Can ID be disproven?

What a thread! I'm obviously new to the forum and nearly did myself in on this one.

Welcome, stephen. I don't think you missed a whole lot after the first six pages, and I'm sure we can fill you in on it, in case it seems necessary. To be honest, the last several pages have been pretty random.

A brief comment. I think your post was more religious than scientific. It speculated a lot on how a designer would work, for one thing. That's religious speculation.

Also, I think any intelligent being can recognize the concept of "design" even if they don't have a word for it in their language. I'm fairly confident the Polynesian Cargo Cults from WWII era could recognize the goods that the "gods" delivered as designed artifacts.

I read an article today about the discovery of a pyramid that no one had noticed earlier in Bosnia. There was this hill, but it had four sides, all of which were the same size, and which were aligned with north, south, east, and west. Erosion had erased the other man made features, but these features were taken as evidence of design. It just didn't fit with the features of nature. It is possible to look at something and discern design from its features.

Can one do that with cells? That will require further discussion. Join in if you wish. (My answer is, "I don't think so, but I can't prove them wrong.")
 
ID has access to all the information science has. Are they ignoring it? If so, what are they ignoring? In this case, I'm referring to abiogenesis. What are they ignoring there? However, the question applies to anything else they might be ignoring. What is it that they have incorrect?

They are ignoring, deliberately (my guess if for political reasons) the basic logical fallacy of anything called "Intelligent Design". The phrase itself means nothing as is fact redundant (see my earlier post).

They are ignoring the truly vast body of evidence and the many years of sincere scientific inquiry and substituting a few years of intellectual games as an "answer" or "critique" to evolution.

They are ignoring the world they live in. If you look deeply and carefully in the mirror or walk outside and look again deeply and carefully, evolution seems the clearest explanation of everything, especially when you consider "change over time" is most certain fact about the universe we know.

Design directly implies a limited power (and I would argue human power only). God (or being capable of building a universe) would have no need for "design". Super Aliens might, but is anybody other than the UFO fringe really serioiusly arguing that point?
 
3. They cherry-pick information, "overlooking" clear examples of the very intermediate evolutionary forms they claim could not have existed!


Pehaps you could do some cherry picking of your own, and come up with a place where they said this?

(Note: There are ID believers who will say these things. Creationists sometimes say these things, and all creationists are IDers. I've mentioned Behe and Dembski as credible IDers, meaning people whose opinions I respect. Do they ever say these things?)
 
They are ignoring, deliberately (my guess if for political reasons) the basic logical fallacy of anything called "Intelligent Design". The phrase itself means nothing as is fact redundant (see my earlier post).

Redundancy is not illogical. If a small child says 'look at the big whales', it is redundant in the sense that all whales from the child's perspective are big. However it is the property of bigness that the child wishes to emphasize. Thus with 'Intelligent Design', all design may be intelligent, there is nothing illogical about emphasizing that association.
 
Pehaps you could do some cherry picking of your own, and come up with a place where they said this?

(Note: There are ID believers who will say these things. Creationists sometimes say these things, and all creationists are IDers. I've mentioned Behe and Dembski as credible IDers, meaning people whose opinions I respect. Do they ever say these things?)
Ah, great, the No True Scotsman fallacy. Really. :rolleyes:

Unfortunately, you tried it with the very people to whom I refer.

Where, sir, is the answer to my question about ID research?
 
They are ignoring the world they live in. If you look deeply and carefully in the mirror or walk outside and look again deeply and carefully, evolution seems the clearest explanation of everything,

Including abiogenesis?

Design directly implies a limited power (and I would argue human power only). God (or being capable of building a universe) would have no need for "design". Super Aliens might, but is anybody other than the UFO fringe really serioiusly arguing that point?

Prometheus and Epimetheus did not have unlimited power. They are perfectly good designer candidates. Chimps that stack chairs in order to get the bananas are designing.

But those are quibbles. The real problem here is that your argument is religious. God would behave thus and such.

I doubt anyone in the ID crowd would have any objection to being called the D crowd instead. They frequently speak of "design" without the "intelligent" part.
 
Welcome, stephen. I don't think you missed a whole lot after the first six pages, and I'm sure we can fill you in on it, in case it seems necessary. To be honest, the last several pages have been pretty random.

Thanks for the welcome. Although, I am about to try to dismantle ID, I'm impressed how mostly respectful though pointed the discussions are here.

A brief comment. I think your post was more religious than scientific. It speculated a lot on how a designer would work, for one thing. That's religious speculation.

That's a strange conclusion - I may have referred to religion, but certainly my viewpoint is not "religious". My point is that humans are the only designers we know of. Design is a human activity. In order for ID to even began to argue, the need to prove that other beings, including a God would design.

Otherwise, I could start a theory that included any "assumption" I want.

Also, I think any intelligent being can recognize the concept of "design" even if they don't have a word for it in their language. I'm fairly confident the Polynesian Cargo Cults from WWII era could recognize the goods that the "gods" delivered as designed artifacts.

I never said that the 5,000 year old person would lack the word for watch. I said they might fundamentally not recognize design or intelligence in the object at all. If you read any studies on very primitive people with sudden contact with current peoples, you will find examples of precisely this.

It is possible to look at something and discern design from its features.

I would argue this statement is meaningless as stated. The only statement I might accept is "it is possible that an intelligent being may recognize an object as designed by someone with similar intelligence if indeed they have experience enough to understand the design process used in the object". In plain English, I would predict that all people on this board would recognize a Casio Databank on the moon as a designed object (meaning, hey, that's human, we must have made that).

I would also predict that if super aliens have built some organic evolution engine on earth that all the people on this board would have no idea such a thing existed until we had evolved to the point to understand such things.
 
I would also predict that if super aliens have built some organic evolution engine on earth that all the people on this board would have no idea such a thing existed until we had evolved to the point to understand such things.

The ID crowd would argue that this has already happened, and that you are right, except for the "super alien" part.
 
Ah, great, the No True Scotsman fallacy. Really. :rolleyes:

Unfortunately, you tried it with the very people to whom I refer.

Where, sir, is the answer to my question about ID research?

It seems to me like the no true reference fallacy.

The answer to your question is lost in the emptiness of my brain. The papers do not exist. The journals do not exist. Why do they not exist?

When Godot gets here, he will tell us.
 
Including abiogenesis?

All these higher level concepts in ID are red herrings for me as until disproved, I think it's self evident that ID is not workable concept at any level. But, to answer you.

Abiogenesis depends on a elementary separation between living and non-living as definition. Current science and tech (look at arguments that some viruses are not really living and some computer virus are living things) that the boundary is not clear.

Evidence points right now that abiogenesis is a quaint concept and what actually happens is something not yet well understood as any "living thing" is actually a collection of "non-living" things and these terms may need to be changed.

But those are quibbles. The real problem here is that your argument is religious. God would behave thus and such.

I believe your risk painting yourself into a corner. If you argue that me challenging the basic logic of the phrase "intelligent design" is religious, that means ID is just a religious thought or impulse. I'm just asking some questions.

When evolution is proposed as a scientific theory, I am fully in my rights as a thinking being to ask "now what do you mean evolution" and to pick apart exactly what you mean by "evolution" until we share the same definition and viewpoint.

Why are you resisting putting "ID" through the same wringer?

I doubt anyone in the ID crowd would have any objection to being called the D crowd instead. They frequently speak of "design" without the "intelligent" part.

That's fine. That simplifies the problems with ID. Design - what is it? If you can't define, prove, analyze and explain the word design (who does it, how it works, what it means, what evidence there is), you can hardly then build a theory based on it.
 
It seems to me like the no true reference fallacy.
Please, sir, look this up so that you can improve yourself.

The answer to your question is lost in the emptiness of my brain. The papers do not exist. The journals do not exist. Why do they not exist?
Really? Unfortunately, you are wrong. At least one such journal exists. Please, sir, look this up so that you can improve yourself.
 
The ID crowd would argue that this has already happened, and that you are right, except for the "super alien" part.

That means we understand (and are capable) of being God or a God. If we recognize and understand God's designs, well, then why not start doing it ourselves? I would argue that is illogical.

The ID crowd is seeing human technology and technical complexity in living things as we have evolved to understand such things and tend to look for patterns we recognize. That's why we see "complexity" because we can and do make it.
 
All these higher level concepts in ID are red herrings for me as until disproved, I think it's self evident that ID is not workable concept at any level. But, to answer you.

Abiogenesis depends on a elementary separation between living and non-living as definition. Current science and tech (look at arguments that some viruses are not really living and some computer virus are living things) that the boundary is not clear.

Evidence points right now that abiogenesis is a quaint concept and what actually happens is something not yet well understood as any "living thing" is actually a collection of "non-living" things and these terms may need to be changed.



I believe your risk painting yourself into a corner. If you argue that me challenging the basic logic of the phrase "intelligent design" is religious, that means ID is just a religious thought or impulse. I'm just asking some questions.

When evolution is proposed as a scientific theory, I am fully in my rights as a thinking being to ask "now what do you mean evolution" and to pick apart exactly what you mean by "evolution" until we share the same definition and viewpoint.

Why are you resisting putting "ID" through the same wringer?



That's fine. That simplifies the problems with ID. Design - what is it? If you can't define, prove, analyze and explain the word design (who does it, how it works, what it means, what evidence there is), you can hardly then build a theory based on it.

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.

Design

Usually considered in the context of the applied arts, engineering, architecture, and other such creative endeavours, "design" is used as both a noun and a verb. "Design" as a verb refers to the process of originating and developing a plan for a new object (machine, building, product, etc.). As a noun, "design" is used both for the final plan or proposal (a drawing, model, or other description), or the result of implementing that plan or proposal (the object produced).

Designing normally requires considering aesthetic, functional, and many other aspects of an object, which usually requires considerable research, thought, modelling, iterative adjustment, and re-design.

Design as a process can take many forms depending on the object being designed and the individual or individuals participating.

In philosophy, the abstract noun "design" refers to pattern, or to purpose/purposefulness (or teleology). Design is thus contrasted with purposelessness, randomness, or lack of complexity.
 
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.

Design

Usually considered in the context of the applied arts, engineering, architecture, and other such creative endeavours, "design" is used as both a noun and a verb. "Design" as a verb refers to the process of originating and developing a plan for a new object (machine, building, product, etc.). As a noun, "design" is used both for the final plan or proposal (a drawing, model, or other description), or the result of implementing that plan or proposal (the object produced).

Designing normally requires considering aesthetic, functional, and many other aspects of an object, which usually requires considerable research, thought, modelling, iterative adjustment, and re-design.

Design as a process can take many forms depending on the object being designed and the individual or individuals participating.

In philosophy, the abstract noun "design" refers to pattern, or to purpose/purposefulness (or teleology). Design is thus contrasted with purposelessness, randomness, or lack of complexity.

But my point is that what is very implicit, in fact so implicit that the need to state it is ignored, is a that it is a human activity. There is exactly zero evidence that anything other than humans design (sure, there might be precursors to design in chimps etc) but if I were ID proponent, I might not use intelligence in chimps to justify the foundations of my argument.
 
But my point is that what is very implicit, in fact so implicit that the need to state it is ignored, is a that it is a human activity. There is exactly zero evidence that anything other than humans design (sure, there might be precursors to design in chimps etc) but if I were ID proponent, I might not use intelligence in chimps to justify the foundations of my argument.

If there is evidence of 'precursors to design' in chimps, then this is some evidence that 'anything other than humans design'. This is a non-zero value.
Unless of course you think that there is some miraculous point during human evolution where hominids went from non-designers to designers and became fully human. If you can identify the black monolith involved (and its intelligent designer), I'd like to know!

:)
 
If there is evidence of 'precursors to design' in chimps, then this is some evidence that 'anything other than humans design'. This is a non-zero value.
Unless of course you think that there is some miraculous point during human evolution where hominids went from non-designers to designers and became fully human. If you can identify the black monolith involved (and its intelligent designer), I'd like to know!

:)

I just watched "2001" last night, strangely enough...it's the film that inspired me to become a filmmaker.

I personally think chimps do display design precursors but design is not well enough understood or defined to constitute "evidence", but my point is that the ID camp has not defined their terms "Intelligent design" with anywhere close to enough rigor to survive even the simplest of questions.
 
Last edited:
sphenisc
If there is evidence of 'precursors to design' in chimps, then this is some evidence that 'anything other than humans design'. This is a non-zero value.
To the ID crowd, does this mean that there is a proto-god?
 
sphenisc
To the ID crowd, does this mean that there is a proto-god?

I think it means to the ID crowd (and too bad they have become a crowd) that they actually don't think through much of what they are saying.

ID is proposing a new scientific method (which you could call a new method for understanding our world). Rather than observing, hypothesizing, testing and theorizing then publishing, they are proposing observing, concluding and publishing, then maybe a little theorizing.
 
I personally think chimps do display design precursors but design is not well enough understood or defined to constitute "evidence", but my point is that the ID camp has not defined their terms "Intelligent design" with anywhere close to enough rigor to survive even the simplest of questions.
It's simpler than that even. Although IDer's don't dismiss and sometimes offer the possibility of the 'designer' as some super alien civilization (hereafter SAC), their real (and quoted) notion of a designer is one that is supernatural.

This implies that the designer didn't just 'design' humans. The designer designed all life. The designer designed all non-life. The designer designed the universe (e.g.: the God of biblical creation - whether or not they all subscribe to this specific intelligent designer is under debate but not hotly denied).

P. Johnson (correct my attribution if incorrect) proposed the 'watchmaker analogy' - that if one found a watch on a beach, one would easily and correctly deduce that it was a product dissimilar to those around it (sand, rocks, trees, water, clouds, etc.) and must have been designed and constructed by something other than natural processes - intelligently designed. This analogy fails precisely where it begins! To look at the universe and find these, we'll call them unnaturally designed objects, is not a flawed concept. We only need to look at the byproducts of human endeavors to make a distinction between the results of natural processes and those of unnatural processes - wherein there are cases where certainty diminishes.

All that aside, now we move one step up. Now we are to determine whether everything in the universe is 'intelligently designed' by the next level. But how did we arrive at the 'watchmaker' conclusion above? Not in a vacuum (eh-hem). But in a comparative analysis. Watch<->rock, watch<->sand, watch<->tree (and so on as long as we like). And, of course, one need not do an exhaustive comparative analysis to come to the conclusion that there are properties of the watch that are not found in nature through natural processes - precision tooling, function, design, purpose (tell time), and so on.

Where does that leave ID? When one says that life was intelligently designed, to what is one comparing? There is no other universe to which to compare. If one says, "non-life", then what created the 'non-life'. Are we to believe that the intelligent designer didn't design the universe, but only the 'life' within it? Or that it spun off the universe as a self-composed system, but had to intervene and 'design' life through a purposeful act because the 'system' was incapable of it? That seems far fetched unless one admits then that the designer must intervene in all cases where the system is incapable (e.g.: building of proteins into chains, combining and mutation of DNA that spawns new 'types').

In other words, wherever our knowledge of natural processes is deficient, then the designer must be intervening to provide impetus for such processes. Far-fetched and unevidential.

Edited to clarify.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom