Can we calm down in this section please?

actually it is a "part" of the brain stem...technically.

TAM;)

I can't believe I missed that one


Than again, my presentation to any ER Doctor or Nurse is "Possible head and neck injury"...or if I get an intern..."They went boom on their head"
 
I can't believe I missed that one


Than again, my presentation to any ER Doctor or Nurse is "Possible head and neck injury"...or if I get an intern..."They went boom on their head"
You get Texas ER docs/interns in NYC???
 
This is actually just a demographic change more than anything. The truthers we're getting now are, for whatever reason, skewing much younger.

We know Rev is 15 but some of you guys would laugh out loud if you could see the faces of the nameless truthers you just typed 3,000 words destroying. Braces and pimples and a T-shirt with a picture of a band on it... skimming posts by 40 year-old professionals making six figures who are trying to explain finer points of structural engineering.

The reason is the 9/11 conspiracy internet meme has largely faded away in the mainstream. A year ago, I couldn't go on a movie review forum, or a Chicago Bears message board, or seek Windows troubleshooting advice from a PC repair forum, without seeing a Loose Change thread. EVERY forum had to have one.

Not now. Now the fad lives on only with the hard-core conspiracy types, and the teenagers who are, to be fair, exactly like we were when we were teenagers.

We did the same thing, each in our own way, embracing that phony kind of cynicism and getting a charge out of the reaction we got from the grown-ups.

Kids want attention. Rev wants attention. If he wasn't doing this, he'd be on a board full of Christians screaming about how there's no god, or he'd be on a suicide help board typing "KILL YOURSELF LOL" in all caps. Anything for the shock, anything to get the grownups stirred up.

He just wants to feel like he is somebody. And it's the same for who knows how many of the new truthers we have here now.

Come on; there hasn't been a new 9/11 theory or witness or piece of "evidence" in many months. It's all just copy-and-paste jobs from little kids. And people like me have a rough day at work and then we come on here and use those kids as punching bags because it's a form of stress release. It's fun. And it's probably wrong.

Why? Because in reality, every one of these new kids could be dispatched with a single reply: "Please see the following links, which debunk every claim you just made."
 
This is actually just a demographic change more than anything. The truthers we're getting now are, for whatever reason, skewing much younger.

We know Rev is 15 but some of you guys would laugh out loud if you could see the faces of the nameless truthers you just typed 3,000 words destroying. Braces and pimples and a T-shirt with a picture of a band on it... skimming posts by 40 year-old professionals making six figures who are trying to explain finer points of structural engineering.

The reason is the 9/11 conspiracy internet meme has largely faded away in the mainstream. A year ago, I couldn't go on a movie review forum, or a Chicago Bears message board, or seek Windows troubleshooting advice from a PC repair forum, without seeing a Loose Change thread. EVERY forum had to have one.

Not now. Now the fad lives on only with the hard-core conspiracy types, and the teenagers who are, to be fair, exactly like we were when we were teenagers.

We did the same thing, each in our own way, embracing that phony kind of cynicism and getting a charge out of the reaction we got from the grown-ups.

Kids want attention. Rev wants attention. If he wasn't doing this, he'd be on a board full of Christians screaming about how there's no god, or he'd be on a suicide help board typing "KILL YOURSELF LOL" in all caps. Anything for the shock, anything to get the grownups stirred up.

He just wants to feel like he is somebody. And it's the same for who knows how many of the new truthers we have here now.

Come on; there hasn't been a new 9/11 theory or witness or piece of "evidence" in many months. It's all just copy-and-paste jobs from little kids. And people like me have a rough day at work and then we come on here and use those kids as punching bags because it's a form of stress release. It's fun. And it's probably wrong.

Why? Because in reality, every one of these new kids could be dispatched with a single reply: "Please see the following links, which debunk every claim you just made."


A terrific post. I think the appeal of Malcolm Kirkman lies in his seemingly inexhaustible knack for coming up with new forms of lunacy. The stuff about Warren Buffet's golf tournament and the "military bad boys" from Offutt AFB is priceless.
 
TAM,


I know this is off subject...but I think you will enjoy it



Redneck Medical Terminology


Artery - The study of paintings.
Bacteria - Back door to cafeteria.
Barium - What doctors do when patients die.
Benign - What you be, after you be eight.
Catscan - Searching for Kitty.
Cauterize - Made eye contact with her.
Colic - A sheep dog.
Coma - A punctuation mark.
Dilate - To live long.
Enema - Not a friend.
Fester - Quicker than someone else.
Fibula - A small lie.
Impotent - Distinguished, well known.
LabourPain - Getting hurt at work. Medical
Staff - A Doctor's cane.
Morbid - A higher offer.
Nitrates - Cheaper than day rates.
Node - I knew it.
Outpatient - A person who has fainted.
Pelvis - Second cousin to Elvis.
Post Operative - A letter carrier.
Recovery Room - Place to do upholstery.
Rectum - Nearly killed him.
Secretion - Hiding something.
Seizure - Salad Dressing
Tablet - A small table.
Illness - Getting sick at the airport.
Tumor - One plus one more.
Urine - Opposite of you're out.
2xCondoms - To be sure, to be sure
 
You see, the miscreants who fabricate vicious slanders of innocent people in order to absolve murderous fanatics of a horrible crime are not my "friends in other camp." Their stupidity masks the genuinely evil nature of their cause. I will gladly defend my contempt for them--"hatred" is too strong a term--as a rational judgment, not a borderline psychotic reaction.

That you incorrectly perceive and then condemn those who question what we were told happened on 9/11 as "stupid" or "evil" is your problem, not theirs. Any rational person would see that there is a lot at stake here, no matter what one believes. Declaring a "War on Terrorism" which cannot be won and waging war against essentially one billion Muslims all on the basis of what could possibly be a great big lie is similarly of great concern.

As TAM pointed out, I live in New York City. My former girlfriend's apartment in Brooklyn Heights is right across the East River from Ground Zero. We could smell the acrid odor for months. I remember parking my car many blocks away, walking by the barricades and roadblocks to stare at mountains of twisted steel that demented lunatics (no names) now pretend didn't exist.

This isn't a game for me. I don't require a physicist to demonstrate that the steel wasn't "dustified." I know it wasn't.

If some minority believes that twisted steel wreckage didn't exist in spite of what you saw with your own eyes, then you can confront those specific people and try to show them where they're wrong, or you can ignore them. What you shouldn't do is assume that their views are representative of the views of everyone else who questions the official 9/11 narrative.

When I call someone an idiot for insisting that no plane hit the South Tower, I'm being rude and uncivil. I'm also venting the emotions stored after many nights on the phone consoling a close friend who watched a plane hit the South Tower, and has been tormented by the memories ever since.

You want me to shut up? Sorry, I choose not to oblige you.

I think the problem is that you assume that the only valid emotional response to what supposedly happened on 9/11 is yours, and yours alone.

You want me to extend courtesy to a deranged lynch mob that spits on the graves of murder victims? "Malcolm Kirkman" would like the opportunity to "set straight" the mother of a young man whose life ended when the plane he was on was hijacked and flown into a building. Should I accord him the respect I would normally extend to anyone who isn't an indescribably cruel and ignorant monster?

Neither you nor other self-proclaimed skeptics have a monopoly on the truth. This business of equating doubt about the 9/11 story with a lack of respect and even contempt for 9/11 victims and their families is revolting, to say the least. Your arrogant certainty about what did and didn't happen that day has transformed into an irrational hatred of anyone who dares question it. Your vain attempt to link this doubt to hate and disrespect of victims and their families is itself contemptible, and has no basis in reason. In fact, if we have been lied to in any way about what happened, then it is you who are helping to cover it up, and perpetuate the lie.

I take credit for flushing Willie Rodriguez out of his hole. My abrasive behavior toward this self-promoting fraud proved an effective means of persuading him to drop his pose and reveal his true character.

Firefighter John Schroeder mentions William Rodriguez as the man who saved him and at least eleven other firefighters that day. Are you prepared to flush 9/11 firefighter Schroeder "out of his hole" too, and reveal him for the "self-promoting fraud" he is? I think the person upon whose true character this behavior reflects is you.

Nowhere have I claimed to be a big gun for the rationalist side. My contributions pale beside those of the brilliant R. Mackey, the invaluable Mark, Beachnut, Apathoid, Newton's Bit, TAM, Gumboot--I'm writing quickly and I'm going to neglect some very important names, so I'll simply apologize to anyone who deserves to be mentioned. But, you know something? I'm willing to stand my contributions alongside yours!

Why do I need a feud with you, of all people?

Why do you need a feud with people who are skeptical of the official 9/11 story? Isn't it enough that they might simply be wrong? What if you're the one who is wrong. Is that even a possibility?
 
TAM,


I know this is off subject...but I think you will enjoy it



Redneck Medical Terminology


Artery - The study of paintings.
Bacteria - Back door to cafeteria.
Barium - What doctors do when patients die.
Benign - What you be, after you be eight.
Catscan - Searching for Kitty.
Cauterize - Made eye contact with her.
Colic - A sheep dog.
Coma - A punctuation mark.
Dilate - To live long.
Enema - Not a friend.
Fester - Quicker than someone else.
Fibula - A small lie.
Impotent - Distinguished, well known.
LabourPain - Getting hurt at work. Medical
Staff - A Doctor's cane.
Morbid - A higher offer.
Nitrates - Cheaper than day rates.
Node - I knew it.
Outpatient - A person who has fainted.
Pelvis - Second cousin to Elvis.
Post Operative - A letter carrier.
Recovery Room - Place to do upholstery.
Rectum - Nearly killed him.
Secretion - Hiding something.
Seizure - Salad Dressing
Tablet - A small table.
Illness - Getting sick at the airport.
Tumor - One plus one more.
Urine - Opposite of you're out.
2xCondoms - To be sure, to be sure


These are priceless...I am going to print this off and bring it into the clinic tomorrow.

TAM:)
 
I think that there is a place for ridicule, contempt and derission when it comes to debating. Yes, this is an educational forum, but certain viewpoints thrive on the indulgences of rational debaters. Holocaust denial, for one, is thrilled to just give the impression that there is any real debate about their arguments. Arguments such as the "no plane, space beam!" school of 911 denial are so disassociated from reality that after the minimal reasonable arguments are exhausted there is little tleft to do but make fun of such nonsense. I think that there is a lot to be said for engaging people who spout such nonsense so as to make them confront the lunacy that is their claims, but at times it is refreshing and perhaps necessary for pomeroo or gravy to call what is batcrap insane, well, batcrap insane.

Kage

P.S. Writing "no planes, space beams!" made me think of the "no soap, radio!" joke. There might be something there...
 
Last edited:
This business of equating doubt about the 9/11 story with a lack of respect and even contempt for 9/11 victims and their families is revolting, to say the least.

There is an AVALANCHE of clips, quotes, and theories that make the 9/11 doubters' contempt, and lack of respect, for the victims rather obvious.

Just a few I can think of off the top of my head:

- Bernard Brown sent his son to die
- Ted Olson is in on the conspiracy because the eulogies he gave for his wife occasionally confused the type of phone she called from
- The passengers aren't that important to the overall plot
- The passengers were paid off, and are living the life of luxury someplace
- The passengers' parents were fooled by super-secret voice morphing technology
- The phone calls are fake because Mark Bingham used his last name in speaking to his mother
- The phone calls are fake because there were no airfones
- The phone calls are fake because cell phone couldn't have worked
- The FDNY was in on the conspiracy

I'm sure there are others. "9-11 Deniers Speak" would be a good place to start.
 
I come here to learn the science behind the events of 9/11. I don't presume to teach it. There's a good chance that I know more about chess and blackjack than anyone who posts regularly on the conspiracy forum, but otherwise, I know who my betters are and I'm eager to hear what they have to say.

It's arrogant to assume there is a good chance you know more about chess and blackjack on any forum. They're both popular, easy to understand games. Blackjack is a very simple zero-sum game. I've memorized basic strategy for multiple variants, H17, S17, LS, Superfun, you name it. I've mastered hi-lo, and hi-opt 2, with index play. I've read most of the relevant books on the subject. I've made enough money playing it to pay for my trips to Las Vegas and then some. Do you know more than me? Maybe, but only an arrogant person would give a damn.

It is this sort of arrogance that fuels your certainty about what happened on 9/11, and it is your ego that makes you want to ridicule all of the "twoofers" for being such supreme idiots, in your estimation. Rest assured there are probably a lot of people smarter than you who have their doubts about 9/11.

Fortunately most of them are realistic enough to know that in fact, they don't know everything, and that perhaps some things simply cannot be known with any degree of certainty, no matter how authoritatively the evidence is presented.

By the way, you might want consider taking up poker. That's where all the fish are.
 
That you incorrectly perceive and then condemn those who question what we were told happened on 9/11 as "stupid" or "evil" is your problem, not theirs. Any rational person would see that there is a lot at stake here, no matter what one believes. Declaring a "War on Terrorism" which cannot be won and waging war against essentially one billion Muslims all on the basis of what could possibly be a great big lie is similarly of great concern.


My condemnation of their stupidity results from their heavy reliance on bogus science and endlessly repeated falsehoods. Their tactics are intellectually fraudulent, as exemplified by your threadbare line about "what we were told happened on 9/11." No, Big Brother didn't "tell" us anything. Thousands of individuals converged to produce a compelling narrative. I rail against the "Impossibly Vast Conspiracy" because fantasist mythology requires us to swallow the absurd, preposterous notion that the Democrat who works for NIST, the apolitical air traffic controller, the passionately liberal newspaper editor who published the passenger manifests showing the hijackers' names and seating positions, the firefighters who risked (and lost) their lives in burning buildings, the forensic examiners, the seismologists at the Lamont-Doherty labs, are ALL complicit in a mind-boggling crime committed for nothing more than the enrichment of Dick Cheney's cronies.

The misnamed War on Terror is directed against the jihadists who want to kill us. It can, and must, be won.



If some minority believes that twisted steel wreckage didn't exist in spite of what you saw with your own eyes, then you can confront those specific people and try to show them where they're wrong, or you can ignore them. What you shouldn't do is assume that their views are representative of the views of everyone else who questions the official 9/11 narrative.


What fantasist positions are defensible? What evidence has come to light in almost six years that throws doubt on the mainstream narrative?




I think the problem is that you assume that the only valid emotional response to what supposedly happened on 9/11 is yours, and yours alone.


You are a poor mind-reader. No, a common emotional response to what did happen on 9/11/01 is joy that the Great Satan got what it had coming. Mine is the valid emotional response for rationalists who accurately assess the threat posed by radical Islam.




Neither you nor other self-proclaimed skeptics have a monopoly on the truth.




We appear to have a monopoly on the search for truth.



This business of equating doubt about the 9/11 story with a lack of respect and even contempt for 9/11 victims and their families is revolting, to say the least.



The contempt shown by fantasists for the victims and their families is certainly revolting.


Your arrogant certainty about what did and didn't happen that day has transformed into an irrational hatred of anyone who dares question it.


Wrong. Overwhelming evidence shows that America was attacked by nineteen well-trained, highly-motivated jihadists who hijacked four planes and crashed three of them into buildings. I have yet to meet a conspiracy liar who asked sincere questions. Your side doesn't question anything. You erect an edifice of falsehoods to distort a reality that you find distasteful: America simply can't be the victim of an unprovoked attack. You will stop at nothing to muddy the waters.


Your vain attempt to link this doubt to hate and disrespect of victims and their families is itself contemptible, and has no basis in reason.


You've got to be kidding! How many quotes from twoofers do you think the posters here could find that show the most astounding insensitivity, cruelty, and naked contempt for the families of the victims? How much mockery of Todd Beamer, Mark Bingham, Stanley Praimnath, and Barbara Olson would you like to read?


In fact, if we have been lied to in any way about what happened, then it is you who are helping to cover it up, and perpetuate the lie.


How does telling lies expose a cover-up? How does fabricating nonsense about imaginary beam weapons, nonexistent explosives, and faked calls from the doomed planes help anyone but the jihadists who, I must remind you, want to kill us?


Firefighter John Schroeder mentions William Rodriguez as the man who saved him and at least eleven other firefighters that day. Are you prepared to flush 9/11 firefighter Schroeder "out of his hole" too, and reveal him for the "self-promoting fraud" he is? I think the person upon whose true character this behavior reflects is you.


Should we all emit the obligatory belch about Willie's heroism on 9/11? His appalling behavior since then has placed his account deeply in the red. So far, we know that Schroeder claims he heard explosions. That, presumably, negates the testimony of the vast majority of first-responders who loathe the conspiracy liars.


Why do you need a feud with people who are skeptical of the official 9/11 story? Isn't it enough that they might simply be wrong?


An honest debate is always welcome, but the fantasy movement shuns honest debate. The problem is, they want to parade their errors in the street and lynch innocent people.


What if you're the one who is wrong. Is that even a possibility?


Not on this.
 
Last edited:
It's arrogant to assume there is a good chance you know more about chess and blackjack on any forum. They're both popular, easy to understand games. Blackjack is a very simple zero-sum game. I've memorized basic strategy for multiple variants, H17, S17, LS, Superfun, you name it. I've mastered hi-lo, and hi-opt 2, with index play. I've read most of the relevant books on the subject. I've made enough money playing it to pay for my trips to Las Vegas and then some. Do you know more than me? Maybe, but only an arrogant person would give a damn.

It is this sort of arrogance that fuels your certainty about what happened on 9/11, and it is your ego that makes you want to ridicule all of the "twoofers" for being such supreme idiots, in your estimation. Rest assured there are probably a lot of people smarter than you who have their doubts about 9/11.

Fortunately most of them are realistic enough to know that in fact, they don't know everything, and that perhaps some things simply cannot be known with any degree of certainty, no matter how authoritatively the evidence is presented.

By the way, you might want consider taking up poker. That's where all the fish are.


a nerve has been struck

TAM;)
 
When I call someone an idiot for insisting that no plane hit the South Tower, I'm being rude and uncivil. I'm also venting the emotions stored after many nights on the phone consoling a close friend who watched a plane hit the South Tower, and has been tormented by the memories ever since.

You want me to shut up? Sorry, I choose not to oblige you.

I think the problem is that you assume that the only valid emotional response to what supposedly happened on 9/11 is yours, and yours alone.

I disagree with this. He is explaining why HE reacts the way he does (as he did in the paragraph above it. I omitted that paragraph because I still struggle with the quote function.)

I read this thread start to finish and I wanted to say something. I have been reading this forum for a long time. Much, much longer than I have been posting. I try to refrain because I am not as bright as the rest of you bulbs ;) and I am driven by my emotions. That leads to very BAD posting.

Anyway, I was trying to figure out who UW was referring to. I was kind of surprised it was Pomeroo. I had to go back and reread Pom's response to UW to be sure that I understood it correctly and I wasn't distracted while reading (kids yelling mom and whatnot.)

I have seen some posts by several posters here where I go "wow, that was really harsh." Pomeroo is not the only one. Don't get me wrong, I completely understand. If I were smarter and posted more, this thread would have been dedicated to me. Actually, I would have been banned.

The thing is, how can you blame anyone for getting emotional about this?? Seriously. Especially, being a New Yorker, having family or friends who were deeply and directly impacted by this tragedy. How can you? There are times that Gravy says something and I think it was snide or harsh. Then I remember how much time and energy he has spent debunking these theories and I just let it slide or realize how I would be a lot worse. Heck, even TAM said something the other day that I was shocked about. (not too much later, he got a yellow card for it) If it were me, I would have a really hard time not saying "you rule[8] moron" followed up with a smack in the face.

I also think that Pomeroo can use "New Yorker." I cannot imagine what it was like to be there as the events unfolded. It is so different being there than watching it on TV. Remember what it was like when you saw it on TV, you were horrified, speechless, etc. But then remember how much worse it was when they started playing the voicemails of the people stuck above the impact area in the towers. You know the ones saying goodbye, or that they were scared. I was already beside myself watching it, but then they started playing the voicemails. I think I would have lost it if I had been a New Yorker too. I totally think New Yorkers (obviously, not counting people who actually lost family members) were impacted by this event more than others. If the news wasn't enough of a constant reminder, you have smells, sights and sounds that lingered longer than the news because it happened in your backyard.

Furthermore, I think that if actual first responders were on this forum, they would make Pomeroo look like a girl scout. That is probably why they aren't here. You want to see emotion and reaming people a new one...they would be at the top of the list.

I am a little disappointed about UW putting Pomeroo on ignore. The first reaction people have when confronted about their behavior is to be defensive. Cut him some slack. Pomeroo explained why he gets the way he does. He admitted he was rude and uncivil. Didn't he say he would try to behave? But he was put on ignore anyway. He didn't completely cave in, but he acted like he would try to behave. He even said he didn't hate Rev. Come on that's a start!

I am going out on a limb here and am ready for attack. Ok, I am bracing myself.... UW, I think you handled this wrong. I was oblivious (no shocker there) to whom the OP was referring, but the rest of you knew. You included enough info in the OP for people to figure out who it was. Why even bother "not mentioning names"? Just friggen come out and say 'Pomeroo, I think you are getting carried away here and you are ticking me off.' Don't beat around the bush. Pom can come back and say 'this is why, sorry I will try harder' then we could go to the group hug. I think he would have respected that approach more. I understand the OP can be applied to other posters here as well, but it is clear to me that you were having an issue with Pomeroo. I am not surprised that Pomeroo was defensive in the beginning because of the way you presented it. It reminded me of a meeting where the supervisor doesn't have the guts to come right out and say it to the employee, so he calls everyone in, because they all are guilty of it from time to time. However, as the meeting progresses it is obvious who the "bad" employee is. In this case, not only did the bad employee get scolded in front of everyone, he was fired (put on ignore) too.

Maybe that was not the way it was intended to come across, but that is how it looked to me.

I will shut up after this...I promise. Every person is different. Sometimes just understanding what the person is about will give you a different perspective about their post. Now, if I see Pomeroo get rude, I will understand why. It isn't just because he is a jerk.
 
There is an AVALANCHE of clips, quotes, and theories that make the 9/11 doubters' contempt, and lack of respect, for the victims rather obvious.

Just a few I can think of off the top of my head:

- Bernard Brown sent his son to die
- Ted Olson is in on the conspiracy because the eulogies he gave for his wife occasionally confused the type of phone she called from
- The passengers aren't that important to the overall plot
- The passengers were paid off, and are living the life of luxury someplace
- The passengers' parents were fooled by super-secret voice morphing technology
- The phone calls are fake because Mark Bingham used his last name in speaking to his mother
- The phone calls are fake because there were no airfones
- The phone calls are fake because cell phone couldn't have worked
- The FDNY was in on the conspiracy

I'm sure there are others. "9-11 Deniers Speak" would be a good place to start.

I've seen that video. Avery was wrong to say that about Brown, and to suggest that Olsen is complicit because he confused what kind of phone his wife was using is ridiculous.

As for the comment about the passengers, that was taken out of context to make the speaker look as if he didn't care about the passengers. I didn't get that impression at all.

I think it's a little odd that Bingham used his surname when identifying himself to his mother. I've never done that in my entire life. Does Mrs. Bingham have another son Mark by a different father? Is this proof or even evidence of phone call fakery? Hardly. Odd? I think so, yes.

Based on what I've read about cell phones, I don't think they would have worked at altitude. I'm not in a position to know this authoritatively, but I've read what appear to be contradictory statements to this effect.

I don't think the FDNY was "in on" the conspiracy.

In any event, none of these people speak for me, so I take offense at the idea that I'm disrespectful of anyone. I have a stake in wanting to know what happened on 9/11 just as much as anyone else, and I have my doubts as to what I've been told. I'm not in a position to prove anything to anyone, nor do I accept the "debunkers" explanation for certain events. I'm convinced that it's impossible to know the whole truth, and there are a lot of uncertainties that will probably never be resolved to my satisfaction.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom