Can/should European nations maintain their white majorities?

I have explained several real-world consequences of reducing racism.
I know, and instances of real world consequences aren't really what we are debating. My objection is to you making a general principle out of them.

I asked you to detail some real-world benefits of increased racism: you have, yet again, avoided answering the question.
I'm pretty sure an example of this was given by your side of the debate earlier. It was OK for blacks to have indentarian feeling because they were under attack. Hypothetically if there was a movement to give one racial group with negative associations, and make it ok to insult and discriminate against that ethnic group but not others and so on such that that group felt under attack, then some kind of ingroup solidarity that you would call racist is the obvious counter to it.

You seem undecided whether your acceptance of racism is because you reside an an ivory tower (hopefully, the off-white of ivory is acceptable to you, I know it's not pure white) in which real-world consequences are sublimated by 'Platonic ideals'
This is incorrect. Again, I am concerned about real world consequences, I'm just not making a self evident universal law out of them.

, and you are far too lofty to stoop to considering such things as the actual consequences of your actions,
Again, I care about consequences, I do not believe in your universal law. I have explained this repeatedly.

or whether you are arguing from a point of view of pure pragmatism, in which the only consequences worth considering are real-world ones.
What consequences do you think I should take into account that don't take place in the real world? I must be misunderstanding.

It is also worth noting that your rejection of any form of morality is not a decision made in isolation.
I don't reject "any form of morality ". I reject self evident universalist morality. That morality comes from French enlightenment philosophy and I think it is profoundly incorrect and leads to a sort of totalitarian religious like fervour in which anyone who doesn't accept the morality is seen as an evil heretic. I think in its current form it is a type of secularised puritanism.

If you reject morality, then others will see you as at least amoral, and very possibly, immoral.
I don't reject morality though. I just don't share your universalist French enlightenment securised puritan morality. For that I am an evil and hateful heretic.

Your claims to be able to advise on a society's policies and long-term strategies, then, are unlikely to be well-received, as those around you will conclude that your proposals are not guided by any sense of right or wrong, and thus may well not result in any benefit for anyone except you.
That is where you are profoundly wrong and mistaken. Morality has existed for thousands of years. You can see aspects of it in other primates. There are different moralities in different places. All of those people with their different moral intuitions and experiences were not waiting for 21st Century progressive liberal politics to invent morality for it. You have one morality amongst many. There is nothing special about yours.

Ironically, this will lead to a form of racism, in that you will be discriminated against because of your antipathy to morality. You may want to live like that, as a pariah, in a lofty but lonely rejection of the mores of those around you, but I would find this scant compensation for such a bleak existence.
It is possible. Progressive liberalism is as censorious and authoritarian in some respects as the New England puritans when they first landed in the new world. The weird thing is that having exposed myself to that by explaining my views, I keep being accused of concealing my true opinions like this is a witch trial and you want me to confess to curdling all the milk.

Racism has real-world consequences, no matter how much you wish it doesn't.
I haven't said it doesn't have real world consequences. That is the part of it I care about, not whether it is contrary to your dogma.

Preaching down at the great unwashed about how special you are still doesn't make you correct. To do that, you need to provide some evidence that racism has benefits. You have still not done that.
I think this is incorrect. The argument would have to be that it can have no benefits. I'm arguing against it being universally bad. I think it was Warp12 who was giving examples of racist policies that progressives supported like affirmative action, and he was told that those were good because of blah, blah, blah. Effectively when racism is good or excusable, it isn't racism and liberal progressives get to decide what is and isn't good and excusable. There is a no true scotsman problem here.

No amount of pontificating will make any difference. People here have, for the most part, been very patient with you. Eventually, though, this will degenerate into pointing and laughing, if you cannot present some actual details or specifics. Up to you, your royal sageness. :rolleyes:
Maybe they will, but this forum represents the left most 10% of American culture if we look at it's progressive opinions. The fact that that 10% laughs doesn't bother me. You guys seem to be incapable of understanding that yours is one morality amongst many and that there are entirely different ways of constructing morality than the French enlightenment model you have. I keep explaining this, and it is just ignored as if I never said it.

Hopefully you notice above that I have answered the question you say I am not answering.
 
As I can't be bothered trawling back through the pages of this thread, and as I also have no desire to deal with yet more waffle about Burke, Plato &c, perhaps someone could do me the favour of answering this:

Have we had a clear definition yet of what European culture is, and also what connection there is between this culture and skin colour?
I believe it is a branch of the indo-european cultural tradition. It isn't something that can be well defined because it evolved over huge periods of time and is therefore messy. It is associated with skin colour because it was associated with a particular people in a particular geography and that was the skin colour they had. Until relatively recently mass migration wasn't such a big thing so the strong association between skin colour and and culture persists. It could be there are some genetic aspects to that tradition, I think some ethnic groups have higher testosterone than others fo example, but it isn't really necessary to suppose that.

For example, if part of that culture is Christianity, well, there are now far more brown-skinned Christians than white-skinned ones, so opposing immigration on those grounds is not a valid reason.
It's an evolving tradition that is older and deeper than Christianity. There are clearly things this cultural tradition has in common that makes it different to Japanese culture.
 
Last edited:
I know, and instances of real world consequences aren't really what we are debating. My objection is to you making a general principle out of them.


I'm pretty sure an example of this was given by your side of the debate earlier. It was OK for blacks to have indentarian feeling because they were under attack. Hypothetically if there was a movement to give one racial group with negative associations, and make it ok to insult and discriminate against that ethnic group but not others and so on such that that group felt under attack, then some kind of ingroup solidarity that you would call racist is the obvious counter to it.


This is incorrect. Again, I am concerned about real world consequences, I'm just not making a self evident universal law out of them.

Again, I care about consequences, I do not believe in your universal law. I have explained this repeatedly.


What consequences do you think I should take into account that don't take place in the real world? I must be misunderstanding.


I don't reject "any form of morality ". I reject self evident universalist morality. That morality comes from French enlightenment philosophy and I think it is profoundly incorrect and leads to a sort of totalitarian religious like fervour in which anyone who doesn't accept the morality is seen as an evil heretic. I think in its current form it is a type of secularised puritanism.


I don't reject morality though. I just don't share your universalist French enlightenment securised puritan morality. For that I am an evil and hateful heretic.


That is where you are profoundly wrong and mistaken. Morality has existed for thousands of years. You can see aspects of it in other primates. There are different moralities in different places. All of those people with their different moral intuitions and experiences were not waiting for 21st Century progressive liberal politics to invent morality for it. You have one morality amongst many. There is nothing special about yours.


It is possible. Progressive liberalism is as censorious and authoritarian in some respects as the New England puritans when they first landed in the new world. The weird thing is that having exposed myself to that by explaining my views, I keep being accused of concealing my true opinions like this is a witch trial and you want me to confess to curdling all the milk.


I haven't said it doesn't have real world consequences. That is the part of it I care about, not whether it is contrary to your dogma.


I think this is incorrect. The argument would have to be that it can have no benefits. I'm arguing against it being universally bad. I think it was Warp12 who was giving examples of racist policies that progressives supported like affirmative action, and he was told that those were good because of blah, blah, blah. Effectively when racism is good or excusable, it isn't racism and liberal progressives get to decide what is and isn't good and excusable. There is a no true scotsman problem here.


Maybe they will, but this forum represents the left most 10% of American culture if we look at it's progressive opinions. The fact that that 10% laughs doesn't bother me. You guys seem to be incapable of understanding that yours is one morality amongst many and that there are entirely different ways of constructing morality than the French enlightenment model you have. I keep explaining this, and it is just ignored as if I never said it.

Hopefully you notice above that I have answered the question you say I am not answering.

You mean like "Immigrants destroy cultures because of reasons"?
 
You mean like "Immigrants destroy cultures because of reasons"?
That isn't what I think, but to the extent that there is overlap with what I think... that is merely a provisional opinion. I'm not shocked when people disagree. It isn't an axiom that is simply true and about which I get distressed if people disagree. I don't claim it is self evident. I don't claim it is universally true in all circumstances. I am sure there are situations where immigration helps cultures. It is something I can discuss, rather than simply restating it over and over like "but racism is bad". I don't think people are evil for disagreeing with me about it.

Again, you guys seem to be incapable of absorbing world views that differ from your own.
 
Last edited:
That isn't what I think, but to the extent that there is overlap with what I think... that is merely a provisional opinion. I'm not shocked when people disagree. It isn't an axiom that is simply true and about which I get distressed if people disagree. I don't claim it is self evident. I don't claim it is universally true in all circumstances. I am sure there are situations where immigration helps cultures. It is something I can discuss, rather than simply restating it over and over like "but racism is bad". I don't think people are evil for disagreeing with me about it.

Again, you guys seem to be incapable of absorbing world views that differ from your own.

Dogwhistle for "I am incapable of absorbing a worldview where every human is equal therefore I am accusing you of being incapable of absorbing world views that differ from your own"

Or in short: the usual projection/admission from "conservatives".
 
Dogwhistle for "I am incapable of absorbing a worldview where every human is equal therefore I am accusing you of being incapable of absorbing world views that differ from your own"
You are confusing "absorbing" with "adopting". I'm perfectly familiar with the world view. I used to be a leftie. Also, what people mean by "equal" can mean such a broad swath of things that I might even agree with the philosophy. Spiritual equality is the basis for a lot of pro-life positions.

Or in short: the usual projection/admission from "conservatives".
You are confused.
 
You are confusing "absorbing" with "adopting". I'm perfectly familiar with the world view. I used to be a leftie. Also, what people mean by "equal" can mean such a broad swath of things that I might even agree with the philosophy. Spiritual equality is the basis for a lot of pro-life positions.


You are confused.

More projection. :)
 
I think it quite strange that in a thread whose beginning point is a question of whether a nation should keep its white majority, and is based on the presumption that this approach to the future, to which your first responses are to support the disparagment of diversity and to speak of what is "desirable, " with the implicit if not explicit presumption that the present stat is not, I am accused of being a "utopian" for suggesting that the adoption of new policies to achieve that ideal might come at too high a price.
 
I think it quite strange that in a thread whose beginning point is a question of whether a nation should keep its white majority, and is based on the presumption that this approach to the future, to which your first responses are to support the disparagment of diversity and to speak of what is "desirable, " with the implicit if not explicit presumption that the present stat is not, I am accused of being a "utopian" for suggesting that the adoption of new policies to achieve that ideal might come at too high a price.
One can't talk about whether a cost is too high without agreeing on the costs of the various options, which we don't and won't. You think the three quarters of a million dead in the Civil War was worth it, so presumably it is at least conceivable that, were there some kind of a link between immigration and the decline of the west, a terrible price would in fact be acceptable.

Anyway, your argument isn't based on cost, it's based on such a policy being a moral evil, so there is no point in getting in to costs.
 
I think it quite strange that in a thread whose beginning point is a question of whether a nation should keep its white majority, and is based on the presumption that this approach to the future, to which your first responses are to support the disparagment of diversity and to speak of what is "desirable, " with the implicit if not explicit presumption that the present stat is not, I am accused of being a "utopian" for suggesting that the adoption of new policies to achieve that ideal might come at too high a price.


It's a dodge.

Question: Do you think pedophilia is wrong?

shuttit's dodge: There is no absolute good and bad. You are platonic in your commitment to ideals. Something something Burke, whoever the **** that wanker is.

I mean, duh. You're not speaking with a bunch of ignorant cross-eyed fools here, that wallow in Jesus-worshipping superstitions. In a sense we're all pragmatists. If we think pedophilia wrong, it is because we find its effects harmful. The difference is, to us the effect on the children also counts. -----And likewise with the racism thing, and all its subset issues, like mixed marriages.

He's basically using this pragmatism thing, and this Burke he's dug out from some musty corner, as red herrings to divert attention, to basically change the subject. That much is fully clear by now.

The only thing unclear is whether he's only trying to fool us, or himself as well.
 
I know, and instances of real world consequences aren't really what we are debating. My objection is to you making a general principle out of them.

If the consequences are entirely negative, then it has made itself a general principle.

I'm pretty sure an example of this was given by your side of the debate earlier. It was OK for blacks to have indentarian feeling because they were under attack. Hypothetically if there was a movement to give one racial group with negative associations, and make it ok to insult and discriminate against that ethnic group but not others and so on such that that group felt under attack, then some kind of ingroup solidarity that you would call racist is the obvious counter to it.

That may be, but I never said such a thing, nor do I agree with it.
Moreover, your example simply shows that racism is a negative thing, and increased racism creates more hatred and intolerance, and solves nothing.
Have you heard of Martin Luther King? The Civil Rights movement in the US succeeded by doing the exact opposite of your example there.

This is incorrect. Again, I am concerned about real world consequences, I'm just not making a self evident universal law out of them.

Then list the positive real-world consequences of racism. Oh, and I didn't see your answer to my question about Tower Hamlets. If the 43% of its population were deported, how would that benefit the area?

I don't reject "any form of morality ". I reject self evident universalist morality. That morality comes from French enlightenment philosophy and I think it is profoundly incorrect and leads to a sort of totalitarian religious like fervour in which anyone who doesn't accept the morality is seen as an evil heretic. I think in its current form it is a type of secularised puritanism.

Curious. Upthread, a list was posted of what constituted European culture. The Enlightenment philosophies were specifically listed as part of that culture.
In addition, culture is defined by common values.
You are rejecting significant parts of European culture (Christianity too), and also rejecting the general definition of what constitutes a culture, whilst at the same time saying you want to defend that culture. It seems to me that, as you so roundly reject European culture, you are far more of a threat to it than any of the primitive darkies you are so worried about. Have you considered emigrating, so as to save European culture?

I don't reject morality though. I just don't share your universalist French enlightenment securised puritan morality. For that I am an evil and hateful heretic.

As you have demonstrated no replacement morality, then my charge of amorality at minimum stands. You do not appear to have any moral or ethical compass at all, and seem quite proud of that fact. The word 'sociopath' springs to mind. If you disagree, you could always state something that you feel is morally right, or morally wrong.

It is possible. Progressive liberalism is as censorious and authoritarian in some respects as the New England puritans when they first landed in the new world. The weird thing is that having exposed myself to that by explaining my views, I keep being accused of concealing my true opinions like this is a witch trial and you want me to confess to curdling all the milk.

This is not a witch hunt, and I am not a Puritan. I'm not even sure I'm a liberal progressive: perhaps you could define your terms?

I haven't said it doesn't have real world consequences. That is the part of it I care about, not whether it is contrary to your dogma.

You just won't say what those consequences are. OK. :rolleyes:

I think this is incorrect. The argument would have to be that it can have no benefits. I'm arguing against it being universally bad. I think it was Warp12 who was giving examples of racist policies that progressives supported like affirmative action, and he was told that those were good because of blah, blah, blah. Effectively when racism is good or excusable, it isn't racism and liberal progressives get to decide what is and isn't good and excusable. There is a no true scotsman problem here.

Again, you are attributing views to me that I do not hold. I am not a fan of affirmative action.

Maybe they will, but this forum represents the left most 10% of American culture if we look at it's progressive opinions. The fact that that 10% laughs doesn't bother me. You guys seem to be incapable of understanding that yours is one morality amongst many and that there are entirely different ways of constructing morality than the French enlightenment model you have. I keep explaining this, and it is just ignored as if I never said it.

I doubt that. We have, I think, one communist on this forum. I am not aware of any other far-left members. Also, I am not American, nor am I far-left.
 
It's a dodge.
It is not.

Question: Do you think pedophilia is wrong?
I have said already that I'm not against morality. What I'm against is universalist, rationalistic morality that comes from the French enlightenment. The pro-paedophilia/anti-age of consent activism comes from the same universalist/rationalist source.

shuttit's dodge: There is no absolute good and bad. You are platonic in your commitment to ideals. Something something Burke, whoever the **** that wanker is.
There is no universal good or bad. It can be useful to pretend there is, but there isn't. Cultures develop ideas of what is moral and immoral over long periods of time and iterate on that. It's an evolutionary approach. I don't think the idea that racism is a moral evil came out of that approach, so I am suspicious of it. Even if it had, I wouldn't regard it as universal for all peoples. Many of the specific instances of racism that you would object to, I would likely object to as well... I would just get to that view in a different way.

I mean, duh. You're not speaking with a bunch of ignorant cross-eyed fools here, that wallow in Jesus-worshipping superstitions.
You just have a different, newer set of superstitions which, just like many Christians, you consider to be universal in some way. Christianity though has survived for 2000 years across very different situations, so it's core seems unlikely to be absolutely an immediately toxic to society. Progressive morality has been around for the blink of an eye, so I am rather less confident about it.

In a sense we're all pragmatists. If we think pedophilia wrong, it is because we find its effects harmful.
That is a conservative view. Morality based on experience. Much left wing, rationalist thought derived from the sort of assumptions your morality is based on has reached the opposite conclusion on paedophilia.

The difference is, to us the effect on the children also counts. -----And likewise with the racism thing, and all its subset issues, like mixed marriages.
I have said repeatedly that these effects count. Liberals have this blind view that they are the only side that cares, and that if you cared you would support their solutions. What separates us is not that I don't care about the suffering of other people, the issue is more like that I think you radically underestimate the difficulty, unintended consequences and tradeoffs of solving these problems.

He's basically using this pragmatism thing, and this Burke he's dug out from some musty corner, as red herrings to divert attention, to basically change the subject. That much is fully clear by now.
Burke is not some obscure figure. He is arguably, and often described as, the father of conservatism. It's like calling John Locke an obscure figure. Imagine we were having a conversation about Liberal thought and I'd never heard of the French or American revolutions, Locke, Paine, or any of the various articulations of universalist rights like the Constitution. It would be a bit of a difficult and confusing conversation.

The only thing unclear is whether he's only trying to fool us, or himself as well.
The idea that I am trying to fool you by presenting you with the philosophical and historical basis of conservatism, and saying I find significant parts of it convincing, is bizarre. This isn't some secret and unknown tradition.
 
Last edited:
If the consequences are entirely negative, then it has made itself a general principle.
That isn't the way these principles were developed or applied though. I mean, there is all sorts of discrimination actively practiced by progressives that are considered "good". Expressing racial hate is excused because of historic injustices, and other explanations. You routinely have anti-white statements trotted out as "merely speaking the truth". Affirmative action goes without saying. You have two moralities sitting on top of one another.... a universalist, rationalistic one that simply says "racism is bad" and a pragmatic one that gets flipped to when it is convenient.

That may be, but I never said such a thing, nor do I agree with it.
Moreover, your example simply shows that racism is a negative thing, and increased racism creates more hatred and intolerance, and solves nothing.
Ingroup and outgroup bias is simply a fact of the world. The utopia where it isn't and some evil person has come in to this garden of eden trying to turn everybody racist isn't the world. The world we live in is one where minorities are political interest groups who can be leveraged as voting blocks and in return get advantages for their members. That is the world. Or at least it is the US and UK and an increasing number of other places as mass immigration creates these voting blocks waiting to be used.

Have you heard of Martin Luther King? The Civil Rights movement in the US succeeded by doing the exact opposite of your example there.
It was a nice idea. I like it. The problem is that people "not be[ing] judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character" can't really coexist with a perminant bureaucracy of racial social engineering, unresolvable racial greviences being leveraged for political power, and "whiteness studies". I think it was dying for a long time, but it was clearly dead by the end of Obama's first term. Believing in this is like being a libertarian.... it's a lovely philosophy, but it only works if everybody is playing by a very particular set of rules, which they aren't. For the Martin Luther King solution to work, you simply can't have political parties playing to racial voting blocks. So we are back to talking about utopias.... I think as utopias go, this was a nice one.

Then list the positive real-world consequences of racism. Oh, and I didn't see your answer to my question about Tower Hamlets. If the 43% of its population were deported, how would that benefit the area?
This is the problem. Once you've done it, the problems are bordeline non-fixable. De Tocqueville talks about this extensively in relation to the South. The North escaped the problems of slavery by selling what slaves they had to the South.... at least one southern state was more than 50% black. De Tocqueville and the people he talked to in the South basically saw nothing but generation upon generation of racial strife coming and nothing that could be done to avoid it beyond maintaining the existing system. He mentions mixing the races together as in South America as another solution, but clearly that wasn't happening to anything like the degree necessary.

I'm not sure that the non-reversability of the situation is really an argument in it's favour.

Curious. Upthread, a list was posted of what constituted European culture. The Enlightenment philosophies were specifically listed as part of that culture.
They are certainly products of European culture. It feels much too specific to me. Plus the enlightenment took very different forms in different places. Rousseau, Hulme and Kant were all exemplars of the enlightenment, so I think what ever it is needs to be a lot more general and less specific than the philosophy of John Locke.

In addition, culture is defined by common values.
Something like that. Depending on where you go with this, I might quibble.

You are rejecting significant parts of European culture (Christianity too), and also rejecting the general definition of what constitutes a culture, whilst at the same time saying you want to defend that culture.
I think people are taking rather recent, surface level things as being the "culture of the west". Culture can mean those things of course, but I don't think when people talk about it in this thread they mean opera, or double entry book keeping.... . There are always many streams at any one time. I think your stream is going in the wrong direction. Conservative thought is part of the western tradition just as much as the enlightenment thought you appeal to. It's worth remembering that the British enlightenment was a very different thing to the French one, with America being much more influenced by French. What you are really talking about is a development from the French enlightenment, that combined with a number of other things after WW2 to form the politics of the 1960s. As a dominant cultural force, we are only really talking about when that generation took power.... so maybe the 1990s. This is also the generation that killed the MLK dream.

I am English, and all of this is a Franco-American culture being backfilled on top of us. It is antithetical to the version of the Enlightenment that happened on this island. It makes me think very much of Rousseaue's attempt to destroy David Hulme.

It seems to me that, as you so roundly reject European culture, you are far more of a threat to it than any of the primitive darkies you are so worried about. Have you considered emigrating, so as to save European culture?
You are talking about a very brief amount of time, and a single part of the culture within that narrow strip of time. There is a trend for something like conservatism and something like progressivism to be in constant dialogue and contention. One seeking to preserve the things that are of value from the past, the other thinking that the idea it had yesterday should supercede all that collected experience. One thinking that man is perfectable, one that unless he is governed correctly he will revert to savagery. One thinking that the only rason utopia hasn't been constructed is because the previous generation are wicked, the other thinking that utopias are very often more like dystopias. Through that dialogue there is progress of a sort. One or other side getting the upper hand for a time, even an extended time, does not necessarily change the deep culture. If "European culture" means anything, we are talking about something deeper than all this aphemera.... it's the collected experience and prejudices of thousands of years.

As you have demonstrated no replacement morality, then my charge of amorality at minimum stands.
You are expecting morality to be of a particular form. My morality is the slowly developing collection of experiences, prejudices and taboos of 1000 years of English culture, 500 years of Saxon culture before that, and Rome and Greece before that. It's like the steriotypical understanding of the difference between Common Law with all it's precedent, and Roman Law with all it's explicit rules. The fact that 5 minutes ago somebody dreamed up a new morality, and has managed to get a lot of people onboard with it, doesn't get past this basic difference in terms of where that morality comes from. That makes me suspicious of this morality. The fact that this new morality is implementing non-reversable changes that look to me to risk ending this dialog between conservative and progressive traditions within the culture makes me more suspicious. It's not the first time I suppose, something similar happened with the various religious turmoils that are eventually somewhat resolved by Elizabeth I.

You do not appear to have any moral or ethical compass at all, and seem quite proud of that fact. The word 'sociopath' springs to mind. If you disagree, you could always state something that you feel is morally right, or morally wrong.
This is the basic problem. You have no conception of what conservative ethics looks like, how it works, or what it's history is. No wonder you think conservatives are terrible people. Again, this is one of the dominant world views in western thought going back hundreds of years.

This is not a witch hunt, and I am not a Puritan. I'm not even sure I'm a liberal progressive: perhaps you could define your terms?
I think by "progressive" you mean the political tribe that AOC is a member of. Some political philosophers divide liberalism into two schools, progressive liberalism and modus vivendi liberalism.. Vivendi liberalism is basically dead. A brief description is given below from Mearsheimer's The Great Delusion: Liberal dreams and international realities:

Political liberalism, in fact, comes in two varieties: what some call modus vivendi liberalism and progressive liberalism, a terminology I use throughout this book.11 There are basically two important differences between them, the first of which concerns how they think about individual rights. Modus vivendi liberals conceive of rights almost exclusively in terms of individual freedoms, by which they mean the freedom to act without fear of government intrusion. Freedom of speech, freedom of the press, and the right to hold property are representative examples of these rights. The government exists to protect these freedoms from threats that might emanate either from within the broader society or from outside it. Progressive liberals prize the same individual freedoms, which are sometimes called negative rights, but they are also deeply committed to a set of rights that are actively promoted by the government. They believe, for example, that everyone has a right to equal opportunity, which can be achieved only with active government involvement. Modus vivendi liberals are intensely opposed to this notion of positive rights.

You just won't say what those consequences are. OK. :rolleyes:
You want me to list the terrible consequences of racism? People are killed because of it. Is that a sufficient answer?

Again, you are attributing views to me that I do not hold. I am not a fan of affirmative action.
OK, I apologise if I mischaracterised you. Good, but the thing is we do live in a world where things like affirmative action and a host of other racist policies and attitudes are a thing. Such things are official federal policy, the are UK government policy, the UN believes in them. There is the Ron Paul libertarian path to change, I do not think that that has proved very successful. While it is not succeeding, people who believe in and implement explicit race based discrimination against white people are gleefully talking about how this group will be turned into a minority by the immigration they support. Faced with that, and the failure of the MLK approach, nice as it was.... what then?

I doubt that. We have, I think, one communist on this forum. I am not aware of any other far-left members. Also, I am not American, nor am I far-left.
Apologies again. I'm not talking economics, I'm talking social policy. What even is a Communist any more? Just look at the trans issue, or abortion, or Trump. This forum is absolutely, stridently on one side of all of that and a host of other issues besides.

May I ask what country you are from so that I can take that account in considering your politics? I'd be curious to know whether you consider yourself to be a vivendi or progressive liberal given the above definition.
 
Last edited:
He's basically using this pragmatism thing, and this Burke he's dug out from some musty corner, as red herrings to divert attention, to basically change the subject. That much is fully clear by now.
A couple of days ago, shuttit was using "religion" as a pejorative while telling us we should read Burke, specifically Burke's "critique of the French Revolution", in which Burke expressed his belief that religion is the foundation of civil society.

That was laughable. I assumed shuttit was just another pseudointellectual poseur, but no, shuttit now claims to have "a positive view of religion", and has essentially admitted the contempt for religion shuttit displayed two days ago was a dishonest rhetorical device.

Telling us we could best understand shuttit's views by reading Burke was just a dodge. In light of several conflicts between shuttit's arguments and Burke's views (of which shuttit's apparent contempt for religion was only the most obvious), I assumed shuttit, like so many who urge us to read the Bible, was not terribly familiar with Burke's ideas, but no. shuttit now emphasizes shuttit's disagreements with Burke, without identifying specific disagreements other than Burke's fascination with Marie Antoinette.

shuttit's references to Burke also appear intended to apply some pseudointellectual polish to an argument you wouldn't want to find in a punch bowl.

The only thing unclear is whether he's only trying to fool us, or himself as well.
Yep.
 
A couple of days ago, shuttit was using "religion" as a pejorative while telling us we should read Burke, specifically Burke's "critique of the French Revolution", in which Burke expressed his belief that religion is the foundation of civil society.
I was not using religion as a pejorative. I have told you this already.

That was laughable. I assumed shuttit was just another pseudointellectual poseur, but no, shuttit now claims to have "a positive view of religion", and has essentially admitted the contempt for religion shuttit displayed two days ago was a dishonest rhetorical device.
I was not using religion as a pejorative. You provided a long list of times I compared humanism to religion and so on, but I didn't use it as a pejorative. You are simply mistaken. The closest that you can get is that I thought you would not like the comparison, maybe it is from your heart that the feeling that it is a pejorative comes rather than mine? Christianity admits it's revealed, religious nature.... humanism and French enlightenment morality have pretensions to being the product of reason.

W.D.Clinger;13814122[url=http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=13813635#post13813635 said:
Telling us we could best understand shuttit's views by reading Burke was just a dodge.[/url] In light of several conflicts between shuttit's arguments and Burke's views (of which shuttit's apparent contempt for religion was only the most obvious), I assumed shuttit, like so many who urge us to read the Bible, was not terribly familiar with Burke's ideas, but no. shuttit now emphasizes shuttit's disagreements with Burke, without identifying specific disagreements other than Burke's fascination with Marie Antoinette.
Why on Earth would it be important for me to exhaustively search Burke for things I disagree with in order to present an argument that he made that I agree with? When does this ever happen in debate? If somebody quotes Foucault are they being dishonest unless they also support legalised paedophilia? This is a ridiculous standard. Also you remain profoundly mistaken about what I said a couple of days ago about religion.
 
Last edited:
I was not using religion as a pejorative. I have told you this already.


I was not using religion as a pejorative. You provided a long list of times I compared humanism to religion and so on, but I didn't use it as a pejorative. You are simply mistaken. The closest that you can get is that I thought you would not like the comparison, maybe it is from your heart that the feeling that it is a pejorative comes rather than mine? Christianity admits it's revealed, religious nature.... humanism and French enlightenment morality have pretensions to being the product of reason.


Why on Earth would it be important for me to exhaustively search Burke for things I disagree with in order to present an argument that he made that I agree with? When does this ever happen in debate? If somebody quotes Foucault are they being dishonest unless they also support legalised paedophilia? This is a ridiculous standard. Also you remain profoundly mistaken about what I said a couple of days ago about religion.


"Read Burke... Not those writings of his.

But read Burke rather than my explanation of what I believe"
 
I was not using religion as a pejorative. I have told you this already.


I was not using religion as a pejorative. You provided a long list of times I compared humanism to religion and so on, but I didn't use it as a pejorative. You are simply mistaken. The closest that you can get is that I thought you would not like the comparison, maybe it is from your heart that the feeling that it is a pejorative comes rather than mine? Christianity admits it's revealed, religious nature.... humanism and French enlightenment morality have pretensions to being the product of reason.


Why on Earth would it be important for me to exhaustively search Burke for things I disagree with in order to present an argument that he made that I agree with? When does this ever happen in debate? If somebody quotes Foucault are they being dishonest unless they also support legalised paedophilia? This is a ridiculous standard. Also you remain profoundly mistaken about what I said a couple of days ago about religion.

Because then you would not be cherrypicking :rolleyes:
 
I was not using religion as a pejorative. I have told you this already.


I was not using religion as a pejorative. You provided a long list of times I compared humanism to religion and so on, but I didn't use it as a pejorative. You are simply mistaken....


....Also you remain profoundly mistaken about what I said a couple of days ago about religion.


When I was mistaken about shuttit using the word "religion" and related concepts as pejoratives, my mistake was based upon examples such as these:

I don't share the same rituals, taboos and fetishes as you. Like most of the world, I do not share your catechisms.... Once I've told you that, what is the point of over and over again saying "so which interpretation of the Trinity do you have?"? I don't share your religion. Maybe it's shocking to you that I don't believe the wafer is the body of Christ. I still wish my fellow man well, and think that increasing the sum of human happiness is a noble aim. Go ahead and excommunicate me for thinking that the way to achieve that is different from the one in your Gospel.

Read Burke.

I didn't say what was at the root of the problem. The concept of blame and guilt is you using your morality to understand the situation. Please, park that. I don't know how many times I can tell you guys, I do not share your secular religion.

No, not humanitarianism. Humanism perhaps, which is a secular religion. You keep trying to smuggle in your religious catechisms as if they were universal self evident truths. They aren't.

Sure, obviously because it's your secular religious belief. A catholic might find it terribly important how many rosaries one does, or when one last confessed. It's not my world view. Again, most of the world does not share your concerns, and I think it is unlikely they ever will share your concerns.


Turning now to shuttit's post of less than an hour ago, with my highlighting of some amusing typos:

It was a nice idea. I like it. The problem is that people "not be[ing] judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character" can't really coexist with a perminant bureaucracy of racial social engineering, unresolvable racial greviences being leveraged for political power, and "whiteness studies"....


This is the problem. Once you've done it, the problems are bordeline non-fixable....

I'm not sure that the non-reversability of the situation is really an argument in it's favour.
I'm not sure, but I think shuttit is saying some of the responses to what should be a non-problem have made that non-problem borderline unfixable.

They are certainly products of European culture. It feels much too specific to me. Plus the enlightenment took very different forms in different places. Rousseau, Hulme and Kant were all exemplars of the enlightenment, so I think what ever it is needs to be a lot more general and less specific than the philosophy of John Locke.
Hulme?

I am English, and all of this is a Franco-American culture being backfilled on top of us. It is antithetical to the version of the Enlightenment that happened on this island. It makes me think very much of Rousseaue 's attempt to destroy David Hulme .
David Hulme is a Professor of Development Studies at the University of Manchester.

As for the identity of this Rousseaue who attempted to destroy Professor Hulme, I have no idea. (Before you suggest it was just a misspelling of Rousseau, let me remind you that Jean-Jacques Rousseau died in 1778, long before Professor Hulme was born. Before you suggest "David Hulme" was just a misspelling of David Hume's last name, ask yourself whether someone like shuttit would have misspelled Hume's name twice in the same post.)

....One thinking that the only rason utopia hasn't been constructed is because the previous generation are wicked....If "European culture" means anything, we are talking about something deeper than all this aphemera .... it's the collected experience and prejudices of thousands of years.
Maybe "Hulme" was a misspelling after all.

It's like the steriotypical understanding of the difference between Common Law with all it's precedent, and Roman Law with all it's explicit rules.
Maybe it's just me, but I'd be more impressed by shuttit's extravagant displays of erudition if shuttit knew when to use an apostrophe.

This is the basic problem. You have no conception of what conservative ethics looks like, how it works, or what it's history is. No wonder you think conservatives are terrible people. Again, this is one of the dominant world views in western thought going back hundreds of years.
I don't think all conservatives are terrible people. Some are, but the world also contains a few liberals who can't spell worth a darn.

You want me to list the terrible consequences of racism? People are killed because of it. Is that a sufficient answer?
It's nice to find a point of agreement.
 
"Read Burke... Not those writings of his.
You are complaining that I referenced a specific argument? For some reason I should also have included another tangentially related position of his that I also agree with? Why? Would it have mattered if I had disagreed with him on a different argument? What are you talking about? If I mention pythagoras's theorem it's because that's the bit of pythagoras that I think is relevant, not his beliefs about beans.

"But read Burke rather than my explanation of what I believe"
I've explained what I think, people try to read between the lines to intuit my "true beliefs" because nobody in the world could hold the beliefs I claim to have. I give an example of a very famous and well known articulation of those beliefs by the founder of a well known branch of politics that was based on them and everybody acts like their knowledge of politics doesn't extend beyond Steven Pinker.
 
You are complaining that I referenced a specific argument? For some reason I should also have included another tangentially related position of his that I also agree with? Why? Would it have mattered if I had disagreed with him on a different argument? What are you talking about? If I mention pythagoras's theorem it's because that's the bit of pythagoras that I think is relevant, not his beliefs about beans.


I've explained what I think, people try to read between the lines to intuit my "true beliefs" because nobody in the world could hold the beliefs I claim to have. I give an example of a very famous and well known articulation of those beliefs by the founder of a well known branch of politics that was based on them and everybody acts like their knowledge of politics doesn't extend beyond Steven Pinker.

Can you link to your explanation of "White/European Culture" and how it "is in danger from mass immigration" real quick?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom