Can/should European nations maintain their white majorities?

But again evil getting to invoke wild alternative reality speculation and demand it be weighed against actual wrong it is doing in the real world is the tactic now.
 
But again evil getting to invoke wild alternative reality speculation and demand it be weighed against actual wrong it is doing in the real world is the tactic now.



I *was* being ridiculous, but you're probably right.
 
I don't think anyone is having a hard time understanding, in broad terms, the arguments of an 18th Century conservative. Anything which upsets the current order is a bad thing and should be discouraged. From a man who did very well under the system that was in place at the time, this is understandable.

What people are disagreeing with IMO are:

  • That Burke is an exemplar for political and social thinking
  • That Burke is that relevant these days
Perhaps you could expand on these two points?
 
I don't think anyone is having a hard time understanding, in broad terms, the arguments of an 18th Century conservative. Anything which upsets the current order is a bad thing and should be discouraged. From a man who did very well under the system that was in place at the time, this is understandable.



What people are disagreeing with IMO are:



  • That Burke is an exemplar for political and social thinking
  • That Burke is that relevant these days
And he was a Liberal Conservative, shuttit seems to want to ignore that Liberal word.
 
I'm going to try reverse psychology.

If I start a thread about the most obscure 18th century political philosopher I can find will someone finally defend their racism in it?
 
Edited by xjx388: 
<SNIP> Removed moderated content


Of course, whenever I use the word "should" in this sort of discussion it is according to my moral framework.

You seem to be saying that your moral framework is agnostic on the rights of individuals when they don't affect anyone else.

The underpinning of any moral or ethical framework is ultimately based on axioms or values. Mine is generally that increasing suffering is bad and increasing happiness is good. Of course there are difficult questions where one is balancing one against the other, but this particular question is not that.

If your moral framework is agnostic on whether marriage between consenting adults should be banned, then in my view, it's pretty useless and also highly distasteful.

The best you have come up with is a vague idea that it might lead to a possible but never-defined harm.

Which is an argument that can be used to justify doing nothing in any situation.




I disagree that such things don't affect anyone else. You, as a single individual, doing something may have a negligible impact on other people, but it's like the Kantian conception of ethics "what if everybody did it".... most issues that are treated as individual issues actually have huge social implications when a significant number of people are engaging in them.

I think individual issues are like perfect circles, they don't exist in nature. You are right though, what ever ethics I may have is certainly not based on any enlightenment rights of the individual idea.


That's fine, but I don't think that that is typically the basis of liberal reasoning. I think people much more commonly just equate a thing like liberty or equality with happiness, and then reason from those things. I'm more of a Burkian.


Moral ethics that clash with our own always appear distasteful. I'm sure that yours are distasteful to me. This is a given. As to whether inter-racial marriage should be allowed, you are reasoning based on a conception of things that impact the wider society being purely individual matters. Does this in fact increase suffering or happiness? I think these are complicated questions that really depend on the circumstances. If it increased suffering, would it still be good because it's an individual choice and that really takes precedence?

What I see a lot is a denial of the possibility that there is conflict between things like liberty, equality, and the general happiness of man. I think the world is a complicated place and very often they are in conflict.
Again, if you cannot even assert that it would be wrong to ban interracial marriage, you need to get a better morality that allows you to make decisions.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
This is factually wrong, 100%.
Culture is a question of the place(s) you grow up in, and has nothing to do with ethnicity, as should be obvious to anyone who heard of Adoption.
Also, ex-Cubans in Florida or 2nd generation Mexicans in Texas and California have a thing to say about you putting them into a "political voting block".

Take a step back and think about your priors here.
I would modify that 100 percent slightly (and sadly) because it is possible for a culture to be racist or ethnocentric in practice, and when it is, of course, separation is guaranteed.

Artificial division forces difference which we can then see upside-down. People will criticize others for not dressing in the club blazer, forgetting that they were never allowed in.
 
Apparently the line is based on blood race culture and at least one person in this thread claims to be able to tell which "culture" you belong to by the way you look*

* - and not from what you're wearing or other fashion/taste related factors, but from your general physiognomy

Does it involve feeling bumps on my head?
 
This is an imperfect world in which different, incompatible goods contend. Of course it can be OK to mistreat people.

This is the point where I stop debating and start pointing and laughing. Whether this is amused horror, or horrified amusement is unclear, but either way, it seems this is the only appropriate reaction.
shuttlt, we are done. I have no time for sociopaths with pretensions of erudition.
 
It is not.


I have said already that I'm not against morality. What I'm against is universalist, rationalistic morality that comes from the French enlightenment. The pro-paedophilia/anti-age of consent activism comes from the same universalist/rationalist source.


There is no universal good or bad. It can be useful to pretend there is, but there isn't. Cultures develop ideas of what is moral and immoral over long periods of time and iterate on that. It's an evolutionary approach. I don't think the idea that racism is a moral evil came out of that approach, so I am suspicious of it. Even if it had, I wouldn't regard it as universal for all peoples. Many of the specific instances of racism that you would object to, I would likely object to as well... I would just get to that view in a different way.


You just have a different, newer set of superstitions which, just like many Christians, you consider to be universal in some way. Christianity though has survived for 2000 years across very different situations, so it's core seems unlikely to be absolutely an immediately toxic to society. Progressive morality has been around for the blink of an eye, so I am rather less confident about it.


That is a conservative view. Morality based on experience. Much left wing, rationalist thought derived from the sort of assumptions your morality is based on has reached the opposite conclusion on paedophilia.


I have said repeatedly that these effects count. Liberals have this blind view that they are the only side that cares, and that if you cared you would support their solutions. What separates us is not that I don't care about the suffering of other people, the issue is more like that I think you radically underestimate the difficulty, unintended consequences and tradeoffs of solving these problems.


Burke is not some obscure figure. He is arguably, and often described as, the father of conservatism. It's like calling John Locke an obscure figure. Imagine we were having a conversation about Liberal thought and I'd never heard of the French or American revolutions, Locke, Paine, or any of the various articulations of universalist rights like the Constitution. It would be a bit of a difficult and confusing conversation.


The idea that I am trying to fool you by presenting you with the philosophical and historical basis of conservatism, and saying I find significant parts of it convincing, is bizarre. This isn't some secret and unknown tradition.


shuttit, I've clearly acknowledged that, basis what you've said to me, you appear to be more of a true pragmatist rather than a racist per se. I was interested for seeing whether there are any limits to that true pragmatism of yours, and hence those two questions I'd asked you in my post #652, that you left unaddressed. I also clearly explained, in that post, just why, despite that, it is very clear to me that your "true pragmatism" is no more than a dodge. And it is that, without a shadow of a doubt.

It's very simple. You are asked whether you think banning inter-"race" marriages is right or wrong. There is no reason why that simple question should not be answered with a simple "I'm for it", or "I'm against it", or "I'm indifferent to it" answer. Not in theory, not in some abstract sense, but in actuality, in this real world --- so that to be literally indifferent to the prospect of banning inter-race marriages is to be utterly complicit in racism.

What you're trying to do here is to weasel out of taking a position by retreating into abstractions.

Look, it's simple. Say you are in a position to support either (or neither) of two positions --- whether by voting, or otherwise --- the only difference between which is that one advocates banning inter-race marriages, and the other is against ever considering any such move. Which do you support? Or will you refrain from supporting either? Why?

Now please don't just snip out that foregoing paragraph in isolation, like you tend to do, and launch into another long monolog on what Burke groaned out while jacking off in archaic English, complete with diphthongs, or about decomposed Greek philosophers and their ******* caves. That would be no more than yet another dodge. Engage, if you would, with the entirety of what I'm saying, or not at all. ~~~~~~~We're asking you your view on banning inter-race marriages, whether you'd support such a move, or not. The why of it is a secondary matter, that of course you're welcome to also discuss if you like. If you're a cross-eyed Jesus-cultist, then you might quote some weirdo commandment from some moth-eaten book written by ignorant ancients, and base your answer off of that, to answer with a "Yes" or a "No", to whether you support banning inter-race marriages. If you're an idealist, then you might explain the reasons for your ideals, and off of that support your answer. And if you're pragmatist --- as why shouldn't you be --- then, equally, you could clearly state whether or not you support such a move, and then, in addition, explain how exactly your pragmatism leads you to that answer. But, no matter the basis of your answer, no matter whether you're a superstitious Jesus-fetishist, or an idealist, or a hard-nosed pragmatist, or a despicable racist, no matter of which of these four you are, there is no reason why you shouldn't be able to come out with a clear answer to that question, a clear "Yes" or "No" to whether you support or don't support banning inter-race marriages --- and, in addition, if you like, provide detailed justification for your answer using whatever it is you base that answer on.


What you keep repeatedly doing here ---- certainly in your posts addressed to me ---- is simply dodge. I ask you whether you support banning inter-race marriages, and you ask me if I'm willing to countenance killing others to prevent that. Well, the first time I got taken in by that dodge, and went on to introspect and come to the conclusion that I haven't the stomach to do that ---- but the point is, that was basically changing the subject, and my not catching on to your dodge did enable you, that time, to successfully change the subject, away from the (to you) uncomfortable question that was asked of you. Then when I ask you that same question again, you then bring in that sainted Burke of yours, and also bring in a discussion on idealism vis-a-vis pragmatism. All of that is a dodge, pure and simple, shuttit. It is also basically attacking a strawman, your repeated insistence that you refuse to take a "universal" position, because no one is asking you to do that: Just take that position in your own given polity and constituency, or any other real-life polity or constituency that you might be invested in enough to formulate a considered opinion on, in as pragmatic terms as you care to take it. You are being asked: Do YOU support banning inter-race marriages (let's say, to narrow it down, in whatever country/constituency you yourself vote in). Yes, or No? It's a simple question. No reason why you shouldn't, after answering with a Yes or a No, you shouldn't also append an explanation/justification for your choice, and basing that explanation off of your own philosophy ---- be it blind faith in religious superstitions, be it some set-in-stone ideals, or be it hard-nosed pragmatism, or be it shamelessly racist ideas.

I've already said this to you before, but here, for the last time, is why I've come off convinced that your answers, at least to me, are simply a dodge. I'm guessing you're dodging yourself as well as us, that is, refusing to own up to yourself the nature of your choices, because only a monster would actually acquiesce to such choices, and no one likes to think of themselves as a monster, so there's the cognitive dissonance thing kicking in: that's a charitable view, BTW, because it means I don't think you're being deliberately dishonest with us, with the express coldly reasoned intention of misleading us. But for all of that it's a dodge, this pragmatism sidebar of yours. I mean, by all means be as hard-nosed a pragmatist as you like, but that's no reason not to be able to come to concrete decisions about specific questions as it relates to the real world.
 
Last edited:
shuttit, I've clearly acknowledged that, basis what you've said to me, you appear to be more of a true pragmatist rather than a racist per se. I was interested for seeing whether there are any limits to that true pragmatism of yours, and hence those two questions I'd asked you in my post #652, that you left unaddressed. I also clearly explained, in that post, just why, despite that, it is very clear to me that your "true pragmatism" is no more than a dodge. And it is that, without a shadow of a doubt.
Apologies. There have been a lot of posts and things get missed. I will revisit those questions.

It's very simple. You are asked whether you think banning inter-"race" marriages is right or wrong. There is no reason why that simple question should not be answered with a simple "I'm for it", or "I'm against it", or "I'm indifferent to it" answer. Not in theory, not in some abstract sense, but in actuality, in this real world --- so that to be literally indifferent to the prospect of banning inter-race marriages is to be utterly complicit in racism.

What you're trying to do here is to weasel out of taking a position by retreating into abstractions.

Look, it's simple. Say you are in a position to support either (or neither) of two positions --- whether by voting, or otherwise --- the only difference between which is that one advocates banning inter-race marriages, and the other is against ever considering any such move. Which do you support? Or will you refrain from supporting either? Why?
Why are they for it, why against it? Presumably if one of them is advocating it, some situation exists that makes that position plausible to a lot of people, what is that situation? I have no opinion in the abstract.

Now please don't just snip out that foregoing paragraph in isolation, like you tend to do, and launch into another long monolog on what Burke groaned out while jacking off in archaic English, complete with diphthongs, or about decomposed Greek philosophers and their ******* caves. That would be no more than yet another dodge. Engage, if you would, with the entirety of what I'm saying, or not at all. ~~~~~~~We're asking you your view on banning inter-race marriages, whether you'd support such a move, or not.
Under what circumstances? Why? If there is any possibility of it being implemented, it must seem like a good idea to quite a lot of people, what are their reasons? This isn't a dodge. As I keep saying, I have no position in the abstract.

The why of it is a secondary matter, that of course you're welcome to also discuss if you like.
It isn't a secondary matter. Maybe it is for you, but not for me. Which fork in the road should I take, left or right....? Were they go is a secondary matter. For the reasons not to matter you have to have a system of morality that regards such things as good or bad regardless of the outcome. I've told you, I don't.

If you're a cross-eyed Jesus-cultist, then you might quote some weirdo commandment from some moth-eaten book written by ignorant ancients, and base your answer off of that, to answer with a "Yes" or a "No", to whether you support banning inter-race marriages.
I'm not religious. These questions of things being good or bad in the abstract aren't really answerable without some notion of universal divinely revealed truths.

If you're an idealist, then you might explain the reasons for your ideals, and off of that support your answer. And if you're pragmatist --- as why shouldn't you be --- then, equally, you could clearly state whether or not you support such a move, and then, in addition, explain how exactly your pragmatism leads you to that answer.
Why would a pragmatist support something in the abstract regardless of practical considerations? That feels like the opposite of pragmatism.

But, no matter the basis of your answer, no matter whether you're a superstitious Jesus-fetishist, or an idealist, or a hard-nosed pragmatist, or a despicable racist, no matter of which of these four you are, there is no reason why you shouldn't be able to come out with a clear answer to that question, a clear "Yes" or "No" to whether you support or don't support banning inter-race marriages --- and, in addition, if you like, provide detailed justification for your answer using whatever it is you base that answer on.
As I understand it, pragmatism is about considering things practically in the real world. You are asking me to give pragmatic answers to non-practical questions. That's not possible.

What you keep repeatedly doing here ---- certainly in your posts addressed to me ---- is simply dodge. I ask you whether you support banning inter-race marriages, and you ask me if I'm willing to countenance killing others to prevent that.
Well, yes... because I am trying to make it practical and turn it into a question about the real world. If your view is that we should implement policy based on idealised moral considerations and ignoring the real world outcomes, then I cans see how me asking such questions would be irrelevant. I'm not arguing that accepting the deaths of a bunch of people would necessarily be wrong to achieve your aims. Many great achievements that are near universally seen as moral goods involved a trade off in blood.

Well, the first time I got taken in by that dodge, and went on to introspect and come to the conclusion that I haven't the stomach to do that ---- but the point is, that was basically changing the subject, and my not catching on to your dodge did enable you, that time, to successfully change the subject, away from the (to you) uncomfortable question that was asked of you.
It's not changing the subject. Your policy ideas that you found in abstract moral considerations have real world costs. Depending on those costs, you might not in fact have the stomach for the policies that you want me to agree to or disagree with in the abstract. I agree with your stomach. I think the thinking you were doing is how I am thinking about the question.

Then when I ask you that same question again, you then bring in that sainted Burke of yours, and also bring in a discussion on idealism vis-a-vis pragmatism. All of that is a dodge, pure and simple, shuttit. It is also basically attacking a strawman, your repeated insistence that you refuse to take a "universal" position, because no one is asking you to do that: Just take that position in your own given polity and constituency, or any other real-life polity or constituency that you might be invested in enough to formulate a considered opinion on, in as pragmatic terms as you care to take it.
It could only be implemented nationally, I would think, in the UK and would almost certainly violate all sorts of human rights law. There would be riots and it would end the political career of any politician who supported it and the destroy the party who implemented it. I can't begin to imagine what the impact would be on the ongoing Brexit fun... it might even somehow get us back into the EU as the backlash would certainly blame Brexit. It could tip Scotland into leaving the Union. I doubt the bureaucracy of government would comply. I doubt a single mixed race marriage would be prevented. Is that a good enough answer? There is simply no way to implement such a policy in the UK.

You are being asked: Do YOU support banning inter-race marriages (let's say, to narrow it down, in whatever country/constituency you yourself vote in). Yes, or No?
Like I say, there is simply no way of such a policy being implemented in the UK, or for any party with any hope of electoral success to support such a policy and survive. No mainstream party is actually interested in meaningfully restricting immigration. What would be the purpose of pushing this incredibly divisive policy that couldn't be implemented when there are far more important and, at least marginally, less divisive policies that they aren't pushing either. What have you learned from my answer other than the practical impossibility of such a policy?

It's a simple question. No reason why you shouldn't, after answering with a Yes or a No, you shouldn't also append an explanation/justification for your choice, and basing that explanation off of your own philosophy ---- be it blind faith in religious superstitions, be it some set-in-stone ideals, or be it hard-nosed pragmatism, or be it shamelessly racist ideas.
Any attempt to push such a law that had even the appearance of a chance of success would, I think, lead to an authoritarian crackdown on the people who supported it. Unless one is an accelerationist, supporting this policy would be self defeating.

I've already said this to you before, but here, for the last time, is why I've come off convinced that your answers, at least to me, are simply a dodge. I'm guessing you're dodging yourself as well as us, that is, refusing to own up to yourself the nature of your choices, because only a monster would actually acquiesce to such choices, and no one likes to think of themselves as a monster, so there's the cognitive dissonance thing kicking in: that's a charitable view, BTW, because it means I don't think you're being deliberately dishonest with us, with the express coldly reasoned intention of misleading us. But for all of that it's a dodge, this pragmatism sidebar of yours. I mean, by all means be as hard-nosed a pragmatist as you like, but that's no reason not to be able to come to concrete decisions about specific questions as it relates to the real world.
See my answers above.
 
So what hypothetical harms are you concerned about that means you are unsure whether it would be a good idea to ban mixed race marriages?

If your argument is simply that there might be something bad that you're not sure about, then that is an argument for never doing anything.
 
So what hypothetical harms are you concerned about that means you are unsure whether it would be a good idea to ban mixed race marriages?

If your argument is simply that there might be something bad that you're not sure about, then that is an argument for never doing anything.

Which would fit his fanboy-ism of Burke to a T.
 
Apologies. There have been a lot of posts and things get missed. I will revisit those questions.


Why are they for it, why against it? Presumably if one of them is advocating it, some situation exists that makes that position plausible to a lot of people, what is that situation? I have no opinion in the abstract.


Under what circumstances? Why? If there is any possibility of it being implemented, it must seem like a good idea to quite a lot of people, what are their reasons? This isn't a dodge. As I keep saying, I have no position in the abstract.


It isn't a secondary matter. Maybe it is for you, but not for me. Which fork in the road should I take, left or right....? Were they go is a secondary matter. For the reasons not to matter you have to have a system of morality that regards such things as good or bad regardless of the outcome. I've told you, I don't.


I'm not religious. These questions of things being good or bad in the abstract aren't really answerable without some notion of universal divinely revealed truths.


Why would a pragmatist support something in the abstract regardless of practical considerations? That feels like the opposite of pragmatism.


As I understand it, pragmatism is about considering things practically in the real world. You are asking me to give pragmatic answers to non-practical questions. That's not possible.


Well, yes... because I am trying to make it practical and turn it into a question about the real world. If your view is that we should implement policy based on idealised moral considerations and ignoring the real world outcomes, then I cans see how me asking such questions would be irrelevant. I'm not arguing that accepting the deaths of a bunch of people would necessarily be wrong to achieve your aims. Many great achievements that are near universally seen as moral goods involved a trade off in blood.


It's not changing the subject. Your policy ideas that you found in abstract moral considerations have real world costs. Depending on those costs, you might not in fact have the stomach for the policies that you want me to agree to or disagree with in the abstract. I agree with your stomach. I think the thinking you were doing is how I am thinking about the question.


It could only be implemented nationally, I would think, in the UK and would almost certainly violate all sorts of human rights law. There would be riots and it would end the political career of any politician who supported it and the destroy the party who implemented it. I can't begin to imagine what the impact would be on the ongoing Brexit fun... it might even somehow get us back into the EU as the backlash would certainly blame Brexit. It could tip Scotland into leaving the Union. I doubt the bureaucracy of government would comply. I doubt a single mixed race marriage would be prevented. Is that a good enough answer? There is simply no way to implement such a policy in the UK.


Like I say, there is simply no way of such a policy being implemented in the UK, or for any party with any hope of electoral success to support such a policy and survive. No mainstream party is actually interested in meaningfully restricting immigration. What would be the purpose of pushing this incredibly divisive policy that couldn't be implemented when there are far more important and, at least marginally, less divisive policies that they aren't pushing either. What have you learned from my answer other than the practical impossibility of such a policy?


Any attempt to push such a law that had even the appearance of a chance of success would, I think, lead to an authoritarian crackdown on the people who supported it. Unless one is an accelerationist, supporting this policy would be self defeating.


See my answers above.


****, man. There you go, pulling that same old stunt again.

Whether you support issue A in polity X, or not, what the **** does that have to do with what others think of it, and why? Are you opinions and decisions no more than a reflection, or distorted refraction, of others' views ---- is that yet another fresh Burke-ism you're going to introduce here, that you've no opinions that are independent of others' opinions?

I'm not dancing this weird dance any more. For the last time, here's something that might, if you read it with an open mind, get you to see what you're getting sorely wrong, all of your reading of political philosophy notwithstanding: If you're religious, then your religion gives you set-in-stone morals and answers to (most) ethical questions. If you're a skeptic, you no longer have that certainty. You must now work things out on your own. But that doesn't mean you operate in a moral vacuum, that doesn't mean you are unable to decide right from wrong, ever. And that working out things on your own means having to inform yourself adequately, or as adequately as you can, to formulate meaningful opinions. Well, that's how, it seems to me, it would work with pragmatism. (And indeed, in the sense I've just now spelt out, we're all of us pragmatists!) If you're asked whether you'd support banning mixed-race marriages, then, if you wish to seriously engage with that question, if only to yourself, then it is on you, you not us, to find out what the factors are that would drive your decision, and how they stand. You live in UK, you've said, so fine: If the party you vote for decided on that as a major plank for the next election, would you support it? Basis an as-is situation, assuming things are exactly as they are now, what would you decide? That's on you, man, not others asking the question. What the **** does it matter what someone else thinks, and why they think that? Suppose such a plan were introduced in the US, and supposing you were invested enough to form an opinion: again, then it is incumbent on you to find out what factors might be relevant to you, not on others. Again, on an as-is basis, as things are in the US, would you support such a move?

Why on earth do you persist in lobbing the ball back to us, and demanding of us that we spell out all of the variables for you? Do you come running to us to hand-hold you through all of your national and local elections, do you come running to us to tell you what and how to think, and whom to vote for? So why now, with this single issue?

Look man, I'm done playing this ******* charade. We disagree, we disagree fundamentally, both about the rights and wrongs of racism, and also about whether you're honestly doing this thing. But that's fine, no reason for any unpleasantness over that: Go in peace, man, and God bless.




eta:

I agree with your stomach. I think the thinking you were doing is how I am thinking about the question.


Except we don't think similarly at all. This, right here, is what's wrong with how you're addressing this issue.

I squarely oppose banning mixed-race marriages. On pragmatic grounds, I suppose, in a way; although you might see a codification of such pragmaticism into heuristics/effective-rules as idealism; but call it what you will, I oppose it. True, I will not, I find, on thinking this over, acquiesce to being instrumental, myself, in killing a whole bunch of people, in order to stop this monstrous ban from being put in place; but still, that notwithstanding, I totally oppose it, as I keep saying, and as you refuse to once say. And I'll go further: While I won't be instrumental in killing others, I'll do what I can to distance myself from a state that might pass these laws, including moving away from there, even at some cost to myself. In short, and shorn of details, I oppose such a move. As I am prepared to clearly declare, even though I won't kill for it. And as you very skillfully keep avoiding having to take an actual stand on, yourself, and unlike me.




eta one last time:

If your view is that we should implement policy based on idealised moral considerations and ignoring the real world outcomes,


What on earth leads you to imagine that might be my view, even after my having clearly spelt out that that is most certainly not my view? After I've clearly specified, in words of one syllable, that no one is asking you to implement policy "based on idealised moral considerations and ignoring real world outcomes", where the **** do you get that "if" from at all? Hold you hand to your heart and tell me that isn't a ******* dodge, that isn't a disingenuous stawman-straddling stunt. I mean, no reason for you to insert that kind of a ridiculous "if" at all, even to begin with; but now, now after I spend a whole post spelling exactly that out, you blithely do it again? Who on earth are you trying to fool?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom