...
Now about your "very simple argument";
I would say it is, if anything, not an argument, but a too simple question.
Rather than shake your fist over their supposedly not doing what you think they should have done, you
should be pointing out how their findings are flawed?
I do not care if they creatively used a different approach to the problem, as long as it was scientifically
legitimate.
...
I think Tom argues their findings are flawed because their methods were incompetent - they did not follow any accepted protocol. Accepted and sure methods exist to identidy thermite, and they failed to use them. Their results are inconclusive, their conclusions massaged.
Let's rehash:
- They did not use any method at all that would establish the actual chemical compounds and their relative masses
- The DSC test resulted in energy releases that cannot possibly explained by the thermite reaction, but they failed, or didn't even try, to explain what caused the >3.9kJ/g results
- The SEM images show crystals. They noted their existence, but failed to identify them (as Kaolin, as it turns out)
- They tried to ruke out paint, but failed to identify the paint, failed to detail which tests they did on which paints, and what the test results were. They also failed to rule any other paints
- They claim that the test results of the chips indicates they are thermitic in nature, but failed to show any actual thermitic material that has the same properties (energy release, ingredients, peak power, ignition temperature), rendering their conclusion spurious.
- They know that ther is an energetic organic matrix present, but failed to quantify it.
- They claim that they separated Al from Si and O, but failed to show that, in the one sample they soaked in MEK, the Al had been in association with the Si and O to start with. If you show the "after", but not the "before", you can't validly claim that anything happened. The proof that elemental Al was present throughout is very weak at best.
- Their whole argument basically rests on the obeservation that Fe, Al and O are present in the material. That simply is not enough.