2) To move further afield, it is not clear to me that we need to have an origin of the universe. I see no reason to think that it cannot be eternal going both forward and backward in time. Idle speculation on my part.
Cheers,
Hank
I agree. I could explain what I was thinking about, and will if someone really cares, but I'l try to get back on track. As you noted, the origin of the universe isn't really germaine to the discussion, which is about what happened afterwards.
Before I talk about the nature of science, and whether "supernatural" events can ever be included in scientific study, I want to bring up a point. It's not a new point. It's an old one. There is a lot of talk about the errors in what "they", the ID crowd says, but there are very few actual references to what they really and truly say. As I read about the Dover trial and started reading a few excerpts about what they said, it seemed much more reasonable than I expected. Indeed, in the work of MacBehe and MacDembski, I couldn't find anything that misrepresented evolution, or which made any glaring errors of fact or logic.
The worst I found was that they had overstated their conclusions, and that Dembski in particular insisted that he was not making an argument from ignorance, but I thought he was. If anyone would like to post an example of real, honest to goodness whoppers on their part, i.e. statements that are Just Plain Wrong, I would like to see them. If I'm defending a pair of clods that can't tell genes from jeans, I want to know it.
Now about science.
Well, I suppose the dictionary is a good place to start. At the risk of offending someone here, I'll just go ahead and quote it.
It seems there are six entries in my dictionary.
1. Originally, state of fact or knowing. (I don't think that's what we want.)
2. Systematized knowledge derived from observation, study, and experimentation, carried on in order to determine the nature or principles of what is being studied. (That's what I think of. If it uses the scientific method, it's science.)
3. A branch of knowledge or study, as in the science of music.
4. (a) the systematized knowledge of nature and the physical world: (b) any branch of this. (I think this is what Hank had in mind. Is it Hank?)
5. skill....based on training, as in the "science of boxing".
6. Christian Science. (I think we can ignore that one.)
I will let Hank speak for himself, but I think 2 and 4 are the ones most of us think of. 4 might be the one where contention is created though. Science concerns itself with the nature and the physical world. God's outside of that. He doesn't work by the laws of nature. Therefore, whether he exists or not, he isn't science. Talking about God is, by definition, not science. Right?
Well, not quite. Let us imagine that God not only exists, but that he works miracles, on either a large scale or small. Let us imagine that, once in a while, divine healing realy takes place, or lightning is really made to strike just because God wanted it to. Or maybe that God chooses a particular mutation, or that God intervenes to make sure a particular organism survives so that its DNA could be passed on. I don't believe in that, but plenty of people do. Let us imagine, for the sake of argument, that they are correct.
Then, in order to understand nature and the physical world, you would have to understand God and/or the "supernatural". If there is no God, then God is irrelevant to science. However, if there is a God, He's right back in the thick of things. ID proponents believe that not only is He around, but that evidence of Him can be detected. Are they correct? I can't prove them wrong. But if I automatically assume that He plays no role, then I have made an unscientific assumption.