Can we calm down in this section please?

I've seen that video. Avery was wrong to say that about Brown, and to suggest that Olsen is complicit because he confused what kind of phone his wife was using is ridiculous.

As for the comment about the passengers, that was taken out of context to make the speaker look as if he didn't care about the passengers. I didn't get that impression at all.

I think it's a little odd that Bingham used his surname when identifying himself to his mother. I've never done that in my entire life. Does Mrs. Bingham have another son Mark by a different father? Is this proof or even evidence of phone call fakery? Hardly. Odd? I think so, yes.

Based on what I've read about cell phones, I don't think they would have worked at altitude. I'm not in a position to know this authoritatively, but I've read what appear to be contradictory statements to this effect.

I don't think the FDNY was "in on" the conspiracy.

In any event, none of these people speak for me, so I take offense at the idea that I'm disrespectful of anyone. I have a stake in wanting to know what happened on 9/11 just as much as anyone else, and I have my doubts as to what I've been told. I'm not in a position to prove anything to anyone, nor do I accept the "debunkers" explanation for certain events. I'm convinced that it's impossible to know the whole truth, and there are a lot of uncertainties that will probably never be resolved to my satisfaction.


1. Of the calls that were allegedy made with cell phones, as opposed to those shown to be made by airfones, how many were made "at Altitude"? For instance, one of the few mentioned that were via cellphone, was Felt's call from the lavatory. This was made at very low altitude, 5000-7000 feet.

2. SO do you not believe Alice Hoglan when she explained that Mark's addressing her in such a manner was not unusual and did not strike here as being "strange"?

TAM:)
 
I don't think the FDNY was "in on" the conspiracy.
Sorry, but as covered HERE, there isn't one single 9/11 conspiracy theory that, once broken down, can possibly be accomplished without either the firefighters being in on it or self-debunking pretty much every single piece of their own "best evidence" about controlled demolitions to get around it.
 
It's arrogant to assume there is a good chance you know more about chess and blackjack on any forum. They're both popular, easy to understand games.



Chess is easy to understand? Most grandmasters would disagree. At least, the ones I know would.



Blackjack is a very simple zero-sum game. I've memorized basic strategy for multiple variants, H17, S17, LS, Superfun, you name it. I've mastered hi-lo, and hi-opt 2, with index play. I've read most of the relevant books on the subject. I've made enough money playing it to pay for my trips to Las Vegas and then some. Do you know more than me? Maybe, but only an arrogant person would give a damn.


Hi-Opt II? With a side-count of aces?

I'm teasing because I used Hi-Opt II--with a side of aces--when I played in hand-held games in the eighties and nineties.

I prefer not to go into details, but although you are a good player if what you claim is true, I do know something about the game. If you own Don Schlesinger's Blackjack Attack you will notice a few clues scattered throughout the book.



It is this sort of arrogance that fuels your certainty about what happened on 9/11, and it is your ego that makes you want to ridicule all of the "twoofers" for being such supreme idiots, in your estimation. Rest assured there are probably a lot of people smarter than you who have their doubts about 9/11.


It really isn't arrogance at all. I'm just thinking statistically. How likely is it that I will find a rated master or a professional card counter on a forum frequented by a hundred or so people?

I know this sounds mean, but I don't think anybody smarter than me swallows the conspiracy moonshine. It's too silly.


Fortunately most of them are realistic enough to know that in fact, they don't know everything, and that perhaps some things simply cannot be known with any degree of certainty, no matter how authoritatively the evidence is presented.

By the way, you might want consider taking up poker. That's where all the fish are.


Actually, I took up poker over thirty years ago. I've dealt the game professionally and I ran my own game for many years. I haven't done too bad playing it, either.
 
<snip>I will shut up after this...I promise. Every person is different. Sometimes just understanding what the person is about will give you a different perspective about their post. Now, if I see Pomeroo get rude, I will understand why. It isn't just because he is a jerk.

No need to "shut up after this", jab. Your opinion is certainly valid and was eloquently stated. Jump on in any time. :)

Personally, I like both UW and Pomeroo, and would not like to see either of them leave or get their knickers in too much of a twist over this little dustup. I agree with UW's point in the OP about the response to some of the twoofer windups recently, and I hate seeing those threads go to 35 levels of derail into a twoofer free-for-all on every long-debunked point that has been raised and answered numerous times before, and sometimes they really do turn into unnecessary insult-fests when it would have, perhaps, been better to ignore them or to respond only calmly and rationally to them. I also understand why and how it is easy to get sucked into such nonsense sometimes, for reasons that others have stated previously in this thread (and others).

I disagree with UW's manner of calling Pomeroo out on this thread, though, and agree with you in that regard. It was unnecessary and, in my view, somewhat over-stated. In any event, it could have been handled much more diplomatically and without the drama of calling Pomeroo out on this thread.

Pomeroo freely admits that some of his posts have been a bit over the top, and has taken his lumps when he's been sanctioned for it, but he also explains very clearly why he has done so with cogent, rational reasons. Also, having had the benefit of seeing him on Hardfire, it is obvious that he is more than capable of separating his "public persona" from his personal posting here at the forum. I do not think that there is anything wrong with him bringing his personal side to the forum - he is human like the rest of us, after all. His positive contributions here far, far outweigh the negative.

As for the "ignore" function, it's not for me, but I think that it may very well serve a useful purpose for others, including - such as in this case - a poster just taking a break from reading the posts of another poster who annoys him/her.

Bottom line for me is that I hope UW and Pomeroo patch things up, eventually, and that neither of them leaves, or stops being themselves, or stops contributing their valuable insights here.

P.S. Welcome to the forum :w2:
 
Last edited:
I disagree with this. He is explaining why HE reacts the way he does (as he did in the paragraph above it. I omitted that paragraph because I still struggle with the quote function.)

I read this thread start to finish and I wanted to say something. I have been reading this forum for a long time. Much, much longer than I have been posting. I try to refrain because I am not as bright as the rest of you bulbs ;) and I am driven by my emotions. That leads to very BAD posting.

Anyway, I was trying to figure out who UW was referring to. I was kind of surprised it was Pomeroo. I had to go back and reread Pom's response to UW to be sure that I understood it correctly and I wasn't distracted while reading (kids yelling mom and whatnot.)

I have seen some posts by several posters here where I go "wow, that was really harsh." Pomeroo is not the only one. Don't get me wrong, I completely understand. If I were smarter and posted more, this thread would have been dedicated to me. Actually, I would have been banned.

The thing is, how can you blame anyone for getting emotional about this?? Seriously. Especially, being a New Yorker, having family or friends who were deeply and directly impacted by this tragedy. How can you? There are times that Gravy says something and I think it was snide or harsh. Then I remember how much time and energy he has spent debunking these theories and I just let it slide or realize how I would be a lot worse. Heck, even TAM said something the other day that I was shocked about. (not too much later, he got a yellow card for it) If it were me, I would have a really hard time not saying "you rule[8] moron" followed up with a smack in the face.

I also think that Pomeroo can use "New Yorker." I cannot imagine what it was like to be there as the events unfolded. It is so different being there than watching it on TV. Remember what it was like when you saw it on TV, you were horrified, speechless, etc. But then remember how much worse it was when they started playing the voicemails of the people stuck above the impact area in the towers. You know the ones saying goodbye, or that they were scared. I was already beside myself watching it, but then they started playing the voicemails. I think I would have lost it if I had been a New Yorker too. I totally think New Yorkers (obviously, not counting people who actually lost family members) were impacted by this event more than others. If the news wasn't enough of a constant reminder, you have smells, sights and sounds that lingered longer than the news because it happened in your backyard.

Furthermore, I think that if actual first responders were on this forum, they would make Pomeroo look like a girl scout. That is probably why they aren't here. You want to see emotion and reaming people a new one...they would be at the top of the list.

I am a little disappointed about UW putting Pomeroo on ignore. The first reaction people have when confronted about their behavior is to be defensive. Cut him some slack. Pomeroo explained why he gets the way he does. He admitted he was rude and uncivil. Didn't he say he would try to behave? But he was put on ignore anyway. He didn't completely cave in, but he acted like he would try to behave. He even said he didn't hate Rev. Come on that's a start!

I am going out on a limb here and am ready for attack. Ok, I am bracing myself.... UW, I think you handled this wrong. I was oblivious (no shocker there) to whom the OP was referring, but the rest of you knew. You included enough info in the OP for people to figure out who it was. Why even bother "not mentioning names"? Just friggen come out and say 'Pomeroo, I think you are getting carried away here and you are ticking me off.' Don't beat around the bush. Pom can come back and say 'this is why, sorry I will try harder' then we could go to the group hug. I think he would have respected that approach more. I understand the OP can be applied to other posters here as well, but it is clear to me that you were having an issue with Pomeroo. I am not surprised that Pomeroo was defensive in the beginning because of the way you presented it. It reminded me of a meeting where the supervisor doesn't have the guts to come right out and say it to the employee, so he calls everyone in, because they all are guilty of it from time to time. However, as the meeting progresses it is obvious who the "bad" employee is. In this case, not only did the bad employee get scolded in front of everyone, he was fired (put on ignore) too.

Maybe that was not the way it was intended to come across, but that is how it looked to me.

I will shut up after this...I promise. Every person is different. Sometimes just understanding what the person is about will give you a different perspective about their post. Now, if I see Pomeroo get rude, I will understand why. It isn't just because he is a jerk.


How the hell do you know I'm not a jerk, you [rule 8]ing [rule 8]?!

Kidding--just kidding. Sheesh!

Seriously, Mark has spent much more time than I have at Ground Zero, and I'd bet heavily that he can recount exchanges with twoofers that would make you lose your breakfast.

I will strive for a kinder, gentler pomeroo--the pomeroo that my little doggies know and love.
 
1. Of the calls that were allegedy made with cell phones, as opposed to those shown to be made by airfones, how many were made "at Altitude"? For instance, one of the few mentioned that were via cellphone, was Felt's call from the lavatory. This was made at very low altitude, 5000-7000 feet.

I don't know. How many? Who established the altitude at which calls were originated, and how?

2. SO do you not believe Alice Hoglan when she explained that Mark's addressing her in such a manner was not unusual and did not strike here as being "strange"?

TAM:)

I find it strange, whether or not she found it strange. On the other hand, I would hope a mother is able to authenticate her own son over the phone. Who asked her this question anyway?
 
No need to "shut up after this", jab. Your opinion is certainly valid and was eloquently stated. Jump on in any time. :)

Personally, I like both UW and Pomeroo, and would not like to see either of them leave or get their knickers in too much of a twist over this little dustup. I agree with UW's point in the OP about the response to some of the twoofer windups recently, and I hate seeing those threads go to 35 levels of derail into a twoofer free-for-all on every long-debunked point that has been raised and answered numerous times before, and sometimes they really do turn into unnecessary insult-fests when it would have, perhaps, been better to ignore them or to respond only calmly and rationally to them. I also understand why and how it is easy to get sucked into such nonsense sometimes, for reasons that others have stated previously in this thread (and others).

I disagree with UW's manner of calling Pomeroo out on this thread, though, and agree with you in that regard. It was unnecessary and, in my view, somewhat over-stated. In any event, it could have been handled much more diplomatically and without the drama of calling Pomeroo out on this thread.

Pomeroo freely admits that some of his posts have been a bit over the top, and has taken his lumps when he's been sanctioned for it, but he also explains very clearly why he has done so with cogent, rational reasons. Also, having had the benefit of seeing him on Hardfire, it is obvious that he is more than capable of separating his "public persona" from his personal posting here at the forum. I do not think that there is anything wrong with him bringing his personal side to the forum - he is human like the rest of us, after all. His positive contributions here far, far outweigh the negative.

As for the "ignore" function, it's not for me, but I think that it may very well serve a useful purpose for others, including - in this case - just taking a break from reading the posts of someone who annoys you.

Bottom line for me is that I hope UW and Pomeroo patch things up, eventually, and that neither of them leaves, or stops being themselves, or stops contributing their valuable insights here.

P.S. Welcome to the forum :w2:


My peace offer to UW stands.
 
Sorry, but as covered HERE, there isn't one single 9/11 conspiracy theory that, once broken down, can possibly be accomplished without either the firefighters being in on it or self-debunking pretty much every single piece of their own "best evidence" about controlled demolitions to get around it.

I find that ridiculous. I thought of one just now. Lets assume that the 9/11 narrative is 100% true, from the nineteen hijackers to Osama Bin Laden. But instead of "Islamic fascism" and a keen hatred of the west being Bin Laden's motive, he was instead paid off handsomely by some wealthy operative in the west, who himself had some other motive. Lets call it the "Bin Laden was taking orders from someone else" theory. It precludes the complicity of firefighter involvement altogether. However unlikely you think this possibility is, it remains. Maybe you should recount the possibilities.
 
I find that ridiculous. I thought of one just now. Lets assume that the 9/11 narrative is 100% true, from the nineteen hijackers to Osama Bin Laden. But instead of "Islamic fascism" and a keen hatred of the west being Bin Laden's motive, he was instead paid off handsomely by some wealthy operative in the west, who himself had some other motive. Lets call it the "Bin Laden was taking orders from someone else" theory. It precludes the complicity of firefighter involvement altogether. However unlikely you think this possibility is, it remains. Maybe you should recount the possibilities.
Unicorns with invisibility powder works too, but I meant any of the theories that truthers actually care about pursuing.
 
I've seen that video. Avery was wrong to say that about Brown

It is not only "wrong", it is completely reprehensible to accuse someone of sacrificing their own child, to support a ridiculous theory the accuser has no evidence for and after six years has yet to put together a coherent narrative of.

to suggest that Olsen is complicit because he confused what kind of phone his wife was using is ridiculous.

I agree, it is ridiculous. However, many leaders of the 9-11 Truth Movement -- you know, those people who are just questioning the events of 9-11, like you -- make that very argument.

As for the comment about the passengers, that was taken out of context to make the speaker look as if he didn't care about the passengers. I didn't get that impression at all.

Well, I do get that impression, and so do a lot of other people. Part of the reason I get that impression is because of the complete lack of care for the passengers Dylan Avery has shown in numerous other stupid remarks he's made over the years. (I can't believe I forgot "LOL boxcutters.") The comment about the passengers was not a one-time incident to which benefit of the doubt may be applied.

I think it's a little odd that Bingham used his surname when identifying himself to his mother. Is this proof or even evidence of phone call fakery? Hardly. Odd? I think so, yes.

This factoid is routinely cited by 9-11 Truthers as ironclad proof that the person calling was not Mark Bingham. Here's Jim Fetzer, speaking in this article:

"We have had phony tapes before using voices that were authentic. Mark Bingham, a passenger on Flight 93, is supposed to have called his mother and said, 'Hi, Mom, this is Mark Bingham!' His mother confirmed it was his voice, but does anyone seriously believe that Mark Bingham would have used his last name in identifying himself to his mother?"

Your original objection was to Pomeroo's description of 9-11 doubters as stupid and evil. This theory requires the conspirators to either move Mark Bingham someplace other than the fated flight and kill him there, keep him on the plane and call his own mother using somebody else's voice, or something even more ludicrous. Either way, it insists that the person on the phone was not Mark Bingham, and that his own mother was some kind of dunderhead for believing it was. This theory is about as good an example of "stupid and evil" that exists anywhere in the universe.

Based on what I've read about cell phones, I don't think they would have worked at altitude.

Then I suggest you defer to people who are in a position to know this authoritatively. I'm sure the Links section here can point you in the right direction.

I don't think the FDNY was "in on" the conspiracy.

Well, there's no shortage of "people questioning 9-11" who do. FDNY complicity is central to one of the most popular conspiracy theories out there, namely the one involving Larry Silverstein's "pull it" remark.

In any event, none of these people speak for me, so I take offense at the idea that I'm disrespectful of anyone.

Excuse me? Since you entered this thread you've done nothing but lecture us about how "people who question the 9-11 story" comport themselves intellectually. For you to now get your nose out of joint when I lump you with them when you share the same beliefs, is disingenuous.

And if you have any doubt about the basic events of 9-11, then these people jolly well DO speak for you, as they are the leaders of the 9-11 Truth movement.
 
I don't know. How many? Who established the altitude at which calls were originated, and how?



I find it strange, whether or not she found it strange. On the other hand, I would hope a mother is able to authenticate her own son over the phone. Who asked her this question anyway?

This is a great example of why people get frustrated.

We have thread after thread after thread after thread after thread after thread after thread after thread after thread addressing this issue.

It has been debunked to bits. It has been debunked down to its molecules, down to the atoms, down to the subatomic particles and the invisible elves that live inside those.

And it doesn't matter. Because a message board is infinitely expandable, and they can always start another thread to drag out the same old claims. Again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and aRRRRRRRGGGGHHH!!!!!

*thump*
 
My peace offer to UW stands.

Quoted for UW.

Having said that, if UW is still upset/angry/(not sure what word to use here) it may be best to give the ignore feature a few days yet.

It can be very useful as a tool to help calm down.
 
Chess is easy to understand? Most grandmasters would disagree. At least, the ones I know would.

But who doesn't know a few grandmasters, really? I won't brag. But the ubiquity and relative simplicity of chess pretty much guarantees that you're going to find some accomplished chess players on a computer forum. As an aside, Gary Kasparov has one of the biggest egos any person I've ever seen.

Hi-Opt II? With a side-count of aces?

I'm teasing because I used Hi-Opt II--with a side of aces--when I played in hand-held games in the eighties and nineties.

I prefer not to go into details, but although you are a good player if what you claim is true, I do know something about the game. If you own Don Schlesinger's Blackjack Attack you will notice a few clues scattered throughout the book.

Yes, Hi-Opt II. I used it for a specific single-deck variant of blackjack in Barona, California, where keeping track of Aces is very profitable. I own Schlesinger's book and it is excellent, although the tables are a bit dated given the existence of CVCX.

It really isn't arrogance at all. I'm just thinking statistically. How likely is it that I will find a rated master or a professional card counter on a forum frequented by a hundred or so people?

I know this sounds mean, but I don't think anybody smarter than me swallows the conspiracy moonshine. It's too silly.

Well, you found one. I think at this point in history I'm more inclined to take a swig of the conspiracy moonshine than the government kool-aid. As for whether or not you're smarter than I, if you're ever in Southern California we can play some backgammon for stakes. I'll even compliment you on how intelligent you are, after you pay me off.

Actually, I took up poker over thirty years ago. I've dealt the game professionally and I ran my own game for many years. I haven't done too bad playing it, either.

Yes, it's a fantastic game. The best thing about poker is that it is easy to learn, but difficult to play well. It is easy to attribute poker success to skill rather than luck, which makes it a gold mine for those of us willing to take the time to know the odds.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom