Can ID be disproven?

Meadmaker said:
Michael Behe believes that all life descended from common, single celled ancestors. That's what I meant in reference to him being an evolutionist. He also believes that it did not happen without divine guidance. Indeed, he believes it could not have happened without divine (or at least designer, but we know what he means) guidance. He rejects that part of the theory.
That makes him a divinely-guided evolutionist or something. Please stop using terms with accepted definitions for ideas that are major alterations of the accepted definition.

There is no divine guidance in the theory of evolution.

~~ Paul
 
Last edited:
It does? Falsifiable you say.

Science per se has no views; homo saps who deem themselves scientists may. How would you justify the falsifiability claim you made?

It is, by it's very definition. If it were not, it would not be scientific, see? A scientific theory is falsafiable. Period.
 
I see. Which abiogenesis theory are you happiest with, falsifiable of course "or it wouldn't be scientific".


Paul said:
There is no divine guidance in the theory of evolution.
Yeah, that's the discussion we're having. You're still in the right thread.
 
Last edited:
It certainly doesn't.

But can you direct me to some information on the workable, falsifiable, hypothesis for abiogenesis. I haven't been able to come up with anything more complicated that the open faced sandwich model, and that wasn't exactly spelled out in great detail. I wouldn't know how to falsify it.
This site looks like it has some good links.

Though I have not read it, the book The Spark of Life: Darwin and the Primeval Soup looks very interesting.

The point is that there is lots of information out there if you are truly interested in falsifiable scientific hypotheses (and, dare I say it, theories) about abiogenesis. There is nothing mystical about it.
 
It is not correct to equate "random" and "discriminatory." .

then my argument falls at the first fence. :(
If 'random' instead equates to 'discrimination' then this suggests you regard 'random' as a noun in this context.

More appropriate to say is that "random" in the first sense is descriptive, while "random" in the second sense is not a descriptive term; it is establishing the process as the thing itself.

You regard 'random' as 'the thing itself', i.e. as a noun (in this context)?

Look at the other term appended to "random" in its use regarding a descriptor of evolution: "chance." Chance is a descriptor (chance meeting) it is also a noun (chance). Chance and random have been equated in this conversation. If something is random, it is chance.

But 'chance' can be both an adjective and a noun as you've demonstrated, is it possible that random can be both? Is it not possible to interpret the use of 'random' in the phrase 'Evolution is random' as an adjective rather than a noun?

Evolution is neither random nor chance. Nor is dating discrimination. Nor is an iterative process iteration. Nor is a baseball player a baseball. Nor is a summer storm Summer.

These analogies only hold if you insist that 'random' is a noun, since all your other sentences finish with nouns.

If you think that 'random' can only be a noun in this context, do you regard it as synonymous with 'randomness'? How do you regard 'stochastic'?
 
Hammegk said:
Yeah, that's the discussion we're having. You're still in the right thread.
There is no divine guidance in the theory of evolution, same as the rest of science. If you want divine guidance, make up a new name. Then after you do the work to define divine guidance and demonstrate that your new theory is correct, we'll incorporate the results into the accepted theory of evolution.

Meanwhile, it is disingenuous to say that Behe is an evolutionist. But, after all, big fat lies are the staple of ID creationism.

Liar: Ooh, I'm an evolutionist. I just think there is an intelligent designer in there somewhere.

Me: Okay, who is the designer, how did he do it, and when did he do it?

Liar: That is not part of my program.

Me: What is your program?

Liar: To say that I'm an evolutionist, but to mean that goddidit.

Me: You're a big fat liar who tells lying lies.


~~ Paul
 
Let's not forget the very simple point that the "God - er, I mean, the Intelligent Designer - designed and created evolution" claim is completely vacuous.

If I take what would appear to be an evenly balanced coin, and flip it ten thousand times, and discover that it comes up heads approximately as often as it comes up tails, there is no reason to conclude that some external force induced it to flip "fairly". Fair flipping is what we would logically expect from a balanced coin.

Now, if we take a coin that we think should be balanced, and statistical analysis shows that one side is favored over another, then we can reasonably conclude that an external factor is involved. If we eliminate all known causes of bias, then (and ONLY then) should be consider the possibility of a previously-unknown factor.

The evolution of biological and non-biological populations is precisely what we would expect to be the result of natural selection alone. Natural selection is the inevitable result of some very simple principles of statistics, which are an inevitable result of basic mathematics. Claiming that such results were "designed" is falling back on the God-of-the-gaps, and is invalid.
 
Let's examine the whoppers. The errors of Behe and Dembski, cited by Paul.

Dembski discusses the probability of the flagellum falling together as a discrete combinatorial object. Either (a) he is rejecting evolution as the source of the flagellum, or (b) he is an idiot.

~~ Paul

It's tempting to say that a is correct, and leave it at that. Dembski rejects evolution as the source of the flagellum. This isn't exactly news. Also, a and b are not mutually exclusive.

So, really, I don't understand the phrasing. However, there have been a number of complaints about Dembski's probability calculations, and I will assume that the general complaint that shows Dembski's error is somehow related to that probability calculation. So, it's worth discussing, whether or not I can figure out exactly what Paul was saying.

Dembski has indeed made a calculation that showed the probability of the flagellum falling together is really, really, small. I think the exact odds were a gazillion to one.

The usual response to this is to say he is an idiot because that isn't how evolution happens. Sometimes, not content with merely asserting stupidity, they might also add that he knows that isn't how evolution happens, and that therefore his mischaracterization is deliberate. On this board, it's considered cool to say "straw man" at that point.

He does indeed know that this isn't the model evolution proposes for assembly of flagella, and he states this frequently, although scientists don't exactly like the way he states it. He states it by saying that there is no model for how flagella develop, and he's right.

But that isn't the point of his argument anyway. He is using that probability as an indicator of complexity. This isn't some sort of bizarre, weird ID thing. As a second semester physics student, I had homework problems that required me to calculate entropy, a measure of complexity, for hands of cards. He's doing the same thing here, although he doesn't use the term, "entropy". His "specified complexity" is suspiciously close to the statistical definition of entropy.

(Book plug: William Poundstone, The Recursive Universe. Until I read that book, I didn't understand the statistical interpretation of the second law of thermodynamics, and I learned some cool stuff about Conrad's "Game of Life".)

He is pointing out that living systems are very, very, complex. Then, he asks how complex systems come into existence. He looks around at other complex systems, and asks where they came from. In every case where we know the origin of a complex system, that complex system came about from design. He then claims it is reasonable to infer that design played a role in those complex systems, as well.

In other words, his calculations shouldn't be taken as "Evolution says the flagellum fell together from a bunch of random stuff, but that is highly improbable. Therefore Evolution is wrong." Rather, it should be taken as "Evolution can't explain how the flagellum came together. If it were to fall together randomly, it would be highly improbable. We know of other systems that also would be highly improbable to fall together randomly. In all of those systems where the origin can be determined, design was a factor. Therefore, we think design was a factor here, as well."

It isn't a proof that design happened, and he doesn't claim it is. However, it doesn't strike me as some sort of off the wall, wacky, concept, nor does it misrepresent anything about evolution.

I'll refrain from further comment until some feedback is received.
 
Let's examine the whoppers. The errors of Behe and Dembski, cited by Paul.



It's tempting to say that a is correct, and leave it at that. Dembski rejects evolution as the source of the flagellum. This isn't exactly news. Also, a and b are not mutually exclusive.

So, really, I don't understand the phrasing. However, there have been a number of complaints about Dembski's probability calculations, and I will assume that the general complaint that shows Dembski's error is somehow related to that probability calculation. So, it's worth discussing, whether or not I can figure out exactly what Paul was saying.

Dembski has indeed made a calculation that showed the probability of the flagellum falling together is really, really, small. I think the exact odds were a gazillion to one.

The usual response to this is to say he is an idiot because that isn't how evolution happens. Sometimes, not content with merely asserting stupidity, they might also add that he knows that isn't how evolution happens, and that therefore his mischaracterization is deliberate. On this board, it's considered cool to say "straw man" at that point.

He does indeed know that this isn't the model evolution proposes for assembly of flagella, and he states this frequently, although scientists don't exactly like the way he states it. He states it by saying that there is no model for how flagella develop, and he's right.

But that isn't the point of his argument anyway. He is using that probability as an indicator of complexity. This isn't some sort of bizarre, weird ID thing. As a second semester physics student, I had homework problems that required me to calculate entropy, a measure of complexity, for hands of cards. He's doing the same thing here, although he doesn't use the term, "entropy". His "specified complexity" is suspiciously close to the statistical definition of entropy.

(Book plug: William Poundstone, The Recursive Universe. Until I read that book, I didn't understand the statistical interpretation of the second law of thermodynamics, and I learned some cool stuff about Conrad's "Game of Life".)

He is pointing out that living systems are very, very, complex. Then, he asks how complex systems come into existence. He looks around at other complex systems, and asks where they came from. In every case where we know the origin of a complex system, that complex system came about from design. He then claims it is reasonable to infer that design played a role in those complex systems, as well.

In other words, his calculations shouldn't be taken as "Evolution says the flagellum fell together from a bunch of random stuff, but that is highly improbable. Therefore Evolution is wrong." Rather, it should be taken as "Evolution can't explain how the flagellum came together. If it were to fall together randomly, it would be highly improbable. We know of other systems that also would be highly improbable to fall together randomly. In all of those systems where the origin can be determined, design was a factor. Therefore, we think design was a factor here, as well."

It isn't a proof that design happened, and he doesn't claim it is. However, it doesn't strike me as some sort of off the wall, wacky, concept, nor does it misrepresent anything about evolution.

I'll refrain from further comment until some feedback is received.

Meadmaker, you are so, so, so wrong!!

It's Conway's Game of Life. :)
 
Meanwhile, it is disingenuous to say that Behe is an evolutionist. But, after all, big fat lies are the staple of ID creationism.

All right, Paul. Have it your way. He believes in the common descent of all organisms from single celled organisms.

What do you think he ought to be called?
 
Can anyone tell me what this man is talking about?
Lost track of the discussion already? An ID Journal, sir, exists, sir, at least one, sir. If you would be so kind, sir, as to find the ID research article examples I requested pages and pages ago. SHOW ME THE ID RESEARCH THAT SUGGESTS ID IS REALLY SCIENTIFIC. SHOW ME THE ARTICLES DEMONSTRATING ANTI-ID NULL HYPOTHESES THAT COULD NOT BE REFUTED.

Is this clear enough, sir?
 
There is a common misconception about ID. This common misconception is that ID is not compatible with evolution.

And of course, the reason this "common misconception" exists is because every ID proponent on the planet with the possible exception of Meadmaker has been painting it on the rooftops.

There's also a "common misconception" that the capital of France is Paris, promulgated by every cartographer in the world.
 
It isn't a proof that design happened, and he doesn't claim it is. However, it doesn't strike me as some sort of off the wall, wacky, concept, nor does it misrepresent anything about evolution.
Bullpucky. Again. The fundamental misrepresentation is that the probability calculations need to be done in a) a stepwise fashion and b) as a chain of conditional probabilities. But our friend ignores that by way of his unfounded foregone conclusion that it can't have happened stepwise.
 
All right, Paul. Have it your way. He believes in the common descent of all organisms from single celled organisms.

What do you think he ought to be called?
Well, since his main thrust is that there is some greater entity behind it, perhaps "Guided diversification". Maybe "Godolution."
 
Well, since his main thrust is that there is some greater entity behind it, perhaps "Guided diversification". Maybe "Godolution."
Well, since this "God" or "not_God" or "almost God" or "CLod" must have poked his fingers in several times to have made all of this happen, may I suggest coitus interruptus might be more appropriate?
 
Hammegk said:
I didn't realize you were at the policy making level. Does Your Holyness prefer burnt offerings? First born sons? What?
I prefer clarity of discussion, which includes restraint in the redefinition of terms. Science eschews the goddidit factor because it's no explanation at all. If someone tosses in some goddidit, I would not say that he "believes in evolution."

~~ Paul
 
I prefer clarity of discussion, which includes restraint in the redefinition of terms. Science eschews the goddidit factor because it's no explanation at all. If someone tosses in some goddidit, I would not say that he "believes in evolution."

~~ Paul

Shhhh, Paul, you're spoiling it! Tricky is bucking to have a Book Of Darwin inserted just after Genesis. Dang, boy, you're gonna mess him up. That, and his beatification bid.


St. Tricky. Just rolls off the tongue, don't it?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom