base your assertion?


You are missing the central point that no matter HOW you claim the video was created, the variations must be an artefact.

Assertion.

IF a video of a passing plane had been copied in, this plane also could not change its speed in this way, so you would still have to explain the apparant variations as an artefact.

Yes, and artifact of camera motion. That's what the paper is all about.

And since you will have to acknowledge that the artefact can exist in a faked video, you will also have to acknowledge that it can exist in a real video. Thus, the presense of this phenomenon does not provide evidence of fakery.

No, the variations cannot exist on a stabilized video. Either you didn't read, or do not understand the paper.
 
How does "more witnesses are being discovered who said there were no planes" even come close to explaining the THOUSANDS of witnesses who DID see planes?

ETA: you seem to want to just brush this off, but to us, and most rational observers, this is a MAJOR problem with your theory.
 
Last edited:
How does "more witnesses are being discovered who said there were no planes" even come close to explaining the THOUSANDS of witnesses who DID see planes?
As I've mentioned before, in a city of 8+ million (not to mention tourists and people on the nearby Jersey shore) there were likely hundreds of thousands of witnesses when the second plane hit.

No plane nonsense is a wonder to behold.
 
My study is only about Chopper 5, but there are more and more witnesses being discovered who said there were no planes.


I asked you this once before, but predictably, you didn't answer me. Where exactly were these no-plane witnesses?
Were they in position to have an unobstructed view of the impacts?
 
Actually, many of the videos show conflicting data, different paths, colors, etc.
You must have funny ideas about what constitutes conflicting data.

Again, as someone who was home on 9/11, and spent the rest of that day and the next two doing little else but watching the news from a variety of networks (ABC, NBC, CBS, CNN, CTV, CBC, BBC), I saw plenty of the crash footage as it was aired over those three days at it came in to the stations.

I see no conflicts in any of it whatsoever. It all looks exactly like it should look, no contradictions, and most certainly none of it looks faked in any way. Fakery always gives itself away in the little details, especially in regards to how things move, and I was able to watch them in broadcast television quality and not in low resolution digital copies.
 
You must have funny ideas about what constitutes conflicting data.
We have two different videos which show UA175 approaching through 2 different paths in 3D space. We also have videos taken from very close to the same angles, which show the plane to be very different colors. Is this funny?

Again, as someone who was home on 9/11, and spent the rest of that day and the next two doing little else but watching the news from a variety of networks (ABC, NBC, CBS, CNN, CTV, CBC, BBC), I saw plenty of the crash footage as it was aired over those three days at it came in to the stations.

I see no conflicts in any of it whatsoever. It all looks exactly like it should look, no contradictions, and most certainly none of it looks faked in any way. Fakery always gives itself away in the little details, especially in regards to how things move, and I was able to watch them in broadcast television quality and not in low resolution digital copies.
Corsair, two points:

1. I've already proven to you that I can make fake videos on my little laptop that you can't tell are fake.

2. There are little details of motion that betray the fakery. That's what my paper is all about.
 
This is a thread about my paper. We can discuss the no-plane witnesses on another thread.


This thread is a dead horse. Your paper has been done to death. It is NOT accepted by people here and totally rejected as some kind of proof of fakery that day.

One of the reasons it is rejected so soundly is because of the overwhelming physical and eye-witness testimony that contradicts it. Perhaps it's time for a "how could so many eye witnesses and different cameras not notice there were no planes hitting the WTC, and how could any rational person ignore that on one of the most witnessed major events in world history?" thread.
 
Until someone points out errors in the paper, either in premise or methodology, the paper stands. With version one, the only complaint was margin of error. I have addressed that in version two. I have data to back my claim that the margin of error is too low. The claim that margin of error is too high is backed by nothing at this point.

Can anyone link me to any data or study which provides any intellectual foundation for the assertion that the margin of error in Chopper 5 is too high to make the kinds of measurements that I make?

Thank you.
 
Until someone points out errors in the paper, either in premise or methodology, the paper stands. With version one, the only complaint was margin of error. I have addressed that in version two. I have data to back my claim that the margin of error is too low. The claim that margin of error is too high is backed by nothing at this point.

Can anyone link me to any data or study which provides any intellectual foundation for the assertion that the margin of error in Chopper 5 is too high to make the kinds of measurements that I make?

I have seen both your premise and methodology questioned succinctly many times in this very thread. Basically, to my satisfaction, it has been shown that your analysis proves nothing, especially when faced with evidence that contradicts your findings.

All we have left is to deal with the huge preponderance of physical evidence and eye-witness accounts that contradict it.

I realize why you would be dragging your feet about that, but you need to deal with it eventually; you have to lift your eyes off your grainy, compressed video and look at the real world.
 
Regnad, your comment has nothing to do with the premise of my paper. Strictly speaking, there could have fake video AND a real plane witnessed by thousands. From a scientific perspective, the two are not necessarily mutually exclusive. This is about science and the scientific method. I have a science paper that purports to prove that Chopper 5 is a video composite.

Is anyone here willing and able to address the scientific merits of the paper? If there are errors in either premise or methodology, please point them out.

You guys must know that the more you avoid and try to change the subject, the more it convinces me that I am absolutely right.

What's wrong with my paper?
 

William Seger is playing semantics. Increasing the size of a picture does not create any more data, but it does allow greater precision in stabilizing, and greater precision in placing wireframes, thus greater precision in measurement. Essentially it allows us to move things by what would have been 1/2 pixel at the original size. Increasing the image size does indeed serve to reduce margin of measurement error.


The error in my controls is <6%, in Chopper 5 it is>35%.

If Seger is correct, how does he explain the stability of my control cases?
 
Last edited:
ace, your paper has been addressed and found lacking due to the fact that there were thousands of eye witnesses (including my uncle and aunt who where there that day) that saw the plane hit the south tower. they were less than a block away when it happened.

you are simply playing a game here; you can't simply brush of everyone's comments about eyewitnesses by simply saying "this is only about my paper"

the eye witnesses HAS EVERYTHING to do iwht your paper


so until you give a succinct details account how thousands of eyewitnesses didn't see those planes, your paper fails since the first word.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom