Can ID be disproven?

sphenisc
To the ID crowd, does this mean that there is a proto-god?
The ID crowd has built themselves a logical trap. While they pretend not to reach the Goddidit conclusion, it is clear that is their only possible conclusion. They argue that we are too complex not to have been designed by something. If that something is a material being, then it, too, must be subject to this complexity argument. It, too, must have a designer. And that designer must have a designer. And that designer. And so on.

The only way out of the infinite regress is some kind of God. But then they're in a bigger pickle, because they've tried to use logic within our logical universe, but abandon that logic with the "Goddidit" answer.

The way out of this is to argue that God also has a designer. Then God gotta daddy, and God's daddy gotta daddy, and we're right back to an infinite regress.
 
It's simpler than that even. Although Where does that leave ID? When one says that life was intelligently designed, to what is one comparing? There is no other universe to which to compare.

Excellent, well articulated point. In fact, I wrote a post on the ID board with a similar point as the first time someone mentioned ID to me years back, my first response was "compared to what?". The other universes that were stupidly designed?
 
They argue that we are too complex not to have been designed by something. If that something is a material being, then it, too, must be subject to this complexity argument. It, too, must have a designer. And that designer must have a designer. And that designer. And so on.

The only way out of the infinite regress is some kind of God.

Also a good point that had not to occurred to me though it's pretty obvious now that I think about it. It ties in my point that "designing" must be an activity of a limited, fallible being. Otherwise, it would be unneccessary. And if intelligence must be "designed", well, you would have to have a infinite regression or regression to an omnipotent to escape the trap.

Actually, it occurs to me that ID is actually arguing for "DI" i.e. the "Design of Intelligence". They need to explain the existence of intelligence and rather than the hard work that might present and instead have just flipped it.
 
Last edited:
Human designers can only make things out of existing materials; they cannot create ex nihilo. Therefore the intelligent designer, postulated by analogy to human design, is not the creator. We may have two infinite regresses here.

~~ Paul
 
Human designers can only make things out of existing materials; they cannot create ex nihilo. Therefore the intelligent designer, postulated by analogy to human design, is not the creator. We may have two infinite regresses here.

~~ Paul
Oh, my, Paul. Its not just turtles all the way down, is it? Its also turtle eggs. All the way down. One would think some of the shells (either set) would crack, no?
 
Human designers can only make things out of existing materials; they cannot create ex nihilo. Therefore the intelligent designer, postulated by analogy to human design, is not the creator. We may have two infinite regresses here.

~~ Paul

Exactly! That's one important reason I believe ID is broken before it get's started. All the arguments about blood clots, complexity etc. mean nothing and go round and round. If the basic premise is not valid, definable or explainable, then why even go there?

Let's start at the bottom/beginning for the debate then ID falls apart before it can get started.
 
I just watched "2001" last night, strangely enough...it's the film that inspired me to become a filmmaker.

I personally think chimps do display design precursors but design is not well enough understood or defined to constitute "evidence", but my point is that the ID camp has not defined their terms "Intelligent design" with anywhere close to enough rigor to survive even the simplest of questions.

Do you think that Archaeology has sufficiently defined the term 'design' with enough rigor to survive even the simplest of questions? If so, can't ID borrow their definition; if not, should Archaeology be denounced for it's unscientific approach?
 
<snip>

But as to who owns the "burden of proof" in a scientific argument, I would say that it is whoever is trying to persuade someone else.

I must have expressed myself badly, allow me to rephrase.

The title of this thread "Can ID be disproven?", has the burden of proof backward. The scientific community need not disprove ID; it is the job of ID's advocates to prove that they have something meriting consideration. They have thus far studiously avoided doing so.

It is true that the presuader has the burden of proof. In the case of the current discussion, ID proponents are making a claim, hence the burden to prove anything is on them.

To insult the intelligence of thinking people by saying that something clearly religious is 1) not religious, and 2) scientific, should reasonable be expected to provoke the reaction from scientifically literate people that it did.

That's a fair critique, especially as relates to the "we aren't saying the designer is God" aspect, but I think that is partly caused by the artificial exclusion on legal grounds of any mention of God in the context of science, when in a government institution. See below.

There is no law against mentioning God in a scientific context, noe is it an artificial excelusion, if exclusion it is. Science seeks natural explanations for natural phenomena; that tends to exclude the supernatural.

This is not done willy-nilly; it is the only way that science can function as a useful discipline. If we decide that science must consider the supernatural as a possible explanation, it ceases to be useful. A supernatural theory is not testable, and therefore useless in a scientific context.

Are they really [ID proponents] doing that [suggesting we cannot know things], or are they suggesting we change the method by which we learn? Are they saying that perhaps there is a limit to what natural law can teach us? They are saying, and here I disagree with them, that nature is telling us that there is a designer. If they could convince you of that, would you then say, "I have nothing more to learn?"
(bold statements added by me. --HJA)

The problem is not that natural laws have limited explanitory power: no reasonable person, reflecting for a time, will come to any other conclusion. The point is that science restricts itself to what it can explain through natural agents, things we can test, measure, and eventually come to understand at some level.

ID's notion of a designer tries to short-circuit this process by inserting an intelligent agent, when there is no reason to think it is needed. ID's designer is something non-testable, non-measureable, and infinitely malleable. Any objection can be explained away as part of the designer's powers or designs. This is not a scientific proposition, but something else (a whacky 'what if?' sort of thing, in my mind...)

Once we go supernatural, we have left the realm of logic and science, and should admit as much.

This statement, and many variants thereof, are made frequently, but is that true?
It is, indeed, the foundation upon which science is built.
Can God be part of science? I say He can. Let’s try an experiment.

A wise man (observation) once told me that the secret of wisdom is to learn the name of God, and then type it onto an internet forum (hypothesis). I have learned this name, so I will conduct an experiment. I will type that name into this forum, and within fifteen seconds, I will be filled with incredible understanding.(experiment). The reason this works is spelled out in the super-secret draft of Madonna’s upcoming book on Kaballah. (theory).

OK.

Fernblatt J. Whipplesnick III.

(waiting)

Hmmm. Still dumb as a post.

We have just disproved our theory. Either I have the wrong name of God, or the whole darned theory just doesn’t work. Either way, I had a theory that made a specific, testable, prediction, and was subjected to scientific scrutiny.

The hypothesis was subjected to a test. It is not clear that the test was well designed by the experimentor, nor is it clear that any conclusion one way or the other can be drawn from the test.

Further, it says nothing about God -- or, rather, supernatural explanations -- belonging in science. You made, in your example, an assertion that some supernatural effect wuold occur given the correct incantation. That is did not happen -- you say -- upon your incanation leaves us no more knowledgeable about the claim made (that posting god's name in a forum will confer wisdom) than before. I submit there is no way to test the claim, as no test will leave us knowing more about the truth of the claim.

Let’s try another one. This is the theory of Kashrut. Kashrut is the Jewish dietary law. The adjectival form is “kosher”, which means, “conforming to Kashrut”. Let’s go back a few thousand years on the eastern end of the Mediterranean Sea.

Solomon ben Levi is in mourning. He had thrown a magnificent feast for his daughter. It was so magnificent that it took three days to prepare the food! In that hot summer sun, it was hard work. There was incredible roast pork, succulent shrimp and clams, stuffed bat wings, and kid boiled in goat’s milk! Yum. Sadly, within a day after the wedding, his daughter and half the guests became sick, and many, including his beloved Leah, died. (observation).

Why had God punished him? Maybe it was the food. (hypothesis)
Solomon ben Levi -- due to his grief, no doubt -- errs here. The assumption, unproven, is that Leah and the others died due to divine retribution. There is no reason to think that God cared one way or the other about the food. Maybe Leah was a hrlot behind ben Levi's back, maybe God was feeling whimsical that day, maybe he wanted to show a man that God does as she will.

The scientific part of this story is the hypothesis "the food is at fault for the illness". "God did it to punish me" is irrelevant to the study (and a bit arrogant). There is no way to know that God did it, so science remains silent on that: maybe God is punishing ben Levi (or would it just be 'Levi?), maybe not. Can't tell, and it does not matter.

<snip: ben Levi studies who dies from food>
This is the scientific part, but...
Now, everyone knows that God creates life and death, and punishes people who do what He does not like by killing them before their time. Obviously, he was angry at pork-eaters, and so killed them, not every time, but at statistically significant rates. (Theory.)
This oversteps the bounds of science. What ben Levi has learned is that certain foods seem to kill people more than certain other foods. That is a scientific inquiry, arriving at some sort of theory, and fine so far as it goes. It lays the base for more study and refinement.

When he goes further, and says that God must be at work here, he leaves science behind. God is not part of the theory, except as adornment. The data on who does eating what would not be any more or less true or useful if ben Levi thought it was some other agent (dragons? bacteria? space aliens from Uranas?) causing the illness. All he could say scientifically from his studies would be that something that appears to be in the food is causing the illness. What that is is yet unknown to him, but certainly an area for further study.

Knowing as we do that he hadn't a chance of finding or observing the microscopic organisms that were his problem, we can probably forgive him for thinking it is something supernatural. He did the best he could. The God explanation is orthogonal to the work, however.
<snip>
So, science and God are not mutally exclusive. There is nothing inherently unscientific about God.
True, they are not mutually exclusive. This is the point. Science has nothing, and can have nothing, to say about God one way or the other. I think a ba=etter term would be that God is extra-scientific.
<snip> If the evidence points to the supernatural, then science has to go there. Does it point there? I don't think so, but it is hardly a closed case.
I will repeat: there is no way that the evidence can point toward (or away from) a supernatural explanation of any phenomenon. By its nature, the supernatural is outside of nature, and can do as it pleases (including making things appear to us to follow natural laws). It is thereforn not a useful way to understand the natural world. Ever.

Thinking about God -- or "a higher power as we understand it" -- could potentially be useful for some other areas: theology, philosophy, or similar. It is not the opposite of science, rather it has nothing to do with science.

Cheers,

Hank
 
So many strawmen. Good to see y'all have it all figured out to your liking ... ;)

The closer we look at matter the less there is of it, we can't even begin to define energy, we have yet to decide if space-time per se has meaning, Higgs has taken us back to the aether .... on & on.
 
So many strawmen. Good to see y'all have it all figured out to your liking ... :wink:

The closer we look at matter the less there is of it, we can't even begin to define energy, we have yet to decide if space-time per se has meaning, Higgs has taken us back to the aether .... on & on.

Go Away!

Unless you have something to post that counters...
 
Do you think that Archaeology has sufficiently defined the term 'design' with enough rigor to survive even the simplest of questions? If so, can't ID borrow their definition; if not, should Archaeology be denounced for it's unscientific approach?

Valid question but perhaps I did not make myself clear. First, "design" as it applies to Archaeology points to problems with ID. We can only dig up and proclaim as "designed" stuff that we have the potential to design ourselves. So, yes, Archaeology has a working definition.

But Archaeology on Planet X (yes, a Duck Dodgers reference) would be in trouble as we have no tested mechanism for recognizing alien and/or superior design. We can speculate, but that's not "evidence".

So for ID, they are not talking about recognizing human design, they are talking about recognizing alien or superior design. There is zero evidence that we in fact could/would recognize it.
 
Last edited:
I'll take it from the fact you ignore my request for other examples of statements in English which exhibit the logical inconsistency of 'random processes are not random', that you tacitly concede there is a problem.

The analogy you draw isn't exact in that the first example contrasts a adjective plus noun, with an adjective; whereas the second contrasts an adjective+noun with a noun. I'll assume that this is an irrelevant difference and you would accept 'dating=discriminatory' for the fourth line of your analogy.

I'll also assume that I can substitute 'is a' for '=' before a nounal phrase, and 'is' before an adjective with out altering the meaning of the statements you make.

This gives
Evolution is a random process.
and
Evolution is random.


Dating is a discriminatory process.
and
Dating is discriminatory.

This format looks like two thirds of a logical syllogism. We have

x is a y process.
???????????
x is y.

If we replace ?????????? with

A y process is y.

Then we have a 'naively' valid syllogism. You appear to agree with the first premise and disagree with the conclusion, therefore it is the second premise in each case, which you regard as false i.e.

A random process is random.
A discriminatory process is discriminatory.
It is not correct to equate "random" and "discriminatory." More appropriate to say is that "random" in the first sense is descriptive, while "random" in the second sense is not a descriptive term; it is establishing the process as the thing itself. Look at the other term appended to "random" in its use regarding a descriptor of evolution: "chance." Chance is a descriptor (chance meeting) it is also a noun (chance). Chance and random have been equated in this conversation. If something is random, it is chance. Evolution is neither random nor chance. Nor is dating discrimination. Nor is an iterative process iteration. Nor is a baseball player a baseball. Nor is a summer storm Summer.

Reduction of a description to a more easily refutable term is dishonest argument.
This is consistent with your prior statements which indicate that you consider
'A random process is not random.' to be true.

I assume therefore that you regard 'A discriminatory process is not discriminatory.' to be true.
Incorrect, as established with the "random" and "chance" categories, one would appropriately call evolution "random" evolution, rather than just random.
In wch case I withdraw my statement that you've ignored my request for other examples, though you've made me work to find it!

I think you're approach is that a 'random process' indicates that there is a random component to the process which can still have a very substantial deterministic element; whereas a 'process is random' indicates that the process is alomst entirely the result of randomness.

Perhaps the whole thing comes down to how much of an entity x has to have property y, before we can say x is y?

If I say 'the sky is blue', 'a tree is green' or 'the earth is spherical', how much leeway do I get on cloud cover, brown bark or oblateness, before I'm declared wrong?
This is confusion of a descriptive term and its definition. You are describing a property of the object. The property is clearly an adjective for the object, whereas the description of "evolution is random chance" is an equality. It is outlined as the phrases "do you think life was designed, or happened by random chance?" Evolution is not mentioned; it is coded for with the term "random chance" specifically to make it appear unlikely. One would not similarly say "Do you think we live on a plateau or a spherical?" It's nonsense at that point.
The personal boundary set by the reader will, I think, vary from individual to individual. If you feel, as PatKelley does, that Meadmaker's/IDers boundary is drawn too low and this is designed to mislead the public then fine. I suspect that Meadmaker was writing for a JREFforum audience with an IQ and subject knowledge considerably above the population average and felt that others would gloss over the 'differences in boundary drawing', in order to address the more substantial points that were being made.
The point is that it was not coined by Meadmaker; that is giving too much credit. It is lifted in whole cloth from the ID movement's propaganda, and is very much in the vein of the original terminology of "The Big Bang." A dismissive perjorative designed to mislead the neutral or uninformed reader as to the simplicity, illogic or basis of an opposing argument.
This whole section is basically an argument about definition - again. It would I feel be more productive to substitute an alternative word, such as 'stochastic', which [ for the purposes of further discussion] can be defined to imply only that some ( not necessarily large or important) elements of a process are random.
------
Personally I have no problems with any of the statements:

Evolution is a random process.
Evolution is random.
Dating is a discriminatory process.
Dating is discriminatory.

But that's because I value adjectival postional equivalence more highly than other people's misreadings of valuefree statements. That's my personal prejudice, I'm a prejudiced person ...see.
:)
 
Please, sir, look this up so that you can improve yourself.


Really? Unfortunately, you are wrong. At least one such journal exists. Please, sir, look this up so that you can improve yourself.

Can anyone tell me what this man is talking about?
 
I would also predict that if super aliens have built some organic evolution engine on earth that all the people on this board would have no idea such a thing existed until we had evolved to the point to understand such things.

Let me explain my earlier response to this statement. It was apparently somewhat opaque.

The ID crowd thinks that God, not aliens, has already built an organic evolution engine, and the people on this board, as predicted, do not realize that such a thing actually exists.
 
Exactly! That's one important reason I believe ID is broken before it get's started. All the arguments about blood clots, complexity etc. mean nothing and go round and round. If the basic premise is not valid, definable or explainable, then why even go there?

Let's start at the bottom/beginning for the debate then ID falls apart before it can get started.

But so does everything else. All of our natural laws are causal. The current state of the system is based on the current input and previous state. So what happened before there was a previous state? This is a problem for every possible answer to the question of the origin of the universe, whether it is a God or a non-God.
 
When he goes further, and says that God must be at work here, he leaves science behind.

It looks to me that our next definition fight is going to have to be about "science".


Is science inherently naturalistic? I'll get back to you on my answer to that one. The short version is that no, they are not. I would say that the "theory of Kashrut", including the God part, is a scientific theory. The long answer will require some documentation.
 
It's simpler than that even. Although IDer's don't dismiss and sometimes offer the possibility of the 'designer' as some super alien civilization (hereafter SAC), their real (and quoted) notion of a designer is one that is supernatural.
A SAC for terra just pushes ID elsewhere.

"Supernatural" is a meaningless concept bandied about by materialists (and accepted by dualists, I suppose).


And BillHoyt, Paul, etal may actually believe they are on to something with the Turtles all the way down foolishness.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom