Chavez taking necessary steps to ensure equality and liberty

Just your opinion ( based on nothing )..

If people become fed up with the " loss of freedom ", they can not change him?

You have strange ideas about what people can do when a demagogue has taken over the power in the government and cracked down on people's freedoms.

Can they vote him out? Oh sure, but how likely are they to do so if the opposition has been crushed? What opposing points of view will they hear if media that's too critical of the demagogue is shut down? Chavez uses his talk of helping the poor to cover his power grabs and suppression of any who would oppose him. While his style is different, it reminds me in many ways of Vladimir Putin.

The Russian leader has used the government to crush the opposition and re-nationalized much of the media while at the same time maintaining high approval ratings among the people. Can they vote for someone not hand-picked by Putin in the next election? Theoretically, yes. In practice, opponents won't have a chance. The money and power of the government and the vast majority of the media, now under government control, will support Putin's candidate. Control of information is a huge deal and why the Chavez question is more complicated than "if the poor like him, who are we to say otherwise?"
 
Sadly, when a demogogue takes power,one of the first things is does is either abolish or rig elections so there is no way he can be removed from office.
Then the only way to get rid of him is wait for he total collapse or remove him from office via the firearm of your choice.
 
The Russian leader has used the government to crush the opposition and re-nationalized much of the media while at the same time maintaining high approval ratings among the people. Can they vote for someone not hand-picked by Putin in the next election? Theoretically, yes. In practice, opponents won't have a chance. The money and power of the government and the vast majority of the media, now under government control, will support Putin's candidate. Control of information is a huge deal and why the Chavez question is more complicated than "if the poor like him, who are we to say otherwise?"
Why does the name Peron leap to mind?

DR
 
Man, some people from Argentina would put you on a black list for the above comment...

You will always find people who will defend the demagogues, the dictators (or would-be dictators), be them from the left or from the right. Many even miss or look forward those times... For these people, life seems quite simpler under the umbrella of such leaders.
 
Man, some people from Argentina would put you on a black list for the above comment...

You will always find people who will defend the demagogues, the dictators (or would-be dictators), be them from the left or from the right. Many even miss or look forward those times... For these people, life seems quite simpler under the umbrella of such leaders.

Many peope in Italy think Mussolini was not that bad, people in Russia are nostalgic of the Communist dictatorship, and I bet there are quite some people in China that do not think that with democracy things may improve that much.

Basically, the equation dictatorship = bad, democracy = good is not always right, even if I agree and prefer to live in a democracy.
 
You have strange ideas about what people can do when a demagogue has taken over the power in the government and cracked down on people's freedoms.

Can they vote him out? Oh sure, but how likely are they to do so if the opposition has been crushed?

Mm..
Basically, writing the X, in the voting paper, in a box which is not the one of " Senhor Ugo Chavez "?

What opposing points of view will they hear if media that's too critical of the demagogue is shut down?

If people want to change, they will not care a heck about the media..
People are not that stupid

Chavez uses his talk of helping the poor to cover his power grabs and suppression of any who would oppose him. While his style is different, it reminds me in many ways of Vladimir Putin.

The Russian leader has used the government to crush the opposition and re-nationalized much of the media while at the same time maintaining high approval ratings among the people.

Maybe, there is a reason for that, you are not willing to see..

Can they vote for someone not hand-picked by Putin in the next election?

Yes, there are already two diffeerent, strong candidates for the next elections in Russia

Theoretically, yes. In practice, opponents won't have a chance. The money and power of the government and the vast majority of the media, now under government control, will support Putin's candidate.

And, people can kiss the media " bye bye ", and vote for who they prefer..
 
Well of course it's my opinion. But it's a lie on your part to say that that opinion was based upon nothing, when I've already told you some of the things it's based upon. I expected better of you, Matteo.

Dictators are people who take away free elections.
If there are elections, and presidents are elected by the voters, in a regular election, they are not, by definition, dictators.
Now, you can say that Chavez has fought against media of the other side, something that Berlusconi did, broadly, with many means, in Italy too, you can say that Chavez is a demagogue, but, until Chavez takes away free elections, he is not a dictator, not an aspiring dictator, etc.
 
This is a complete strawman. Zig has not stated this, nor is it reasonably dervied from what he has said, which appears to be along the lines of [paraphrase coming]:

OK..
OK..
I over-reacted.
I apologize ( to Ziggurat )

Elections are *necessary* for a free democracy, but are not *sufficient*, by themselves, to ensure it.

What is " sufficient ", then?
 
Dictators are people who take away free elections.

You could define a dictator that way, sure. But recall: I did not say Chavez was a dictator, I said he was an aspiring dictator. That means he wants to be one, not that he is one.

If there are elections, and presidents are elected by the voters, in a regular election, they are not, by definition, dictators.

For certain definitions of "regular", sure. But happening at regular time intervals isn't enough: they have to be free, fair, and open. I have concluded that Chavez intends to make sure that elections in Venezuela do not remain so. If I am correct, that makes him an aspiring dictator. If I am not correct, it is not my definitions of the terms I use but only my conclusions in regard to this particular case which would make him not an aspiring dictator.

Now, you can say that Chavez has fought against media of the other side, something that Berlusconi did, broadly, with many means, in Italy too, you can say that Chavez is a demagogue, but, until Chavez takes away free elections, he is not a dictator, not an aspiring dictator, etc.

That simply doesn't make sense. This paragraph essentially defines aspiring dictator as being the exact same thing as a full-fledged dictator. If Chavez intends to take away free elections but has not done so yet, that may disqualify him from being a dictator at present, but it most certainly does not disqualify him from being an aspiring dictator.
 
You could define a dictator that way, sure. But recall: I did not say Chavez was a dictator, I said he was an aspiring dictator. That means he wants to be one, not that he is one.

To define Chavez as " aspiring dictator ", you have to provide evidence that he is willing to shut down free elections in the future.
I have not seen such an evidence, so far.
Beware that I may be wrong.

For certain definitions of "regular", sure. But happening at regular time intervals isn't enough: they have to be free, fair, and open. I have concluded that Chavez intends to make sure that elections in Venezuela do not remain so. If I am correct, that makes him an aspiring dictator.

Really " free ", " fair " and " open " elections, are generic concepts, that you can rarely apply in full to any election, I fear.
Take for example what happened in Florida in 2000.
Was it 100% fair?
I do not know.
We have a big problem, in Italy, as political parties do not open their candidates` lists so that voters can vote for the candidate they want.
Does that make elections not " open "?
Maybe.
Beware, I do not say you are wrong, just that the concepts of free and fair are, maybe, not applied in full even in the West..
 
We will know sooner or later if he is going to become a dictator. Some smaller moves he may make in the near future will likely be abolishing independent review of elections, reporter assassinations like what's been happening in Russia recently, outlawing any civilian groups opposed to him, and a lot of smaller things that in and of themselves are bad but not necessarily dictator status.

I found a website recently that had this in one of the article tags "Although imperfect, no country anywhere is closer to a model democracy than Venezuela under President Hugo Rafael Chavez Frias. "

I browsed through and it seems everyone writing for it has their face firmly placed in between the lips Chavez doesn't kiss with. If this isn't old news and anyone is interested:

http://www.venezuelanalysis.com/
 
To define Chavez as " aspiring dictator ", you have to provide evidence that he is willing to shut down free elections in the future.
I have not seen such an evidence, so far.
Beware that I may be wrong.


Its weird, he basically had the assembly give him supreme power a while back. He has the power to shut down free elections now. He's been floating the idea of removing his own term limit as well.
 
Is it possible to elect a dictator? Of course. If a leader has absolute power other than his ability to halt elections then he is a dictator.

Chavez comes awfully damn close. When a leader can seize businesses and close key opposition channels then I think it is unreasonable to argue the person isn't in many ways a dictator. Hell, at least the guy is a dick.
 
We will know sooner or later if he is going to become a dictator. Some smaller moves he may make in the near future will likely be abolishing independent review of elections, reporter assassinations like what's been happening in Russia recently, outlawing any civilian groups opposed to him, and a lot of smaller things that in and of themselves are bad but not necessarily dictator status.

I found a website recently that had this in one of the article tags "Although imperfect, no country anywhere is closer to a model democracy than Venezuela under President Hugo Rafael Chavez Frias. "

I browsed through and it seems everyone writing for it has their face firmly placed in between the lips Chavez doesn't kiss with. If this isn't old news and anyone is interested:

http://www.venezuelanalysis.com/
What's rather ironic is the degree to which people defend Chavez while attacking Bush. Yet, can you imagine the outrage if Bush did what Chavez has done? Me too.
 
Many peope in Italy think Mussolini was not that bad, people in Russia are nostalgic of the Communist dictatorship, and I bet there are quite some people in China that do not think that with democracy things may improve that much.

Basically, the equation dictatorship = bad, democracy = good is not always right, even if I agree and prefer to live in a democracy.

Matteo, my point was that dictators and demagogues can either be left- or right-handed. There are numerous similarities in their actions, speeches and policies. Chavez is making moves that we, in Latin America, have seen before in right winded and left-winded governments. When it comes to the economy, they never worked in the long term, despite the fact that the crowds supported them, at least at the beggining. And when it comes to democracy and freedom, they were always a sign of worse things to come.

Let me remind you that dictatorships do have elections... We had elections in Brazil under the millitary and countries that are not exactly prime examples of democracy do have elections. The totalitarian governments just help you by previously deciding on who you can vote and eventually fixing some "distortions" or "problems" in vote numbers... Totalitarian governments do not need to ban elections, they just have to controll them. And they do so. And they quite often use them to legitimate themselves. "I was re-elected by the will of the people!"

ETA: Dang! RandFan was faster and better!
 
Last edited:
Basically, the equation dictatorship = bad, democracy = good is not always right, even if I agree and prefer to live in a democracy.
Of course dictatorships are considered good by a certain population of any group of people living under a dictatorship. I think that misses the point. One could make a similar argument that slavery = bad and freedom = good is not always right.

“I freed a thousand slaves I could have freed a thousand more if only they knew they were slaves.” -- Harriet Tubman

If it is possible to make the argument that freedom is preferable to slavery then it is possible to make the argument that democracy is preferable to dictatorship.
 
Matteo, my point was that dictators and demagogues can either be left- or right-handed. There are numerous similarities in their actions, speeches and policies. Chavez is making moves that we, in Latin America, have seen before in right winded and left-winded governments. When it comes to the economy, they never worked in the long term, despite the fact that the crowds supported them, at least at the beggining. And when it comes to democracy and freedom, they were always a sign of worse things to come.

Let me remind you that dictatorships do have elections... We had elections in Brazil under the millitary and countries that are not exactly prime examples of democracy do have elections. The totalitarian governments just help you by previously deciding on who you can vote and eventually fixing some "distortions" or "problems" in vote numbers... Totalitarian governments do not need to ban elections, they just have to controll them. And they do so. And they quite often use them to legitimate themselves. "I was re-elected by the will of the people!"

ETA: Dang! RandFan was faster and better!
I would have to disagree to the later. :) Good post.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom