Can we calm down in this section please?

On the behalf of DGM


Why are you trying to derail this thread?

Unlikely:


1) Secret societies are not permitted in communist countries.


2) a foreign power could not announce the need for increasing our security, doing so would require legislation, such as the "patriot act"


3) The last quote is a very accurate description of the Council on Foreign Relations, which every president we have had since Woodrow Wilson has been a member of. Except for Kennedy and Reagan - who was also shot by a 'lone gunman"



Was he talking about communism when he said:

I'm on ignore so if someone wouldn't mind relaying this to REV.
 
"The high office of President has been used to foment a plot to destroy American freedom, and before I leave office I must inform the citizen of his plight."


JFK said this? When? All right, I'll bite: What on earth could he have been referring to?
I really want to see the source for this quote.


All right, I was doing it again. I really do intend to mend my nasty ways.
The quote is bogus and I happen to know that it's bogus. I know this because I checked it out a couple of years ago on a libertarian forum.

http://www.jfklibrary.org/Historica...Reference+Desk/Columbia+University+Speech.htm


Columbia University "Speech"


President Kennedy's supposed speech at Columbia University, November, 1963.

Many references to this fictitious speech exist in assassination theorist material. Supposedly, the President was discussing changes in the Federal Reserve and the gold standard, and this topic was somehow linked to his assassination. Others also claim he said, "The high office of President has been used to foment a plot to destroy American freedom, and before I leave office I must inform the citizen of his plight." But the simple fact is that President John F. Kennedy did not speak at Columbia University in November of 1963.
Those who believe in the "fact" of President Kennedy having made such a speech, either at Columbia or some other place, will simply deny this denial. At best, they will say that because "all or most records" have been destroyed, we simply don't know the truth; at worst, they will claim that there is a conspiracy to keep this issue silent. If someone chooses to believe in the existence of this speech, he or she does so as a matter of faith, which is fine, as long as that person realizes that it is religion and not history in which he or she is dealing.
 
Last edited:
"The high office of President has been used to foment a plot to destroy American freedom, and before I leave office I must inform the citizen of his plight."


JFK said this? When? All right, I'll bite: What on earth could he have been referring to?
I really want to see the source for this quote.

I agree, it sounds completely made up.
 
Given my conversations with pomeroo here, I have put him on ignore. Nothing personal on his human persona, but his internet personality stirs the blood in me. This thus causes exchanges that go against the basic ideal of my thread here.

I simply find nothing of use in anything pomeroo (notice I do not say 'Ron' here) has to say, so until he gets a better grasp on using a forum, I'm not listening.

Nothing personal Ron.

But Pomeroo, yes it is.
 
Further comment on JFK's "quote':

Kevin Nelson cited this in his 'Notable, Quotable Presidents' story. He subsequently wrote about it in his retraction: "My apologies for the inclusion of several quotes of questionable authenticity. I was duped by the sheer ubiquity of the Kennedy quote, from a diverse range of websites professing ideologically opposite agendas. In my hours of searching for a definitive source for this quote, I checked a UCSB website that chronicles presidential speeches, but all of the Kennedy links were down. They did have him speaking in New York City in the days before the Columbia speech, and as the site is not comprehensive, there is a possibility he was at Columbia on the 12th. This will require further research, and calls to Columbia University and the Kennedy Library."

http://fangfacedreamweaver.6te.net/quotes/qtfalsely.html
 
I wan't you to examine people other than truthers, such as the lying swines in the government who really do have no scruples.

All those who believe every word that emantes from a politician's mouth raise your hand,,, er ,, post your agreement here.

Therein lies one problem with those who believe that 911 was an inside job. It comes up over and over again that they assume all of us who say, "wait a minute , this that or the other thing you are saying makes no sense for this that and other reasons", are loyal American Republican Party members who believe and follow the lead of outr politicians. This of course bears little resembelance to the reality. while a few people here actually like the present adin or at least are Americans and republicans, many of us truly do not.

I am not an American and be definition neither am I a Republican Party supporter. In fact I voted "New Democratic Party" (a socialist party) in the last Canadian Federal election. I believe strongly that GWB and his administration will be seen by history as the worst in US history. I believe that GWB, Cheney and Rumsfeld are not only incompetant to do the jobs they had but utterly incompetant to further the goals of the neo-conservative movement.

To be then have it implied that I am just toadying along with the pronouncements of politicians, let alone those of a foreign government(foreign to me) galls me to no end.

Compounding this is the fact that many is the time that I am told this by someone who while making technical/scientific pronouncements illustrates their complete misrepresentation or utter lack of comprehension of what they are attempting to pontificate about.

I certainly try to keep the sarcasm down but man is it hard when someone tells you that gravity or Hooke's Law do not work in the fashion that I was taught they do by university professors or who demonstrates a lack of ability to do simple algebraic manouvers.
 
Given my conversations with pomeroo here, I have put him on ignore. Nothing personal on his human persona, but his internet personality stirs the blood in me. This thus causes exchanges that go against the basic ideal of my thread here.

I simply find nothing of use in anything pomeroo (notice I do not say 'Ron' here) has to say, so until he gets a better grasp on using a forum, I'm not listening.

Nothing personal Ron.

But Pomeroo, yes it is.


My "internet personality" is that of someone who despises the conspiracy theorists for their dishonesty and their smears of innocent people. If that "stirs the blood" of someone who seems to agree with me about what's happening in the world, then I am baffled. Truly, utterly mystified. I'm sure you feel you're making a point, but I don't comprehend it.

A young twoofer presents a bogus JFK quote and I expose it--why is that of no value? Why didn't you expose it yourself?
 
Would you care to join TAM in playing an online game with me?
I am on a self imposed retirement from live games but i'll gladly play you via email so it can be leisurely. What is this now, a forum for chessaholics????
 
Given my conversations with pomeroo here, I have put him on ignore. Nothing personal on his human persona, but his internet personality stirs the blood in me. This thus causes exchanges that go against the basic ideal of my thread here.

I simply find nothing of use in anything pomeroo (notice I do not say 'Ron' here) has to say, so until he gets a better grasp on using a forum, I'm not listening.

Nothing personal Ron.

But Pomeroo, yes it is.
I think this is probably a good idea for now. There's an awful lot of emotion here on both sides, and I would hate to lose either of you due to an internet feud.
 
Undesired Walrus said:
and I have evidence many here are sick of it.

Well, if this is true, I will withdraw from the fray.

Pomeroo, I wish to say on the record that I am NOT sick of you. I admire what you say about the reprehensible people that make up the 9-11 conspiracy movement, and the way you say it.
 
Pomeroo, I wish to say on the record that I am NOT sick of you. I admire what you say about the reprehensible people that make up the 9-11 conspiracy movement, and the way you say it.


Thank you. I sincerely appreciate the kind words.
 
Given my conversations with pomeroo here, I have put him on ignore. Nothing personal on his human persona, but his internet personality stirs the blood in me. This thus causes exchanges that go against the basic ideal of my thread here.

I simply find nothing of use in anything pomeroo (notice I do not say 'Ron' here) has to say, so until he gets a better grasp on using a forum, I'm not listening.

Nothing personal Ron.

But Pomeroo, yes it is.

UW:

Well, I think that is a little hasty, given we seem to making "some" progress here. "Pomeroo" is really an extension of Ron, and while it maybe one that, at present you find irritates, to the extreme, "pomeroo" has offered alot to this forum, in terms of his insight, and his approaching the people who can provide the facts on the issues.

That said, this is not a marriage, and I am not your priest of counsellor, so, whatever will be...will be.

TAM:)
 
I think this is probably a good idea for now. There's an awful lot of emotion here on both sides, and I would hate to lose either of you due to an internet feud.


I find it crazy to be feuding with someone with whom I agree almost completely.
 
2¢:

this pains me, like Steve Reich and Richard Dawkins fighting.

I'm a fan of both the walrus and the polar bear.

I look through the new posts, and will read anything by Pomeroo.

(He's part of a list of must-reads that includes others with different styles.)

Apollo/Greening is also worth reading--even his condemnations of the forum.

This forum depends on controversy for interest, and anything short of threats of violence should be allowed. I'm a supporter of looser standards and less enforced civility. Nor should we hold ourselves to some standard of 'true skepticism' or open-mindedness. Or attempt to feign open-mindedness.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom