Can/should European nations maintain their white majorities?

OK. But the thing there is that while the attitudes to immigration may go up and down, in the UK at least, those who think that there is too much immigration has always dwarfed the number who would be keen for more. You have a minority tone policing the majority, while at the same time increasing the thing driving that discontent.


Right, but punishing it doesn't make it go away. What you are doing is suppressing it.


OK. This is straightforward. The views you are advocating are effectively the views of the elite, the media class and so on. What we are talking about is that class imposing its will on the rest of the country and suppressing dissent. I don't disagree that that is what has happened, and to some degree what has always happened. Does it make the causes of the dissent go away though? This goes back to the Fabians despising the poor in whose benefit they were supposedly working.

Having said that ... in some ways immigration will make the problem better in that if there is no longer a united majority culture, it becomes less of an obstacle to the changes. The Amazon diversity solution to unions. The Tower of Babel as a model for power. The immigrants who have been brought in may be racist as well, but they will be made stronger by immigration and so will likely support it. From a Machiavellian point of view, it looks OK, but it also looks like a recipe for unresolvable racial strife.

At the end of the day, this is your tribe vs my tribe.

You keep asserting that immigration will lead to racial strife, but what proof do you have?
The racial strife in the US has far more to do with the fact that even post civil war the US made their non-white population second class citizens with less rights and no real prospect out of poverty than race.
The Roman Empire managed to deal with immigration for centuries in a far less civilized age by assuring that everyone had the same (small) chance to rise to the top and had none of your promised racial strife.
 
The underlying trend continues to be from barbarism to civilisation, despite the occasional setback. That doesn't mean we'll ever reach a point when there are no more barbarians.
The Whig view of history.
 
You keep asserting that immigration will lead to racial strife, but what proof do you have?
The racial strife in the US has far more to do with the fact that even post civil war the US made their non-white population second class citizens with less rights and no real prospect out of poverty than race.
The Roman Empire managed to deal with immigration for centuries in a far less civilized age by assuring that everyone had the same (small) chance to rise to the top and had none of your promised racial strife.
Everyone did not have the same equal chance to rise to the top in Rome. Absolutely they didn't. Republican Rome was an aristocracy. They did the same thing that always happens, they relied on money pouring in from the periphery and constant growth to fund a top heavy centre where huge amounts of the population where non-productive and kept going by patronage from the top in the form of bread and circuses. The moment they stopped growing, they started collapsing. They relied increasingly on foreign labour to keep the economy and the war machine going to the point where the Emperors became barbarians and abandoned Rome.
 
Last edited:
"You see I'm totally validated in being a horrible person if I'm factually wrong about literally everything."
 
Everyone did not have the same equal chance to rise to the top in Rome. Absolutely they didn't. Republican Rome was an aristocracy. They did the same thing that always happens, they relied on money pouring in from the periphery and constant growth to fund a top heavy centre where huge amounts of the population where non-productive and kept going by patronage from the top in the form of bread and circuses. The moment they stopped growing, they started collapsing. They relied increasingly on foreign labour to keep the economy and the war machine going to the point where the Emperors became barbarians and abandoned Rome.

You were asked for evidence for racial strife, you delivered an extremely weak stream of consciousness. This is not your local pub.
 
Sure, perhaps. The recent posts have been mentioning multiculturalism. Thinking about it, I'm puzzled what some people on this thread must think multiculturalism means since supposedly America has one culture called "American culture" that everybody has by virtue of being an American. Anyway, one of the issues with multiculturalism is that it encourages immigrants to retain their different cultures, hence preserving race as a good proxy for culture.
What's so hard to understand about venn diagrams.

Almost every culture has subcultures and is intern a subculture itself.

There is an American Culture which is a subculture of western culture and has southern subcultures, western subcultures, urban subcultures, black subcultures.......

Where the US has traditionally excelled was at assimilation. Not forcing immigrants to adopt US culture entirely and abandon their own, but letting folks retain some of the old country while adopting the larger US culture and the larger culture changing itself. You know, cultural appropriation. I'd argue human culture would be a lot poorer with out it. No Rock, No Jazz, No Broadway style musicals. We'd be stuck with authentic pizza and authentic sushi.

that's not to say, it hasn't been bumping. Mass migration has almost always been associated with organized crime for instance. The Irish, the Jews, the Italians, the Chinese, the Mexicans all either brought gangs with them or started new ones when they got here.
 
What's so hard to understand about venn diagrams.

Almost every culture has subcultures and is intern a subculture itself.

There is an American Culture which is a subculture of western culture and has southern subcultures, western subcultures, urban subcultures, black subcultures.......

Where the US has traditionally excelled was at assimilation. Not forcing immigrants to adopt US culture entirely and abandon their own, but letting folks retain some of the old country while adopting the larger US culture and the larger culture changing itself. You know, cultural appropriation. I'd argue human culture would be a lot poorer with out it. No Rock, No Jazz, No Broadway style musicals. We'd be stuck with authentic pizza and authentic sushi.

that's not to say, it hasn't been bumping. Mass migration has almost always been associated with organized crime for instance. The Irish, the Jews, the Italians, the Chinese, the Mexicans all either brought gangs with them or started new ones when they got here.

More weak right wing extremism and propaganda :boggled: Also another one using the phrase "US culture" but (of course) unwilling to define it.
 
Re fresh immigrants and gangs: You forgot the Russian mafia.

Here in Detroit,* we had Belgian mobs for some decades. They were pretty flagrant. The Cadieux Cafe a few blocks from me started as a purpose-built speakeasy, yes, bricks and mortar on a busy road, and the police were very nice about it. I think some of those Belgian uglies are still around.

* Which is an approx. 82% black city. Oooooh! how I'd love to take shuttlt on a tour!
 
One more time, as the information clearly hasn't been processed:
The definition of racism:
Prejudice, discrimination, or antagonism by an individual, community, or institution against a person or people on the basis of their membership of a particular racial or ethnic group, typically one that is a minority or marginalized.
The belief that different races possess distinct characteristics, abilities, or qualities, especially so as to distinguish them as inferior or superior to one another.

When your children moved out into the world, if they moved amongst the great mass of the population, they would have found black people who are biased in favour of other black people, latino people who are biased in favour of other latino people and so on. About the only people who aren't like this are white progressives who are biased against white people. They would also discover that out in the world race does carry information about people, for example due to affirmative action, if they went to university they would likely see asians at the top of the class, while black students struggle at the bottom. If they were mugged, it is disproportionately likely to be by a black man. It's possible to shield children from these things, but people aren't racist for no reason.

And STILL the information has not been processed!
This preference for people like you is not racism. Saying you prefer blondes to brunettes is not racism. Nothing from the post above is racism.

Racism is what the definition of racism is. It really isn't that hard to understand- although, apparently it is.
 
With fish-hooks and razor blades sewn into lapels so if someone tried to get hold of you by your lapels they sliced their fingers open.
Just when I was young it would be rare on a night out on the town - and this was in the old licencing regimes of pubs closing at 10:30 and 11 - that you wouldn't have been in a pub where someone had got glassed that night.


Heh, that's a pretty cool idea. Never seen that trick described before, not even in fiction. If you can think up a way of doing that without ending up cutting your own throat --- and I guess people did, else they wouldn't have been walking around in those things, like you say --- then I can see how that can be very effective, and extremely satisfying.
 
Everyone did not have the same equal chance to rise to the top in Rome. Absolutely they didn't. Republican Rome was an aristocracy. They did the same thing that always happens, they relied on money pouring in from the periphery and constant growth to fund a top heavy centre where huge amounts of the population where non-productive and kept going by patronage from the top in the form of bread and circuses. The moment they stopped growing, they started collapsing. They relied increasingly on foreign labour to keep the economy and the war machine going to the point where the Emperors became barbarians and abandoned Rome.

Join the army, get rewarded, get power. Whether you came from Nubia, Gallia, Dacia, Italia or anywhere else. People from all parts of the empire could and did live everywhere and had the ability to rise regardless of 'race'
Sure, the very system itself was eventually doomed to fail due to it's corruption and internal problems, but it never failed due to 'race strife'.
 
Yeah, it had nothing to do with frontier generals proclaiming themselves emperor, marching their legions towards the home province, leaving the frontier weak, exhausting the manpower reserves (both sides casualties being Roman troops and allied auxiliaries), and the winner purging the ranks even further.

Then, look at the entire Stillicho/Aleric arc. Pure and unrepentant ethnic bigotry lead to one fantastic blunder after another. Really, it was their steadfast refusal to allow immigration into vast uninhabited portions of the empire that fed both manpower shortages and a plethora of enemies desperate to settle, willing to assist in defence for doing so. It was a policy that worked remarkably well when tried and resulted in very a "romanized" people within a couple of generations.

Look at Quintilius "give me back my legions" Varus.

TL;DR: tell me you don't know Roman history without telling me you don't know Roman history...
 
Everyone did not have the same equal chance to rise to the top in Rome. Absolutely they didn't. Republican Rome was an aristocracy. They did the same thing that always happens, they relied on money pouring in from the periphery and constant growth to fund a top heavy centre where huge amounts of the population where non-productive and kept going by patronage from the top in the form of bread and circuses. The moment they stopped growing, they started collapsing. They relied increasingly on foreign labour to keep the economy and the war machine going to the point where the Emperors became barbarians and abandoned Rome.


Ha ha ha, the emperors didn't become barbarians; "barbarians", firmly within quotes, became emperors. And the locus of power shifting beyond Rome isn't what ended the Empire; if that were the only thing happening, then a Byzantium-or-wherever-centered Empire, while maybe no longer "Roman", would be no bad thing. And nor was dissolution of Empire in itself necessarily a bad thing.

Heh, shuttit, you reveal a great deal more about your thinking than you put in words, or than you maybe realize.

Pure pragmatism is a weird enough thing; but in your case it's simply the (weird) lipstick you're trying to put on your grotesque pig of an idea, which is simply racism.
 
And some of the descendants of those barbarians are today looking to keep out their own barbarians, possibly including those of Roman descent.
 
You are claiming that the past was less violent? I would love to see you support that claim. Eh? What am I saying.

He's already been shown the evidence that this is not true. He even claimed to have been aware of it before that- and yet he still rejects the evidence, and bases his conclusions on things he knows aren't true.
Less Burke, more berk, really.
 
Which other field of human knowledge would you still be quoting stuff from someone over 300 years dead? (Apart from history)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom