Chavez taking necessary steps to ensure equality and liberty

And the only reason Chavez didn't shut down RCTV immediately was because he still didn't have the support of the courts and legislature. It took him two years to replace, through aggressive campaigning and attrition, sufficient legislators and judges so that they would let him do what he did.

It wasn't because he supports liberty or freedom of the press.
 
The ability of the militant ..underline militant ..left to throw aside all their rhetoric about individual freedom and support any dictator who comes along with the proper slogans never ceases to amaze me.
 
why do the Americans care about Chavez? Is it because they cannot control him and dont have easy access to thier oil.He has made life better for the poor of his country.
 
why do the Americans care about Chavez? Is it because they cannot control him and dont have easy access to thier oil.He has made life better for the poor of his country.

If you don't see anything wrong with the news in the OP, then I guess you have a big problem.
 
why do the Americans care about Chavez? Is it because they cannot control him and dont have easy access to thier oil.He has made life better for the poor of his country.


Ah,the Mussolini defense.
"Yes,Mussolini is a Ruthless Dictator,but he made the trains run on time".
And don't get me started about how the Left embraced that Great Champion Of Humanity Joseph Stalin,and answered all criticism of him with the chant:
"LIES!LIES! ALL CAPTALIST LIES!".
The point is,sadly, a number of people on the left...not all,but some...are willing to embrace any brutality or oppression if someone "makes things Better".
 
I watched a documentry by John Pilger which was focused on how life has changed for the poor of Venenzuela.
They showed how everyone now has access to medical treatment,schooling and programmes for workers with better pay.These people live in shacks on the hillsides and for years had nothing while the rich on the other side just got richer and richer.A story which happens all over the world.
The poor people see a big difference to their lives and seem to have confidence in their president.
Still fail to see why America should be bothered.
 
According to the UN, Venezuela's Human Development Index has not been keeping pace with the rest of Latin America (see Figure 2, in the linked article, in which the Latin American HDI surpasses Venezuela's). And this despite astronomical growth in oil revenues.

To date, wealth inequality has increased, not decreased. Anti-poverty programs have had no appreciable impact. Now, the excuses for the failure to impact poverty are many: unspecified sabotage by America, lingering (unspecified) economic problems from the coup, Chavez' programs are long-term and not short-term, natural disasters, etc.

But some things that are not mentioned:
  • Chavez is giving financial support to Colombian rebels
  • Chavez orchestrated a bailout of the Argentinian economy as part of his effort to set up Venezuela as a counterpoint to the World Bank.
  • Chavez, as a PR stunt, gave millions of odllars in subsidies to low-income American families over the past winter
  • Chavez spent billions on weapons for his armed forces
  • Chavez gave billions in aid to African nations

As for why we "care about Chavez"? We don't particularly. This forum will discuss anything anybody cares to put forward. I suspect the prevalence of Chavez articles has less to do with Chavez, but rather the contortions to which some people will engage to defend him.

If people decided to anoint Rafael Correa the new darling of the Left, and then Correa began to restrict free speech, you'd see threads about Ecuador, not because Ecuador is some sort of threat to America, but because it would be entertaining to watch people strive to lionize and villainize the man.
 
Chavez belongs to a new generation of populistic (spelling?) rulers like Evo Morales and Correa (not, not me, he guy from Ecuador). They use a leftist discourse to masquerade populistic policies. These include nationalization of multinational energy and mining industries as well as farms, steel plants, etc. Assistentialistic policies are also always within the "doctrine", in order to keep the people happy and dependent of the government.

Despite the "Down with the USA" speech, they keep selling their oil to...
And Chavez minnions enjoy spending their vacations at...
And their preferred car is the...
 
why do the Americans care about Chavez? Is it because they cannot control him and dont have easy access to thier oil.

Not so. We have very easy access to Venezuelan oil, and will continue to. Just as Venezuela has easy access to American markets for their primary export. Much as Chavez likes to pretend he's standing up to American "agression", the one thing he wouldn't dare do is cut off oil supplies to the US. And it's not because we'd take him out if he did, it's because Venezuela depends on US markets for their oil more than we depend on Venezuela. If he shut off oil shipments to America, he'd have a lot more to worry about from domestic unrest (due to the economic implosion that would cause) than from American invervention.

He has made life better for the poor of his country.

I'm sure he has, for some of them. But it was bought at the expense of their liberties, and his moves towards a command economy (and the inevitable catastrophic mismanagement it brings) will prevent any long-term economic growth and ensure that their lot cannot continue to improve. Hardly a good bargain.
 
According to the UN, Venezuela's Human Development Index has not been keeping pace with the rest of Latin America (see Figure 2, in the linked article, in which the Latin American HDI surpasses Venezuela's). And this despite astronomical growth in oil revenues.

To date, wealth inequality has increased, not decreased. Anti-poverty programs have had no appreciable impact. Now, the excuses for the failure to impact poverty are many: unspecified sabotage by America, lingering (unspecified) economic problems from the coup, Chavez' programs are long-term and not short-term, natural disasters, etc.
Bold emphasis mine. And this is when things get dicey for a Dear Leader wannabe - when their draconian wealth-redistribution schemes don't yield their promised results, a scapegoat must be found. Then the real atrocities can begin!
 
I watched a documentry by John Pilger which was focused on how life has changed for the poor of Venenzuela.
:rolleyes: John Pilger's anecdotal evidence keeps running smack into the economic indicators. In 2002 Pilger anounced that Chavez was improving the life of Venezuelan poor. Five years later, there is no indication of improvement. In his last article on Venezuela, Pilger mentions the economic collapse and rise of poverty in Venezuela from 18% in 1980 to 65% in 1995, but never mentions: (1) the 1995 rate was an anomoly, measured at the worst point in Venezuelan economic history; (2) today poverty is, at best, a few points lower than its usual rate of 48% (it's about 46% now) -- which is remarkably little, given how well the Venezuelan economy is doing.

Yes, medical access is improved, though the quality of medical access has not. That's just a trade-off of quantity and quality.

The poor people see a big difference to their lives and seem to have confidence in their president.
The poor people believe that Chavez will make a big difference int heir lives because he keeps promising he will and he manages to blame his failure ot deliver on his enemies. Because he's a demagogue.

Still fail to see why America should be bothered.
I find it funny that people complain that America is ignorant of the world, but when they show an interest in the world, people wonder why we should bother.

What makes you think America is "bothered"?
 
I watched a documentry by John Pilger which was focused on how life has changed for the poor of Venenzuela.
They showed how everyone now has access to medical treatment,schooling and programmes for workers with better pay.These people live in shacks on the hillsides and for years had nothing while the rich on the other side just got richer and richer.A story which happens all over the world.
The poor people see a big difference to their lives and seem to have confidence in their president.
Still fail to see why America should be bothered.

It would be interesting to hear the point of view of some Venezuelan, on this issue.
Alas, there does not seem to be any, in this forum..
 
The poor people believe that Chavez will make a big difference int heir lives because he keeps promising he will and he manages to blame his failure ot deliver on his enemies. Because he's a demagogue.

You should not speak on behalf of the Venezuelan poors, assuming that they can be easily fooled
Chavez seems to have quite a strong support, from his own country.

Chávez went on to win the 1998 presidential election on December 6, 1998 with 56% of the vote
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hugo_Chávez

The Venezuelan recall referendum of 15 August 2004 was a referendum to determine whether Hugo Chávez, the current President of Venezuela, should be recalled from office. The result of the referendum was to not recall Chávez.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venezuelan_recall_referendum,_2004


I find it funny that people complain that America is ignorant of the world, but when they show an interest in the world, people wonder why we should bother.

What makes you think America is "bothered"?

The point people are afraid, is which kind of " interest " is America having torwards poor countries, such as Venezuela ( if we want to consdier Venezuela as " poor " )
 
:rolleyes: John Pilger's anecdotal evidence keeps running smack into the economic indicators. In 2002 Pilger anounced that Chavez was improving the life of Venezuelan poor. Five years later, there is no indication of improvement. In his last article on Venezuela, Pilger mentions the economic collapse and rise of poverty in Venezuela from 18% in 1980 to 65% in 1995, but never mentions: (1) the 1995 rate was an anomoly, measured at the worst point in Venezuelan economic history; (2) today poverty is, at best, a few points lower than its usual rate of 48% (it's about 46% now) -- which is remarkably little, given how well the Venezuelan economy is doing.

I do not think if your idea about the Venezuelan economy can be considered 100% fair..

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hugo_Chávez#Economic_policy
During Chávez's presidency from 1999 to 2004, per-capita GDP dropped 1–2%,[126] but with the help of rising oil prices, the end of the oil strike, and strong consumption growth, recent economic activity under Chávez has been robust. GDP growth rates were 18% in 2004,[127] 9% in 2005,[128] and 9.6% in the first half of 2006, with the private sector growing at a 10.3% clip.[129] From 2004 to the first half of 2006, non-petroleum sectors of the economy showed growth rates greater than 10%.[130] Datos reports real income grew by 137% between 2003 and Q1 2006.[131] Official poverty figures dropped by 10%

Disclaimer
The above assumptions do not mean, in any way, any support or endorsement of Chavez from my side
 
You should not speak on behalf of the Venezuelan poors, assuming that they can be easily fooled
Chavez seems to have quite a strong support, from his own country.

...snip...

From my personal (and to a certain point anedoctal), poor people of South America can be and are easilly fooled by demagogic politicians. I could make a list of Brazillian politicians I consider as such. The overall situation was seen many times before at other countries from Latin America. Its interesting to note that they can either be from left or right, and always use nationalistic appeals, blaming other countries or foreign companies for their internal problems. The problems always come from an external source...

They do give some tidbits that cause mall improvments do the poor, but they also bring variable ammounts of totalitarianism togheter. In the middle- and long- terms, the outcome is not good.

I could speak a bit about Venezuela, but the information would not be very different from what's available at the press. Not to mention that I could be considered by some as biased, since I work at an international mining company.

Note: Despite my lack of support for Chavez, Morales and Co., I consider myself as a moderate leftist or a "left-handed" centrist. As a result, I've been called godless destroyer of the family, property and freedom by some on the right and a selfish brain-washed puppet of the imperialism by others in the left...
 
You should not speak on behalf of the Venezuelan poors, assuming that they can be easily fooled
Chávez seems to have quite a strong support, from his own country.
According to the UN, the lives of the poor in Venezuela has not improved under Chávez, and yet he remains as popular as ever. My conclusion is that they still believe he will deliver on his promises. That he is a demagogue is evident from the disconnect between his promises and his actions.

Chávez went on to win the 1998 presidential election on December 6, 1998 with 56% of the vote
Um... and this has to do with anything I wrote how? Did I deny that Chávez was elected by majorities? (No, I did not.)
The point people are afraid
Who in America is afraid of Chávez? What is your evidence of this?

How hypocritical of you to chide me for speaking "on behalf of poor Venezuelans" while you seem to have no compunction speaking on behalf of Americans.

I do not think if your idea about the Venezuelan economy can be considered 100% fair.
I wasn't speaking of the Venezuelan economy, which is of course doing better since it is entirely dependent on rising oil prices, but of the lives of the poor within Venezuela, which has not improved relative to lives of the poor in Latin America as a whole over the same time period.

It is a sad fact of reality in many third-world countries that the lives of the poor do not improve measurably even when the economy does well. In the pre-Chávez regime, it was because the profits went to the capitalists, who spent the money abroad on luxuries. In the Chávez regime it goes into the hands of Chávez, who uses the money to try to export Chavismo into places like Africa and Argentina.

The above assumptions do not mean, in any way, any support or endorsement of Chavez from my side
No, but it does mean you aren't paying attention to the arguments. The poor in Venezuela are not better off under Chávez. If they think they are (and I have no doubt they do), it is because they have hope. That hope, however, is false because Chávez isn't using the money to improve the lives of the poor in Venezuela (beyond some programs designed to make it appear that way on the cheap). He is exporting the money abroad in attempt to spread his message of Chavismo.

And I think that, just as American largess abroad hasn't won America many allies, other nations will smile and take Chávez's money and will then act in their own interests regardless of what Chávez thinks his money is buying.
 
From my personal (and to a certain point anedoctal), poor people of South America can be and are easilly fooled by demagogic politicians. I could make a list of Brazillian politicians I consider as such. The overall situation was seen many times before at other countries from Latin America. Its interesting to note that they can either be from left or right, and always use nationalistic appeals, blaming other countries or foreign companies for their internal problems. The problems always come from an external source...

Why do you give me suh an easy shot, Neto-san?
Do I have to mention the total demagogue that the U.S. have now??
How did he make the Americans swallow the lies on the war??
" ..and God bless America "..
OOOOOOOHHHHHH! YEEEAAAAHH!!

They do give some tidbits that cause mall improvments do the poor, but they also bring variable ammounts of totalitarianism togheter. In the middle- and long- terms, the outcome is not good.

Let the poor decide

I could speak a bit about Venezuela, but the information would not be very different from what's available at the press. Not to mention that I could be considered by some as biased, since I work at an international mining company.

Maybe, you are rich..

Note: Despite my lack of support for Chavez, Morales and Co., I consider myself as a moderate leftist or a "left-handed" centrist. As a result, I've been called godless destroyer of the family, property and freedom by some on the right and a selfish brain-washed puppet of the imperialism by others in the left...

Yes, the same old story.
If Left is bad, the Right have to be good, and the other way around.
BTW..
If you have time, I am always willing to take on that old thread " Where am I? "
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom