Can/should European nations maintain their white majorities?

****, man. There you go, pulling that same old stunt again.

Whether you support issue A in polity X, or not, what the **** does that have to do with what others think of it, and why? Are you opinions and decisions no more than a reflection, or distorted refraction, of others' views ---- is that yet another fresh Burke-ism you're going to introduce here, that you've no opinions that are independent of others' opinions?
My opinions on what would be a good policy is based on what I think would be the effect of that policy in the world. That necessarily involves other people. Policy positions that do not take into account how they would work in the real world seem like decadent affectations to me.

I'm not dancing this weird dance any more. For the last time, here's something that might, if you read it with an open mind, get you to see what you're getting sorely wrong, all of your reading of political philosophy notwithstanding: If you're religious, then your religion gives you set-in-stone morals and answers to (most) ethical questions.
I gree.

If you're a skeptic, you no longer have that certainty. You must now work things out on your own.
Maybe.

But that doesn't mean you operate in a moral vacuum, that doesn't mean you are unable to decide right from wrong, ever. And that working out things on your own means having to inform yourself adequately, or as adequately as you can, to formulate meaningful opinions.
I don't operate in a moral vacuum. My morality is based on how I think things are going to play out in the world, hence I'm suspicious of abstract moral claims to truth.

Well, that's how, it seems to me, it would work with pragmatism. (And indeed, in the sense I've just now spelt out, we're all of us pragmatists!)
No. Pragmatism is about practical solutions in the real world, not abstract moral statements that are invariant of real world practicality. That is the opposite of pragmatism. You were being pragmatic when you said something like you didn't have the stomach for your principles if the costs were too high in terms of lives. What you are looking for is an unpragmatic, morally absolutist answer, which is exactly what I am uncomfortable with.

If you're asked whether you'd support banning mixed-race marriages, then, if you wish to seriously engage with that question, if only to yourself, then it is on you, you not us, to find out what the factors are that would drive your decision, and how they stand.
I've told you. In the UK there is absolutely zero possibility of this being implemented, so either we have to suppose mind control is involved, or we are looking at whether it is sensible to push a policy that will not be implemented and what the implications of pushing a policy that won't be implemented will be. Interracial weddings will certainly not be impacted. Pragmatically, the question is nonsense. You might as well ask me how many angels can dance on the head of a pin.

You live in UK, you've said, so fine: If the party you vote for decided on that as a major plank for the next election, would you support it?
They would be completely destroyed. I doubt they would make it to the election. The entire media machine would turn on them. There would be riots. The civil service would refuse to cooperate. There is no practical way this could happen. If some unforeseeable miracle occurred that suddenly made this a popular position, you need to tell me what that miracle would be. Clearly something is going on that is making people think this is necessary.

Basis an as-is situation, assuming things are exactly as they are now, what would you decide? That's on you, man, not others asking the question.
It couldn't happen as is. Their leader would be removed from office. Again, any such policy would come with an explanation justifying it. Given that they would certainly be destroyed, and I don't regard it as an important issue, and if they made this the centre of their platform without explanation.... then maybe I would assume they had gone mad. This is not the real world we are talking about. In the real world politicians try to frame issues like this around some kind of justification and don't in any case put forward policies that would make the entire ruling elite foam at the mouth.

What the **** does it matter what someone else thinks, and why they think that? Suppose such a plan were introduced in the US, and supposing you were invested enough to form an opinion: again, then it is incumbent on you to find out what factors might be relevant to you, not on others. Again, on an as-is basis, as things are in the US, would you support such a move?
If it happened in the US, I would assume it wouldn't happen at random and out of nowhere. There would be some kind of rule world justification that I would consider.

Why on earth do you persist in lobbing the ball back to us, and demanding of us that we spell out all of the variables for you?
Because I keep telling you that, for me, this question doesn't have an answer in the abstract.

Do you come running to us to hand-hold you through all of your national and local elections, do you come running to us to tell you what and how to think, and whom to vote for? So why now, with this single issue?
No, but those elections are typically about practical, non-abstract, real world questions. I don't recall ever having voted on the basis of some kind of moral absolute.

Look man, I'm done playing this ******* charade. We disagree, we disagree fundamentally, both about the rights and wrongs of racism, and also about whether you're honestly doing this thing. But that's fine, no reason for any unpleasantness over that: Go in peace, man, and God bless.
ok.
 
My opinions on what would be a good policy is based on what I think would be the effect of that policy in the world. That necessarily involves other people. Policy positions that do not take into account how they would work in the real world seem like decadent affectations to me.


I gree.


Maybe.


I don't operate in a moral vacuum. My morality is based on how I think things are going to play out in the world, hence I'm suspicious of abstract moral claims to truth.


No. Pragmatism is about practical solutions in the real world, not abstract moral statements that are invariant of real world practicality. That is the opposite of pragmatism. You were being pragmatic when you said something like you didn't have the stomach for your principles if the costs were too high in terms of lives. What you are looking for is an unpragmatic, morally absolutist answer, which is exactly what I am uncomfortable with.


I've told you. In the UK there is absolutely zero possibility of this being implemented, so either we have to suppose mind control is involved, or we are looking at whether it is sensible to push a policy that will not be implemented and what the implications of pushing a policy that won't be implemented will be. Interracial weddings will certainly not be impacted. Pragmatically, the question is nonsense. You might as well ask me how many angels can dance on the head of a pin.


They would be completely destroyed. I doubt they would make it to the election. The entire media machine would turn on them. There would be riots. The civil service would refuse to cooperate. There is no practical way this could happen. If some unforeseeable miracle occurred that suddenly made this a popular position, you need to tell me what that miracle would be. Clearly something is going on that is making people think this is necessary.


It couldn't happen as is. Their leader would be removed from office. Again, any such policy would come with an explanation justifying it. Given that they would certainly be destroyed, and I don't regard it as an important issue, and if they made this the centre of their platform without explanation.... then maybe I would assume they had gone mad. This is not the real world we are talking about. In the real world politicians try to frame issues like this around some kind of justification and don't in any case put forward policies that would make the entire ruling elite foam at the mouth.


If it happened in the US, I would assume it wouldn't happen at random and out of nowhere. There would be some kind of rule world justification that I would consider.


Because I keep telling you that, for me, this question doesn't have an answer in the abstract.


No, but those elections are typically about practical, non-abstract, real world questions. I don't recall ever having voted on the basis of some kind of moral absolute.


ok.



God you've actually convinced yourself that you're doing this honestly. This is ...super disturbing. And I cannot help, against my better judgment, trying one last time to get through to you.

In your weird conception of pragmatism, you're counting the resultant strife that some proposal might result in, basis how others react to it. But does your weird idea of pragmatism not take into account the impact on the people such a proposal might directly impact? When you're considering whether pedophilia is good or bad, you're taking into account whether or not others might react to a law allowing or banning it, but do you not take into account the effect on the children --- which part of it is independent of how others take to some proposal about some law about pedophilia? When you're considering whether or not to round up racists and castrate them one and all, your pragmatism considers any strife that may result, but does it not take into account the suffering of the said racists from and following the castration, even if there's no strife and killing over passing and implementing the law? Likewise, when you pass laws banning inter-race marriage, does your pseudo-pragmatism not consider the impact, the effect, that might have on the actual people who are going to be prevented from marrying, as well as how that will result in people regarding and interacting with one another, and independent of any killings that might result from passing and implementing the law?

I've no clue how Burke defines pragmatism, but viewed from an everyday and, may I say it, pragmatic POV, such a conception of pragmatism seems utterly cross-eyed.
 
I don't operate in a moral vacuum. My morality is based on how I think things are going to play out in the world, hence I'm suspicious of abstract moral claims to truth.

You're describing, I think, a sort of consequentialist viewpoint. That can be valid, but it doesn't really say a lot about your take on morality because it doesn't really speak to what you'd consider a bad consequence. It's a model of moral responsibility that lacks any indication of moral principles for that responsibility to measure up to.

They don't have to claim to be "universal" but it would mean something if there was some kind of moral principle you were arguing for.
 
So, i find myself here trying to think of a more "abstract moral claim to truth" than "my morality is based on how I think things are going to play out in the world."

I'm stumped.

Anyone else?
 
So, i find myself here trying to think of a more "abstract moral claim to truth" than "my morality is based on how I think things are going to play out in the world."

I'm stumped.

Anyone else?


It's a dodge, plain and simple. Probably to keep from oneself the monstrous nature of one's actual de facto views, the cognitive dissonance thing. It feels more soothing, more respectable, less depraved, to able to say, "I'm a pragmatist", than to have to admit, to oneself first and foremost, that "I'm a racist monster."

No sane person can possibly actually think and operate like this: "Ah, they're proposing to nationalize all private property, and castrate all racists, and kill every first-born, and also make the use of wiseass hyperbole punishable by compulsory community service by moderating internet forums, is it? Now what do I do, support this issue, or not? Let me see which option causes more opposition and strife and bloodletting, and I'll decide accordingly. My son, playing there? My neighbors' sons? This poor little ...thing of mine, that I've had so much fun with? This nice house I've built after years of toil? Oh, those are no concern of mine, I'm a pragmatist, and what's more a Burkean, and don't forget the diphthongs over the u and the e." No one ******* thinks like this, at least no one sane. It's a dodge, to keep from having to come face to face with the depravity of one's actual beliefs and choices.
 
There are a lot of frightened people out there who feel threatened by change. The combination of increasing globalisation, exposure to different cultures (both irl and online), increased acceptance of "others" and so on has left them living in a world which is unrecognisable from that in which they felt happiest - the one in which they spent their formative years.

Without sounding too much like one of those nauseating motivational posters, there are two ways to respond to the winds of change. You can be like a tree, move with the change and in the process become stronger or you can be like a block of concrete, resist and be fine right up to the point where you fail catastrophically.

The talk of preserving culture IMO is trying to wind back the clock to the point where these frightened people feel comfortable again. Different people will have different points at which that will happen. For some it may "only" require LBGTQIA2S+ people to go back in the closet where they belong, others may want all those darkies (and -ski's) to **** off back to where they belong.
 
It's a dodge, plain and simple. Probably to keep from oneself the monstrous nature of one's actual de facto views, the cognitive dissonance thing. It feels more soothing, more respectable, less depraved, to able to say, "I'm a pragmatist", than to have to admit, to oneself first and foremost, that "I'm a racist monster."
Other people's belief systems are not a dodge. There is nothing intrinsically true or correct about the your cultural assumptions. People who reject it aren't faking it.

No sane person can possibly actually think and operate like this: "Ah, they're proposing to nationalize all private property, and castrate all racists, and kill every first-born, and also make the use of wiseass hyperbole punishable by compulsory community service by moderating internet forums, is it? Now what do I do, support this issue, or not? Let me see which option causes more opposition and strife and bloodletting, and I'll decide accordingly. My son, playing there? My neighbors' sons? This poor little ...thing of mine, that I've had so much fun with? This nice house I've built after years of toil? Oh, those are no concern of mine, I'm a pragmatist, and what's more a Burkean, and don't forget the diphthongs over the u and the e." No one ******* thinks like this, at least no one sane. It's a dodge, to keep from having to come face to face with the depravity of one's actual beliefs and choices.
The idea that deciding on policy based on the anticipated impact of the policy vs religious pieties being entirely inconceivable is a very parochial view of the world. You even say that you would revert to pragmatism when you don't have the stomach for the outcome of the morality you supposedly follow and can't conceive of anybody not following.
 
It is a dodge if you refuse to expand on what hypothetical harm you are worried about that prevents you from stating whether you consider bans on mixed race marriages to be good or bad.
 
You're describing, I think, a sort of consequentialist viewpoint. That can be valid, but it doesn't really say a lot about your take on morality because it doesn't really speak to what you'd consider a bad consequence. It's a model of moral responsibility that lacks any indication of moral principles for that responsibility to measure up to.

They don't have to claim to be "universal" but it would mean something if there was some kind of moral principle you were arguing for.
Yes. Well put. Look, one get's a sense of what is good and bad from the culture, ones parents, history etc. It's provisional and organic though. Generally, I would say that maximizing inter-generational happiness is important to me. I've not got a hard and fast law about it though that I would pursue regardless of the outcome. The world feels too complicated for that.
 
Yes. Well put. Look, one get's a sense of what is good and bad from the culture, ones parents, history etc. It's provisional and organic though. Generally, I would say that maximizing inter-generational happiness is important to me. I've not got a hard and fast law about it though that I would pursue regardless of the outcome. The world feels too complicated for that.

Weak and completely empty response.
 
Can You Tell a Meaningful Quote From Pseudo-Profound ********

I just spent an hour of my life*randomizing*meaningless New Age-style quotes. It’s more fun than it has any right to be.

...

The same quote generator was used in a scientific study about receptivity to ********. (The other site they used is a Deepak Chopra quote generator. Can you tell the fake quotes from his real ones? I cannot.)

So, the study found that people who find these quotes profound tend to be more prone to irrational thinking. They’re more likely to fall for conspiracies. The study says that “some individuals may have an excessively “open” mind that biases them to make inflated judgments of profundity, regardless of the content.”
 
To answer the OP though, I think it's massively socially irresponsible and impractical to maintain such a radical policy around a slippery racial concept. Limiting citizenship to people who can speak the native language to a reasonable degree sounds more sane and enforceable, if we're going there.
 
OK, how about each country patents one color, and every citizen undergoes melanin therapy to make their skin color that exact shade. Like, all UKians blue skinned, etc. Then you'll know at a glance what nationality someone is.

I'm claiming my share if any of you lift this idea for the next sci fi bestseller.
 
OK, how about each country patents one color, and every citizen undergoes melanin therapy to make their skin color that exact shade. Like, all UKians blue skinned, etc. Then you'll know at a glance what nationality someone is.

I'm claiming my share if any of you lift this idea for the next sci fi bestseller.

I want to nominate you for something...anything...this post need it...this forum is obliged to give it the recognition it deserves.

Also...who should I make the cheque out to?
 
OK, how about each country patents one color, and every citizen undergoes melanin therapy to make their skin color that exact shade. Like, all UKians blue skinned, etc. Then you'll know at a glance what nationality someone is.

I'm claiming my share if any of you lift this idea for the next sci fi bestseller.

And “never the twain shall meet”….
 
To answer the OP though, I think it's massively socially irresponsible and impractical to maintain such a radical policy around a slippery racial concept. Limiting citizenship to people who can speak the native language to a reasonable degree sounds more sane and enforceable, if we're going there.

Ooh, another big Irish emigration wave coming if you apply that rule!:D

More seriously: which language? Can you be a Spanish citizen if you speak fluent Basque? Or a US one with fluent Spanish? If yes, then would Urdu or Punjabi count as a British language now, as a lot of citizens speak them? If not, why not?
 
OK, how about each country patents one color, and every citizen undergoes melanin therapy to make their skin color that exact shade. Like, all UKians blue skinned, etc. Then you'll know at a glance what nationality someone is.

I'm claiming my share if any of you lift this idea for the next sci fi bestseller.

I think it's been covered.

https://i.ytimg.com/vi/s_V6knB0lA4/maxresdefault.jpg
 
Ooh, another big Irish emigration wave coming if you apply that rule!:D

More seriously: which language? Can you be a Spanish citizen if you speak fluent Basque? Or a US one with fluent Spanish? If yes, then would Urdu or Punjabi count as a British language now, as a lot of citizens speak them? If not, why not?

As far as "gammons" would consider, the only British language is English. Native Welsh and Gaelic speakers are just bloody minded trouble-makers and Cornish is just a type of pasty.

Languages which have been "imported" are completely unacceptable, regardless of how many people speak them because they dilute our culture. Instead they will sit in their pyjamas in their bungalows and call some kind of ombudsman. ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom