Chemical Engineer Mark Basile confirms Harrit nano-thermite results

Hold on isnt the problem that thermite needs to be able to cut
horizontally not vertically through a steel column?


I'm a Mech Eng, and I'm pretty sure I could work out a way to do it......now doing it without leaving a single trace of how I did it....... :)

Now why are we insisting that it needs to cut through the columns?.....just heating them up a lot would do the same thing as the fire did.....soften the steel till it failed. But again how to do that without anyone noticing and without leaving a trace.........and again why bother when you have a plane......
 
Last edited:
You can't test what you don't have and as far as i can see Jones isn't about to give anyone else any of it. Whatever it is.


and of course he would also have to prove it is what he says it is and that he did not adulterate it.............pesky chain of evidence problem.....
 
Now why are we insisting that it needs to cut through the columns?.....just heating them up a lot would do the same thing as the fire did.....soften the steel till it failed. But again how to do that without anyone noticing and without leaving a trace.........and again why bother when you have a plane......

Furthermore, why insist on cutting through the columns when the steel that was recovered showed they failed at their connection points? And on top of that, wasn't it the truthers who first claimed that the columns happened to be demolished in a way that they were recoverable as 30 foot lengths, thus making it easy to truck away? Yes, many of the columns were indeed recovered in those lengths, but for good reason too: That's how long individual ones were, and it lends support to the fact that columns failed at their connection points. Anyway, my point is that proposing a collapse method that cut through a column actually contradicts evidence, not to mention previous trutherisms.

-----

While we're at it: Sheeplesnshills, are you trying to lure Max Photon back to the forums? :D
 
Miragememories said:
"What qualifies you to claim the findings of Niels H. Harrit,, Jeffrey Farrer, Steven E. Jones, Kevin R. Ryan, Frank M. Legge, Daniel Farnsworth, Gregg Roberts, James R. Gourley and Bradley R. Larsen are illegitimate?"
Edx said:
"I love how truthers can argue from authority when it suits them, but can also argue the exact opposite.

So right now MM is arguing from authority, but point out that just under 1360 architects and engineers worldwide is a pathetic laughable figure of supporters when approx 17,000 engineers are newly credentialed every year just in the US alone and they have no peer reviewed publications in legitimate journals and all of a sudden he would start saying that I am making an argument from authority and peer review is a sham. And of course since experts like Dr Bazant have more experience and expertise than all truthers put together he has to somehow say that his expertise doesnt matter."
Miragememories said:
"Is there a point somewhere in that diatribe?

I missed the part of your argument where you explain how the research of these scientists has been proven faulty?"
Edx said:
"Maybe you missed the part where you say no one can comment because Harrit and Jones are super experts (though of course they arent).

But hey lets take your logic and then destroy you with it, why do you think any of you truthers are qualified to critique Dr Bazants work?

Oh wait, NOW its different right?"

Yes I did miss that part. Please point out where I say no one can comment?

Destroy me with logic? Is that some sort of personal threat?

I believe that making the asinine statement "...experts like Dr Bazant have more experience and expertise than all truthers put together..." reveals an even greater lack of credibility on your own part.

MM
 
... I believe that making the asinine statement "...experts like Dr Bazant have more experience and expertise than all truthers put together..." reveals an even greater lack of credibility on your own part. ...
Dr Bazant beats all 911 truth combined. You have no structural engineer experts in 911 truth; you have zero evidence and no experts. You have delusions, no evidence. How many more years before you get yourself an education which enables you to understand 911 instead of following idiots with fantasies on 911.
 
for sunstealer to address from previous page:
that was an interesting read. but:

"The melting temperature depression of nanoparticles is
apparent only when the particle size is smaller than 100 nm.
If the particle size is larger than 100 nm, the melting temperature
of the particles approximately equals to the corresponding
bulk materials, in other words, the melting temperature
of nanoparticles is independent of the particle size."


from the active thermitic paper, the iron was 100 nm and the AL was 40 nm by 1 micron.

so, do you think melting point depression had any effect on those particles?
 
not sure what you are getting at here. The red layer consists of rhombohedral Fe2O3 and the grey layer is iron oxide (can't remember which type now) so there's the source of iron. The microspheres aren't just iron or iron rich if I recall correctly, they contain other elements too.

Is he talking about pure Iron (Fe) - the data speaks for itself and clearly shows iron present in two (oxidised) forms.

I have absolutely no problem with iron/aluminium/silicon/oxygen microspheres being discovered upon the burning of paint when those elements are present in the paint itself.

You do not need 1500°C plus to melt iron or FeO!! The size and shape of a particle has an effect on the melting temperature - the smaller the particle the lower the melting point.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Melting-point_depression
http://nano.xunbiz.net/doc/018-2004-mcp-melting.pdf

Most truthers don't understand the difference between a bulk property and a nano or micro-property.

for sunstealer to address from last page:
this is what jones said to greening regarding this issue:

prof jones: "Dr. Farrer and Danny and I have looked at many of these post-DSC spheres, many do NOT contain Al. See for example Fig 21 in our paper:

Look again at the data (above) -- there is no Al in evidence. Furthermore, the amounts of Si and Ca and especially S here is trivial. The melting points of iron and of iron oxide are both above 1200 C, yet the DSC reached only 700 C, insufficient to cause melting of iron or iron oxide."

http://webcache.googleusercontent.c...y+and+I+have+looked"&cd=4&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us
 
for sunstealer to address from last page:
this is what jones said to greening regarding this issue:

prof jones: "Dr. Farrer and Danny and I have looked at many of these post-DSC spheres, many do NOT contain Al. See for example Fig 21 in our paper:

Look again at the data (above) -- there is no Al in evidence. Furthermore, the amounts of Si and Ca and especially S here is trivial. The melting points of iron and of iron oxide are both above 1200 C, yet the DSC reached only 700 C, insufficient to cause melting of iron or iron oxide."

http://webcache.googleusercontent.c...y+and+I+have+looked"&cd=4&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us

sunstealer quote from another thread:
"Nanothermite is only using a smaller particle size. Nano does not mean magic or super-duper mmmkay.

Fe2O3 + 2Al → 2Fe + Al2O3 + heat

The waste product is Fe and Al2O3 - I suggest you learn some basic chemistry."



thanks for showing everyone that this iron microsphere was made from a thermitic reaction!!
 
I just caught up with the last couple days of this thread and tfk and Sunstealer have nailed the flaws in the truther "analysis", IMO, in addition to stating methods that would be definitive. It won't have any effect on truther die-hards, of course, but it points the way to understanding for others willing to read and learn.

I'd like to suggest an alternative analysis method that I think could also be definitive and that is to prepare microtome sections of the chips and then do micro-Raman and micro-infrared spectroscopy on the different layers seen in the sections. Raman should identify the inorganics and IR the organics. These methods are used for forensic analysis of paint chips, for example paint from vehicles. Raman has been used successfully to identify inorganic pigments in forensic cases such as art history disputes. Using the spectral results, as well as color and thickness of the layers as measured with optical microscopy, the samples would be very well characterized and could be compared with what's known about the paints and finishes used in the towers. And who knows? Even though Jones', etal results seem to indicate the materials are not thermitic (contrary DSC results), analyzing the layers with proper methods might confirm their claims.

But as has been stated, there's not a snowball's chance that Jones will let his samples come anywhere near a lab with the right people and instruments to decide the question once and for all.

ferd
 
I just caught up with the last couple days of this thread and tfk and Sunstealer have nailed the flaws in the truther "analysis", IMO, in addition to stating methods that would be definitive. It won't have any effect on truther die-hards, of course, but it points the way to understanding for others willing to read and learn.

I'd like to suggest an alternative analysis method that I think could also be definitive and that is to prepare microtome sections of the chips and then do micro-Raman and micro-infrared spectroscopy on the different layers seen in the sections. Raman should identify the inorganics and IR the organics. These methods are used for forensic analysis of paint chips, for example paint from vehicles. Raman has been used successfully to identify inorganic pigments in forensic cases such as art history disputes. Using the spectral results, as well as color and thickness of the layers as measured with optical microscopy, the samples would be very well characterized and could be compared with what's known about the paints and finishes used in the towers. And who knows? Even though Jones', etal results seem to indicate the materials are not thermitic (contrary DSC results), analyzing the layers with proper methods might confirm their claims.

But as has been stated, there's not a snowball's chance that Jones will let his samples come anywhere near a lab with the right people and instruments to decide the question once and for all.

ferd

Source of your claim that "there's not a snowball's chance that Jones will let his samples come anywhere near a lab with the right people and instruments to decide the question once and for all".

Put up or shut up.

MM
 
Source of your claim that "there's not a snowball's chance that Jones will let his samples come anywhere near a lab with the right people and instruments to decide the question once and for all".

Put up or shut up.

MM

The proof is that he hasn't done it.
 
Source of your claim that "there's not a snowball's chance that Jones will let his samples come anywhere near a lab with the right people and instruments to decide the question once and for all".

Put up or shut up.

MM

How about Jones put up or shut up? :rolleyes: He's the only holding onto his samples.
 
Last edited:
Yes I did miss that part. Please point out where I say no one can comment?

When you said...

What qualifies you to claim the findings of {bunch of truthers} are illegitimate?
- MM

In other words, unless you are more qualified than X your comments are not valid.

Therefore I can make the same argument as you: What qualifies you to claim the findings of Dr Bazant are illegitimate? But oh, now you'll claim its unfair right?

As was my point initially, you argue from authority purely when it suits you and switch back just as easily.

Destroy me with logic? Is that some sort of personal threat?

Only if you think of your argument's validity as a personification of yourself and my logic as a knife, in which case yes it is.

I believe that making the asinine statement "...experts like Dr Bazant have more experience and expertise than all truthers put together..." reveals an even greater lack of credibility on your own part.

MM

Well feel free to share a truther or even a group of truthers that have more experience, qualifications, accolades and publications than Dr Bazant. Please, please do.
 
Last edited:
The proof is that he hasn't done it.
You seem to under the mistaken belief that Dr. jones is the custodian of all the WTC dust samples.

Referring specifically to Mark Basile;

Physicist said:
"Now, back to the chain of custody. So it is not from collapsing buildings. It did come from the dust of the WTC.
As I said, samples were sent separately to Dr. Farrer and myself. These samples all showed the same red/gray material. A separate sample was sent to a scientist, Mark Basile working in New England and he also sees the same active red/gray material. I have to say one thing while I am discussing the efforts by Mark Basile. He was the first one to ignite a red/gray chip and observe the spheres, the tiny iron-rich spheres in the residue after the red/gray chip is ignited. And so I think it is important to give him credit for that observation and we looked in our residues from the red/gray chips and we also found these spheres. I would just like to say that was found independently, and first, by Mark Basile."

Most of the contributing collectors (except for an anonymous NYC museum) have been named, and all have kept portions of their samples.

They have also dealt directly with people other than Dr. Jones.

And certainly the EPA must have samples.

You fail to make your point.

MM
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom