Lukraak_Sisser
Philosopher
- Joined
- Aug 20, 2009
- Messages
- 6,482
OK. But the thing there is that while the attitudes to immigration may go up and down, in the UK at least, those who think that there is too much immigration has always dwarfed the number who would be keen for more. You have a minority tone policing the majority, while at the same time increasing the thing driving that discontent.
Right, but punishing it doesn't make it go away. What you are doing is suppressing it.
OK. This is straightforward. The views you are advocating are effectively the views of the elite, the media class and so on. What we are talking about is that class imposing its will on the rest of the country and suppressing dissent. I don't disagree that that is what has happened, and to some degree what has always happened. Does it make the causes of the dissent go away though? This goes back to the Fabians despising the poor in whose benefit they were supposedly working.
Having said that ... in some ways immigration will make the problem better in that if there is no longer a united majority culture, it becomes less of an obstacle to the changes. The Amazon diversity solution to unions. The Tower of Babel as a model for power. The immigrants who have been brought in may be racist as well, but they will be made stronger by immigration and so will likely support it. From a Machiavellian point of view, it looks OK, but it also looks like a recipe for unresolvable racial strife.
At the end of the day, this is your tribe vs my tribe.
You keep asserting that immigration will lead to racial strife, but what proof do you have?
The racial strife in the US has far more to do with the fact that even post civil war the US made their non-white population second class citizens with less rights and no real prospect out of poverty than race.
The Roman Empire managed to deal with immigration for centuries in a far less civilized age by assuring that everyone had the same (small) chance to rise to the top and had none of your promised racial strife.
Also another one using the phrase "US culture" but (of course) unwilling to define it.