Chavez taking necessary steps to ensure equality and liberty

Why do you assume that Chavez is an aspiring dictator?
Disclaimer
I may be wrong

I do not assume, I conclude. There is a difference. The first clue was that he has, from the beginning, expressed unfailing admiration for Castro. And his actions have been easy to predict using the assumption that he wants to be a dictator just like his hero. Term limits in the constitution he helped pass? It was easy to see they wouldn't remain for very long. Why did he put them in there to begin with, if he was only going to change them later? To keep up appearances while consolidating power, nothing more. Chavez never had any intention of stepping down. He's built up a cult of personality around himself for a reason: he wants to be president for life.

Oh, and let's not forget getting the legislature to grant him the ability to rule by decree. But maybe that disproves my position: maybe that demonstrates that he's no longer aspiring to dictatorship, but has already attained it.
 
When the poor feel they cannot survive without killing and eating the rich, the rich might as well pack their bags and run.

By giving the poor hope that they can turn their ecconomy around and re-distribute the nation's resources for the good of Venezuela, Chavez may actually be doing more to promote domestic peace than we have done anywhere.

Venezuela has oil and farmland. But the farmland is not used to grow beans for the campasinos. It is used to grow beef for the middle and upper classes. The rich skim off the oil revenues and buy luxury foods abroad while the workers can barely afford to both eat and take their chioldren to a doctor.

So the Cuban doctors are providing a lower level of care? Compared to WHAT? Is surgery and physical therapy care you can't obtain worth more than an aspirin and a dressing for an injury? You could say the same thing about the American health care system. Sure, we have the best doctors in the world, but the hospitals demand a profit for their shareholders, so you find yourself paying five bucks for a single bandaid.

The most devastating blow to the Venezuelan ecconomy had nothing to do with any damage Chavez did. It was the strike by whiny punk oil industry management, refusing to continue production.

Chavez is telling the international oil companies that that is not THEIR oil under the ground in Venezuela, and they are having a temper tantrum.

As for shutting down the television station that tried to get him killed, I would say that Chavez showed a lot more mercy than Bush would have. Bush wanted to bomb al Jazeera, for crying out loud.

Now, had Chavez frog-marched management out of the building at the point of a bayonet before their license expired, you would have a legitimate complaint. That he waited until the license ran out shows one thing about Chavez that is more democratic than about Bush. He sees himself as limited by law.

As for his ecconomic aid to other countries, I applaud Chavez. The World Bank needs to be scrapped on reformed and all loans forgiven. It has just become an instrument for the privatization of the commons in developing nations, to the benefit of the entrepreneurial classes of richer nations. Chavez may be taking the first steps toward a mutual growth policy in which poorer nations can invest in their own infrastructure without enriching corporations that will exploit them as cheap labor. If African nations can develop their own infrastructure without becoming debt slaves to the capitalists, Chavez may soon have a market besides us for his oil.

Chavez is far from the monster Bush would have you think he is. He has not rounded up and disappeared his opponents like some of our pet fascists have in Latin America.

Viva Chavez.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Useful_idiot
 
Bush wanted to bomb al Jazeera, for crying out loud.
This is a myth. Let me walk you through this one.

Al Jazeera is a media company headquartered in Qatar.

Qatar is an American ally (for the moment) that has both a major HQ (CENTCOM) and a nice sized air base operating by the sufferance of The Emir Al Thani (May Allah smile upon his fortunes.)

To bomb Al Jazeera would mean bombing Qatar. From, I suppose, aircraft based in Qatar.

Absurd.

The Emir is the guy who tossed out his dad in a bloodless coup, began modest liberalization and reforms, which included giving the green light for Al Jazeera to begin operating in his country. This was a bold experiment in reform in the Persian Gulf region, and it still earns the Emir some guff from his neighboring royalty now and again.

Nowhere will you find a presidential order, or contingency, to attack Al Jazeera. Now, there were made some comments, IIRC by Sec Def Rumsfeld or one of his spokesmen, about disabling some transmitting nodes/antennas/repeater stations/channels used by Al Jazeera in some parts of the Arab world. How is uncertain (there are a variety of ways to do that without dropping a bomb) but whoever came up with that strikes me as an idiot, politically.

Deliberately attack the free press outlet run by your ally's permission, when you are a champion of more transparency in government and reform in the Mid East, is about as counter productive a policy move as I can think of. Yes, it is biased, no one said the media/image war is easy.

Sarge, if you can't quote me an attributable statement from President Bush that he felt Al Jazeera should be bombed, I can't but ask you to retract that error, as it only weakens your position. If you can, I shall accept that my memory is bad, and that I tweaked you nose in error.
Chavez is far from the monster Bush would have you think he is. He has not rounded up and disappeared his opponents like some of our pet fascists have in Latin America.
I tend to agree on the first, and "as far as I know, this is true" on the second. I will also suggest Bush is not quite the demon Chavez accused him of being in his speech at the UN. Hyperbole seems to be the coin of the realm in a lot of places these days.
Viva Chavez.Viagra
There, fixed it for ya. :D

:duck:

DR
 
Sarge, if you can't quote me an attributable statement from President Bush that he felt Al Jazeera should be bombed, I can't but ask you to retract that error, as it only weakens your position. If you can, I shall accept that my memory is bad, and that I tweaked you nose in error.

Apparently the news originated from the Daily Mirror, a UK tabloid...

The White House always denied it:
http://www.cnn.com/2005/WORLD/europe/11/22/us.al.jazeera/index.html?iref=newssearch

and if he did say something like this, it was probably one of Bush's failed attempts at humor, and not in any way a real plan from the White House:

The Washington Post cited an unnamed senior Washington diplomat saying that the Bush remark as reported by the Daily Mirror "sounds like one of the president's one-liners that is meant as a joke." But, the diplomat said, "it was foolish for someone to write it down, and now it will be a story for days."
http://en.wikinews.org/wiki/Alleged_Bush-Blair_Al-Jazeera_bombing_transcript_leaked
 
. Do you really believe, for example, that Rush Limpbaugh is on the strongest signal in every market and Thom Hartmann and Randi Rhodes are shuffled off to the hamster-powered stations because most Americans like what the fat deaf junky has to say? Or is it because only a handful of companies own all the outlets and have the power to buy our right to speek and to hear right out from under us.

Uh,because Limbaugh (and I can't stand him either) gets bigger ratings than Hartmann and Rhodes?
The fact is the talk radio Demo does skew to the right
I agree that there should be limits on how many radio stations in a single area that one company should own.But this idea of bringing back a "Fairness Doctrine" is an assault on Free Speech.
Sad to see you slip from traditonal liberalism into a kind of Neo Marxism.
 
I do not assume, I conclude. There is a difference. The first clue was that he has, from the beginning, expressed unfailing admiration for Castro.

Ah! Ah! Ah! Ah!
You are so funny..
So what?
Half of the Italians I know have a unfailing admiration for Che Guevara..

And his actions have been easy to predict using the assumption that he wants to be a dictator just like his hero. Term limits in the constitution he helped pass? It was easy to see they wouldn't remain for very long. Why did he put them in there to begin with, if he was only going to change them later? To keep up appearances while consolidating power, nothing more. Chavez never had any intention of stepping down.

Does any leader have any intention to step down, if he can remain in power for the rest of his life, with the population` s consensus?

He's built up a cult of personality around himself for a reason: he wants to be president for life.

Oh, and let's not forget getting the legislature to grant him the ability to rule by decree. But maybe that disproves my position: maybe that demonstrates that he's no longer aspiring to dictatorship, but has already attained it.

Even if Chavez can be re-elected for n-terms, still, he has to be re-elected to be President again and again.
I am not sure of this, so correct me if I am wrong.
In this case, he is not, and he will not be a dictator
 
Ah! Ah! Ah! Ah!
You are so funny..
So what?
Half of the Italians I know have a unfailing admiration for Che Guevara..

I will be charitable and assume you're having a problem understanding precise definitions of words. Look up assume. Look up conclude. Consider the context in which you used the word "assume", and the context in which I used the word "conclude". I conclude that Chavez is an aspiring dictator. This is different from me assuming that Chavez is an aspiring dictator, which is what you said. The distinction between assuming and concluding is not trivial.

As for half of the Italians you know having an unfailing admiration for Che, I can only conclude (there's that word again) that half the Italians you know are bloody stupid morons. I cannot and do not conclude anything about Italians in general, because the sample of Italians you know may be quite unrepresentative. I could assume that, but it would only be an assumption (and I don't actually assume that half of them are).

Does any leader have any intention to step down, if he can remain in power for the rest of his life, with the population` s consensus?

Yes indeed. Let me give you a little history lesson about the US: the two-term limit on presidents was for most of the history of our republic not even a formal requirement. It was a tradition started by George Washington (who would easily have won additional terms had he wanted to), which was never broken until Roosevelt during WW2. And it was never broken prior to this because presidents felt that it was the right thing to do, despite there being no legal requirement to do so. It was only adopted as part of the US constitution (and never in law prior to that) in 1951.

Even if Chavez can be re-elected for n-terms, still, he has to be re-elected to be President again and again.

That's not hard to do, given sufficient control of other aspects of the state and society. Saddam, after all, was elected by the vast majority of Iraqis. Elections alone do not make a democracy.
 
I will be charitable and assume you're having a problem understanding precise definitions of words. Look up assume. Look up conclude. Consider the context in which you used the word "assume", and the context in which I used the word "conclude". I conclude that Chavez is an aspiring dictator. This is different from me assuming that Chavez is an aspiring dictator, which is what you said. The distinction between assuming and concluding is not trivial.

As for half of the Italians you know having an unfailing admiration for Che, I can only conclude (there's that word again) that half the Italians you know are bloody stupid morons.

Not about the Italians I know
Che is an extremely popular figure among Italians, and, not only among Italians..

I cannot and do not conclude anything about Italians in general, because the sample of Italians you know may be quite unrepresentative. I could assume that, but it would only be an assumption (and I don't actually assume that half of them are).

See above..

Yes indeed. Let me give you a little history lesson about the US: the two-term limit on presidents was for most of the history of our republic not even a formal requirement. It was a tradition started by George Washington (who would easily have won additional terms had he wanted to), which was never broken until Roosevelt during WW2. And it was never broken prior to this because presidents felt that it was the right thing to do, despite there being no legal requirement to do so. It was only adopted as part of the US constitution (and never in law prior to that) in 1951.

I know about it..
So, why do you bash Chavez?
Disclaimer:
I may be wrong about what Chavez did..

That's not hard to do, given sufficient control of other aspects of the state and society. Saddam, after all, was elected by the vast majority of Iraqis. Elections alone do not make a democracy.

I see..
And, what does?
 
When people disagree with you, you call him/her as " idiot ", uh?
Well, that is an idiot` s behaviour..
I disagree with LeftSergeant` s comments, but I found them quite intellingent.
Oh, wait, maybe I am an idiot too..
Did you read the link?

Do you understand what the term is meant to describe?

DR
 
I know about it..

Then why did you ask if anyone ever willingly stepped down when they could have remained in office? If you already knew that there were plenty of examples of exactly that, why did you challenge me on that point? Were you trying to use an argument you knew to be false?

So, why do you bash Chavez?

Because I've concluded that he's an aspiring dictator. I thought that was clear. Why wasn't it?

I see..
And, what does?

The rule of law, protection for individual freedoms (including property rights, BTW), and open political debates are all necessary components. Without them elections become merely symbolic. And Chavez has been dismantling them. He has slowly but surely been removing the obstacles which might prevent him from ruling as a dictator.
 
* drinks beer *
* burps *


Mind you, just as an afterthought, to several people such as Marksman and Rob Lister, I would gently suggest nationals from a country managing to comprehensively screw itself through the smoke-and-mirrors economics of the sub-prime market should be a hell of a lot more reticent before they start jumping up and down in forced outrage over the economic mismanagment shown by Chavez.

Just a thought; people in glass houses, throwing stones, all that, dontcha know?
:)

* returns to burping at beer carton *
 
* drinks beer *
* burps *



Just a thought; people in glass houses, throwing stones, all that, dontcha know?
:)

* returns to burping at beer carton *

Keep drinking but what you said still won't make any sense to a rational person. Consumers and businesses in Chavez's country can make retarded decisions just like American ones can. Bill, Bush, and whoever takes over next don't force anyone to apply for risky loans nor force lenders to offer them.
 
Because I've concluded that he's an aspiring dictator. I thought that was clear. Why wasn't it?

Just your opinion ( based on nothing )..

The rule of law, protection for individual freedoms (including property rights, BTW), and open political debates are all necessary components. Without them elections become merely symbolic.

Really?
If people become fed up with the " loss of freedom ", they can not change him?
Another one, with the " America-only-is-right " mind..
 
Just your opinion ( based on nothing )..

Well of course it's my opinion. But it's a lie on your part to say that that opinion was based upon nothing, when I've already told you some of the things it's based upon. I expected better of you, Matteo.

Really?
If people become fed up with the " loss of freedom ", they can not change him?

Impossible to change from a dictatorship? No. Difficult? Hell yes. Dictatorships, particularly in oil-rich countries where the dictators can survive off the work of a small sliver of the population, can be very stable things. Surely you can recognize that, can't you?

Another one, with the " America-only-is-right " mind..

Nothing of the sort, Matteo. You are attributing to me a position I have never expressed. And you should know better. America is hardly alone in recognizing the importance of rule of law and individual rights in creating representative government, and I never claimed or implied otherwise.
 
Just your opinion ( based on nothing )..

This is not a valid response. I think you are being a little lazy in responding, rather than dishonest, but you are off-track.

You may disagree with Zig's conclusions. You may even honestly state that you do not believe that his position is supported by *enough* evidence (in your own opinion. But to say his opinion is supported by nothing means you are either being intentionally disrespectful or have not been reading his posts.

Really?
If people become fed up with the " loss of freedom ", they can not change him?
Another one, with the " America-only-is-right " mind..

This is a complete strawman. Zig has not stated this, nor is it reasonably dervied from what he has said, which appears to be along the lines of [paraphrase coming]:

Elections are *necessary* for a free democracy, but are not *sufficient*, by themselves, to ensure it.

You generally argue better than this, M -- but your response on this was poor. I'm putting down as an off day for you.

ETA: Oh, and by the way, simply labeling something as "American" doesn't mean that it is wrong automatically any more than it means that it is right.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom