Can ID be disproven?

Let me explain my earlier response to this statement. It was apparently somewhat opaque.

The ID crowd thinks that God, not aliens, has already built an organic evolution engine, and the people on this board, as predicted, do not realize that such a thing actually exists.

Where does any ID proponent say that God build an organic evolution machine? If so, where is the machine located and can I order one?:D

The only evidenced "evolution machine" is evolution as current science proposes. If ID is claiming God built evolution, why do they aggressively dispute evolutionary theory? That' s a complete contridiction.

Also, you are misreading my statement - by "people on this board", I mean humans at this point in time, including the ID camp, so how could the recognize something they can't recognize???
 
But so does everything else. All of our natural laws are causal. The current state of the system is based on the current input and previous state. So what happened before there was a previous state? This is a problem for every possible answer to the question of the origin of the universe, whether it is a God or a non-God.

Your reply does not seem to address the issue we are talking about, which was not cause and effect.

We were talking about the fact that the concept "intelligent design" as described is nonsensical.
 
A SAC for terra just pushes ID elsewhere.

"Supernatural" is a meaningless concept bandied about by materialists (and accepted by dualists, I suppose).

That's the problem, isn't it? If SAC just pushes ID elsewhere (to be slightly sarcastic: "It's turtles everywhere you look!") and SNB (SuperNatural Being) is meaningless, then what is left? We have removed natural intelligence as well as supernatural intelligence. That leaves non-intelligence - unless you have an alternative to posit?

BTW: thanks for a related response. :)
 
That's the problem, isn't it? If SAC just pushes ID elsewhere (to be slightly sarcastic: "It's turtles everywhere you look!")
I'd say the discussion of where, and when, it all started is far beyond this level of discourse. Personally I tend to go with Atman=Brahman.

and SNB (SuperNatural Being) is meaningless, then what is left? We have removed natural intelligence as well as supernatural intelligence. That leaves non-intelligence - unless you have an alternative to posit?
How, and from where, have we "removed natural intelligence" -- whatever that is?

BTW: thanks for a related response. :)
My responses usually are. :) (Even the one you objected to, as I see it.)
 
All of our natural laws are causal. The current state of the system is based on the current input and previous state. So what happened before there was a previous state? This is a problem for every possible answer to the question of the origin of the universe, whether it is a God or a non-God.

Two things occur to me on seeing this statement:

1) It is important to note that the origin of the universe -- or of life, for that matter -- is irrelevant when considering the ID vs. evolution "controversy". Thus this thread may be moving afield.

2) To move further afield, it is not clear to me that we need to have an origin of the universe. I see no reason to think that it cannot be eternal going both forward and backward in time. Idle speculation on my part.

Cheers,

Hank
 
Last edited:
Two things occur to me on seeing this statement:

1) It is important to note that the origin of the universe -- or of life, for that matter -- is irrelevant when considering the ID vs. evolution "controversy". Thus this thread may be moving afield.

2) To move further afield, it is not clear to me that we need to have an origin of the universe. I see no reason to think that it cannot be eternal going both forward and backward in time. Idle speculation on my part.

Hank

I suspect the further afield responses are because there has been no direct or sustainable response to the what exactly does the phrase "Intelligent Design" mean question? We all know the off-the-cuff press release answers, but a truthful answer to the question is really all that is needed.
 
2) To move further afield, it is not clear to me that we need to have an origin of the universe. I see no reason to think that it cannot be eternal going both forward and backward in time. Idle speculation on my part.

Cheers,

Hank

I agree. I could explain what I was thinking about, and will if someone really cares, but I'l try to get back on track. As you noted, the origin of the universe isn't really germaine to the discussion, which is about what happened afterwards.

Before I talk about the nature of science, and whether "supernatural" events can ever be included in scientific study, I want to bring up a point. It's not a new point. It's an old one. There is a lot of talk about the errors in what "they", the ID crowd says, but there are very few actual references to what they really and truly say. As I read about the Dover trial and started reading a few excerpts about what they said, it seemed much more reasonable than I expected. Indeed, in the work of MacBehe and MacDembski, I couldn't find anything that misrepresented evolution, or which made any glaring errors of fact or logic.

The worst I found was that they had overstated their conclusions, and that Dembski in particular insisted that he was not making an argument from ignorance, but I thought he was. If anyone would like to post an example of real, honest to goodness whoppers on their part, i.e. statements that are Just Plain Wrong, I would like to see them. If I'm defending a pair of clods that can't tell genes from jeans, I want to know it.

Now about science.

Well, I suppose the dictionary is a good place to start. At the risk of offending someone here, I'll just go ahead and quote it.

It seems there are six entries in my dictionary.
1. Originally, state of fact or knowing. (I don't think that's what we want.)
2. Systematized knowledge derived from observation, study, and experimentation, carried on in order to determine the nature or principles of what is being studied. (That's what I think of. If it uses the scientific method, it's science.)
3. A branch of knowledge or study, as in the science of music.
4. (a) the systematized knowledge of nature and the physical world: (b) any branch of this. (I think this is what Hank had in mind. Is it Hank?)
5. skill....based on training, as in the "science of boxing".
6. Christian Science. (I think we can ignore that one.)

I will let Hank speak for himself, but I think 2 and 4 are the ones most of us think of. 4 might be the one where contention is created though. Science concerns itself with the nature and the physical world. God's outside of that. He doesn't work by the laws of nature. Therefore, whether he exists or not, he isn't science. Talking about God is, by definition, not science. Right?

Well, not quite. Let us imagine that God not only exists, but that he works miracles, on either a large scale or small. Let us imagine that, once in a while, divine healing realy takes place, or lightning is really made to strike just because God wanted it to. Or maybe that God chooses a particular mutation, or that God intervenes to make sure a particular organism survives so that its DNA could be passed on. I don't believe in that, but plenty of people do. Let us imagine, for the sake of argument, that they are correct.

Then, in order to understand nature and the physical world, you would have to understand God and/or the "supernatural". If there is no God, then God is irrelevant to science. However, if there is a God, He's right back in the thick of things. ID proponents believe that not only is He around, but that evidence of Him can be detected. Are they correct? I can't prove them wrong. But if I automatically assume that He plays no role, then I have made an unscientific assumption.
 
If ID is claiming God built evolution, why do they aggressively dispute evolutionary theory? That' s a complete contridiction.

There is a common misconception about ID. This common misconception is that ID is not compatible with evolution. I am occaisionally responsible for spreading that misconception here, by using ID and evolution as if they were opposites, but because you are new to the thread, you may have missed a lot of that discussion.

At any rate, you may or may not be aware that some ID supporters fully accept the reality of evolution. In particular, Michael Behe, most prominent among scientists who are ID supporters, is an evolutionist.

The aspect of evolutionary theory that they all reject is the part that says it happened without divine guidance.

As for, "if God built evolution", I know that I am in part to blame for that little twist in the thread, so I take responsibility, but this sort of view of evolution, which might be considered a bit "deistic", is not accepted by most IDers. They think that the active participation of God, either by choosing when to mutate DNA, or how to guide survival of the not quite fittest, was necessary.
 
"Supernatural" is a meaningless concept bandied about by materialists (and accepted by dualists, I suppose).
The dictionary gives its etymology as medieval Latin so this makes it more likely a meaningless concept bandied about by dualists. Go to newadvent.org to see it still being bandied about by dualists.

And I would think that materialists would reject the concept by definition.
 
Meadmaker said:
At any rate, you may or may not be aware that some ID supporters fully accept the reality of evolution. In particular, Michael Behe, most prominent among scientists who are ID supporters, is an evolutionist.

The aspect of evolutionary theory that they all reject is the part that says it happened without divine guidance.
You know, you are one of the most squirrely posters I've ever talked with. If an IDer has to modify the theory of evolution to inject divine guidance, then he is not accepting the theory of evolution.

Dembski discusses the probability of the flagellum falling together as a discrete combinatorial object. Either (a) he is rejecting evolution as the source of the flagellum, or (b) he is an idiot.

"An irreducibly complex biological system, if there is such a thing, would be a powerful challenge to Darwinian evolution."
---Michael Behe

~~ Paul
 
Last edited:
There is a common misconception about ID. This common misconception is that ID is not compatible with evolution.

That's simply not true. I have been researching that topic and have dozens of references from Behe and others disagreeing with any number of aspects of evolution and most of them quite wholesale. You are underestimating and/or missing the fact the Intelligent Design is a political movement and political movement only.

The aspect of evolutionary theory that they all reject is the part that says it happened without divine guidance.

All? That again is not accurate. Many IDs pointedly avoid "divine" references, bending backwards completely. A small vocal minority pushes "super aliens" or other such non divine.

As for, "if God built evolution", I know that I am in part to blame for that They think that the active participation of God, either by choosing when to mutate DNA, or how to guide survival of the not quite fittest, was necessary.

This is more your argument or statement (not sure if you actually believe it) than ID. Most ID proponents categorically reject any evolution of complex systems or interspecies jumps, God directed or not.
 
You know, you are one of the most squirrely posters I've ever talked with. If an IDer has to modify the theory of evolution to inject divine guidance, then he is not accepting the theory of evolution.

I didn't say he accepted the theory. I said he accepted the reality.

Oops. I think there's an opacity problem, isn't there?

Michael Behe believes that all life descended from common, single celled ancestors. That's what I meant in reference to him being an evolutionist. He also believes that it did not happen without divine guidance. Indeed, he believes it could not have happened without divine (or at least designer, but we know what he means) guidance. He rejects that part of the theory.

Were the Behe and Dembski references the "whoppers"? I will proceed on that assumption, although I will spare you for at least a day.

Stephen,
Many, perhaps even most, ID proponents are creationists, but not all are.
 
Last edited:
100 years? If you're very, very, lucky. I guess I'm going to have to remind you about black holes again.

/.QUOTE]


I guess I'm going to have to remind you about mortality.

*sigh*

My point, Meadmaker, is that no-one having this discussion will be alive to witness the results. Black holes, remember? We don't have to witness it to pretty much figure out how it works.
 
ID has access to all the information science has. Are they ignoring it? If so, what are they ignoring? In this case, I'm referring to abiogenesis. What are they ignoring there? However, the question applies to anything else they might be ignoring. What is it that they have incorrect?

(Edited for content.)

Evolution does not deal with abiogenesis, Meadmaker. And yes, IDers do not agree with "all the information science has". Otherwise they'd have same views as us, see?

How does science know more then ID? Simple. Science has a workable, falsafiable, hypothesis for abiogenisis, etc. ID does not.
 
Last edited:
*sigh*

My point, Meadmaker, is that no-one having this discussion will be alive to witness the results. Black holes, remember? We don't have to witness it to pretty much figure out how it works.

In the case of black holes, we have a mathematical model that describes their formation, and the way in which they interact with the world. Do we have such a model in the case of the formation of the bacterial flagellum?


I read an interesting quote from Dembski last night. He noted that it is very common for people supporting Darwinian evolution to say, "Evolution is as much a proven theory as relativity or quantum mechanics." He noted that you never hear physicists saying, "Relativity is as much a proven theory as evolution."
 
Evolution does not deal with abiogenesis, Meadmaker.

It certainly doesn't.

But can you direct me to some information on the workable, falsifiable, hypothesis for abiogenesis. I haven't been able to come up with anything more complicated that the open faced sandwich model, and that wasn't exactly spelled out in great detail. I wouldn't know how to falsify it.
 
Last edited:
In the case of black holes, we have a mathematical model that describes their formation, and the way in which they interact with the world. Do we have such a model in the case of the formation of the bacterial flagellum?

So mathematical models are 'true scientific knowledge'? Interesting...


I read an interesting quote from Dembski last night. He noted that it is very common for people supporting Darwinian evolution to say, "Evolution is as much a proven theory as relativity or quantum mechanics." He noted that you never hear physicists saying, "Relativity is as much a proven theory as evolution."

It is a scientific fact that evolution occurs, Meadmaker. Any argument must be made as to the mechanism of evolutionary change.
 
It certainly doesn't.

But can you direct me to some information on the workable, falsifiable, hypothesis for abiogenesis. I haven't been able to come up with anything more complicated that the open faced sandwich model, and that wasn't exactly spelled out in great detail. I wouldn't know how to falsify it.

Any hypothesis we have is better then ID, which has none, Meadmaker. ID is not a scientific hypothesis.
 
And I would think that materialists would reject the concept by definition.
So would I. That's what makes me wonder if the defenders of science here who keep dragging it up to beat on it have a clue.


Taffer said:
My we think highly of ourself, don't we?
Apparently.


Science has a workable, falsafiable, hypothesis for abiogenisis,
It does? Falsifiable you say.

Science per se has no views; homo saps who deem themselves scientists may. How would you justify the falsifiability claim you made?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom