Can/should European nations maintain their white majorities?

As far as "gammons" would consider, the only British language is English. Native Welsh and Gaelic speakers are just bloody minded trouble-makers and Cornish is just a type of pasty.

Languages which have been "imported" are completely unacceptable, regardless of how many people speak them because they dilute our culture. Instead they will sit in their pyjamas in their bungalows and call some kind of ombudsman. ;)

I'm not sure that's what's being argued here.
I thought the idea was that anything after the Romans was the language of immigrants, and the only true British language was Celtic? (I don't know where Latin stands in this, but racist theories of culture are not known for their coherence or consistency.)
 
I want to nominate you for something...anything...this post need it...this forum is obliged to give it the recognition it deserves.

Also...who should I make the cheque out to?


Ha ha ha, thank you, Susheel. Check already received: you appreciation is payment enough. Go ahead now and write that bestseller if you like! :thumbsup:


Actually, yes, I’d thought it a fun idea when I’d posted that, and now that I reread it, it still sounds like a cool idea, though I say it myself, for a sci fi about a post-color world ---- or, seen differently, a whole-*******-riot-of-colors world. You look at a guy, or girl, and immediately figure out where they’re from. And everyone within a country’s the exact same color, so, finally, we’ll have an end to this accursed BS about skin color that keeps plaguing us even in this day and age; and that these two weird threads keep going on and on about, without any hope of ever coming to any kind of resolution, neither over here nor in the larger world outside.
 
I'm not sure that's what's being argued here.
I thought the idea was that anything after the Romans was the language of immigrants, and the only true British language was Celtic? (I don't know where Latin stands in this, but racist theories of culture are not known for their coherence or consistency.)

What's being argued, IMO, is that there was a high water mark for British English culture which has been diluted by various things including:

  • Immigration and immigrants, especially those that don't speak English as their native language and/or those who aren't white
  • Acceptance of people who aren't cis-gendered heterosexuals
  • Families other than Dad, Mum and 2.4 children
  • People with religions other than Church of England Christianity - including those without any religion
  • People "pandering" to minorities
  • Welsh and Scottish nationalists (including the standing of Welsh and Scots Gaelic) and devolution - they should be grateful for rule from London
  • Any kind of change which is deemed undesirable by those harping back to those "good old days"

They don't care about original inhabitants, languages and culture because those inhabitants, languages and culture were clearly inferior.
 
those inhabitants, languages and culture were clearly inferior.
It has nothing to do with the original inhabitants, inferior or otherwise. Look, I think one of the basic differences in worldview is about the extent to which realist concerns are still a factor in the world. To frame it in its most extreme way, imagine yourself a some barbarian tribe. The world is full of dangers. There are reasons why you might not trust any random stranger and let them in to your tribe, there is a reason why you'd want your children to fulfil particular roles, pair up and have kids. The world imposes practical constraints.

Since the war, American power and prosperity has meant that there are no real threats, more so since 1991, and at a societal level, there is no shortage of resources. I think you have two reactions to that. You have one reaction, which is say "terrific" and explore the possibilities of a world where many of the constraints have gone away. The other reaction is to see that safety and wealth as having arisen out of a particular set of behaviours that need to be maintained, at least to some degree, to sustain the safety and wealth. The second group have clearly lost, we will see what happens.
 
It has nothing to do with the original inhabitants, inferior or otherwise. Look, I think one of the basic differences in worldview is about the extent to which realist concerns are still a factor in the world. To frame it in its most extreme way, imagine yourself a some barbarian tribe. The world is full of dangers. There are reasons why you might not trust any random stranger and let them in to your tribe, there is a reason why you'd want your children to fulfil particular roles, pair up and have kids. The world imposes practical constraints.

Since the war, American power and prosperity has meant that there are no real threats, more so since 1991, and at a societal level, there is no shortage of resources. I think you have two reactions to that. You have one reaction, which is say "terrific" and explore the possibilities of a world where many of the constraints have gone away. The other reaction is to see that safety and wealth as having arisen out of a particular set of behaviours that need to be maintained, at least to some degree, to sustain the safety and wealth. The second group have clearly lost, we will see what happens.

Weak and completely incoherent.
 
What's being argued, IMO, is that there was a high water mark for British English culture which has been diluted by various things including:

  • Immigration and immigrants, especially those that don't speak English as their native language and/or those who aren't white
  • Acceptance of people who aren't cis-gendered heterosexuals
  • Families other than Dad, Mum and 2.4 children
  • People with religions other than Church of England Christianity - including those without any religion
  • People "pandering" to minorities
  • Welsh and Scottish nationalists (including the standing of Welsh and Scots Gaelic) and devolution - they should be grateful for rule from London
  • Any kind of change which is deemed undesirable by those harping back to those "good old days"

They don't care about original inhabitants, languages and culture because those inhabitants, languages and culture were clearly inferior.

Mostly agreed, with the exception of the C of E. Our resident racist apologist is not a Christian, and appears to oppose religion in general. This is most probably because religion, for all its faults, lays out a system of morality, and this particular member is also opposed to morality.
I'm not sure about the status of the Welsh and Scottish minorities, at least according to the perverse viewpoint being advanced here. I believe that, as remnants of the original British (i.e. pre-Roman) culture, they are actually more authentically British than anything Anglo-Saxon or London-centric.
The propensity for Druidic human sacrifice is presumably one of the aspects of original British culture that our 'humble Burkean conservative' does not wish to maintain, despite its central role in that culture. Because reasons we mere mortals cannot possibly comprehend. :rolleyes:
 
Mostly agreed, with the exception of the C of E. Our resident racist apologist is not a Christian, and appears to oppose religion in general.
If you are talking about me, you are mistaken. I have said already, that I am not against religion. There was another poster who mistakenly thought that implying liberal moral truths were in some way equivalent to religious truths was me using religion as a pejorative.
 
If you are talking about me, you are mistaken. I have said already, that I am not against religion. There was another poster who mistakenly thought that implying liberal moral truths were in some way equivalent to religious truths was me using religion as a pejorative.

Extremely weak form of "If I don't want to follow the rules of your puny society you can't make me, harharhar!!"
 
Eventually, there'll only be white minorities. Should/could/oughta/supposed to/u.s.w. European countries preserve them? Will the idea even occur to anybody?
 
Extremely weak form of "If I don't want to follow the rules of your puny society you can't make me, harharhar!!"

It's all a bit too Red Dragon for my tastes.
"I will not be bound by pedestrian concepts of morality! I will soar above your petty and leaden ideas of shared values! PUNY MORTALS! YOU WILL QUAIL BEFORE THE MAGNIFICENCE OF MY BECOMING!"
*Voice from below*
"That's nice dear, but we haven't got any quails. Now come down for your supper, because your fish fingers are becoming cold."
 
It's all a bit too Red Dragon for my tastes.
"I will not be bound by pedestrian concepts of morality! I will soar above your petty and leaden ideas of shared values! PUNY MORTALS! YOU WILL QUAIL BEFORE THE MAGNIFICENCE OF MY BECOMING!"
*Voice from below*
"That's nice dear, but we haven't got any quails. Now come down for your supper, because your fish fingers are becoming cold."

:D:thumbsup: Yeah, the "I don't need to obey your idea of morality because of reasons" gets me the most.
 
It has nothing to do with the original inhabitants, inferior or otherwise. Look, I think one of the basic differences in worldview is about the extent to which realist concerns are still a factor in the world. To frame it in its most extreme way, imagine yourself a some barbarian tribe. The world is full of dangers. There are reasons why you might not trust any random stranger and let them in to your tribe, there is a reason why you'd want your children to fulfil particular roles, pair up and have kids. The world imposes practical constraints.

Since the war, American power and prosperity has meant that there are no real threats, more so since 1991, and at a societal level, there is no shortage of resources. I think you have two reactions to that. You have one reaction, which is say "terrific" and explore the possibilities of a world where many of the constraints have gone away. The other reaction is to see that safety and wealth as having arisen out of a particular set of behaviours that need to be maintained, at least to some degree, to sustain the safety and wealth. The second group have clearly lost, we will see what happens.

I'm concerned about realist concerns, because most of these cultural realists seem to throw their hands up and say we can't do much about it, indeed shouldn't do much about it, and spend most of their time chastising liberals or progressives who are trying to change things, who usually approach the issues from a position of empathy.

Our minds are quite plastic. We aren't resigned to our natural tendencies. We can acknowledge them and at the same time make an effort to move past them if they don't uncover some serious threat to our safety or survival.
 
If you are talking about me, you are mistaken. I have said already, that I am not against religion. There was another poster who mistakenly thought that implying liberal moral truths were in some way equivalent to religious truths was me using religion as a pejorative.
Yes, that is in the archives.

What follows is recycled from a post that appears to have been sent to AAH because it responded to a back-and-forth that was off-topic. I have deleted the offending text.

I know the examples, you linked to them before. Me saying I don't share your religion is not a condemnation of religion.
Saying you don't share someone's religion could have been said honestly. Your rhetoric was dishonest because you yourself inserted religion and religious ideas into the conversation. You did that because you wanted to characterize your opponents' arguments as religious in nature, which they weren't. The reason you wanted to characterize their arguments as religious is because you couldn't think of a better way to pretend their arguments were irrational. Your religious rhetoric was doubly dishonest because, as you later admitted, you yourself have a positive view of religion.

The problem is that one set of values are being pushed out from the US and infecting everything else. Doing that is causing stresses to build up that is causing things to fracture. That is like some kind of value imperialism.
American imperialism raises its ugly head. Again. This time, however, it isn't literal imperialism. It's value imperialism, or moral imperialism, or intellectual imperialism.

shuttit writes as though the rest of the world (or maybe just Europe, or maybe just the UK, or maybe just England) doesn't have the values, morals, or intellect to withstand the American juggernaut. I'm sorry to hear about shuttit's low opinion of those non-Americans, but the title of this thread does not ask whether European nations can maintain their white values/morals/intellect against the American onslaught.
 
I'm concerned about realist concerns, because most of these cultural realists seem to throw their hands up and say we can't do much about it, indeed shouldn't do much about it, and spend most of their time chastising liberals or progressives who are trying to change things, who usually approach the issues from a position of empathy.

Our minds are quite plastic. We aren't resigned to our natural tendencies. We can acknowledge them and at the same time make an effort to move past them if they don't uncover some serious threat to our safety or survival.

Tribalism is a natural instinct for the reasons shuttit explains, but so's hitting people over the head and taking their stuff. Civilised people control and, when necessary, overrule their natural instincts. Tribalism is dangerous in modern multicultural societies and civilised people need to overrule it when they find themselves thinking in those terms, in the same way they overrule the urge to hit someone.
 
I'm concerned about realist concerns, because most of these cultural realists seem to throw their hands up and say we can't do much about it, indeed shouldn't do much about it, and spend most of their time chastising liberals or progressives who are trying to change things, who usually approach the issues from a position of empathy.

Our minds are quite plastic. We aren't resigned to our natural tendencies. We can acknowledge them and at the same time make an effort to move past them if they don't uncover some serious threat to our safety or survival.
As much as notionally we may not be resigned to our natural tendencies, we pretty clearly haven't actually escaped them. Just look at the difference in the difference in the rate of violent offending between men and women. This is still a world in which these old tendencies are powerful forces that we ignore at our peril.
 
As much as notionally we may not be resigned to our natural tendencies, we pretty clearly haven't actually escaped them. Just look at the difference in the difference in the rate of violent offending between men and women. This is still a world in which these old tendencies are powerful forces that we ignore at our peril.

We certainly shouldn't ignore them, teaching children where they come from, and why they should no longer be tolerated, is essential for peaceful multicultural societies.

We have laws against violence, and also (generally) against hate speech and discrimination. The OP wonders if exceptions should be made for the last to "maintain white majorities" - it is asking whether one particular natural instinct, tribalism, should be indulged, not ignored. I'm saying it should be neither indulged nor ignored but actively discouraged.
 
We certainly shouldn't ignore them, teaching children where they come from, and why they should no longer be tolerated, is essential for peaceful multicultural societies.
Ok, but if it turns out not in fact to be possible to teach these things away?

We have laws against violence, and also (generally) against hate speech and discrimination. The OP wonders if exceptions should be made for the last to "maintain white majorities" - it is asking whether one particular natural instinct, tribalism, should be indulged, not ignored. I'm saying it should be neither indulged nor ignored but actively discouraged.
Tolerating these things or not doesn't make them go away. Violent crime is discouraged and look at how much violent crime there is. Maybe that isn't what you expect to happen, but I think it underpins a lot of the arguments.
 
OK, let's look at how much violent crime there is.
Oh, it's been declining steadily, worldwide, for decades.
Interestingly, one of the reasons given for the fall in violent crime rates is........*drumroll*........
Immigration!
Studies of the United States have shown that increases in the concentration of immigrants are associated with decreases in violent crime rates, especially homicide and robbery. This relationship suggests that increasing immigration to the United States may be responsible for part of the recent drop in violent crime rates in the United States.

The crime drop or crime decline is a pattern observed in many countries whereby rates of many types of crime declined by 50% or more beginning in the mid to late 1980s and early 1990s.

On average, international crime declines from 1995 to 2004 were as follows: 77.1 percent in theft from cars, 60.3 percent in theft from person, 26.0 percent in burglary, 20.6 percent in assault and 16.8 percent in car theft. The crime drop since the early 1990s has occurred in many countries, including the United States, the United Kingdom, and New Zealand.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crime_drop

The graphs in this link are quite illuminating- they show a dramatic drop in homicide rates, from the Middle Ages up to the present.
With reference to the topic of this thread, it is interesting to note that the supposed golden ages of white majorities and limited immigration that the OP wishes to preserve were characterised by markedly high rates of violence.
 
Ok, but if it turns out not in fact to be possible to teach these things away?


Tolerating these things or not doesn't make them go away. Violent crime is discouraged and look at how much violent crime there is. Maybe that isn't what you expect to happen, but I think it underpins a lot of the arguments.

Young kids who are not brought up with racism don't care about skin colour. When my kids were young, I could see how they and their friends played together.

And how they described which friend was which.
 
OK, let's look at how much violent crime there is.
Oh, it's been declining steadily, worldwide, for decades.
Interestingly, one of the reasons given for the fall in violent crime rates is........*drumroll*........
Immigration!



https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crime_drop

The graphs in this link are quite illuminating- they show a dramatic drop in homicide rates, from the Middle Ages up to the present.
With reference to the topic of this thread, it is interesting to note that the supposed golden ages of white majorities and limited immigration that the OP wishes to preserve were characterised by markedly high rates of violence.

Anecdote from long ago when I was 15 or so. I was on my way home in the bus when an older lady, about 60 or so, sat next to me and then started complaining about how the youth of today was rotten and how there was so much more violence in the streets etc etc.
I got fed up and told her that when she was my age dutch Blackshirts were marching down the streets beating up anyone disagreeing with their politics or actual razzias.

She got angry and moved to a different part of the bus.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom