Chemical Engineer Mark Basile confirms Harrit nano-thermite results

Miragememories said:
"Yes I did miss that part. Please point out where I say no one can comment?

I believe that making the asinine statement "...experts like Dr Bazant have more experience and expertise than all truthers put together..." reveals an even greater lack of credibility on your own part."
Edx said:
"When you said...
What qualifies you to claim the findings of {bunch of truthers}Niels H. Harrit,, Jeffrey Farrer, Steven E. Jones, Kevin R. Ryan, Frank M. Legge, Daniel Farnsworth, Gregg Roberts, James R. Gourley and Bradley R. Larsen are illegitimate?- MM

In other words, unless you are more qualified than X your comments are not valid.

Therefore I can make the same argument as you: What qualifies you to claim the findings of Dr Bazant are illegitimate? But oh, now you'll claim its unfair right?

As was my point initially, you argue from authority purely when it suits you and switch back just as easily."

I corrected your intentional misquote from my original post.

In other words?

No, the words I used do not require special interpretation. Everyone is entitled to comment, but the weight of validity assigned to comments has to be based on some kind of criteria.

It was you, in your original statement, that made the asinine claim "...experts like Dr Bazant have more experience and expertise than all truthers put together..."

On what basis do you justify your conclusion that Dr. Bazant's work far outweighs that of the list of scientists referred to above?

Miragememories said:
"I believe that making the asinine statement "...experts like Dr Bazant have more experience and expertise than all truthers put together..." reveals an even greater lack of credibility on your own part."
Edx said:
"Well feel free to share a truther or even a group of truthers that have more experience, qualifications, accolades and publications than Dr Bazant. Please, please do."

Dr. Jones alone has over 50 peer-reviewed papers in his career. But we both know you are just blowing smoke (and good smoke based on how foggy your statements are), and can in no way place Dr. Bazant on such a God worthy pedestal.

MM
 
It was you, in your original statement, that made the asinine claim "...experts like Dr Bazant have more experience and expertise than all truthers put together..."

On what basis do you justify your conclusion that Dr. Bazant's work far outweighs that of the list of scientists referred to above?
For starters, Bažant has published more papers than all of those scientists put together.

Dr. Jones alone has over 50 peer-reviewed papers in his career. But we both know you are just blowing smoke (and good smoke based on how foggy your statements are), and can in no way place Dr. Bazant on such a God worthy pedestal.
50 papers is pretty good. If Dr Jones continues to publish papers at that rate, and Dr Bažant never publishes another paper, then Dr Jones will catch up to Dr Bažant in another 250 years or so.
 
... On what basis do you justify your conclusion that Dr. Bazant's work far outweighs that of the list of scientists referred to above?



Dr. Jones alone has over 50 peer-reviewed papers in his career. But we both know you are just blowing smoke (and good smoke based on how foggy your statements are), and can in no way place Dr. Bazant on such a God worthy pedestal.

MM
Good for Jones, he also thinks the earthquake in Haiti was caused by the United States. He is nuts, you have a nut making up themite which was not found on the steel at the WTC. You have delusions. Bazant is qualified, your clowns are nut case paranoid conspiracy theorists who can't figure out 911 given the answers and 9 years. Like you, your experts have delusions of CD due ignorance on daylight fires, and gravity.

What is the primary source of energy for CD? Gravity.

The results of Jones and Harrit nano-thermite paper are thermite did not do the WTC. Basile confirms that fact with ease. You are a follower who like to post lies about 911, relax, you are good at it.

If the thermite claims were true, it would have been discovered on September 12th, right after 911. But fires did it, that was discovered on September 11th when the 19 terrorists you apologize for by making up false claims did it all by themselves.
 
Last edited:
I just caught up with the last couple days of this thread and tfk and Sunstealer have nailed the flaws in the truther "analysis", IMO, in addition to stating methods that would be definitive. It won't have any effect on truther die-hards, of course, but it points the way to understanding for others willing to read and learn.

I'd like to suggest an alternative analysis method that I think could also be definitive and that is to prepare microtome sections of the chips and then do micro-Raman and micro-infrared spectroscopy on the different layers seen in the sections. Raman should identify the inorganics and IR the organics. These methods are used for forensic analysis of paint chips, for example paint from vehicles. Raman has been used successfully to identify inorganic pigments in forensic cases such as art history disputes. Using the spectral results, as well as color and thickness of the layers as measured with optical microscopy, the samples would be very well characterized and could be compared with what's known about the paints and finishes used in the towers. And who knows? Even though Jones', etal results seem to indicate the materials are not thermitic (contrary DSC results), analyzing the layers with proper methods might confirm their claims.

But as has been stated, there's not a snowball's chance that Jones will let his samples come anywhere near a lab with the right people and instruments to decide the question once and for all.

ferd

Source of your claim that "there's not a snowball's chance that Jones will let his samples come anywhere near a lab with the right people and instruments to decide the question once and for all".

Put up or shut up.

MM

Amazing, MM.

ferd makes several very substantial points.

1. Jones et al use of non-definitive tests.
2. suggestion to use micro-Raman testing for inorganics.
3. suggestion to use IR spectroscopy for organics.
4. incorporating those results with optical microscopy results.

And yet you manage to ignore all that & latch onto a throw-away comment at the end. And demand that he provide a source for his opinion.

That's, uh, enlightening as to the seriousness with which you address these issues.

By the way, you continue to evade my question to you buried in Point 1 above. What does it say about any scientist that they ignore definitive tests, and make up their own non-definitive ones?

Your continuing evasion is also enlightening as to the seriousness with which you address these issues.

By the way, Jones has had his samples for about 3 years now. To which laboratory that has been certified to test for thermite has he delivered samples?

Excuse me. What did you say? "None"…??

In three years?

On an issue this critical?

Hmmmmm, what do you think it will take for him to see the enormous advantage to his case to have an independent, qualified lab perform standard, accepted that reveal - without question - the presence of thermite?

Your acceptance of Jones et al's continuing delinquency in taking this crucial step that would solidify the Truth Movement's untenable defense of thermite is, uh, enlightening as well.

As is your defense of Jones et al. Who is leaving you & your movement to twist in the wind, like a bunch of fools. While he … ignores you all.

Best to learn who your real friends are, MM.


tk
 
MM,


Dr. Jones alone has over 50 peer-reviewed papers in his career. But we both know you are just blowing smoke (and good smoke based on how foggy your statements are), and can in no way place Dr. Bazant on such a God worthy pedestal.

MM

It ain't the length of publications list.
It's the substance.

Let's compare:

Jones:

PEER-REVIEWED PUBLICATIONS

9/11 publications:

Niels H. Harrit, Jeffrey Farrer, Steven E. Jones, Kevin R. Ryan, Frank M. Legge, Daniel Farnsworth, Gregg Roberts, James R. Gourley, Bradley R. Larsen, “Active Thermitic Material Discovered in Dust from the 9/11 World Trade Center Catastrophe,” The Open Chemical Physics Journal, April 2009.

K. Ryan, J. Gourley and S.E. Jones, "Environmental Anomalies at the World Trade Center: Evidence for Energetic Materials", Environmentalist, August 2008.

S.E. Jones, et al. "Fourteen Points of Agreement with Official Government Reports on the World Trade Center Destruction", Open Civil Engineering Journal, April 2008.

Steven E. Jones, “What accounts for the molten metal observed on 9/11/2001?”, Journal of the Utah Academy of Sciences, Arts and Letters, 83:252, 2006.
___

Pre-9/11 publications

S.E. Jones and J.E. Ellsworth, "Cold (metal-enhanced) fusion, geo-fusion, and cold nucleosynthesis", Condensed Matter Nuclear Science, 2005, London: World Scientific, p. 617.

Jenni Christensen Currit and Steven E. Jones, "Solar Cookers for Developing Countries," published in the Solar Cooking Archives 2004, available at: http://solarcooking.org/Solar-Ovens-for-Developing-Countries.htm

Jenni Christensen Currit and Steven E. Jones, "Introduction to Solar Cooking (CARES Program)," published in the Solar Cooking Archives 2004, available at: http://solarcooking.org/Introduction-to-Solar-Cooking.ppt.

S.E. Jones, et al, Charged-particle Emissions from Metal Deuterides, International Conference on Cold Fusion-10, Cambridge, MA, August 2003. Published at http://lenr-canr.org/acrobat/JonesSEchargedpar.pdf

S. E. Jones, et al, Neutron Emissions from Metal Deuterides, International Conf on Cold Fusion-10, Cambridge, MA, August 2003. Published at http://lenr-canr.org/acrobat/JonesSEneutronemi.pdf

Steven E. Jones, The Project Gutenberg EBook of The BYU Solar Cooker/Cooler, 2002, www.gutenberg.net/etext04/cookr11.txt.

C. McMillan and S.E. Jones, “Tests of the Solar Funnel and Bowl Cookers in 2001,” published in the Solar Cooking Archive as a reviewed web article at solarcooking.org/funneltests01.htm

S. E. Jones, “Chasing Anomalous Signals: The Cold Fusion Question,” Accountability in Research, Vol. 8, pp. 55-58, Fall 2000.

S.E. Jones, et al, “The Solar Funnel Cooker. How to Make and Use the BYU Solar Cooker/Cooler,” published in the Solar Cooking Archive as a reviewed web article at solarcooking.org/funnel.htm, in Spanish at /funnel-span.htm.

Steven E. Jones, Samuel T. Jones, and David E. Jones, “Archaeometry Applied to Olmec Iron-ore Beads,” BYU Studies 37, no. 4 (Oct. 1998), 128-142.

Steven E. Jones, et al, Discussion of reply to “Examination of claims of Miles et al. in Pons-Fleischmann-type cold fusion experiments,” Journal of Physical Chemistry, 102 (April 30, 1998), p. 3642-8.

Lee D. Hansen, Steven E. Jones et al, “A response to hydrogen + oxygen recombination and related heat generation in undivided electrolysis cells,” J. Electroanalytical Chemistry, 447 (1998) 223-226.

D.S. Shelton, S.E. Jones, et al “An assessment of claims of ‘excess heat’ in ‘cold fusion’ calorimetry,” Thermochimica Acta 297 (1997) 7-15.

Steven E. Jones, et al, "Raman Spectrographic System for Quantitative Analysis of Isotopic Hydrogen Mixtures for Muon Catalysis Experiments," Hyperfine Interactions 101/102 (1996) 695- 698.

S.E. Jones, L.B. Rees, and W.E. Dibble, "Post-Use Review. Physics for Scientists and Engineers," American Journal of Physics, 63(2), 188-189, Feb. 1995.

Steven E. Jones and Lee D. Hansen, “Examination of claims of Miles et al. in Pons-Fleischmann-type cold fusion experiments,” Journal of Physical Chemistry, 99 (1995) 6973-6979.

J. E. Jones, L. D. Hansen, S. E. Jones, D.S. Shelton, and J. M. Thorne, “Faradaic efficiencies less than 100% during electrolysis of water can account for reports of excess heat in ‘cold fusion ‘ cells”, Journal of Physical Chemistry, 99 (1995) 6966-6972..

S. Taylor, S. Jones, et al "Search for neutrons from deuterided palladium subjected to high electrical currents," Transactions of Fusion Technology, Vol. 26, 180-185, Dec. 1994.

S.E. Jones, S.F. Taylor, and A.N. Anderson, "Evaluation of muon-alpha sticking from liquid, non-equilibrated d-t targets with high tritium fractions," Hyperfine Int. 82 (1993) 303-311.

S.E. Jones, "Cold Fusion," Forum for Applied Research and Public Policy, Winter 1992, 94-97.

S.E. Jones, "Current issues in cold fusion research: Heat, helium, tritium, and energetic particles," Surface and Coat. Tech. 51 (1992) 283-289

S.E. Jones, et al, eds., "Anomalous Nuclear Effects in Deuterium/Solid Systems," Brigham Young University, October 1990, American Institute of Physics: Conference Proceedings 228, NY (1991).

S.E. Jones, et al., "Anomalous Nuclear Reactions in Condensed Matter: Recent Results and Open Questions," J. Fusion Energy 9:199-2091, (November 1990).

H.O. Menlove, S.E. Jones, et al, "Measurement of Neutron Emission from Ti and Pd in Pressurized D2 and D2O Electrolysis Cells," J. Fusion Energy 9, 1990 (November 1990).

A. Bertin, S.E. Jones, et al, "First Experimental Results at the Gran Sasso Laboratory on Cold Nuclear Fusion in Titanium Electrodes," J. Fusion Energy, 9, 1990. (November 1990)

J.D. Davies, S.E. Jones, et al, "A Direct Measurement of the Alpha-Muon Sticking Coefficient in Muon-Catalysed d-t Fusion," J. Phys. G: Nucl. Part. Phys. 16, 1529-1537, (1990).

S.E. Jones, et al, "Response to ‘Biases in Cold Fusion Data’," Nature 343: 704 (1990)

J.D. Davies, S.E. Jones, et al, "Search for 2.5 MeV Neutrons from D2O Electrolytic Cells Stimulated by High-Intensity Muons and Pions," Il Nuovo Cimento 103A (1), 155-161 (1990).

A. Bertin, S.E. Jones, et al, "Experimental evidence of cold nuclear fusion in a measurement under the Gran Sasso Massif," Il Nuovo Cimento 101: 997-1006 (1989).

S.E. Jones, E.P. Palmer, J.B. Czirr, D.L. Decker, G.L. Jensen, J.M. Thorne, and S.F. Taylor & J. Rafelski, "Observation of Cold Nuclear Fusion in Condensed Matter," Nature 338: 737-740 (April 1989).

S.E. Jones, et al (editors), Muon-Catalyzed Fusion 1988, Proceedings of the Muon-Catalyzed Fusion Workshop, May 1-6, 1988, Sanibel Island (co-sponsored by Brigham Young University and University of Florida at Gainesville), AIP Conf. Proc. 181, New York, 1989.

S.E. Jones, "Survey of Experimental Results in Muon-Catalyzed Fusion," Muon-Catalyzed Fusion 1988 (S.E. Jones, J.Rafelski, H.J. Monkhorst editors), AIP #181 (1989).

M.A. Paciotti, S.E. Jones et al., "First Direct Measurement of alpha-He Sticking in dt-muon-cf," Muon-Catalyzed Fusion 1988 (S.E. Jones, J. Rafelski, H.J. Monkhorst editors), AIP #181 (1989).

K.A. Aniol, A.J. Noble, S. Stanislaus, C.J. Virtue, D.F. Measday, D. Horvath, S.E. Jones, B.C. Robertson and M. Salomon, "Muon Catalyzed Fusion in HD and H2 + D2 Gaseous Mixtures." Muon-Catalyzed Fusion, 2: 63-72 (1988).

R. Gajewski, and S.E. Jones, "A Look at Muon-Catalyzed Fusion Research in the United States," Muon-Catalyzed Fusion, 2: 93-102 (1988).

A.J. Caffrey, S.E. Jones, et al., "Muon-Catalyzed Fusion Experiments at LAMPF," Muon Catalyzed Fusion 1: 52-66 (1987).

M. Leon, S.E. Jones, et al, "3He scavenging as a Source of Information in Muon-Catalyzed d-t Fusion," Muon-Catalyzed Fusion, 2: 231-237 (1988).

J. Rafelski and S.E. Jones, "Cold Nuclear Fusion," Scientific American, 257: 84-89 (July 1987).

S.E. Jones, "Update on muon-catalyzed fusion research at LAMPF," Invited talk at the Symposium on Muon-Catalyzed Fusion, 1-3 September 1986, Tokyo, Japan; Muon-Catalyzed Fusion 1: 21-28 (1987).

K. Nagamine, S.E. Jones et al, "Muonic X-ray Measurement on the Alpha-sticking Probability for Muon Catalyzed Fusion in Liquid d-t Mixtures," Invited to talk at the Symposium on Muon-Catalyzed Fusion, 1-3 September 1986, Tokyo, Japan; Muon-Catalyzed Fusion 1: 137-159 (1987).

S.E. Jones, "Can 250+ fusions per muon be achieved?," Invited talk for Erice School-Workshop, Erice, April 3-9, 1987, New York: Plenum Press, 1987, pgs. 73-88.

S.E. Jones, "Muon-Catalyzed Fusion Present and Future,"Scientific Papers of the Institute of Physical and Chemical Research, Tokyo, Japan 80: 17-29 (1986).

S.E. Jones, "Muon-Catalysed Fusion Revisited," (Invited article) Nature 321: 127-133 (1986).

S.E. Jones, "Summary of the Mini-workshop on Muon-Catalyzed Fusion," (S.E. Jones, Chairman) Fusion Technology 10: 157 (1986)

S.E. Jones, et al, "Observation of Unexpected Density Effects in Muon-Catalyzed d-t Fusion," Physical Review Letters 56: 588-591 (1986).

C.D. Van Siclen and S.E. Jones, "Piezonuclear Fusion in Isotopic Hydrogen Molecules," Journal of Physics G. Nucl. Phys. 12: 213-221 (1986).

S.E. Jones, "Engineering Issues in Muon-Catalyzed Fusion," Fusion Technology, 8: 1511-1521 (1985).

S.E. Jones, "Some Surprises in Muon-Catalyzed Fusion," Invited talk at the Ninth International Conference on Atomic Physics, Seattle, Washington, U.S.A., 23-27 July 1984 in Atomic Physics 9, R.S. Van Dyck, Jr. and E.N. Fortson eds., Singapore: World Scientific, 1984, pgs. 99-115.

S.E. Jones, "Muon-Catalyzed Fusion," Physics Today, S-44, (January 1984). (Reprinted from Physics News in 1983, Phillip F. Schewe, editor.)

S.E. Jones, et al, "Experimental investigation of Muon-Catalyzed d-t Fusion," Physical Review Letters 51: 1757-1760 (1983).

S.E. Jones, et al "Experimental Investigation of Muon-Catalyzed d-t Fusion," Third International Conference on emerging Nuclear Energy Systems, Helsinki, Finland, June 1983, Atomkernenergie/Kerntechnik 43: 179-183 (1983).

A.E. Kreymer, S.E. Jones, et al, "Forward Low-mass Enhancement in p-anti-p Seen in Reactions in - d (ns) p anti-p-n and -d (ps) p anti-p--, Physical Review D 22: 36-41 (1980).

C.W. Bjork, S.E. Jones, et al "Measurement of - p - + n near Threshold and Chiral-symmetry Breaking," Physical Review Letters 44: 62-65 (1980).

M.S. Alam, S.E. Jones, et al, "Search for Charge -2 Mesons in the Reaction -d (ps) X- -pforward at 13.2 GeV/C," Physical Review Letters 40: 1685-1688 (1978).


Gee, it looks like, if you wanted to know about muon catalyzed cold fusion or solar ovens, Steve is your boy.

Absolutely zero experience in structural engineering, forensic examination of building debris, chemical searching for thermite, etc. etc. etc.

Or ANY discipline related to ANY aspect of 9/11 "questions".

___
___

Now let's look at Bazant's list.

Well, it's just too damn long. Here's a link.

It's 31 pages long.

But a few highlights …

Education
C.E., Czech Technical University, Prague, Civil Engineering (Structural Engineering) 1960
Ph.D. (in mechanics)., Czechoslovak Academy of Sciences, Prague 1963
Postgraduate diploma in Physics, Charles University, Prague 1966
Docent habil., Czech Technical University, Prague 1967
S.E. 1970, Illinois Registered Structural Engineer


Research
Prof. Bazant's interest spans mechanics of materials and structures, structural safety, response uncertainty, and engineering applications. The current investigations include some fundamental problems in the field of quasibrittle fracture and damage mechanics, fracture scaling and its asymptotics, size effects, probabilistic mechanics and extreme value statistics, ... constitutive models, progressive collapse of buildings, missile impact, seismic response, ... chemical reaction kinetics, ... , thermodynamics, poromechanics, ... His research team has been developing material models for fiber composites, concrete, rocks and soils, sea ice, snow, tough ceramics, sandwich shells, rigid foams, cellular materials, bone, and shape memory alloys. Applications have covered structural and aero-space engineering, building codes, ship design, automotive crashworthiness, arctic engineering, earthquake engineering and nuclear safety. Although the emphasis is theoretical, his team also conducts specialized fracture testing of composites, concretes and rocks. Computational modeling is a heavy component in each problem, but Bazant's attitude is to seek first analytical solutions and asymptotics-based approximations. The current and recent research sponsors include NSF, ONR, DoT, WES, ARO, DoE, AFOSR, Sandia N.L., Chrysler, Boeing, Cirrus Aircraft, and Argonne N.L.

Teaching Activities
Inelastic Analysis of Structures
Stability of Structures
Cohesive Fracture and Scaling


Honors and Awards
Elected to:
National Academy of Sciences;
National Academy of Engineering;
American Academy of Arts and Sciences;
Austrian Academy of Sciences;
Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei (Rome);
Spanish Royal Academy of Engrg.;
Engrg. Academy of Czech Rep.;
Academia di Scienze e Lettere (Milan);
European Academy of Sciences and Arts.

Six Honary Doctorates (Boulder, Prague, Karlsruhe, Milan, Lyon, Vienna).

Awards & Prizes
Prager Medal from Society of Engineering Sciences;
von Karman Medal;
Newmark Medal;
Lifetime Achievement Award;
Croes Medal;
Huber Prize and TY Lin Award from ASCE;
Honarary Member ASCE;
Nadai Medal and Warner Medal from ASME;
L'Hermite Medal from RILEM;
Exner Medal, Austria;
Humboldt Prize, Germany;
Torroja Medal, Spain;
Solin Medal, Prague;
Z. Bazant (Sr.) Medal, Prague;
Stodola Medal, Slovakia;
Roy Award, Am.Ceramic Soc.;
ICOSSAR Award;
Czech Soc. for Mech. Medal;
Outstanding Contribution Award, IACMAS;
Guggenheim, NATO, JSPS, Humboldt, Ford and Kajima Fellowships;
National Winner, 1958 Math.Olympics, Czechoslovakia;

Among top 100 Highly Cited Scientist in Engineering ( >9300 citations )

Former President of SES, IA-FRAMCOS (founder) and IA-CONCREEP (founder);
Former Editor, Journal of Engineering Mechanics, ASCE.


Selected Publications

Textbooks (Number: 6) including:
Bazant, Z.P., and Cedolin, L. (1991). Stability of Structures: Elastic, Inelastic, Fracture and Damage Theories, Oxford University Press, New York (textbook and reference volume); republished (with updates) by Dover Publications (No. 42568-1), New York 2003 (1011 pp. + xxiv pp.).

Jirasek, M., and Bazant, Z.P. (2002). Inelastic Analysis of Structures. J. Wiley & Sons, London and New York (textbook and reference volume, 735 + xviii pp.).

Bazant, Z.P. (2002). Scaling of Structural Strength. Hermes Penton Science (Kogan Page Science), London; 2nd updated ed., Elsevier, London 2005


Books Edited with Chapter Contributions (Number: 20) including:
Bazant, Z.P., Bittnar, Z., Jirasek, M., and Mazars, J., Editors (1994). Fracture and Damage in Quasibrittle Structures: Experiment, Theory and Computer Modeling

Bazant, Z.P., and Ra japakse, Y.D.S., Editors (1999). Fracture Scaling (Proc., ONR Workshop on Fracture Scaling, University of Maryland, College Park, June 10–12, 1999

Xi, Y., Bazant, Z.P., Pijaudier-Cabot, G., and Bittnar, Z., Guest Editors (2005). Model-Based Simulation of Durability of Materials and Structures, special issue of J. of Materials Engineering ASCE 17 (3), 239– 369 (with Editorial, pp. 239–240).

Bazant, Z.P., and Cedolin, L. (1991). "Stability of Structures: Elastic, Inelastic, Fracture and Damage Theories", Oxford University Press, New York (textbook and reference volume, 984 + xxiv pp.).

Bazant, Z.P. (2002). "Scaling of Structural Strength." Hermes Penton Science, London (French transl. with updates, Hermes, Paris, 2004).

Bazant, Z.P. (2004). "Scaling theory for quasibrittle structural failure." Proc., National Academy of Sciences 101 (37), 13397-13399 (inaugural article).

State-of-Art Articles and Research Review Articles (Number: 51)

Published Biographies and Volumes Dedicated to Bazant (Number: 12)

Research Articles in Conference Proceedings (Number: 208)

Public Policy Contributions (Number: 5)

Research Articles in Refereed Journals and Book Chapters (Number: 484), including:

Bazant, Z.P. (2001). “Why did the World Trade Center collapse?” SIAM News (Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics) Vol. 34, No. 8

Bazant, Z.P., and Zhou, Y. (2001). “Why did the World Trade Center collapse?—Simple analysis.” Building Research Journal 49 (3), 135–146


Bazant, Z.P., and Zhou, Y. (2002). “Why did the World Trade Center collapse?—Simple analysis.” J. of Engrg. Mechanics ASCE 128 (No. 1), 2–6;

Bazant, Z.P., and Verdure, M. (2007). “Mechanics of progressive collapse: Learning from World Trade Center and building demolitions.” J. of Engrg. Mechanics ASCE 133 (3), 308–319.

Guo, Z., and Bazant, Z.P. (2006). “Size effect on buckling strength of eccentrically compressed column with fixed or propagating transverse crack.” Int. J. of Fracture 142, 151–162.

Bazant, Z.P., Le, J.-L., Greening, F.R., and Benson, D.B. (2008). “What did and did not cause collapse of World Trade Center twin towers in New York?”. J. of Engrg. Mechanics ASCE 134 (10) 892–906. (5), p. 54.
___


Gee, look at all that stuff related to "structural engineering", "structural strength", "stability of structures", "structural failure", etc.

Nothing about "muon catalyzed fusion", tho…

___

So, it appears that, when it comes to cold fusion, Bazant can't hold a candle to Jones' background. Please remind me. How much of the 9/11 question are related to cold fusion??

I'll let you finish the next part of the conclusion.


tom
 
Miragememories said:
"Source of your claim that "there's not a snowball's chance that Jones will let his samples come anywhere near a lab with the right people and instruments to decide the question once and for all".

Put up or shut up."
tfk said:
"Amazing, MM.

ferd makes several very substantial points.

1. Jones et al use of non-definitive tests.
2. suggestion to use micro-Raman testing for inorganics.
3. suggestion to use IR spectroscopy for organics.
4. incorporating those results with optical microscopy results.

And yet you manage to ignore all that & latch onto a throw-away comment at the end. And demand that he provide a source for his opinion."

I thought sample availability was the relevant point. Big fracking deal if ferd knows a lot about paint analysis.

To me that is all a big dodge from the real question of why thermitic activity is occurring in the red/gray chips?

Now if ferd had said that thermitic activity is not an unusual occurrence in some paints, then I would have shown more interest. But for your red herrings, I have zero interest.

tfk said:
"That's, uh, enlightening as to the seriousness with which you address these issues.

By the way, you continue to evade my question to you buried in Point 1 above. What does it say about any scientist that they ignore definitive tests, and make up their own non-definitive ones?"

I'm not evading anything. It is you who is trying to steer away from what is important. Until you can prove that their tests showing dramatic thermitic activity in the red layer of the red/gray chips are bogus, I see no value in pursuing your side show.

tfk said:
"Your continuing evasion is also enlightening as to the seriousness with which you address these issues.

By the way, Jones has had his samples for about 3 years now. To which laboratory that has been certified to test for thermite has he delivered samples?

Excuse me. What did you say? "None"…??

In three years?

On an issue this critical?

Hmmmmm, what do you think it will take for him to see the enormous advantage to his case to have an independent, qualified lab perform standard, accepted that reveal - without question - the presence of thermite?

Your acceptance of Jones et al's continuing delinquency in taking this crucial step that would solidify the Truth Movement's untenable defense of thermite is, uh, enlightening as well.

As is your defense of Jones et al. Who is leaving you & your movement to twist in the wind, like a bunch of fools. While he … ignores you all.

Best to learn who your real friends are, MM.
"
Well I certainly know who they aren't.

Did you not read this post?;
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=6550176&postcount=360

You can take a horse to water but you can't make it drink.

Dr. Jones and his associates produced a legitimate peer-reviewed paper based on
their findings.

No where have I seen evidence of obstruction to independent investigation into the WTC dust.

Chemical Engineer said:
"I have called for an investigation. I've stood in front of my town, at a town meeting and told them about the work that I've done and said that we need a new investigation. To anyone that was at the town meeting.

My work with this has brought me to feel that this material is just too big of an unanswered question and it really brings us to demand a new investigation. Something that is impartial. That is based in science. Not avoiding looking at the truth or at anything that an investigation would bring us to. This really demands a new investigation. This is hard evidence that can't be refuted by anybody that goes out and gets them self a sample of dust and looks for this material. It is very very simple. You just need to follow the cookbook recipe that has been put together by others at this point and anyone can replicate the work that has been done and confirm this material is there."
Dr. Jeff Farrer said:
"But, those conclusions we made in the paper are very strong given the data. If there is another possibility, that is something someone can come forward with using the same very stringent scientific method that we used in this paper, and publish that, and I can guarantee they will find that our work is completely reproducible. If you find other red/gray chips, they will look and have the same composition and the same behavior in the calorimeter as the red/gray chips that we found. Now if they come up with different conclusions than we do, that is their prerogative of course, and I would like to see that. I like to see other people looking at these things because that reproduces our results and it also brings us to a discussion which needs to happen. We need to be talking about this."

MM
 
Steven E. Jones, “What accounts for the molten metal observed on 9/11/2001?”, Journal of the Utah Academy of Sciences, Arts and Letters, 83:252, 2006.

Never heard of this "publication" before. The other three, however, I have personally verified were not properly reviewed.

Not that it matters, since those three disagree with each other, and the data presented conflict with the conclusions (in the two that actually contain data).

Dead horse, you are beating it.

ETA: Upon review, it appears there never was such a publication, only a one-page abstract for a talk, found here. If someone knows otherwise, please let me know, as I cannot find any full paper at all -- and without such, surely it wasn't reviewed, yet he is claiming it was..? :mad:
 
Last edited:
<snipped for brevity>So, it appears that, when it comes to cold fusion, Bazant can't hold a candle to Jones' background. Please remind me. How much of the 9/11 question are related to cold fusion??

I'll let you finish the next part of the conclusion.

tom
If you wish to see one man as a God, that is your prerogative I guess.

I wasn't aware that word count was so important to you.

But then this is a forum where post count seems to count for more than post quality.

MM
 
Dr. Jones and his associates produced a legitimate peer-reviewed paper based on
their findings.


MM

Is this like your BS about the footprint of a building? Or the symmetrical collapse of the building MM? Hmmm?

You might just want to look up that word salad above and try again.
A "journal" in which the head editor quits in disgust because the "journal" published a "paper" that was outside the scope of the "journal," because the head editor had NO KNOWLEDGE OF THE "PAPER" is NOT a legitimate "peer reviewed paper."

A "paper" in which the authors KNOW the "peer reviewers" is NOT a "legitimate peer reviewed" journal.

A "journal" in which they state to any people wishing to rebut the claims made that the rebuttal has to pay the $700 publishing fee to rebut the claim is not a "legitimate peer review"ed journal.

What part of that is soooo hard to understand? Is it like you making up terms and trying to make them fit? Really?
 
Yup. MM you win. Jones certainly can match tit for tat with Bazant paper-wize, huh? :boggled:
 
"who published more papers?"
is the equivalent of asking
"who has the longest penis?"
in my book

"who has the higher IQ?"
"who has a bigger ego?"
 
You'd get fed up quickly with academia then. Publishing is extraordinarily important.

yet the amount of papers is irrelevant to a paper's contents
unless it's a paper studying the amount of papers published :p
 
Last edited:
I think it's pretty clear that he was replying to Edx who started the pissing contest. See the top post on this page

Now now, this whole thing went exactly the way I knew and predicted it would go.

I pointed out that MM was arguing that unless one is more qualified than Jones/Harrit their comments aren't valid. I was saying that truthers like MM argue from authority when it suits them. That's why I then asked him what qualified any truthers to comment on Dr Bazants work considering he has more accolates, qualifications , experience and publications than all these truthers put together he would decide that I was being unfair and the question was, as you put it, a pissing contest. In other words it's fine for him to argue from authority but when one points out that truthers don't actually have any authority suddenly they will revert right back to arguing that complete opposite. Instead of admitting he was wrong originally to do this, he ignores his logical error.
 
Last edited:
Hmmmm,

Who was it, again, who brought up the number of publications when comparing Jones' credentials to Bazant's…?

Oh yeah. I remember now...

Dr. Jones alone has over 50 peer-reviewed papers in his career. But we both know you are just blowing smoke (and good smoke based on how foggy your statements are), and can in no way place Dr. Bazant on such a God worthy pedestal.

MM

But, now that Jones' (prior to 9/11) "50 peer-reviewed papers" have been shown to be utterly irrelevant to anything related to 9/11, suddenly publication-dangling is gauche??

How do those sour-grapes taste?
____

You seemed to have missed, overlooked, avoided, evaded my point.

The number is indicative. The subject is absolutely crucial.

Not only does Bazant have far, far more publications, Bazant's happen to be in the right topic: structural engineering.

In structural engineering, failure modes, large structures, stability, etc., Bazant is a world class expert & Jones is a neophyte.

I thought sample availability was the relevant point. Big fracking deal if ferd knows a lot about paint analysis.

Thinking that "your points are relevant" and that "everyone else's points are irrelevant" is kind of a pattern for you, ain't it?

Convenient.

Obvious.

Intellectually dishonest & cowardly.

To me that is all a big dodge from the real question of why thermitic activity is occurring in the red/gray chips?

"… thermitic activity …" Is that like, say, "burning"?

Interesting that Jones leaves all you folks twisting in the wind, instead of taking a tiny bit of his material and heating it in an anoxic atmosphere. And demonstrating the possibility that the reaction might really be "themitic", and then publishing the results.

Wow, that'd take him all of about $30 & 30 minutes.

Now if ferd had said that thermitic activity is not an unusual occurrence in some paints, then I would have shown more interest. But for your red herrings, I have zero interest.

If by "thermitic activity" you mean "burning", then yes. This is very common in paints.

I'm not evading anything. It is you who is trying to steer away from what is important.

Hmmmm, you don't believe that it is significant for a researcher to distinguish definitive tests from non-definitive ones. And to perform the definitive ones if possible?

Very interesting.

Shows that you'd be just as incompetent at establishing a test protocol as Jones, Harrit, Farrer, et al were.

Until you can prove that their tests showing dramatic thermitic activity in the red layer of the red/gray chips are bogus, I see no value in pursuing your side show.

You don't understand how this all works.

Farrer, Harrit, Jones et al produced a paper. It is THEIR job to cross all the Ts & dot all the Is. For honest researchers, who really do pursue the truth, whenever anyone brings up a serious, significant objection to their methods or results, they'll go back & honestly validate or invalidate their work based on the critique. And they'll publish their new data, even if it contradicts their first results.

That would be what HONEST researchers do, anyway...

Well I certainly know who they aren't.

Did you not read this post?;
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=6550176&postcount=360

So, you are justifying Jones et al leaving the entire truth movement to swing in the wind as a giant laughingstock to anyone with a knowledge of chemistry, because "other people have dust samples, too."

Wow. Where does one hire an apologist like you?

Dr. Jones and his associates produced a legitimate peer-reviewed paper based on
their findings.

:dl:

… incompetent tests …
… misinterpreted results …
… tests that directly contradict the papers conclusions …
… pay to publish …
… peer reviewed by ?? ...

Is this your spin on the adjective "legitimate"?


tk
 
Last edited:
"who published more papers?"
is the equivalent of asking
"who has the longest penis?"
in my book

"who has the higher IQ?"
"who has a bigger ego?"


In my book, "who has published respected, accepted, cited papers in the pertinent subject" is equivalent to "who has a penis & who is a eunuch?"


tk
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom