I just caught up with the last couple days of this thread and tfk and Sunstealer have nailed the flaws in the truther "analysis", IMO, in addition to stating methods that would be definitive. It won't have any effect on truther die-hards, of course, but it points the way to understanding for others willing to read and learn.
I'd like to suggest an alternative analysis method that I think could also be definitive and that is to prepare microtome sections of the chips and then do micro-Raman and micro-infrared spectroscopy on the different layers seen in the sections. Raman should identify the inorganics and IR the organics. These methods are used for forensic analysis of paint chips, for example paint from vehicles. Raman has been used successfully to identify inorganic pigments in forensic cases such as art history disputes. Using the spectral results, as well as color and thickness of the layers as measured with optical microscopy, the samples would be very well characterized and could be compared with what's known about the paints and finishes used in the towers. And who knows? Even though Jones', etal results seem to indicate the materials are not thermitic (contrary DSC results), analyzing the layers with proper methods might confirm their claims.
But as has been stated, there's not a snowball's chance that Jones will let his samples come anywhere near a lab with the right people and instruments to decide the question once and for all.
ferd