Chemical Engineer Mark Basile confirms Harrit nano-thermite results

You can choose to accept the legitimacy of my typo on silicon or not Tom. It is the truth and that is all that is important.

I do accept it. My follow up comment was a result of another poster - someone who gives you a bad time - writing me a PM and suggesting that I was being too harsh with my previous comment.

I agreed that perhaps I was, and wrote what I did to you. "I don't care about the typo. We all make them."

I also appended that I believe it to be very unlikely that anyone with a chemistry background would make that glaring mistake. So, please enlighten me. What is the extent of your chemistry background.

Mine is 2 required semesters in college, when I was getting my mechanical engineering degree. Doesn't make me any kind of expert.

But I do know the difference between Silicon Valley (Cupertino to Redwood City) & Silicone Valley (Hollywood).

Now about your "very simple argument";

I would say it is, if anything, not an argument, but a too simple question.

Rather than shake your fist over their supposedly not doing what you think they should have done, you should be pointing out how their findings are flawed?

I pointed out EXACTLY how they are flawed. They are inconclusive.

If no conclusive tests existed, or if conclusive tests were so onerous or expensive that one couldn't practically do them, then inventing your own tests, with merely "suggestive" results might be necessary.

If a simple, inexpensive and CONCLUSIVE test is readily available, then inventing your own inconclusive one is incompetent.

What part of this is too hard to understand?

I do not care if they creatively used a different approach to the problem, as long as it was scientifically legitimate.

It was not scientifically legitimate. Several people have pointed out numerous flaws with the study.

My objection overwhelm the trivia within their report. They should never have done that testing in the first place. They should have researched the field, found out the conclusive tests, and done THOSE tests instead.

They were incompetent. (Even tho you don't want to say so.)

Are you interested in the truth Tom or not?

Yup. Are you?

That's why I wouldn't accept inconclusive testing out of anyone. Whether it be NIST, FEMA or Jones, et al.

If you are interested in the truth, why do you accept inconclusive testing, instead of demanding conclusive testing?

Why does Jones?
Why does Farrer?
Why does Harrit?
Why does Basile?

Why do you accept incompetence out of "truther scientists"?

tk
 
Last edited:
this is what jones said to greening regarding this issue:

prof jones: "Dr. Farrer and Danny and I have looked at many of these post-DSC spheres, many do NOT contain Al. See for example Fig 21 in our paper:

Very interesting. The absence of Al is a clear evidence that no thermite reaction occured, as Al is a common by-product of aluminothermic reactions.
 
Miragememories said:
"Now about your "very simple argument";

I would say it is, if anything, not an argument, but a too simple question.

Rather than shake your fist over their supposedly not doing what you think they should have done, you
should be pointing out how their findings are flawed?"
tfk said:
"I pointed out EXACTLY how they are flawed. They are inconclusive.

If no conclusive tests existed, or if conclusive tests were so onerous or expensive that one couldn't practically do them, then inventing your own tests, with merely "suggestive" results might be necessary.

If a simple, inexpensive and CONCLUSIVE test is readily available, then inventing your own inconclusive one is incompetent.

What part of this is too hard to understand?"

Oh for the record, I to have the two mandatory semesters of engineering chemistry from the university I attended. Chemistry was my highest grade in high school but not a favorite subject by any means.

Inconclusive of what?

What qualifies you to claim the findings of Niels H. Harrit,, Jeffrey Farrer, Steven E. Jones, Kevin R. Ryan, Frank M. Legge, Daniel Farnsworth, Gregg Roberts, James R. Gourley and Bradley R. Larsen are illegitimate?

Your response is a lot of babble and totally lacking in the kind of specifics required to prove that the work of those scientists should not be accepted.

Miragememories said:
"I do not care if they creatively used a different approach to the problem, as long as it was scientifically
legitimate."
tfk said:
"It was not scientifically legitimate. Several people have pointed out numerous flaws with the study.

My objection overwhelm the trivia within their report. They should never have done that testing in the first place. They should have researched the field, found out the conclusive tests, and done THOSE tests instead.

They were incompetent. (Even tho you don't want to say so.)"

Again, like so many here in JREF, you make absolute statements apparently for the sole reason that no one can prevent you from doing so.

You talk in generalities about vague, undefined, scientific methods that were ignored, while declaiming as unacceptable, the defined scientific methods that these researchers followed.

What is incompetent, is the argument you seem to believe you have fully presented.

Your prejudice is blinding you.

MM
 
You talk in generalities about vague, undefined, scientific methods that were ignored, while declaiming as unacceptable, the defined scientific methods that these researchers followed.

What is incompetent, is the argument you seem to believe you have fully presented.

Your prejudice is blinding you.

MM

Begging the question.

We've already shown that the heroes are incompetent by not disclosing where they got their control samples from.

They got them from the local football stadium.

Incomptents.

By the way, their refusal to release samples to independent researchers smacks of academic dishonesty.
 
What qualifies you to claim the findings of Niels H. Harrit,, Jeffrey Farrer, Steven E. Jones, Kevin R. Ryan, Frank M. Legge, Daniel Farnsworth, Gregg Roberts, James R. Gourley and Bradley R. Larsen are illegitimate?

I love how truthers can argue from authority when it suits them, but can also argue the exact opposite.

So right now MM is arguing from authority, but point out that just under 1360 architects and engineers worldwide is a pathetic laughable figure of supporters when approx 17,000 engineers are newly credentialed every year just in the US alone and they have no peer reviewed publications in legitimate journals and all of a sudden he would start saying that I am making an argument from authority and peer review is a sham. And of course since experts like Dr Bazant have more experience and expertise than all truthers put together he has to somehow say that his expertise doesnt matter.
 
Last edited:
Miragememories said:
"What qualifies you to claim the findings of Niels H. Harrit,, Jeffrey Farrer, Steven E. Jones, Kevin R. Ryan, Frank M. Legge, Daniel Farnsworth, Gregg Roberts, James R. Gourley and Bradley R. Larsen are illegitimate?"
Edx said:
"I love how truthers can argue from authority when it suits them, but can also argue the exact opposite.

So right now MM is arguing from authority, but point out that just under 1360 architects and engineers worldwide is a pathetic laughable figure of supporters when approx 17,000 engineers are newly credentialed every year just in the US alone and they have no peer reviewed publications in legitimate journals and all of a sudden he would start saying that I am making an argument from authority and peer review is a sham. And of course since experts like Dr Bazant have more experience and expertise than all truthers put together he has to somehow say that his expertise doesnt matter."

Is there a point somewhere in that diatribe?

I missed the part of your argument where you explain how the research of these scientists has been proven faulty?

MM
 
...
I missed the part of your argument where you explain how the research of these scientists has been proven faulty? ...
They have failed to earn a Pulitzer Prize. If their work was true, and their delusions were real, they would have a Pulitzer Prize. However, their paper proves the dust samples were not thermite, and you can't figure it out. You should have become a scientist or engineer, what did you do with the last 9 years besides support idiots with dumb delusions?

Their research is faulty by default. Anyone with a grade school education can figure it out.
 
Oh for the record, I to have the two mandatory semesters of engineering chemistry from the university I attended. Chemistry was my highest grade in high school but not a favorite subject by any means.

Congrats. You are an amateur. Just as I am.

Inconclusive of what?

Duh… "the presence of [insert the name of some substance here]"

Let's see if you can guess:
1. Ice cream
2. bat guano
3. thermite / thermate / thermite / nanothermite / superthermite

What qualifies you to claim the findings of Niels H. Harrit,, Jeffrey Farrer, Steven E. Jones, Kevin R. Ryan, Frank M. Legge, Daniel Farnsworth, Gregg Roberts, James R. Gourley and Bradley R. Larsen are illegitimate?

Humility.

Something that none of Harrit, Farrer, Jones, Ryan, etc., or you, seem to demonstrate.

I acknowledge that I don't have the background to know the right tests to run. Neither do you. Neither did Harrit, Jones, et al.

But I do know the right questions to ask. And the right people to ask.

So I asked 3 experts at 3 different labs, the chemists who actually run the tests and who are accredited for, and experienced in, determining whether or not thermite exists in samples. If you read my post, I explained all this.

I described the tests that Farrer et al did, and asked if they simply provided elements, not compounds. All 3 chemists replied, "yes, that's true."

I asked if those tests were therefore not definitive for the presence of thermite. All 3 chemists replied, "yes, that's true."

I asked, "Is there some test that IS definitive for the presence of thermite?" All 3 chemists replied, "Yes, x-ray diffraction."

The same answers were given to me by three independent, accredited laboratories, who perform these forensic tests for the FBI, Department of Justice, etc. in arson cases.

You get the picture? They have performed these tests hundreds of times in the past.

Unlike your arrogant bunch, who have NEVER ONCE looked for thermite in forensic samples. But decided that they didn't need to ask anyone's help. And tried to do it themselves.

Your response is a lot of babble and totally lacking in the kind of specifics required to prove that the work of those scientists should not be accepted.

Try reading my response for a change.

These aren't MY opinions. They are the opinions of REAL experts.

Again, like so many here in JREF, you make absolute statements apparently for the sole reason that no one can prevent you from doing so.

Yawnnn. Read the substance.

You talk in generalities about vague, undefined, scientific methods that were ignored, while declaiming as unacceptable, the defined scientific methods that these researchers followed.

"Vague"?? "undefined"??

I was incredibly precise. Zero uncertainty in what I said: "If they used non-deterministic tests, when definitive ones are readily available, then they were incompetent."

What part of that sentence is "vague" or "undefined"?

The tests that they did was NOT judged "non-deterministic" by me. It was judged so by real experts.

Do you disagree? Do you think that inconclusive tests are superior to conclusive ones?

Experts, real experts not me, have stated to me clearly that Harrit et al's tests are inconclusive.

You could confirm this for yourself in 20 minutes.

Learn how to use Thomasnet.com . Find a couple of forensics labs that have experience doing thermite testing for the DoJ, the FBI, arson investigators.

Ask them the same questions yourself. Come back & tell me what they say.

Or explain to me why you are afraid to do so.

tk
 
Last edited:
Is there a point somewhere in that diatribe?

I missed the part of your argument where you explain how the research of these scientists has been proven faulty?

MM

This is really simple MM....

Tom PICKED UP THE DAMN PHONE and asked someone who is an expert in this area.

He didn't ask some moronic conspiracy nutcase.....
He didn't ask someone in an unrelated field....
He didn't ask someone who uses cardboard boxes as an analogy to the WTC....

He asked EXPERTS. Stop your complaining and pick up the phone and ask some real experts what they think about your "theories". Many of your truther questions can be answered by just a few simple phone calls.

Oh....I just asked another explosives expert (there are many where I am) what he thought about the truther theories...

I told him about explosives in the towers or possibly thermite/nano thermite.

He told me what he thought and we both had a good laugh.....more entertainment brought to us by the truthers.
 
I was saying that on the day the article was posted at JREF.

I was expecting some proper analysis using XRD (x-ray diffraction) because this would then definitely give the compounds present and their amounts and prove once and for all what the chips are actually made of. They keep using EDS and whilst the graphs look pretty and fool those who don't have any experience they simply cannot be used for a quantitative analysis so their claims are pretty poor.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=4583993&postcount=56
 
Hold on isnt the problem that thermite needs to be able to cut
horizontally not vertically through a steel column?
 
Hold on isnt the problem that thermite needs to be able to cut
horizontally not vertically through a steel column?

You make it sound like there's only one problem. Off the top of my head, I can immediately think of about half a dozen, and that's without trying. Let's see:

Horizontal cutting with thermite is undemonstrated.
The chips yield too much energy.
No XRD to determine the crystal structure of the chips.
Thickness present will raise the steel temperature by only about 4ºC.
No attempt to determine the chemical bonding within the chips.
Most CD theories posit timing on the scale of a few milliseconds, which is impossible with a thermal mechanism.
DSC experiments done in air ambient, so no reason to suppose a thermite reaction took place.
Resemblance of the chips to known paint types.

That's eight serious-to-fatal problems, and I haven't even been paying much attention lately.

Dave
 
You make it sound like there's only one problem. Off the top of my head, I can immediately think of about half a dozen, and that's without trying. Let's see:

Horizontal cutting with thermite is undemonstrated.
The chips yield too much energy.
No XRD to determine the crystal structure of the chips.
Thickness present will raise the steel temperature by only about 4ºC.
No attempt to determine the chemical bonding within the chips.
Most CD theories posit timing on the scale of a few milliseconds, which is impossible with a thermal mechanism.
DSC experiments done in air ambient, so no reason to suppose a thermite reaction took place.
Resemblance of the chips to known paint types.

That's eight serious-to-fatal problems, and I haven't even been paying much attention lately.

Dave

9. Photomicrography revealed the presence of structures who's morphology matches a known substance - kaonlinite - which also happens to match up with the list of elements determined to be present by X-EDS analysis.
ETA: Well, come to think of it, maybe that's what you meant with your last point. But I feel it deserves emphasis, particularly because Sunstealer demonstrated the flaws of Jones and Harrit's analysis using their own data. To me, that's particularly damning of their conclusions.
 
Last edited:
You make it sound like there's only one problem. Off the top of my head, I can immediately think of about half a dozen, and that's without trying. Let's see:

Horizontal cutting with thermite is undemonstrated.
The chips yield too much energy.
No XRD to determine the crystal structure of the chips.
Thickness present will raise the steel temperature by only about 4ºC.
No attempt to determine the chemical bonding within the chips.
Most CD theories posit timing on the scale of a few milliseconds, which is impossible with a thermal mechanism.
DSC experiments done in air ambient, so no reason to suppose a thermite reaction took place.
Resemblance of the chips to known paint types.

That's eight serious-to-fatal problems, and I haven't even been paying much attention lately.

Dave

"Painting" this supposedly thermite material would have required access to core columns and structures no one on Earth would have access to after construction of the towers was completed.

The material would have to be painted on top of an anti-corrosion coating applied to the steel during construction, and so it wouldn't be in direct contact with the steel.

The X-ray microanalysis done to prove the presence of "thermite" was incompetently performed.

Abundant evidence exists both within the paper and by comments made by the authors that significant contrary evidence was ignored.

And it's still early in the morning...
 

And "thank you" for that, SS.

Because it was comments like yours that gave me the right way to frame the question.

Given the background of Harrit & Ferrar (none of the others), and not reading comments like yours, I might have assumed that they had performed definitive tests.

I would have assumed wrong. [But having been down this path a few dozen times, I would have gotten around to asking. Eventually.]

IF the testing done by Harrit et al had also been definitive for thermite (like XRD), THEN we'd have TWO serious questions to answer.

1) What was thermite doing in the rubble?
2) Wow, some possibly competent researchers have uncovered something that needs to be explained. [The implication being that their background & expertise in THIS area could be trusted to lessen (not prevent) their making some significant error in all the myriad details that go unstated in any paper.]

But since the testing is not definitive, then BOTH questions evaporate.

Note that the whole issue of someone replicating their results evaporates as well. Why replicate incompetent tests?


tom
 
Last edited:
And "thank you" for that, SS.

Because it was comments like yours that gave me the right way to frame the question.

Given the background of Harrit & Ferrar (none of the others), and not reading comments like yours, I might have assumed that they had performed definitive tests.

I would have assumed wrong. [But having been down this path a few dozen times, I would have gotten around to asking. Eventually.]

IF the testing done by Harrit et al had also been definitive for thermite (like XRD), THEN we'd have TWO serious questions to answer.

1) What was thermite doing in the rubble?
2) Wow, some possibly competent researchers have uncovered something that needs to be explained. [The implication being that their background & expertise in THIS area could be trusted to lessen (not prevent) their making some significant error in all the myriad details that go unstated in any paper.]

But since the testing is not definitive, then BOTH questions evaporate.

Note that the whole issue of someone replicating their results evaporates as well. Why replicate incompetent tests?


tom

You can't test what you don't have and as far as i can see Jones isn't about to give anyone else any of it. Whatever it is.
 
Is there a point somewhere in that diatribe?

I missed the part of your argument where you explain how the research of these scientists has been proven faulty?

MM

Maybe you missed the part where you say no one can comment because Harrit and Jones are super experts (though of course they arent).

But hey lets take your logic and then destroy you with it, why do you think any of you truthers are qualified to critique Dr Bazants work?

Oh wait, NOW its different right? :rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom