Can/should European nations maintain their white majorities?

Something still seems to be missing. If I understand shutit correctly, he believes counrtries should be able to ban interracial marriage, but has not said whether he thinks they should. Or if that's too broad, whether the US specifically should, if it had the legal power to.

shutit, saying what your direct opinion is on this will advance the discussion from theoretical principles of governance to your opinion and the reasons for it. It will help you be understood, if you want to be.
 
Something still seems to be missing. If I understand shutit correctly, he believes counrtries should be able to ban interracial marriage, but has not said whether he thinks they should. Or if that's too broad, whether the US specifically should, if it had the legal power to.

shutit, saying what your direct opinion is on this will advance the discussion from theoretical principles of governance to your opinion and the reasons for it. It will help you be understood, if you want to be.
You just stated my opinion. Look, you asked politely, so I will answer in the same spirit. Who on Earth would ban trans-racial marriage at the moment in the US? They'd have to be have a death wish. Suppose some brave state decided to do it. The only impact I can see is waves of left wing violence that would be supported by the federal government, media, and wider American empire. The law wouldn't be allowed to stand. The net effect would be more power centralised to DC. I see no possibility of such a law being passed, and no immediate good that could possibly come from it. Long term good involves making predictions through far too much chaos. My thoughts on it are practical, not ideological.

That really is the totality of my view. I'm happy to clarify if the above is unclear.
 
Last edited:
You just stated my opinion. Look, you asked politely, so I will answer in the same spirit. Who on Earth would ban trans-racial marriage at the moment in the US? Suppose some brave state decided to do it. The only impact I can see is waves of left wing violence that would be supported by the federal government, media, and wider American empire. The law wouldn't be allowed to stand. The net effect would be more power centralised to DC. I see no possibility of such a law being passed, and no immediate good that could possibly come from it. Long term good involves making predictions through far too much chaos. My thoughts on it are practical, not ideological.

That really is the totality of my view.


What about laws that ban racists from marrying, and/or from ever procreating? Would you agree that states should be able to pass such laws, should the majority want that? (And, following your example, without going into the merits of the whether it is a good thing or not to castrate racists; that is, treating that latter as a separate question outside the scope of this particular question.)
 
What about laws that ban racists from marrying, and/or from ever procreating? Would you agree that states should be able to pass such laws, should the majority want that? (And, following your example, without going into the merits of the whether it is a good thing or not to castrate racists; that is, treating that latter as a separate question outside the scope of this particular question.)
I don't believe that it is healthy for one particular morality to be imposed over everything. I think that route is intrinsically totalitarian. I think it is probably better that I accept your state governs itself in a way I disagree with, and you accept that my country governs itself in a way that you disagree with. I don't see a solution to trying to impose one system over everyone that doesn't involve something like the Civil War or coercive use of state power to force compliance. Even if you win, you'll have converted the state into something I suspect you aren't going to like.

Whether the above is possible, I don't know. There seems to be a tendency for power to centralise.
 
To save space I will just quote this one bit.

You have widened the scope now from talking about a particular law being repealed to talking about the whole civil rights movement. That I wasn't talking about things before that you have only just introduced isn't my problem. Obviously I take the civil rights movement into account, we just weren't talking about it. Since I doubt it's fundamental assumptions about the world, it doesn't hold the same holy place in my heart that it does in yours.

I was talking about the whole civil rights movement when you dismissed it as not being historical enough for your taste, but will let that go for the moment.

So you doubt the fundamental assumption about the world, which is that black people should enjoy equal human rights? Ok. So be it.

But for all that, I was not, talking about a particular law being repealed, as I say over and over and over. I was asking, not what your action would be with regard to its repeal. That's a done deal. I was asking, over and over and over, whether you would SUPPORT ITS ESTABLISHMENT! For reasons you apparently find unfortunate and ill-advised, it no longer exists. A right has been established. No such law is now in existence. But there are those in this world who would re-establish it, and remove that right. My question, as I have repeated over and over and over, is whether there is some circumstance in which you would SUPPORT ITS ESTABLISHMENT.

That appears to be a question you cannot answer, and I find that very disturbing.
 
I don't believe that it is healthy for one particular morality to be imposed over everything. I think that route is intrinsically totalitarian. I think it is probably better that I accept your state governs itself in a way I disagree with, and you accept that my country governs itself in a way that you disagree with. I don't see a solution to trying to impose one system over everyone that doesn't involve something like the Civil War or coercive use of state power to force compliance. Even if you win, you'll have converted the state into something I suspect you aren't going to like.

Whether the above is possible, I don't know. There seems to be a tendency for power to centralise.


Would you please answer this without prevaricating? If it turns out in one particular state that as high a percentage of the population as, say, 75%, were in favor of it, then do you, personally, believe that that state has the right to legislate and implement the castration of every racist in that state? Yes, or No, please. (And, following your example, we won't actually address the question of whether or not it is good to castrate racists; we'll treat that as a separate question.)

This is not a trick question. I'll clearly spell out what my purpose is in asking this of you. I personally find your stance on this reprehensible; but should you have enough spine to be able to come back with an unequivocal "Yes" to that question, then I'll readily grant that, although reprehensible, your views on this are at least honest and internally consistent. Otherwise, if either you answer with a "No", or if after this you continue prevaricating, then clearly your views would be shown up, without my having to utter a word more on this, as not just reprehensible but also utterly disingenuous in invoking an objection to totalitarianism, in the form you frame that argument, in making your case.



eta: Just to clarify, even though it is obvious: When I say "your views on this", in that last paragraph, what I mean is your views on "allowing" or "banning" "mixed-racial marriages", as you've argued that issue here.
 
Last edited:
That appears to be a question you cannot answer, and I find that very disturbing.
See my above reply to Chanakya. I keep telling you the answer. You keep not listening to the answer and asking the question again.

I am coming at all this from a completely different angle to you. Just accept that rather than trying to orientate me into your world view. You see inter-racial marriage as an absolute moral good. I don't. I don't see it as fundamental. Try to absorb this, please..... I just don't care about interracial marriage. If the stars aligned such that interracial marriage made society better, I would be for it. If the reverse was true, I would be against it. I do not think at the moment that there is any possibility of it being banned, certainly not in such a way that it stuck, so I have no opinion on the matter. That is the answer. There is no secret answer that I am concealing from you. If you don't have an existing mental box to fit my world view into, build a new one.

Given that you think millions of dead are a price worth paying for the world to have been aligned with your views, I'm not sure that my not having a strong opinion about interracial marriage is such a shocking thing.
 
Last edited:
Interracial marriage an "absolute moral good"? Who's saying that? Interracial marriage just...happens. And it has happened for millennia.
 
Woo hoo! Waves! Leftie violence! Gummint coercion! DC power! (AC power too, why not?) The law will not stand!

How simply dreadful.
 
I don't believe that it is healthy for one particular morality to be imposed over everything. I think that route is intrinsically totalitarian. I think it is probably better that I accept your state governs itself in a way I disagree with, and you accept that my country governs itself in a way that you disagree with. I don't see a solution to trying to impose one system over everyone that doesn't involve something like the Civil War or coercive use of state power to force compliance. Even if you win, you'll have converted the state into something I suspect you aren't going to like.

Whether the above is possible, I don't know. There seems to be a tendency for power to centralise.

Exactly, that's why it is a healthy thing to just ignore all those who want to impose an "all white culture" on us. It's better to not pay attention to those freaks.
 
See my above reply to Chanakya. I keep telling you the answer. You keep not listening to the answer and asking the question again.

I am coming at all this from a completely different angle to you. Just accept that rather than trying to orientate me into your world view. You see inter-racial marriage as an absolute moral good. I don't. I don't see it as fundamental. Try to absorb this, please..... I just don't care about interracial marriage. If the stars aligned such that interracial marriage made society better, I would be for it. If the reverse was true, I would be against it. I do not think at the moment that there is any possibility of it being banned, certainly not in such a way that it stuck, so I have no opinion on the matter. That is the answer. There is no secret answer that I am concealing from you. If you don't have an existing mental box to fit my world view into, build a new one.

Given that you think millions of dead are a price worth paying for the world to have been aligned with your views, I'm not sure that my not having a strong opinion about interracial marriage is such a shocking thing.

I think you are avoiding something. Note the highlighted above--that does not say which of those two societies you think we are in. That it doesn't seem possible to take the action doesn't indicate whether you would choose to if it were possible.

There's no chance at all right now of abandoning first-past-the-post voting across the board and using ranked choice voting. And yet I support doing so and I can easily say that. Right now we're not talking about whether it can be done. Only whether you would if you could and it would stick. I don't want to know right now what you think a nation should have the right to do--you have indeed made that clear. I want to know what you think it should do and why, regardless of whether it can.
 
Last edited:
Would you please answer this without prevaricating? If it turns out in one particular state that as high a percentage of the population as, say, 75%, were in favor of it, then do you, personally, believe that that state has the right to legislate and implement the castration of every racist in that state? Yes, or No, please. (And, following your example, we won't actually address the question of whether or not it is good to castrate racists; we'll treat that as a separate question.)
Within the US constitution I presume it doesn't have the right. For myself, I think it would be shocking, I would be against it.... but then again we have our shoes manufactured by slaves and kill hundreds of thousands of people for oil. ... our morality is a performance, even if we method act ourselves into believing it.

I have answered this question. I will answer it one last time. I think enforcing a single morality on everybody is a bad idea. I think generally it makes the world worse rather than better. I would be very suspicious of our ability to force those 75% into compliance without so much blood and chaos that the medicine is worse than the illness. I also agree with Mearsheimer that your view leads to a kind of permanent call to Jihad. There is always another Hitler to be conquered, and if there isn't it will always be in somebody's interests to invent one for us.

The mere fact that there is some place where something I find morally reprehensible is going on is not enough for me to intervene. We have our shoes and phones made by slave, support dictatorships when it suits us and think millions of dead a price worth paying to spread our values to name but a few things. Were it not for our power, nobody would take moral lessons from us.

Part of the reason I harp on about slave labour etc.... is that those are the interests who control Washington. It is those people who you are wanting to empower to enforce your morality. They probably will implement a bunch of things they don't care about like mixed race marriages, but it's a deal with the devil.

This is not a trick question. I'll clearly spell out what my purpose is in asking this of you. I personally find your stance on this reprehensible; but should you have enough spine to be able to come back with an unequivocal "Yes" to that question, then I'll readily grant that, although reprehensible, your views on this are at least honest and internally consistent.
My answer is "yes". Given that my views are reprehensible, I turn the question around.... how much death do you think implementing your view is worth? All these things have a price. How much more power do you want to centralise in Washington where it can be controlled by lobbyists? What are you prepared to do to force your views on the world?

Incidentally, I appreciate what feels like very honest engagement.
 
Last edited:
Within the US constitution I presume it doesn't have the right. For myself, I think it would be shocking, I would be against it.... but then again we have our shoes manufactured by slaves and kill hundreds of thousands of people for oil. ... our morality is a performance, even if we method act ourselves into believing it.

I have answered this question. I will answer it one last time. I think enforcing a single morality on everybody is a bad idea. I think generally it makes the world worse rather than better. I would be very suspicious of our ability to force those 75% into compliance without so much blood and chaos that the medicine is worse than the illness. I also agree with Mearsheimer that your view leads to a kind of permanent call to Jihad. There is always another Hitler to be conquered, and if there isn't it will always be in somebody's interests to invent one for us.

The mere fact that there is some place where something I find morally reprehensible is going on is not enough for me to intervene. We have our shoes and phones made by slave, support dictatorships when it suits us and think millions of dead a price worth paying to spread our values to name but a few things. Were it not for our power, nobody would take moral lessons from us.

Part of the reason I harp on about slave labour etc.... is that those are the interests who control Washington. It is those people who you are wanting to empower to enforce your morality. They probably will implement a bunch of things they don't care about like mixed race marriages, but it's a deal with the devil.


My answer is "yes". Given that my views are reprehensible, I turn the question around.... how much death do you think implementing your view is worth? All these things have a price. What are you prepared to do to force your views on the world?


Although with very many words thrown in, in the end that was squarely answered. Thank you. And I readily concede that your views, while utterly reprehensible and barbaric, are nevertheless honest and consistent, in their readiness to yield to majority view.

Happy to reciprocate by answering clearly. That isn't what I want done, at all, the castration business. Far from evaluating the cost I'm willing to allow to make that happen, on the contrary, I'd be willing to go to great lengths and "allow" a great deal of "cost" to ensure something of that kind never ever came to pass. Because even without the extravagant barbarity of castration thrown in, even simply not permitting racists to marry would, in my book, would be just as reprehensible as not allowing inter-racial marriages, as you quaintly describe them. I don't think a state that allows either law to pass has any right to call itself civilized, and in my view is so ...evil, if a may use a word I rarely use, an institution that its complete dissolution may be a good thing.
 
I think you are avoiding something. Note the highlighted above--that does not say which of those two societies you think we are in. That it doesn't seem possible to take the action doesn't indicate whether you would choose to if it were possible.
A society in which something is impossible isn't a society in which the impossible thing can be positive or negative because it is impossible. Do you want me to say whether it would be positive or negative if we changed society such that it were possible? It would depend how we changed society to make it possible. Maybe Chanakya understands this and can explain it to you, I don't know. There is no answer in my morality to the question that does not take into account the practicalities of implementing it and how it would play out. Given that it can't be implemented, I have no answer.

Your question is like demanding to know whether it is a good idea to drive to the moon. You can't drive to the moon, and if you somehow found a way of doing it.... the answer would probably depend a lot on knowing the details of how you proposed to do it. These things just aren't good or bad in a vacuum.

There's no chance at all right now of abandoning first-past-the-post voting across the board and using ranked choice voting. And yet I support doing so and I can easily say that.
Yes. I have said this repeatedly. That is because of the structure of the liberal world view. You have universal goods that you can reason from and get answers to these kinds of questions.

Right now we're not talking about whether it can be done. Only whether you would if you could and it would stick. I don't want to know right now what you think a nation should have the right to do--you have indeed made that clear. I want to know what you think it should do and why, regardless of whether it can.
There is no "should do" for me about impossibilities, certainly not when taken in isolation. That is another liberal trait.... looking at these things in isolation as if you could choose everything from the a la carte menu. Everything is intertwined. There is no "in isolation" answer to most of your questions.
 
Last edited:
Since the issue isn't really intermarriage, but rather interracial children, I don't see how any country could regulate that except through tightly enforced segregation - or mandatory IVF
 
Happy to reciprocate by answering clearly. That isn't what I want done, at all, the castration business. Far from evaluating the cost I'm willing to allow to make that happen, on the contrary, I'd be willing to go to great lengths and "allow" a great deal of "cost" to ensure something of that kind never ever came to pass. Because even without the extravagant barbarity of castration thrown in, even simply not permitting racists to marry would, in my book, would be just as reprehensible as not allowing inter-racial marriages, as you quaintly describe them. I don't think a state that allows either law to pass has any right to call itself civilized, and in my view is so ...evil, if a may use a word I rarely use, an institution that its complete dissolution may be a good thing.
OK, but how much blood? The figure I found for the deaths in the civil war is approximately 2.5% of the US population at the time. In current numbers that would be about 8.2 million dead and who knows how many wounded, financially ruined, mentally destroyed etc. Would that be a price you would pay to keep interracial marriage? You'd wreck the states whose reprehensible ways you wanted to change, so the suffering would be immense... I wonder if the people you were seeking to save wouldn't suffer more from being rescued than they suffered before.

My point is that, our moral instincts have costs. I don't think there is any likelihood of interracial marriage being banned. At the end of the day though, if half the country want it.... is it really an answer to the question to say "it is wrong therefore we should stop it". OK, but when half the country fundamentally disagree with you, either you find a way of living with things you despise, or you are saying that your principles are worth inflicting suffering on a vast scale. I don't necessarily mean there would be another civil war, but how do you impose your views on so many people who despise your morality? Imagine they were imposing what ever conservative state it is you fear.... what would be required to do that? Is doing that worth it to impose your morality on them? What would you have to become in order to do that?
 
OK, but how much blood? The figure I found for the deaths in the civil war is approximately 2.5% of the US population at the time. In current numbers that would be about 8.2 million dead and who knows how many wounded, financially ruined, mentally destroyed etc. Would that be a price you would pay to keep interracial marriage? You'd wreck the states whose reprehensible ways you wanted to change, so the suffering would be immense... I wonder if the people you were seeking to save wouldn't suffer more from being rescued than they suffered before.

My point is that, our moral instincts have costs. I don't think there is any likelihood of interracial marriage being banned. At the end of the day though, if half the country want it.... is it really an answer to the question to say "it is wrong therefore we should stop it". OK, but when half the country fundamentally disagree with you, either you find a way of living with things you despise, or you are saying that your principles are worth inflicting suffering on a vast scale. I don't necessarily mean there would be another civil war, but how do you impose your views on so many people who despise your morality? Imagine they were imposing what ever conservative state it is you fear.... what would be required to do that? Is doing that worth it to impose your morality on them? What would you have to become in order to do that?


Good question.

I believe the Civil War was worth the cost, given the ideals fought for. But would I personally elect to unleash death and destruction to enforce my morals on (some) others? To be entirely honest, probably not. But I could, and would, elect to have nothing to do with such a state, even if that entailed a personal cost, financial and/or otherwise.
 
Good question.

I believe the Civil War was worth the cost, given the ideals fought for.
I would say it would only be worth the cost if it made people's lives happier (not necessarily in that generation) and was plausibly the best way of achieving that. I am dubious about ideals in the abstract of outcomes. Otherwise it becomes a little bit too much like doing it to keep one's own soul pure.

But would I personally elect to unleash death and destruction to enforce my morals on (some) others? To be entirely honest, probably not.
Isn't that the popular view of what happened in the 1860s? The North believed slavery was wrong and fought a war to force the South to comply?

But I could, and would, elect to have nothing to do with such a state, even if that entailed a personal cost, financial and/or otherwise.
Sure. Maybe we aren't so far apart? I don't think this is where we are going though. Gradually power has been pulled from the states to the federal government and a single centralised morality is being imposed on everybody. It's been bleeding out into the rest of the English speaking world. That is one of the sources of the current tension.
 
Last edited:
You really have to admire the resolve and courage of those who say "I am willing to (have others) suffer for the causes I believe in!"
 
See my above reply to Chanakya. I keep telling you the answer. You keep not listening to the answer and asking the question again.

I am coming at all this from a completely different angle to you. Just accept that rather than trying to orientate me into your world view. You see inter-racial marriage as an absolute moral good. I don't. I don't see it as fundamental. Try to absorb this, please..... I just don't care about interracial marriage. If the stars aligned such that interracial marriage made society better, I would be for it. If the reverse was true, I would be against it. I do not think at the moment that there is any possibility of it being banned, certainly not in such a way that it stuck, so I have no opinion on the matter. That is the answer. There is no secret answer that I am concealing from you. If you don't have an existing mental box to fit my world view into, build a new one.

Given that you think millions of dead are a price worth paying for the world to have been aligned with your views, I'm not sure that my not having a strong opinion about interracial marriage is such a shocking thing.
Once again, I am baffled by your point of view. I have no idea why you believe I think millions of dead are a price worth paying for alignment with my views. What views? What dead? What do you think I am doing or saying to promote this? I'm an American, for sure, but unless you'd like to accept me as an immigrant, which seems unlikely, there's only so much I can do about the sins of the country I was born into.

In any case, I don't think I've ever seen you come up before with the direct answer I highlighted, which is what I was asking, so I will leave it, with apologies if I missed that specific statement previously. Consider it said.

It is my earnest belief that "stars aligning" aside, you cannot make society better by instituting something that makes it worse.

I remember an amusing, if fiercely utilitarian, old computer game called "Hamurabi," (the single M a concession to 8-character file names). In this game one is the administrator of a society with a small body of rules and a budget, and the kicker is that you must allow a certain percentage of your subjects to starve or the society will collapse. I don't think life is that simple.

You might make it better for some, more comfortable for some, even for a majority, but a society is a whole thing, and while the comfort of the many is one value, it is not the only one. In what essential way does your conditional acceptance of racism differ from that of genocide or slavery, other than your personal judgment of its importance?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom