Chopper 5 Velocity Study Proves Video Composite, Reveals Sloppy Photoshopping

Thank you I very much appreciate the other photographs.
Do you see anything different from the picture you are posting in violation of the copy right and the other two airplane crashes?
Such as the color of the plume?
The continuous burning of the fuel and debris not a disconnect from the plume and the ground?
And at least 4 other people claiming that the 2 photos on the right are frauds? One of witch witnessed the impact?
So it is against fair use to make a photo comparing photos? That photo is also not the photo Val took, the pixels just are not the same. In fact pixel for pixel, not a lot of pixels are the same as Val's photo, and I can prove that with some help from Val?

The color, oops the color of black. They all look black, they are all jet fuel fires. What else could they be? Val's photo was taken of the black plume, what else could it be? You do know that color in all three photos is relative to white balance. Color is so personal. No the photo are all real. Black smoke from a jet fuel. What is your point? They are all from jet impacts with the fuel being ignited by hot jet engines; if you do not want a big fire, turn off the jet engines before you crash. That is procedure! In the two accidents the pilots should have shut off the engines, they failed. Kind of like you trying to say Val's photo is fake. 93 pilots were not interested in survival so they left the engines running. I see nothing to but three jet fuel fires and the mushroom cloud, that you could miss if you do not take a snap shot.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TSB-EqorBno It looks different depending when you take the shot.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_EM0hDchVlY see

Until you find evidence, and facts to prove Val made up the photo as she handed to police that day, then you are a person who makes up ideas about 9/11 with no facts or evidence. I can not help it if you can not say up front what you really think. I have seen your post and you seem to be a dyed in the wool truther.

No facts, no evidence just talk, so I am not surprised you are unable to post your true ideas, since you know they are based on shoddy research and not supported in fact.

If you deny you are truther and believe 19 terrorist carried out 9/11. It seems anyone who picks up the killtown ideas is as killtown is.

Idiot's hounding someone who takes a photo. You have joined those who try to discredit others for no real reason. If you want to expose fraud then expose LC as lies, or any part of the truth movement you pick. What a sad thing, 9/11 truth and those who support them and push the fraud. http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/06218/711239-85.stm

I showed you photos of mushroom clouds, as many aircraft impacts produce. I have seen some live. You have seen them in movies. Why are you failing to show Val's photo is fake? So are you joining the animals who are harassing Val? Are you just another conspiracy theorists that posts Flight 93 photo is fake? Why are you pushing ideas without facts. I would hate to have to wade through the junk were you source this tripe.
 
You have only speculation. This is not a "primary source." Having not supported your claims, they are stupid.
Direct statements are not primary source?
Primary source: a firsthand or eyewitness account of an event.Dictionary.com
Levenknight and Purbaugh are by definition primary sources. Point defeated.
Stating that first hand or eyewitness accounts of an event is not a primary source is stupid.
Airline crashes of this type are extremely rare. And the burden of proof is upon you, not me. Argument from incredulity noted and ignored.
Really? See this history of aviation accidents and the pictures of airplanes hitting the ground and the their characteristics. Point defeated.

Nonsense. You're speculating that the effect on vegetation would be different, but you've given no support. Argument from incredulity, again.
Your confused. You stated that the effect of vegetation patterns is similar to the patterns in Shanksville. I accept that.
Because you suggested vegetation patters would be similar, I used your statement to argue that other parts of a crash site would be similar as well, including smoke patterns. I didn't speculate on vegetation patterns.
Your point is defeated due to your misunderstanding of the comment.

Shifting the burden of proof. And the FBI concluded it was genuine, and they did have access to the original. The burden of proof is very high.
The FBI has individuals that make errors. Study the history of the FBI to determine if they are right 100% correct 100% of the time. Believing individuals or an agency is infallible is an incorrect assumption to make.
When the FBI concluded it was genuine was that after an analysis of the digital file by the photo crime lab or by looking at a paper copy in person? I personally do not know.
People who saw the impact and then saw the photo apparently disagree that the photo is genuine. Who is more likely to be correct?

Stop being a jerk.
Attacking the character.

You're welcome to contact Heroic Choices if you doubt her. Explained above. These two relatives have no evidence. Just because they see fit to throw unsubstantiated speculation doesn't mean that you should. Stop believing everything you hear (so long as it agrees with you) and start asking questions.
I do not believe Heroic Choices has the financial records of the photographer. Her bank, accountant, and IRS most likely do. I do not think they release private information to the public. Point defeated.
Speculation? You did the same thing when you stated ALL proceeds went to the charity. Hypocrisy noted.

Speculation from a primary source? One source who saw the impact and never lost sight of the crash scene? I think your confused about this speculation issue.

It has been, and you are misusing my metric. One of the requirements of the process is that you explain your calculation. You have not. You are, by definition, using it wrong. Dismissed.
Point accepted.
However, you haven't tested the validity of the process to my knowledge. To my knowledge, you haven't falsified the metric, either. Finally, you are trying to take a scientific mathematical process to apply to human behavior and motivations. People do lie. People do commit fraud. People do conspire to carry out evil deed. People are motivated to do all sorts of bad things.

Convincing you is not my problem.
Point accepted. The picture should convince me. It doesn't.

You can and probably will hang on to whatever insane delusions you please, regardless of evidence to the contrary.
Attacking the character.

Basic mechanics. Read a book.
[/QUOTE]
You could have said that you don't have the physics to explain the debris pattern.

You stated
every dam person agrees with the photo
. You didn't back up your statement, and in fact, I showed the opposite.
I offered you at least 2, and at most likely 4, proving your statement wrong. Not everyone in the area agrees the photo is a genuine. Point defeated.

On the other hand you offer another person's perspective, but I must accept that as evidence that the photo is genuine, when you don't accept other people's perspective as evidence the photo is fraudulent. Hypocrisy noted.

If they saw something different, that doesn't mean it's a fraud. It may have looked different from different angles.
True. They saw the event and then saw the photo, and concluded it was a fraud. Does a mushroom cloud change in appearance if it is viewed from different directions? Place a mushroom cloud and take photos from 4 different directions. Does it look different? Not to my knowledge.
 
So it is against fair use to make a photo comparing photos? That photo is also not the photo Val took, the pixels just are not the same. In fact pixel for pixel, not a lot of pixels are the same as Val's photo, and I can prove that with some help from Val? The color, oops the color of black. They all look black, they are all jet fuel fires.

What else could they be? Val's photo was taken of the black plume, what else could it be? You do know that color in all three photos is relative to white balance. Color is so personal. No the photo are all real. Black smoke from a jet fuel. What is your point? They are all from jet impacts with the fuel being ignited by hot jet engines; if you do not want a big fire, turn off the jet engines before you crash. That is procedure! In the two accidents the pilots should have shut off the engines, they failed. Kind of like you trying to say Val's photo is fake. 93 pilots were not interested in survival so they left the engines running. I see nothing to but three jet fuel fires and the mushroom cloud, that you could miss if you do not take a snap shot.
Until you find evidence, and facts to prove Val made up the photo as she handed to police that day, then you are a person who makes up ideas about 9/11 with no facts or evidence.

No facts, no evidence just talk, so I am not surprised you are unable to post your true ideas, since you know they are based on shoddy research and not supported in fact.
Fair use-I thought it was a violation of the copyright. That is something that was pointed out against Killtown, wasn't? Violation of a copyright?
You do not accept primary source statements as facts or evidence? I do. Does the law?
Black looks gray? I thought black was black.

Idiot's hounding someone who takes a photo. You have joined those who try to discredit others for no real reason. If you want to expose fraud then expose LC as lies, or any part of the truth movement you pick.
I've never hounded Val. And I agree that others shouldn't. But on the other hand I read debunkers telling truthers to "call 'em up", "talk to the source", etc. Yet when that happens, I'm now reading where debunkers are saying leave people alone. I'm confused as what the debunker community wants the truther community to do in order to prove fraud.
Does the smoke plume in Val's photo appear as a continually burning jet fuel as in the other photographs?
To me it doesn't. I see a patch of blue underneath the smoke plume, just above the trees. Not jet fuel that continues to burn.

Does a person who saw the plane, the impact, and the resulting scene who claims the photo is a fraud, not evidence?

And technically, you can't state that the photo is real unless the digital file is examined by experts. Oh well, we can agree to disagree on the photo and we can both agree a plane crashed at Shanksville. Agreed?:)
 
Last edited:
Really? See this history of aviation accidents and the pictures of airplanes hitting the ground and the their characteristics. Point defeated.
You should reconsider, because it seems you have misunderstood what rare means in this context. Aircraft accidents and crashes are rare - if they weren't nobody would ever take a flight.

That there may be a body of photos and video/film recordings of crashes does not mean that crashes are therefore common.

Also, and this is hugely important, if you are going to use existing crash footage, then one must be sure to only compare crashes that share similar characteristics. You can't compare, for example, a crash on landing to one where the aircraft makes a high-speed, high-angle dive into the ground. These two events are vastly different in their characterisitics, and therefore the visual results afterwards will also be different.

Given the above, how many film/video recordings or still photos are there of accidents where aircraft have plunged into the ground at high-speed and at a sharp nose-down attitude like the way United 93 crashed?

Does a mushroom cloud change in appearance if it is viewed from different directions? Place a mushroom cloud and take photos from 4 different directions. Does it look different? Not to my knowledge.
Why makes you think a cloud of smoke is going to be perfectly symmetrical? There may be overall similarities but the finer details would be quite different.

You also must consider at what point in the cloud's formation a photo was taken - that will change considerably what the cloud will look like.
 
You should reconsider, because it seems you have misunderstood what rare means in this context. Aircraft accidents and crashes are rare - if they weren't nobody would ever take a flight.
That was not stated by the commentator.

That there may be a body of photos and video/film recordings of crashes does not mean that crashes are therefore common.
Also, and this is hugely important, if you are going to use existing crash footage, then one must be sure to only compare crashes that share similar characteristics. You can't compare, for example, a crash on landing to one where the aircraft makes a high-speed, high-angle dive into the ground. These two events are vastly different in their characterisitics, and therefore the visual results afterwards will also be different.
I completley agree. Does that discredit Beachnut's photos?
Given the above, how many film/video recordings or still photos are there of accidents where aircraft have plunged into the ground at high-speed and at a sharp nose-down attitude like the way United 93 crashed?
Excellent question.

Why makes you think a cloud of smoke is going to be perfectly symmetrical? There may be overall similarities but the finer details would be quite different.
You also must consider at what point in the cloud's formation a photo was taken - that will change considerably what the cloud will look like.
Agreed.

This of course doesn't change the primary source statements about the photo.
 
Direct statements are not primary source?

Nope. If I said that you were a baboon, I would not be a primary source. I have no evidence. Neither do they.

Levenknight and Purbaugh are by definition primary sources. Point defeated.
Stating that first hand or eyewitness accounts of an event is not a primary source is stupid.

You spelled "accurate" wrong. It doesn't start with an S.

I've attempted to find any records of Purbaugh or Levenknight, without results. All I've found is this, and it doesn't support your story at all. What have you got? Does it surprise you that we don't accept your word of what some random individual (and in the case of Levenknight {sp}, you keep changing the name of your "source") may or may not have implied, without support, about an event?

Really? See this history of aviation accidents and the pictures of airplanes hitting the ground and the their characteristics. Point defeated.

Airline crashes at over 500 MPH, rolled nearly inverted, are rare. Photographs of same are even more rare, due to their inpredictability and their tendency to happen in remote areas. You haven't even shown the ability to grasp this point, let alone defeat it.

Your confused. You stated that the effect of vegetation patterns is similar to the patterns in Shanksville. I accept that.
Because you suggested vegetation patters would be similar, I used your statement to argue that other parts of a crash site would be similar as well, including smoke patterns. I didn't speculate on vegetation patterns.
Your point is defeated due to your misunderstanding of the comment.
No confusion here at all. You're saying since the vegetation pattern looks similar to low-speed crashes, all features should be similar to low-speed crashes. That's an Affirming the Consequent logical fallacy. My point stands.

The FBI has individuals that make errors. Study the history of the FBI to determine if they are right 100% correct 100% of the time. Believing individuals or an agency is infallible is an incorrect assumption to make.
When the FBI concluded it was genuine was that after an analysis of the digital file by the photo crime lab or by looking at a paper copy in person? I personally do not know.
Speculation. Next.

People who saw the impact and then saw the photo apparently disagree that the photo is genuine. Who is more likely to be correct?
So far, we only have your word for this. Other people who saw the impact, then the photo, have stated that it is genuine. Not looking good for your side, pal.

Attacking the character.
If the shoe fits...

I do not believe Heroic Choices has the financial records of the photographer. Her bank, accountant, and IRS most likely do. I do not think they release private information to the public. Point defeated.
Then you're speculating. Point stands.

Speculation? You did the same thing when you stated ALL proceeds went to the charity. Hypocrisy noted.
Not speculation, I'm going by Val McClatchey's statements. It's not proof, but it is supported. Hypocrisy my eye.

Speculation from a primary source? One source who saw the impact and never lost sight of the crash scene? I think your confused about this speculation issue.
Nope.

Point accepted.
However, you haven't tested the validity of the process to my knowledge. To my knowledge, you haven't falsified the metric, either. Finally, you are trying to take a scientific mathematical process to apply to human behavior and motivations. People do lie. People do commit fraud. People do conspire to carry out evil deed. People are motivated to do all sorts of bad things.
Since you're using my metric wrong -- and I should know, since I wrote it -- you haven't a leg to stand on.

Point accepted. The picture should convince me. It doesn't.
Not my problem. You haven't shown that you can be convinced. Quite the contrary.

You could have said that you don't have the physics to explain the debris pattern.
I could, but it would be a lie. The debris pattern is self-consistent and completely expected. See the graphics on Page 68 of the horrible thread.

Not only do I have these physics, I also have the physics to compute the estimated cloud size, distribution, and location from the fuel size, mechanics of impact, and wind speed. I have. It's in that huge thread. It all checks.

If Val faked this photo, she has an uncanny knack for fluid dynamics and combustion physics, well beyond any expectation.

Dr. Joseph Shepherd, director of the combustion lab at GALCIT and perhaps the most qualified expert in the world, has seen the photo and concluded that it looks entirely plausible. Your incredulity is rooted in ignorance, plain and simple.

You stated . You didn't back up your statement, and in fact, I showed the opposite.
I offered you at least 2, and at most likely 4, proving your statement wrong. Not everyone in the area agrees the photo is a genuine. Point defeated.

The speculations of anyone doth not a point refute.

On the other hand you offer another person's perspective, but I must accept that as evidence that the photo is genuine, when you don't accept other people's perspective as evidence the photo is fraudulent. Hypocrisy noted.
I think you should look up the word "hypocrisy."

True. They saw the event and then saw the photo, and concluded it was a fraud. Does a mushroom cloud change in appearance if it is viewed from different directions? Place a mushroom cloud and take photos from 4 different directions. Does it look different? Not to my knowledge.
Of course it does. Argument from appalling ignorance noted.

But since you haven't even supplied these alleged contrary statements, I am of course selecting only one reason why they don't agree.

Now, then, support your statements or shut up. You haven't supported a thing.
 
Last edited:
Nope. If I said that you were a baboon, I would not be a primary source. I have no evidence. Neither do they.
Will you please stop attacking the character? It sheds poor light on your level of education.
I've attempted to find any records of Purbaugh or Levenknight, without results. All I've found is this, and it doesn't support your story at all. What have you got? Does it surprise you that we don't accept your word of what some random individual (and in the case of Levenknight {sp}, you keep changing the name of your "source") may or may not have implied, without support, about an event?

Let me help your research skills:

Lee Purbaugh first call - 03/27/07
http://www.glownightclub.ca/audio/lee_purbaugh_032707.mp3
Lee Purbaugh second call - 03/28/07
http://www.pumpitout.com/audio/lee_purbaugh_032807.mp3
Kelly Leverknight - 03/07/27
http://www.pumpitout.com/audio/leverknight_032707.mp3

Airline crashes at over 500 MPH, rolled nearly inverted, are rare. Photographs of same are even more rare, due to their inpredictability and their tendency to happen in remote areas. You haven't even shown the ability to grasp this point, let alone defeat it.
I think you spelled unpredictably wrong, but I'm not an expert.

No confusion here at all. You're saying since the vegetation pattern looks similar to low-speed crashes, all features should be similar to low-speed crashes. That's an Affirming the Consequent logical fallacy. My point stands.
Your direct quote from a previous thread that you provided a link to:
Killtown's assertions about the extent of burned and unburned vegetation are based on incomplete evidence cobbled together from TV news screencaptures, and fail to take into accout the litany of airplane crashes that left similar effects on vegetation
Please don't waste my time when I quoted you directly.
Please point out in your above quote the relative speed you were referring to in the litany of airplane crashes you were referring to?
Or are you suggesting that 93 was a low speed crash? I think you caught in your own quotes trap.
Point stands.

Swing-The FBI has individuals that make errors. Study the history of the FBI to determine if they are right 100% correct 100% of the time. Believing individuals or an agency is infallible is an incorrect assumption to make.
When the FBI concluded it was genuine was that after an analysis of the digital file by the photo crime lab or by looking at a paper copy in person? I personally do not know.
RMackey-Speculation. Wrong.
The historical record shows that the FBI is not infallible and that they do make mistakes. Point stands. Can you prove the FBI is infallible? I can prove they do make mistakes. Its called the historical record. You have no way to prove how the FBI examined the authenticity of the photograph, nor do I. Point stands.

If the shoe fits...
You mean I can't argue the point so I will result in attacking the character. Point accepted.

Not speculation, I'm going by Val McClatchey's statements. It's not proof, but it is supported. Hypocrisy my eye.
Source?
Since you're using my metric wrong -- and I should know, since I wrote it -- you haven't a leg to stand on.
Until you prove the validity and falsifiability of the metric, it means nothing.

Not my problem. You haven't shown that you can be convinced. Quite the contrary.
You didn't ask.
How could I be convinced?
1. The original digital file was analyzed by an expert and proven to be valid.
2. The primary source statements who viewed the event and the photo recanted their statements.
What would convince you it was a fraud or is it a religious belief?

Not only do I have these physics, I also have the physics to compute the estimated cloud size, distribution, and location from the fuel size, mechanics of impact, and wind speed. I have. It's in that huge thread. It all checks.
Great. The physics match the photo. That does nothing to prove the validity of the photo. Unless you have the original digital file, the analysis is inconsequential.

Dr. Joseph Shepherd, director of the combustion lab at GALCIT and perhaps the most qualified expert in the world, has seen the photo and concluded that it looks entirely plausible. Your incredulity is rooted in ignorance, plain and simple.
Unless the most qualified expert in the world in digital photography files and analysis has the file itself and examines it, then Dr. Shepherd's assessment is meaningless.
But since you haven't even supplied these alleged contrary statements, I am of course selecting only one reason why they don't agree.

You didn't ask.
Lee Purbaugh first call - 03/27/07
http://www.glownightclub.ca/audio/lee_purbaugh_032707.mp3
Lee Purbaugh second call - 03/28/07
http://www.pumpitout.com/audio/lee_purbaugh_032807.mp3
Kelly Leverknight - 03/07/27
http://www.pumpitout.com/audio/leverknight_032707.mp3


Now, then, support your statements or shut up.

ROFLMAO! Is that the school bell ringing?
 
Last edited:
So it is against fair use to make a photo comparing photos? That photo is also not the photo Val took, the pixels just are not the same. In fact pixel for pixel, not a lot of pixels are the same as Val's photo, and I can prove that with some help from Val? The color, oops the color of black. They all look black, they are all jet fuel fires.

What else could they be? Val's photo was taken of the black plume, what else could it be? You do know that color in all three photos is relative to white balance. Color is so personal. No the photo are all real. Black smoke from a jet fuel. What is your point? They are all from jet impacts with the fuel being ignited by hot jet engines; if you do not want a big fire, turn off the jet engines before you crash. That is procedure! In the two accidents the pilots should have shut off the engines, they failed. Kind of like you trying to say Val's photo is fake. 93 pilots were not interested in survival so they left the engines running. I see nothing to but three jet fuel fires and the mushroom cloud, that you could miss if you do not take a snap shot.
Until you find evidence, and facts to prove Val made up the photo as she handed to police that day, then you are a person who makes up ideas about 9/11 with no facts or evidence.


Fair use-I thought it was a violation of the copyright. That is something that was pointed out against Killtown, wasn't? Violation of a copyright?
You do not accept primary source statements as facts or evidence? I do. Does the law?
Black looks gray? I thought black was black.


I've never hounded Val. And I agree that others shouldn't. But on the other hand I read debunkers telling truthers to "call 'em up", "talk to the source", etc. Yet when that happens, I'm now reading where debunkers are saying leave people alone. I'm confused as what the debunker community wants the truther community to do in order to prove fraud.
Does the smoke plume in Val's photo appear as a continually burning jet fuel as in the other photographs?
To me it doesn't. I see a patch of blue underneath the smoke plume, just above the trees. Not jet fuel that continues to burn.

Does a person who saw the plane, the impact, and the resulting scene who claims the photo is a fraud, not evidence?

And technically, you can't state that the photo is real unless the digital file is examined by experts. Oh well, we can agree to disagree on the photo and we can both agree a plane crashed at Shanksville. Agreed?:)
Yep, flight 93 crashed after the passengers attacked the hijackers and the hijackers failed to reach their target. Plus you have to agree that an engine fell off on impact, as found on 9/11.

I believe Val's photo is real and see not one single fact to prove otherwise. So agreed by all but Killtown.
 
That was not stated by the commentator.
I shall reiterate the progression of events for you:

From Post #520:

Airline crashes of this type are extremely rare.
Note the bolded words.

From post #522 your reply:

Really? See this history of aviation accidents and the pictures of airplanes hitting the ground and the their characteristics. Point defeated.
It seems clear to me you did not properly interpret R.Mackey's comment, based on your reply as quoted above. That's what I was drawing your attention to.
 
I shall reiterate the progression of events for you:

From Post #520:

Note the bolded words.

From post #522 your reply:

It seems clear to me you did not properly interpret R.Mackey's comment, based on your reply as quoted above. That's what I was drawing your attention to.
Thank you. I wasn't sure what this type refers to. Speed? Angle of impact? Motivation of the pilots? Location? Angle of approach? Plane type? Plane crashes were quite frequent on 9/11. But I do agree that plane crashes since the beginning of maned flight are rare.
But perhaps R.Mackey could clear up his bold type for both of us.
I believe Val's photo is real and see not one single fact to prove otherwise. So agreed by all but Killtown.
Well all except me and apparently the Purbaughs and the Leverknights. I see primary source statements then are not considered facts by you. I'm not sure why but then that is your prerogative.
Plus you have to agree that an engine fell off on impact, as found on 9/11.
Until I see the physics of how the engine
landed at the location upon impact as opposed to falling off prior to impact, I can't agree with that statement. In fact the only eyewitness to see the impact states the plane's behavior looked like the pilot was fighting to control the plane.
Back to the color of the plume, this source states the color of the smoke was gray, not black.
Judge preserves lawsuit over Sept. 11 photo
Tuesday, April 03, 2007
By Milan Simonich, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

Her photo shows a blue sky, a red barn and a towering cloud of gray smoke from the downed jet, whose 44 passengers died in the crash near Shanksville.

So is it black or gray? Perhaps you may want to contact the press and those involved in the lawsuit to correct them.
Rmackey-Val is not profiting by this venture, but donates all money sent to Heroic Choices, a charity organization honoring Mr. Todd Beamer, a victim of Flight 93.
Would you care to retract this statement? Or do you accept that you are wrong on your information or worse? The following source shows a motivation for profit and contribution to the foundation. I'm sorry to inform you that you are wrong.

Before her trouble with the AP, Mrs. McClatchey had licensed the use of her photo to various news organizations, including the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, Newsweek and ABC. She generally charged $250 to $350 for one-time use of the picture, admitting she did not know how much freelance photographers commanded.

She is seeking $150,000 in damages, contending the AP was guilty of "willful infringement" of the copyright.

Aside from marketing the photo to news companies, Mrs. McClatchey sold personal copies. She charged $20 for each, $18 of which went to the Todd Beamer Foundation. Mr. Beamer was a passenger on Flight 93. The rest of the money from personal sales went for paper and printing costs, her lawyers said.
Source: Pittsburg-Post Gazette
 
Last edited:
Swing:

the one thing that stuck in my craw the most, of all you said in your reply to me, was this "appeal to authority". Now if I recall, in debating circles, the only time an "appeal to authority" is misused, or inappropriate, is when it is a fallacy, or when the authority is not in fact a true authority.

Therefore, when I ask you to bring it to a photo analysis expert, or a plane crash investigator, it is not an "appeal to authority" in the debating fallacy sense. If I asked you about a photo, and you said it was fake because killtown says it is, and killtown is not a photo analysis expert, than THAT would be an "appeal to authority".

I mean, when you go to the doctor for an opinion on an illness, is that an appeal to authority?

Come on now.

TAM:)
 
and according to that article, Swing, the only time it specifies where the money is going, it is to the Todd Beamer Foundation. the other charges and the suit money have no comment on where the money is going, it simply indicates the amount or the amount she charges...she could then donate it to charity...you do not know, so TECHNICALLY, R.Mackey is not in err, but I admit, it seems as though she possibly gaining some financial reward from it.

TAM:)
 
If I were a truther, I would be very careful about associating myself with killtown.

Even if I agreed with him, which I don't, I would realize it is possible for somebody to agree with me and still be a d*ck.
 
Swing:

the one thing that stuck in my craw the most, of all you said in your reply to me, was this "appeal to authority". Now if I recall, in debating circles, the only time an "appeal to authority" is misused, or inappropriate, is when it is a fallacy, or when the authority is not in fact a true authority.

Therefore, when I ask you to bring it to a photo analysis expert, or a plane crash investigator, it is not an "appeal to authority" in the debating fallacy sense. If I asked you about a photo, and you said it was fake because killtown says it is, and killtown is not a photo analysis expert, than THAT would be an "appeal to authority".

I mean, when you go to the doctor for an opinion on an illness, is that an appeal to authority?

Come on now.

TAM:)

The key for me, is this...I NEVER argue with a truther, to convince him of squat. As a matter of fact, i will often deliberately debate with he or she in a less effective manner, simply to make them bring forward their own silliness for those WATCHING to see. It is those who sit at ring side that I get into the rign for.

TAM, are you just toying with me in order to bring out my silliness or are you trying to carry on a civil conversation?
 
TAM, are you just toying with me in order to bring out my silliness or are you trying to carry on a civil conversation?

Maybe civility is left at the door when you make unfounded, unsubstantiated claims against innocent people of mass murder.

Maybe it is kind of silly to get somewhat annoyed at people that claim
US citizens murdered on mass their fellow country men.

Hey that’s just me, please do carry on and wonder why you are not greeted with people throwing rose petals at your feet when you enter the room.
 
TAM, are you just toying with me in order to bring out my silliness or are you trying to carry on a civil conversation?

I've discussed/debated enough with you over at SLC Blog on most things here. If you bring something new and contraversial to the table, I would discuss it with you. You are civil enough, and most times reasonable enough that I would not pull the "give them enough rope" biz with you.

Why do you quote my line on "appeal to authority". It does bother me when people use that comment incorrectly. To appropriately ask for/expect an authoritative/expert opinion on a subject IS NOT what is meant by the debating fallacy "appeal to authority" so you were using it wrong.

TAM:)
 
If I were a truther, I would be very careful about associating myself with killtown.
Even if I agreed with him, which I don't, I would realize it is possible for somebody to agree with me and still be a d*ck.

I'm not associating myself with killtown. Killtown doesn't think a plane crashed at Shanksville. I do. I do however think the photo is fraudulent. My opinion on the photo has nothing to do with a plane crash or a non-plane crash.

Ok, TAM, I will play.
Therefore, when I ask you to bring it to a photo analysis expert, or a plane crash investigator, it is not an "appeal to authority" in the debating fallacy sense. If I asked you about a photo, and you said it was fake because killtown says it is, and killtown is not a photo analysis expert, than THAT would be an "appeal to authority".

I mean, when you go to the doctor for an opinion on an illness, is that an appeal to authority?

I do accept your point at my error in the appeal to authority. However in the context of the post, your request (is that a better term?;) ) for an authority appeared to be in response to the valid points I made as a non-authority especially in response to the primary sources and the evidence I considered valid to show the photo appears to be fraudulent.

Can I ask why you believe a statement when an authority on digital files has not verified the photo in question, but will only accept evidence of fraud from an authority?

I would also request an authority as stated below to verify not the photo but the original digital file to put the matter to rest. As this, to my knowledge, has not happened, the premise that the photo is a fraud still remains valid.

and according to that article, Swing, the only time it specifies where the money is going, it is to the Todd Beamer Foundation. the other charges and the suit money have no comment on where the money is going, it simply indicates the amount or the amount she charges...she could then donate it to charity...you do not know, so TECHNICALLY, R.Mackey is not in err, but I admit, it seems as though she possibly gaining some financial reward from it.
The amount of money going to the foundation is 18 out of the 20 dollars. The amount Val charged news outlets is $250 to $350. Now TAM, don't you think it would be a point of emphasis in the article within the same paragraph within the context of charity donations to point out Val was donating several hundreds of dollars to the charity gained from the profits as a result of marketing the photo to press outlets?
Come on now?;)
There is no need to speculate when the article tells you where the money is going. Unless further evidence is provided, the money from the sales to news agencies is in all probability going to Val. And of course she has every right to make money off of the alleged photo as it is her photo.

RMackey is wrong as he stated ALL of the money was going to charity. 2 dollars out of every 20 that she sold to private individuals is not going to charity but into her pocket. This figure of course doesn't take into account her sales to news outlets. Therefore, ALL of the money is not going to charity. It's ok TAM to say Rmackey is wrong when he indeed is wrong. And you don't have to admit to anything TAM, the facts speak for themselves. Val is making money off of the photo.
 
Maybe civility is left at the door when you make unfounded, unsubstantiated claims against innocent people of mass murder.
Maybe it is kind of silly to get somewhat annoyed at people that claim
US citizens murdered on mass their fellow country men.
Hey that’s just me, please do carry on and wonder why you are not greeted with people throwing rose petals at your feet when you enter the room.

One, please point out where my thoughts on a single photo has anything to do with mass murder?
I don't consider a shoot down scenario of 93 mass murder. I consider it an act of national defense that did not take place often enough on that fateful day. The other suggestion on this thread that I made was that a bomb went off on Flight 93, which is entirely consistent with the actions of terrorists.
I fully expected to not be treated kindly, however, TAM has proven my expectation wrong as some others have as well.

Another thread that I was active on contained my premise that terrorists, including two possible suspects, used an explosive device in the North Tower basement. That premise was well defended using the empirical method and still remains a valid premise to this day.

And as far as U.S. citizens mass murdering other U.S. citizens..well I think the occurs on an almost daily basis, most recently at Virgina Tech. You can search the historical records of our fine country to find further examples of countrymen murdering in mass other countrymen. That is human nature, State of Grace.
 
Back to the color of the plume, this source states the color of the smoke was gray, not black.

So is it black or gray? Perhaps you may want to contact the press and those involved in the lawsuit to correct them.
The smoke is black, you can call it what ever color you want but it is black and I can prove that it is. But you can call it gray. Black is a darker shade of gray. Jet fuel kind of has a black soot to it, Black. Sorry you want to quibble with me, but all three plumes were from jet fuel, it has a black cloud, and you can call it gray, but all three plumes are the same, from jet fuel. Now why not quibble about the fuel.

So you are saying the plume is black and white, as in gray? Make up you mind. Where did the white come from?

I'm not associating myself with killtown. Killtown doesn't think a plane crashed at Shanksville. I do. I do however think the photo is fraudulent. My opinion on the photo has nothing to do with a plane crash or a non-plane crash.
When will you have some evidence. So far you have Killtown and hearsay. When will you tell us the secret evidence hidden with Charlie Sheen's facts?
 
Last edited:
The smoke is black, you can call it what ever color you want but it is black and I can prove that it is. But you can call it gray. Black is a darker shade of gray. Jet fuel kind of has a black soot to it, Black. Sorry you want to quibble with me, but all three plumes were from jet fuel, it has a black cloud, and you can call it gray, but all three plumes are the same, from jet fuel. Now why not quibble about the fuel.

So you are saying the plume is black and white, as in gray? Make up you mind. Where did the white come from?

When will you have some evidence. So far you have Killtown and hearsay. When will you tell us the secret evidence hidden with Charlie Sheen's facts?

Beachnut, I'm not looking for confrontation.
Two separate news articles state the plume is gray, one of the articles reporting on the current lawsuit is one of those. So not only does the plume smoke look gray to me, but two other reporters who published descriptions as well.

I haven't used a single quote from Killtown, thankyou. The hearsay is not hearsay at all but the direct statements of at least two individuals who saw the region shortly after the impact, with one who saw the impact and a third who was nearby and saw no smoke at all in the sky, hence my continuing referral to these people as primary sources.

Black is a darker shade of gray?
Black: lacking hue and brightness; absorbing light without reflecting any of the rays composing it.
Gray: of a color between white and black; having a neutral hue; Of or relating to an achromatic color of any lightness between the extremes of black and white.
Source: dictionary.com

You see black in Val's photo, I see gray. I see black in your two photos on the right, I see gray in the photo on the left.
You see no differences, I do.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom