You can choose to accept the legitimacy of my typo on silicon or not Tom. It is the truth and that is all that is important.
I do accept it. My follow up comment was a result of another poster - someone who gives you a bad time - writing me a PM and suggesting that I was being too harsh with my previous comment.
I agreed that perhaps I was, and wrote what I did to you. "I don't care about the typo. We all make them."
I also appended that I believe it to be very unlikely that anyone with a chemistry background would make that glaring mistake. So, please enlighten me. What is the extent of your chemistry background.
Mine is 2 required semesters in college, when I was getting my mechanical engineering degree. Doesn't make me any kind of expert.
But I do know the difference between Silicon Valley (Cupertino to Redwood City) & Silicone Valley (Hollywood).
Now about your "very simple argument";
I would say it is, if anything, not an argument, but a too simple question.
Rather than shake your fist over their supposedly not doing what you think they should have done, you should be pointing out how their findings are flawed?
I pointed out EXACTLY how they are flawed. They are inconclusive.
If no conclusive tests existed, or if conclusive tests were so onerous or expensive that one couldn't practically do them, then inventing your own tests, with merely "suggestive" results might be necessary.
If a simple, inexpensive and CONCLUSIVE test is readily available, then inventing your own inconclusive one is incompetent.
What part of this is too hard to understand?
I do not care if they creatively used a different approach to the problem, as long as it was scientifically legitimate.
It was not scientifically legitimate. Several people have pointed out numerous flaws with the study.
My objection overwhelm the trivia within their report. They should never have done that testing in the first place. They should have researched the field, found out the conclusive tests, and done THOSE tests instead.
They were incompetent. (Even tho you don't want to say so.)
Are you interested in the truth Tom or not?
Yup. Are you?
That's why I wouldn't accept inconclusive testing out of anyone. Whether it be NIST, FEMA or Jones, et al.
If you are interested in the truth, why do you accept inconclusive testing, instead of demanding conclusive testing?
Why does Jones?
Why does Farrer?
Why does Harrit?
Why does Basile?
Why do you accept incompetence out of "truther scientists"?
tk
Last edited: