Can we calm down in this section please?

Stateofgrace:

Believe me, I do not go out of my way to upset anyone .... but I will not shy away from saying what I believe.

I consider 9/11 to be a very terrible tragedy, one that many people have not yet come to terms with for whatever reason....

Some people have called me every name under the sun. I try not to let that bother me because I dont believe such people are speaking the truth.

Basically, I guess, I dont take anything personally even when it is obviously intended that way.

As for people "making a profit".... isn't that how the world operates... 9/11 is not immune from the forces of avarice and enmity that drive the great capitalist machine we call the U.S?

Where there's muck there's money.......

Valid point Frank, but have you studied the Witch trials in Salem Mass?
People believed the young teenage Girls that caused the trials were lying but were to afraid to speak up. Because of that, people Innocent people died.
I can also use Linus Pauling as an example he argued that chicken soup had no benefit at all, and that vitamin C. was antiviral. Because he was a Nobel Lorette, Lay people believed him.
Of course we now know that chicken soup has antiviral properties, and Vitamin C does not.
How many people went though hours of UN necessary misery popping Vitamin C when a cup of chicken soup would have been a lot better?
I recently worked with a young man who was going to go to collage he said he was going to study economics, because he felt all engineers were liars, because of 9/11/2001. He actually believed that Controlled Demolition was the cause of building 7 falling as it did.
The guy Frank is a born engineer, he loves building, he can do stuff that is truly gifted, he knows materials, and how to combine materials to build stuff, and his math and knowledge to do it is far above mine.
He was going to throw all his natural talents away, and become an economist because he really believed that there was a large amount of molten metal at ground Zero, so I invited him to my house and Had him help me cut some steel and melt some with my torch.
5 minutes with me and my torch changed his mind, he is now wanting to go to school, he is now excited to study engineering, he wants to build things that improve the world and make peoples lives easier and better.
All it took was a few minutes playing with a cutting torch to show him the facts of what molten and heat soften steel is like.
It is not about debunking Frank it is about simple honesty, lies can only flourish in the dark and lies can do great harm. However a lie can only exist if it is unchallenged by the truth.
When people of good concise, are silent, only those with no concise, and no morals are heard.
I can not change the truth Frank, You as Bright and smart as you are can not change it, Nor can DBB. or Dr. Jones, the truth is the truth, it needs no one to defend it all it needs is someone to speak it.
The problem really boils down to what is the truth and how do we know what it is, for me the way I found the way that works for me.
Is to question the only witnesses that can testify, the materials and the reactions that take place in the buildings on that day.
If that makes me a troofer here so be it if it makes me a Debunker so be it the truth only needs good people to bring it to light, for the lies to die, but it does need good people of good conscience to bring it to light.
 
Chainsaw:

Thanks for the post. You are certainly going about 9/11 research the best possible way - through real world experimentation!

Thomas had it right when he said:

"Except I shall see in his hands the print of the nails, and put my finger into the print of the nails, and thrust my hand into his side, I will not believe"

You know there are many sections of the NIST Report where I have to remind myself that NIST is talking about a computer model rather than what actually happened. This is sloppy writing.... Now, good as NIST's computer models may be, its a golden rule in science that the theoretical part of a research study should be clearly delineated from the experimental part. This is because of the simple fact that a theory may change over time, but the experimental results, (assuming the experimental data were correctly recorded), remain valid for all time.

I guess one of my main criticisms of the NIST Report is that the experimental testing and verification attempted by NIST is often inappropriate and/or seriously flawed. NIST's truss heating test ASTM E-119 is fine for building code dispositioning, but almost useless as a simulation of the WTC fires. Then we have the workstation combustion tests that neglected to include any aircraft fuselage, wing sections, landing gear, etc, in the fire. And lets not forget the on-board oxygen carried by the aircraft.... NIST also failed to carry out any tests of recovered concrete sections or microanalysis of WTC dust samples which would have revealed the iron-rich spheres, and could potentially have found evidence for molten copper, zinc and lead. And NIST is almost nonchalant about the detection of sulfiding of the WTC steel and the presence of species such as copper, nickel and chlorine on the surface of many samples...

So, Chainsaw, I would really like to see more work carried out on WTC dust and debris samples. The analytical data so obtained could then be compared with data for material generated in your real world tests!
 
Apollo20:

You know anyone, off hand, who is best qualified, and able, to analyze the iron spherules, to see if they are likely from heated blood or some other source (such as Thermite Reactions)?

TAM:)
 
Oh, look. What was that I read on another thread about certain types of people using neologisms? How fitting.


I wouldn't like to label Frank a pseudoscientist (although he does behave like one at times) because as far as I can see his science is solid. On the other hand he does appear to endorse certain forms of pseudoscience and other woo woo.
 
Your list of topics that might be construed as in dispute is a little specious I would say.

Which just shows that, as Nozed Avenger has pointed out, you utterly failed to get the point. The subject is irrelevant, what we were all pointing out was that your argument was invalid.

Some people question evolution. There is no controversy, they are just wrong.
Some people question the shape of the Earth. There is no controversy, they are just wrong.
Some people question the holocaust. There is no controversy, they are just wrong.
Some people question the Moon landings. There is no controversy, they are just wrong.
Some people question the events of 11/9...

See where I'm going with this? Just because some people have doubts about something does not mean there is a controversy about it. Sometimes, in fact a lot of the time, they are wrong, simple as that. Of course, whether this is the case with 11/9 is open for debate, but to simply claim that because a few people aren't convinced that there must be something dodgy going on is just a silly argument that will convince nobody who isn't already convinced.

if a theory has any merit it will gain support, if not, it will die.

Like religion?

Ohhhh, boy. Now, I'm beginning to doubt that you are even British. One of the more popular Brit cusswords is considered far too crass for the majority of Canadians. I'm sure you know which one I am referring to.

Ooo, what is it? I have some Canadians I need to insult.;)
 
Chainsaw:

Thanks for the post. You are certainly going about 9/11 research the best possible way - through real world experimentation!

Thomas had it right when he said:

"Except I shall see in his hands the print of the nails, and put my finger into the print of the nails, and thrust my hand into his side, I will not believe"

You know there are many sections of the NIST Report where I have to remind myself that NIST is talking about a computer model rather than what actually happened. This is sloppy writing.... Now, good as NIST's computer models may be, its a golden rule in science that the theoretical part of a research study should be clearly delineated from the experimental part. This is because of the simple fact that a theory may change over time, but the experimental results, (assuming the experimental data were correctly recorded), remain valid for all time.

I guess one of my main criticisms of the NIST Report is that the experimental testing and verification attempted by NIST is often inappropriate and/or seriously flawed. NIST's truss heating test ASTM E-119 is fine for building code dispositioning, but almost useless as a simulation of the WTC fires. Then we have the workstation combustion tests that neglected to include any aircraft fuselage, wing sections, landing gear, etc, in the fire. And lets not forget the on-board oxygen carried by the aircraft.... NIST also failed to carry out any tests of recovered concrete sections or microanalysis of WTC dust samples which would have revealed the iron-rich spheres, and could potentially have found evidence for molten copper, zinc and lead. And NIST is almost nonchalant about the detection of sulfiding of the WTC steel and the presence of species such as copper, nickel and chlorine on the surface of many samples...

So, Chainsaw, I would really like to see more work carried out on WTC dust and debris samples. The analytical data so obtained could then be compared with data for material generated in your real world tests!

True, I would be more than happy to help in that, the main thing that I have found every body ignoring is that there are 4 types of energy involved the the collapses, the first is impact energy, the second is Chemical energy, the 3 is energy stored in the structure, the 4th is just gravity.
Until all the energy sources are quantified the physics of 9/11/2001 will be a realm of mystery.

Impacts of hard hot materials into other reactive materials can catalyze other reactions by increasing the surface area and heating the materials impacted.
You have to put all four energy sources together at once to recreate the environment that existed in the Twin Towers on 2001, leave one out and you get flawed results.
Intellectual dishonesty does not hurt those with degrees, and employed in Science, it hurts those that wish with willing open minds and good conscience to explore science, it hurts the young and impressionable student that is why it is so wrong.
 
Stateofgrace:

Believe me, I do not go out of my way to upset anyone .... but I will not shy away from saying what I believe.

I consider 9/11 to be a very terrible tragedy, one that many people have not yet come to terms with for whatever reason....

Some people have called me every name under the sun. I try not to let that bother me because I dont believe such people are speaking the truth.

Basically, I guess, I dont take anything personally even when it is obviously intended that way.

As for people "making a profit".... isn't that how the world operates... 9/11 is not immune from the forces of avarice and enmity that drive the great capitalist machine we call the U.S?

Where there's muck there's money.......

Thank you for your reply Apollo, it is appreciated as is the input from other members on the questions I have asked you.

I have bolded exactly how I feel about this entire affair. I guess many people feel the same. It is not that I am closed minded or even unwilling to consider for one minute that conspiracies do exist and do occur.

This is the rub though, I actually believe I am correct, I genuinely believe that 911 was not an inside job, I genuinely believe that Al Qaeda carried out this attack and I have seen nothing of any substance to convince me other wise. So yes I guess I would be one of those posters that get wound up and somewhat annoyed when I called sheep, blind, a defender of mass murderers, etc. I don't defend mass murderers, I condemn outright any acts of violence whatsoever and I condemn the death of any individual for somebody else’s beliefs, whether these beliefs are political or religiously motivated.

I simply speak my mind on matters like this and like you if I annoy anybody in doing so, then so be it. I guess it comes with freedom of speech and my own believe that I am entitled to think and belief whatever I like. I am equally entitled to defend my beliefs when I see them attacked.

There is indeed money in muck and yes people do profit from disasters. 911 was not the first to be profited from and I doubt it will be the last. Does it make it right? In my opinion no it doesn’t but profiting from other human beings suffering is always going happen though. It is made worse when people profit simply by distorting what happened, when people simply put together the most dreadful and distasteful videos one can imagine and I assure I have seen some utterly despicable ones, and try to pass it off as in anyway a quest for the truth.
 

The evolutionary derail was indeed in violation of Rule 11; I have split the posts to here.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: jmercer
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom