Can we calm down in this section please?

I'm more inclined to take a swig of the conspiracy moonshine than the government kool-aid.

Gosh, if only there was some kind of third option. One somewhere, I don't know, in the middle...
 
Well, I do get that impression, and so do a lot of other people. Part of the reason I get that impression is because of the complete lack of care for the passengers Dylan Avery has shown in numerous other stupid remarks he's made over the years. (I can't believe I forgot "LOL boxcutters.") The comment about the passengers was not a one-time incident to which benefit of the doubt may be applied.

You got the wrong impression. Mocking the idea that the hijackers supposedly used boxcutters to commandeer a jet doesn't amount to disrespect of the passengers. It's likely that you took a lot of other comments like these similarly out of context in order to demonize Avery.

This factoid is routinely cited by 9-11 Truthers as ironclad proof that the person calling was not Mark Bingham. Here's Jim Fetzer, speaking in this article:

"We have had phony tapes before using voices that were authentic. Mark Bingham, a passenger on Flight 93, is supposed to have called his mother and said, 'Hi, Mom, this is Mark Bingham!' His mother confirmed it was his voice, but does anyone seriously believe that Mark Bingham would have used his last name in identifying himself to his mother?"



It's not proof of anything. It's not even evidence. It's just one more little 9/11 oddity. Why are you beating a dead horse?

Then I suggest you defer to people who are in a position to know this authoritatively. I'm sure the Links section here can point you in the right direction.

Unfortunately, a lot of so-called authorities are liars. I will defer to whomever I damn well please.

Excuse me? Since you entered this thread you've done nothing but lecture us about how "people who question the 9-11 story" comport themselves intellectually. For you to now get your nose out of joint when I lump you with them when you share the same beliefs, is disingenuous.

Except, I've just gotten here and you know little of my beliefs. All you know, is that they are apparently hostile to yours. For you to pretend that you know who I am and what I believe is truly disingenuous.

And if you have any doubt about the basic events of 9-11, then these people jolly well DO speak for you, as they are the leaders of the 9-11 Truth movement.

Wrong. The only person who speaks for me, is myself. Whether or not you categorize everyone you disagree with as stupid or evil, and lump them all into the same boat is mostly your problem. It's only my problem to the extent that I have to share in the consequences of a planet filled with people like you.

Do me a favor and let me know who speaks for you, so that I can jolly well take up this thread with them instead, jolly.
 
See, this Tippit guy seems alright.

If we stay calm, I'm sure he can be converted.

Remember the Fred Phelps family. The more you shout them down, the more set in their beliefs they become, and think everyone else in the world is wrong.

Someone like Fred Phelps however, is impossible to turn back, and has in him so much hate anyway.

I'm not talking about going 'I respect your opinion' 'thanks for coming here' 'welcome to the forum' 'I love this country in which we can debate this', I'm just talking about quitting with the attacks that happen here the second someone from the CT side opens their mouth. A bit like Quad always did, and that frustrated me.
 
So Revolutionary91 isn't going to retract his claim regarding the (fictional) JFK quote? Such are the ways of the seekers of "truth," apparently.
 
Mocking the idea that the hijackers supposedly used boxcutters to commandeer a jet doesn't amount to disrespect of the passengers.

If you think the stuff Dylan Avery says on this page (scroll to the bottom) about the box cutters and Bernard Brown isn't disrespectful to the victims and their families, then, well, you and I just don't have anything to talk about.
 
Last edited:
I don't know. How many? Who established the altitude at which calls were originated, and how?
When there's enough information available, as there is with flight 93, anyone can do it. Compare the call times to the FDR and radar altitude readings at those times.

I find it strange, whether or not she found it strange. On the other hand, I would hope a mother is able to authenticate her own son over the phone. Who asked her this question anyway?
You should bookmark 911myths.com. It, and a few other sites (linked in my signature) provide answers for the questions the conspiracists aren't willing to research, because they want to perpetuate these "anomalies" and "mysteries."

http://www.911myths.com/html/mom__this_is_mark_bingham.html
 
See, this Tippit guy seems alright.

If we stay calm, I'm sure he can be converted.

Thanks for the hopeful message, but that's unlikely. I've been at this conspiracy thing for probably far longer than you have, 1995 in fact, when I first picked up a copy of The Creature from Jekyll Island. I think the best that could happen is that we can eliminate the the most preposterous 9/11 theories from contention, but it looks like you've already done a fairly good job of that. The big problem is that I don't believe a god-damned word the government or media say anymore, not that I've been listening in recent years. I don't see how you or anyone else here can restore this lost credibility. Another problem is that I don't buy the alleged motive.

Then there is the problem that I've come to the conclusion that the New World Order is real. Yes, Virgina, there really are a group of elite financiers who are building a totalitarian world government, composed of the soon-to-be Pan-American Union, the European Union, and the Asian Union. Yes, the open-border policy in spite of the teeming terrorist horde that want to kill us for our freedoms is deliberate, I'm sorry to say. We will merge with Canada and Mexico, "merge" being a euphemism for invasion by peasants importing a low-standard of living, crime, and political unrest. Yes, there really are plans to introduce the Amero, the featured currency of the American Union, after the US dollar is imploded (see this thread for my explanation of how). I'm not an expert on 9/11 "evidence" but I do know money, and the Federal Reserve Conspiracy is real, and yes, it is integral to understanding all of this and putting the 9/11 false flag into context.

I'm not talking about going 'I respect your opinion' 'thanks for coming here' 'welcome to the forum' 'I love this country in which we can debate this', I'm just talking about quitting with the attacks that happen here the second someone from the CT side opens their mouth. A bit like Quad always did, and that frustrated me.

Hear hear. Down with personal attacks. Lets hope that at least one person is converted, lest all our thoughtful typing be in vain. Let the conversion begin!
 
Regarding your second paragraph Tippit, with that much woo I have a serious question, how do you remember to breath?
 
When there's enough information available, as there is with flight 93, anyone can do it. Compare the call times to the FDR and radar altitude readings at those times.

I wasn't asking for you to speculate on how it could possibly be done, I asked who did this research, and how they did it.

You should bookmark 911myths.com. It, and a few other sites (linked in my signature) provide answers for the questions the conspiracists aren't willing to research, because they want to perpetuate these "anomalies" and "mysteries."

http://www.911myths.com/html/mom__this_is_mark_bingham.html


I looked at 911myths.com in the Flight 93 section, and I couldn't find where it mentions anything about FDR or radar analysis. I then tried to google for information on flight 93 cellphone altitude analysis, and found nothing substantial. I found a few CT sites that claim some calls were made at "cruising altitude", but how did they know that?
 
Regarding your second paragraph Tippit, with that much woo I have a serious question, how do you remember to breath?

I'm sorry, I don't know what "woo" is. Having only seen Star Wars less than ten thousand times I claim no familiarity with the vernacular, or is that some other form of nerdspeak you're using? Breath is a noun. I think you were looking for a verb. How do I remember to breathe? How do you breathe in that Storm Trooper outfit?
 
I'm sorry, I don't know what "woo" is. Having only seen Star Wars less than ten thousand times I claim no familiarity with the vernacular, or is that some other form of nerdspeak you're using?
How the rule8 does anyone find James Randi's website without knowing what woo is?
 
How the rule8 does anyone find James Randi's website without knowing what woo is?
Well, for what it's worth, I didn't really think about the usage of the word in the context that it's used here until I came to these forums.

However, a few weeks of lurking was more than sufficient for me to pick up the meaning of the word in regards to its usage here. So by the time I officially signed on I was quite familiar with it.
 
Thanks for the hopeful message, but that's unlikely. I've been at this conspiracy thing for probably far longer than you have, 1995 in fact, when I first picked up a copy of The Creature from Jekyll Island. I think the best that could happen is that we can eliminate the the most preposterous 9/11 theories from contention, but it looks like you've already done a fairly good job of that. The big problem is that I don't believe a god-damned word the government or media say anymore, not that I've been listening in recent years. I don't see how you or anyone else here can restore this lost credibility. Another problem is that I don't buy the alleged motive.

Hi Tippit. Why don't you believe anything the government says? I am of course skeptical of my countries movements, but isn't believing they are involved in the most elaborate plan on Earth a bit far? Do you not agree they would have to be literally insane? Like, mentally insane?

Then there is the problem that I've come to the conclusion that the New World Order is real. Yes, Virgina, there really are a group of elite financiers who are building a totalitarian world government, composed of the soon-to-be Pan-American Union, the European Union, and the Asian Union. Yes, the open-border policy in spite of the teeming terrorist horde that want to kill us for our freedoms is deliberate, I'm sorry to say. We will merge with Canada and Mexico, "merge" being a euphemism for invasion by peasants importing a low-standard of living, crime, and political unrest. Yes, there really are plans to introduce the Amero, the featured currency of the American Union, after the US dollar is imploded (see this thread for my explanation of how). I'm not an expert on 9/11 "evidence" but I do know money, and the Federal Reserve Conspiracy is real, and yes, it is integral to understanding all of this and putting the 9/11 false flag into context.

What evidence do you have that the NWO is real? Is it not a bit selfish Tipp, and self involved, to say your freedoms are being crushed when we look at a country like Burma in which child rape and arson are forms of torture?
 
I wasn't asking for you to speculate on how it could possibly be done, I asked who did this research, and how they did it.
And I wasn't speculating. I told you exactly how myself and others who have taken the time to answer your questions have done so.

For example:
http://www.debunk911myths.org/topics/index.php?title=Cell_phones

Use of cell phones at altitude
http://911myths.com/html/mobiles_at_altitude.html

 
What evidence do you have that the NWO is real?
And what exactly are these guys?

originalnwo5dk6gl.jpg
 
Awww, guys, I am so disappointed. This thread started out so well.


I have already split off some things to AAH. There are another batch that might get split off to a new discussion on politics and historic presidential quotes unless this thread gets back on track.

The thread was raised to discuss reducing the vitriol in this subforum, and we really need to do that. When it all moves, the personal stuff and kittens etc are likely to be ruled off-topic and uncivil, and will be removed from threads - definitely from threads that are still active.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: chillzero


Pomeroo, you know my feelings about the great work you and Gravy do. My only concern is having to censor your posts here because of personal attacks. That is all that you are asked to tone down, and it can only further your aim and raise your audience, to deliver it in a polite and reasoned manner.
 
Hi Tippit. Why don't you believe anything the government says? I am of course skeptical of my countries movements, but isn't believing they are involved in the most elaborate plan on Earth a bit far? Do you not agree they would have to be literally insane? Like, mentally insane?

Government spokespeople have a long history of lying. It is of course an overstatement to claim that everyone in the government lies, as I'm sure there are at least a few honest, hard-working people in government. However, I ascribe little value to anything that government says or does.

Are the perps literally insane, as opposed to figuratively insane? I don't think that calculated, audacious power grabs are necessarily the handiwork of the insane. The most audacious of plans tend to be the least believable, and are protected to the degree that their execution is deemed incredible.

What evidence do you have that the NWO is real? Is it not a bit selfish Tipp, and self involved, to say your freedoms are being crushed when we look at a country like Burma in which child rape and arson are forms of torture?

What evidence do you have that the NWO isn't real, or, what rock have you been living under? The evidence is countless video and print featuring politicians, bankers, scholars, executives and other luminaries admitting the existence of the New World Order, and working together to implement a one-world government. At this point I think you would have more credibility if you attempted to spin what it is than by denying its existence outright. Who knows. If you get your notion of reality from the folks who bring you Paris Hilton every night, perhaps it's not surprising that this whole NWO thing seems a bit sketchy.

I've never said that my freedoms have been "crushed". Although I can see where you thought that was implied, I would appreciate it if you don't put words in my mouth. With all due respect to the people of Burma, the slide in civil liberties in this country both pre and post 9/11 has nothing to do with the people of Burma. Nor should the abuses that may occur in Burma preclude me from defending my own liberty here.
 
This is a great example of why people get frustrated.

We have thread after thread after thread after thread after thread after thread after thread after thread after thread addressing this issue.

It has been debunked to bits. It has been debunked down to its molecules, down to the atoms, down to the subatomic particles and the invisible elves that live inside those.

And it doesn't matter. Because a message board is infinitely expandable, and they can always start another thread to drag out the same old claims. Again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and aRRRRRRRGGGGHHH!!!!!

*thump*


Bang on.

I'm not a "debunker" of any sorts - I'm one of the sideline jesters - but even I get frustrated by the sheer unwillingness of truthers to consider any of the information we present to them. I can only imagine what it feels like for Gravy, R. Mackey, Anti-Sophist, MarkyX, Boloboffin, and any of the other real debunkers who's names I have left out.

Sometimes I think that the only thing keeping the "truth" movement alive is our attention. Without us, they would fade away into relative obscurity.

The only thing which makes me think otherwise is the fact that JREF is also a relatively obscure organisation - not many people know of it. Therefore, the attention we pay to the truthers goes largely ignored in itself.

On the rare occasions when I mention the debunking sagas to my friends, their general response is "why do you even bother - no one believes in that ****". But this is starting to drift from the topic, so I will leave it at that.

To respond to the OP, I agree that it would be good if we "lighten up" on the truthers, if only to not give them any ammunition to attack us on personal grounds - which someone not familiar with logical fallacies may find convincing.

On the other hand, I have no direct connection to the events of 9/11 and I do not spend my spare hours pouring over countless documents to prove these nutters wrong, so I will not criticise those who do.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom