Can ID be disproven?

Hello, Hank. Welcome.

hankalme said:
As a way to better understand our world, ID is worthless. It is surrender to ignorance and mysticism.

Someone asked why I was spending so much effort defending ID. It's a fair question, and it relates a little bit to this comment. First, you probably haven't read the whole thread (I hope, for your sake), and I don't know if you know that I'm an atheist, and that I don't believe ID. That must make some people, perhaps you as well, even more confused as to why I would be starting a thread which seemed to support ID, and participating so much.

Examining the argument of the other side -- even trying to support it -- is a fine exercise. It is a great way to come to understand the opposing argument and to see how best to answer it. It helps expose flaws in the "good guy's" arguments tha need adressing. Empathy makes a thinker more effective, and less likely to spout nonsense.

So by all means we need to listen and understand. That does not lend any weight to the ID arguments. A bald assertion, listened to and well understood, is still bollocks as an argument.

I got interested in the topic during the Dover trial. I think the statement read in Dover was a bad idea, but I had mixed feelings about banning it. I just thought it was silly, but harmless.

To read the statement in the biology class is to teach students something that is not true. The statement proposed suggests that there is doubt about the ToE's ability to explain the variety of life we see: that is simply not so. There are arguments about details, but the overarching idea is as solid as any theory science uses.

The actions of the board are also odd, in that they single out a specific theory that coincidentally happens to contradict the worldview of a certain hard-line literalist group of Christians. Clearly there is a religious motivation.

The statement also suggests that the proper way to address a scientific idea you do not like is to pursue a political solution. Giving students in a science class the idea that science works like a legislature is harming their intellectual development.

My primary motive was just what the initial post said it was. I wanted to know whether there was any real evidence that disproved ID. I'm not a biologist, so I was a bit behind in my knowledge of real evolution and its observations in the lab. I though someone might provide some info.

You have the burden of proof backwards. The burden falls on the propoenents of ID to demonstrate any reason to think their explanation has any basis in reality. There are myriad things that could be so, including ID. The question ID proponents remain silent on is, what of it?

Until the ID camp produces some reason for the scientific community to care about their ramblings, they will remain in the hinterlands of pseudoscience.

However, there was another motive, and that other motive has proven more of a driver in the actual thread. Reading the coverage of the trial in forums like this one, among others, I started noticing some patterns. First, it seemed like there was incredible hostility toward ID, far more than it deserved, really, and that hostility seemed to me not directed at it because it was pseudoscience, but much of that hostility seemed to be directed at it because it was religious.

The hostility comes not from ID's being religious but from the disingenuous assertion on the part of its proponents that it is not. Religion is not science, and to assert it is is to do violence to both. To insult the intelligence of thinking people by saying that something clearly religious is 1) not religious, and 2) scientific, should reasonable be expected to provoke the reaction from scientifically literate people that it did.

That hostility worries me, frankly. I'm not a religious man, but my wife and son are religious. My parents are religious. I, myself, go to Jewish temples and even though I don't believe what they say, I go along with it, and don't feel guilty.

I wouldn't have you feel guilty. I go along on the rare occasions I find myself back at mass (weddings and funerals). I see no problem with that.

I am currently reading the Bible, I like the novels of Chaim Potok because of their exmainations of the Judaism. I read and enjoy the mystery novels of Andrew Greely (the Bishop Blackie Ryan series) and Harry Kemelman (Rabbi Small series) more for the theological discussions than for the minor detail of a murder mystery (Kemelman is very clever about bringing in lessons on judaism through Rabbi Small's discussions with many of the machers in the congregation whoh seem quite ignornant about thier faith).

What of it? Religion is a way to think about the why kinds of questions, which are important. It runs into difficulties when it -- or more accurately, it's practitioners -- try to use it to answer [i[how[/i] kinds of questions.

Even if I don't believe in God, I find myself getting increasingly comfortable with the idea of God and the language of God and religion. After fourtysomething years of observation of human behavior, I have reached the tentative conclusion that religion, though frequently abused, is on balance a good thing. So, hostility toward it worries me.

Speaking only for myself, I have no a priori hostility to religion. It does not seem to be an issue in my mind -- hostility to non-religion is the more common problem in the USA today. As an alleged critical thinker, I know that science has nothing to say one way or the other about any particular faith's assertions of the existence of god(s). The strongest statement I can make is that there is no reason to believe in god(s), so I don't. That is not the same as denying their existance.

When a person inserts their religious belief into a discussion, however, there is no reason to defer to it simply because it is an article of faith for them. So, when a religious dogma is held up as an explanation for a natural phenomena (for example, ID), it gets no special treatment. Claims are made, they must be supported.

Thus far, Behe and company have made a lot of assertions that boil down to "the natural pathway to <foo> is not obvious, so it must be designed." This is a statement that inspires my "surrender" comment. It is insulting to humanity to suggest that because something is not immediately obvious, we should then simply give up on thrying to find a natural explanation. This is what Id's proponenents would have us do. This is a religious statement made in a scientific discussion, and is thus properly attacked as non-scientific. That it is also religious is coincidence: that simply makes it easier to attack in a scientific context.

<snip: Behe's not an idiot, not proven wrong -- addressed above>

Now to your comments. You have lumped mysticism and ignorance, and characterized acceptance of ID as "surrender" to them. I won't argue that you are wrong, but only that it exposes unwarranted hostility.

I discussed this in more detail above. In a scientific context, ID represents a surrender to unreason by the insertion of a non-falsifiable supernatural agent.

It represents a surrender to ignorance by asserting that something we may be currently ignorant of -- the exact evolutionary pathway to obtain some structure -- is something we cannot know. Science is in the business of attempting to decrease lack of knowledge -- ignorance -- and ID would have us revel in it, ceasing any attempt to remove the veil. That is not a positive thing.

The hostility I feel toward ID has nothing to do with it being a religious idea. Were I to accept as true the risible assertion of its proponents that ID is not a religious concept, my hostility would be the same. The only possible way that the religious aspect of ID could be provoking me is in Behe, et. al insulting my intelligence by asserting that they are not pushing a religious concept. That hostility would not be directed at any religion, however, but at the people making such insulting arguments.

I don't know how to prove that God exists or God does not exist. I don't know how to prove that the experience of mystics is genuinely supernatural or not.
[\quote]

Neither can be proved or disproved, hence the term "supernatural". Science has nothing to say about the existence of God. Either there is a natural phenomenon to study, or there is no science. Once we go supernatural, we have left the realm of logic and science, and should admit as much.

I know I believe it's a trick of brain chemistry, but who am I to say that it is only brain chemistry? If there really is a God, then "surrender" and "ignorance" would be unfortunate terms, and ID, or even mysticism, may, in fact, tell us a great deal about understanding our world.

Such things can tell us nothing about the natural world. They may hold great truths about what is good and valuable, and how one should act, and how the world should be, but as a way to understand how nature works, they are worse than useless. One should use the correct tool for the job.

Cheers,

Hank
 
The Answer is Yes!

What a thread! I'm obviously new to the forum and nearly did myself in on this one. I did read the first half-dozen pages and skimmed the rest.

However, I'm surprised some really basic simple points were never made (as best as I can tell). I'm working on a ID vs. evolution project (that really is a religion vs. science project that really is a "how do we seek truth" project - you get my point).

I think ID is pretty easy to disprove with very basic logic and semantics. I've tested this stuff out somewhat on an ID board and so far, so good, but interested in getting wacked here.

First, the phrase "intelligent design". It doesn't work as a phrase because it's hard to argue the opposite exists e.g "non-intelligent design". I think pretty much all residents of planet earth will agree that the act of design requires intelligence.

This raises the first interesting tangent - why is the phrase broken? I think it's clear that is a term designed (pun intended) to confuse (see Orwell's "Politics and the English Language").

Okay, off tangent. So, we are left with "design". Introducing "design" as a concept to explain the world, life, the universe, evolution or anything else seems to me to be doomed by its own logic before it gets started.

The only "things" that design are us - homo sapiens (ignoring God for the moment, we will get back to that). There's no evidence of any other beings, earth resident or other than "design". So, unless someone presents evidence (which would be us observing said being "designing" something), it's clear that "design" is a human activity.

There's more. Forget speculation for the moment that super-aliens, gods or God "designs". Why do we, human beings, design? I don't think that's too hard to figure out. Design is the activity of visualizing, planning a construct based on the information the designer has about the environment, tools, resource and goals of the item being designed.

That's seems to me to be a function of limited being. In other words, if you are not "limited" in powers, design is a unnecessary activity.

For example, I don't need to "design" snapping my fingers. I have fingers, I snap them. However, I, as a human in 2005, would need to design a fusion rocket.

That seems to say that the Designer is not omnipotent. He has to pull out the tools, sketch pad and try to figure out how to make it happen. Design = limited. "Poof" = omnipotent.

But, there are ways to ignore this (God chooses to be limited, it's not God, but super aliens, etc.). However, that takes ID on to even shakier ground.

That means alternate, superior "intelligence" designed the "irreducibly complex stuff". But how would we know that and compared to what?

The ID IC analogies of a watch on beach or mousetrap are as lame as lame gets. First, a human from 5,000 years ago (or other similar human) who finds a Casio Databank on the beach is (1) likely to miss it completely (2) eat it (3) think it an artifact from the Gods (4) conclude it's a dead sea creature of some kind. No way he or she concludes it's watch that was "designed".

So recognizing "design" is not a universal characteristic, but is in fact very specific, completely individual. In other words, we only recognize design that we would be potentially capable of.

This is clear in the examples that ID people cite (molecular machines etc.). Humans of today recognize, design and use machines, so we will seem them everywhere. But perhaps "molecular machines" are not in fact "machines" at all, but something else we don't yet understand. (like the solar system is now compared to when we thought it was people driving chariots around in the sky).

ID seems to almost be saying that God is a human being, not so?

The mousetrap is worse. A mousetrap is a device design to trap and kill a mouse. Take out the spring and you can still pick it up and throw it at a mouse. Put the spring back in and put in orbit around Mars and wonder why it does not catch any mice. Dissemble it and build a different device also designed to catch and kill a mouse.

The point? The mousetrap is tool of human intelligence. It's not a being nor a life form (neither is a watch). You can't examine it unless it's fully part of the context of not just humans, but the particular individual holding it.

I could go on even longer than this and these thoughts are not as well organized as they could be, but here's the bottom line.

ID is not really an argument, nor a hypotheses or theory. It really is only misguided, poor attempt at intellectualizing the profound feeling of awe, wonder and dare I say worship that we can experience at the wonders of of universe.

We all ask the questions "Who made this? Why are we here? We are we going?". ID should close shop and let us all re-open these questions in different place than the debate now exists.

Science should not be afraid of those questions either. They certainly belong in the science classroom. But ID does not. I don't think it belongs anywhere, other than in the "bad idea" bin.

But the current response of the scientific community to people's spiritual issues has not been effective or perceived as helpful, so I feel both ID needs to be tossed and science (really scientists) more open.

We need to start talking about the "wonders" of evolution and guide speculation based on what we do know now and what we might know later.
 
If their hypothesis is correct, you'll have direct evidence in less than 100 years, unless you are very, very, lucky.

100 years? If you're very, very, lucky. I guess I'm going to have to remind you about black holes again.

So what can we do? You know what I'm getting at. How much do we know about abiogenesis? In 1980, I read about the "primordial sandwich (open face)" model for abiogenesis. It sounded briefly like the first thing you presented. Has there been any significant advance in understanding the problem since then?

Science (and in particular, molecular biology) knows more then ID does, and that's the point. 'We' never claimed it was perfect, but at least it's some idea. What does ID have? Somewhere between diddly and squat.
 
I will continue to use the word "random" occaisionally, because all of the ID arguments are statistical in nature, and I don't know how to describe statistical arguments without using the word "random".

'stochastic' :) or 'splunge' ; I like 'splunge'.
 
Last edited:
A random event can truly be described as random; a random process cannot.

Does this mean 'a random process is not random', or alternatively, 'a random process' is not the same as ' a process which is random'?

Is this the only instance where an adjective, in English, can be used to precede a noun, but doesn't have the same meaning if it follows the noun?

If there are others like this I'd like to see them, as it upsets all my ideas of A, non-A, mutual exclusivity logic thingies.
:confused:
 
All right. I think I get it. Your objection is closely related to Tricky's problem. Here's my answer...


In fact, isn't it the null hypothesis to Darwinian Evolution? I mean, I know that the phrase "null hypothesis" isn't absolutely defined outside of statistics, but the usual use of the term in these contexts is to describe the opposite of the thing that you are trying to demonstrate. If you can't demonstrate the null hypothesis, it isn't falsifiable.

No, you don't get it Instead you've dodged the question again. One last time: why can't you find papers published in peer-reviewed ID journals that show anti-ID results?

1. Stick to the question.

2. Stick to the question

3. Stick to the question

Very simple rules, no?
 
Does this mean 'a random process is not random', or alternatively, 'a random process' is not the same as ' a process which is random'?

Is this the only instance where an adjective, in English, can be used to precede a noun, but doesn't have the same meaning if it follows the noun?

If there are others like this I'd like to see them, as it upsets all my ideas of A, non-A, mutual exclusivity logic thingies.
:confused:

This goes back to the analogy between dating and discrimination. Discrimination is an apt description of part of dating. But to call dating "discrimination" is a misnomer, muddies the concept, deliberately depicts it in a negative light, and technically is not correct.

Do you think dating is a good idea?
Do you think discrimination is a good idea?

See the problem? Dating is a discriminatory process. Dating is not, however, just discrimination. One word swap, total meaning change.
 
Last edited:
This goes back to the analogy between dating and discrimination. Discrimination is an apt description of part of dating. But to call dating "discrimination" is a misnomer, muddies the concept, deliberately depicts it in a negative light, and technically is not correct.

Do you think dating is a good idea?
Do you think discrimination is a good idea?

See the problem? Dating is a discriminatory process. Dating is not, however, just discrimination. One word swap, total meaning change.

Not really, this isn't a word swap - it's the same word, placed before or after the noun it's related to.
 
Not really, this isn't a word swap - it's the same word, placed before or after the noun it's related to.
Do you see the problem, though, with the word-swap of

evolution = random process
and
evolution = random

The same as
dating = discriminatory process
and
dating = discrimination

The second phrase in each is deliberately deceptive. ID doesn't describe evolution as a random process; it is described, as Meadmaker has done multiple times, as "random chance." This is tantamount to me calling a singles mixer "discrimination night." From the description, if you did not know what it was beforehand, you get a completely erroneous impression.

It is dishonest or ignorant to call evolution "random chance." It is not "random chance." It is a discrete stochastic process, or a random process. This after Meadmaker attempted to introduce technical definitions, and late realized that "random" is not a good descriptor of evolution, while "random process" is.
 
Last edited:
Do you see the problem, though, with the word-swap of

evolution = random process
and
evolution = random

The same as
dating = discriminatory process
and
dating = discrimination

The second phrase in each is deliberately deceptive. ID doesn't describe evolution as a random process; it is described, as Meadmaker has done multiple times, as "random chance." This is tantamount to me calling a singles mixer "discrimination night." From the description, if you did not know what it was beforehand, you get a completely erroneous impression.

It is dishonest or ignorant to call evolution "random chance." It is not "random chance." It is a discrete stochastic process, or a random process. This after Meadmaker attempted to introduce technical definitions, and late realized that "random" is not a good descriptor of evolution, while "random process" is.

I'll take it from the fact you ignore my request for other examples of statements in English which exhibit the logical inconsistency of 'random processes are not random', that you tacitly concede there is a problem.

The analogy you draw isn't exact in that the first example contrasts a adjective plus noun, with an adjective; whereas the second contrasts an adjective+noun with a noun. I'll assume that this is an irrelevant difference and you would accept 'dating=discriminatory' for the fourth line of your analogy.

I'll also assume that I can substitute 'is a' for '=' before a nounal phrase, and 'is' before an adjective with out altering the meaning of the statements you make.

This gives
Evolution is a random process.
and
Evolution is random.


Dating is a discriminatory process.
and
Dating is discriminatory.

This format looks like two thirds of a logical syllogism. We have

x is a y process.
???????????
x is y.

If we replace ?????????? with

A y process is y.

Then we have a 'naively' valid syllogism. You appear to agree with the first premise and disagree with the conclusion, therefore it is the second premise in each case, which you regard as false i.e.

A random process is random.
A discriminatory process is discriminatory.

This is consistent with your prior statements which indicate that you consider
'A random process is not random.' to be true.

I assume therefore that you regard 'A discriminatory process is not discriminatory.' to be true.

In wch case I withdraw my statement that you've ignored my request for other examples, though you've made me work to find it!

I think you're approach is that a 'random process' indicates that there is a random component to the process which can still have a very substantial deterministic element; whereas a 'process is random' indicates that the process is alomst entirely the result of randomness.

Perhaps the whole thing comes down to how much of an entity x has to have property y, before we can say x is y?

If I say 'the sky is blue', 'a tree is green' or 'the earth is spherical', how much leeway do I get on cloud cover, brown bark or oblateness, before I'm declared wrong?

The personal boundary set by the reader will, I think, vary from individual to individual. If you feel, as PatKelley does, that Meadmaker's/IDers boundary is drawn too low and this is designed to mislead the public then fine. I suspect that Meadmaker was writing for a JREFforum audience with an IQ and subject knowledge considerably above the population average and felt that others would gloss over the 'differences in boundary drawing', in order to address the more substantial points that were being made.

This whole section is basically an argument about definition - again. It would I feel be more productive to substitute an alternative word, such as 'stochastic', which [ for the purposes of further discussion] can be defined to imply only that some ( not necessarily large or important) elements of a process are random.
------
Personally I have no problems with any of the statements:

Evolution is a random process.
Evolution is random.
Dating is a discriminatory process.
Dating is discriminatory.

But that's because I value adjectival postional equivalence more highly than other people's misreadings of valuefree statements. That's my personal prejudice, I'm a prejudiced person ...see.
:)
 
Do you aver M-Theory to be "supernatural"?

As I am ignorant of M-Theory -- feel free to fix that -- I aver no such thing, nor can I aver its opposite. "I dunno, and would have to study it some more" is about the best answer I have right now.

Assuming we refer to the stirng theory-related "M-Theory" (fruit of my spending a few inutes on Wikipedia), I am curious about the relevance to this discussion. The article I read talked about a speculation made in 1995 about an area of physics not too weel understood, which has sprked some interest and some research.

What of it?

Cheers,

Hank
 
You have the burden of proof backwards.

Hank,
Liked your post. Made sense. A couple of points.

On this "burden of proof" thing. You posted this in response to my comment that my primary motivation was to find out what had been observed in the lab that I might not know about. That isn't anything at all to do with a "burden of proof". It's a request for information. It is using you folks as a tool to educate myself. That's all.

But as to who owns the "burden of proof" in a scientific argument, I would say that it is whoever is trying to persuade someone else.


To insult the intelligence of thinking people by saying that something clearly religious is 1) not religious, and 2) scientific, should reasonable be expected to provoke the reaction from scientifically literate people that it did.

That's a fair critique, especially as relates to the "we aren't saying the designer is God" aspect, but I think that is partly caused by the artificial exclusion on legal grounds of any mention of God in the context of science, when in a government institution. See below.

It represents a surrender to ignorance by asserting that something we may be currently ignorant of -- the exact evolutionary pathway to obtain some structure -- is something we cannot know. Science is in the business of attempting to decrease lack of knowledge -- ignorance -- and ID would have us revel in it, ceasing any attempt to remove the veil.

Are they really doing that, or are they suggesting we change the method by which we learn? Are they saying that perhaps there is a limit to what natural law can teach us? They are saying, and here I disagree with them, that nature is telling us that there is a designer. If they could convince you of that, would you then say, "I have nothing more to learn?"

Once we go supernatural, we have left the realm of logic and science, and should admit as much.

This statement, and many variants thereof, are made frequently, but is that true?

Can God be part of science? I say He can. Let’s try an experiment.

A wise man (observation) once told me that the secret of wisdom is to learn the name of God, and then type it onto an internet forum (hypothesis). I have learned this name, so I will conduct an experiment. I will type that name into this forum, and within fifteen seconds, I will be filled with incredible understanding.(experiment). The reason this works is spelled out in the super-secret draft of Madonna’s upcoming book on Kaballah. (theory).

OK.

Fernblatt J. Whipplesnick III.

(waiting)

Hmmm. Still dumb as a post.

We have just disproved our theory. Either I have the wrong name of God, or the whole darned theory just doesn’t work. Either way, I had a theory that made a specific, testable, prediction, and was subjected to scientific scrutiny.

Let’s try another one. This is the theory of Kashrut. Kashrut is the Jewish dietary law. The adjectival form is “kosher”, which means, “conforming to Kashrut”. Let’s go back a few thousand years on the eastern end of the Mediterranean Sea.

Solomon ben Levi is in mourning. He had thrown a magnificent feast for his daughter. It was so magnificent that it took three days to prepare the food! In that hot summer sun, it was hard work. There was incredible roast pork, succulent shrimp and clams, stuffed bat wings, and kid boiled in goat’s milk! Yum. Sadly, within a day after the wedding, his daughter and half the guests became sick, and many, including his beloved Leah, died. (observation).

Why had God punished him? Maybe it was the food. (hypothesis)

And so, he traveled the land, asking the people what they ate, and whether anyone had died after eating them. He wanted to see if there were some foods that, when eaten, made people more likely to die. (Experiment).

He found that pork and other non cud-chewers, carnivores, shellfish, and meat boiled in milk all had disproportional death rates. People who ate those foods were more likely to die than those who stuck with beef that had been killed a certain way and vegetables. Also, blood seemed to be bad, as did any meat from carnivores. Now, everyone knows that God creates life and death, and punishes people who do what He does not like by killing them before their time. Obviously, he was angry at pork-eaters, and so killed them, not every time, but at statistically significant rates. (Theory.)

There it is, the theory of Kashrut. Perfectly scientific. Observation, hypothesis, experiment and theory. Specific, testable, predictions. Falsifiability. Everything you need for science, even though God is included in the theory. You would in fact find that Kosher diets are healthier than most other diets when prepared in manners you might find among technologically deficient goat herders. Pork and shellfish easily spoil. Carnivores carry parasites more frequently. Eating bats is gross. This theory served well, and kept Jews fairly healthy for thousands of years, until a better theory with more specific and reliable predictions came along.

So, science and God are not mutally exclusive. There is nothing inherently unscientific about God.

On a related note, I think it is fair to call ID a "God of the Gaps" theory. The Kashrut theory was replaced when a specific "gap" was closed by discovering germs. However, there are still gaps. I don't think it is fair to say that God is, automatically, excluded from all consideration of anything scientific. If the evidence points to the supernatural, then science has to go there. Does it point there? I don't think so, but it is hardly a closed case.
 
Science (and in particular, molecular biology) knows more then ID does, and that's the point.

ID has access to all the information science has. Are they ignoring it? If so, what are they ignoring? In this case, I'm referring to abiogenesis. What are they ignoring there? However, the question applies to anything else they might be ignoring. What is it that they have incorrect?

(Edited for content.)
 
Hank,
A wise man (observation) once told me that the secret of wisdom is to learn the name of God, and then type it onto an internet forum (hypothesis). I have learned this name, so I will conduct an experiment. I will type that name into this forum, and within fifteen seconds, I will be filled with incredible understanding.(experiment). The reason this works is spelled out in the super-secret draft of Madonna’s upcoming book on Kaballah. (theory).

OK.

Fernblatt J. Whipplesnick III.

Finally, an answer to "who made God?"

Fernblatt J. Whipplesnick II
 
No, you don't get it Instead you've dodged the question again. One last time: why can't you find papers published in peer-reviewed ID journals that show anti-ID results?

1. Stick to the question.

2. Stick to the question

3. Stick to the question

Very simple rules, no?

Because the papers don't exist? As far as I know, the journals don't exist, either, but feel free to post citations to them, if I'm wrong. And "peer reviewed" would be a questionable description of any that did exist in a "pro-ID journal".

But, if they did exist, what would an "anti-ID result" look like?

In general, Bill, this is another case where I truly am missing the point. Don't leave me hanging here. What is it?
 
ID has access to all the information science has. Are they ignoring it? If so, what are they ignoring? In this case, I'm referring to abiogenesis. What are they ignoring there? However, the question applies to anything else they might be ignoring. What is it that they have incorrect?

(Edited for content.)
1. They have their own logical conclusion incorrect. Deliberately so, it seems.

2. They have no science, as your inability to understand or answer my fundamental question attests.

3. They cherry-pick information, "overlooking" clear examples of the very intermediate evolutionary forms they claim could not have existed!

4. They woefully misunderstand both "complexity" and probability theory.

Where are your answers, sir, concerning the published research? How many times must I pose the question? How many times will you attempt to dodge it?
 
But as to who owns the "burden of proof" in a scientific argument, I would say that it is whoever is trying to persuade someone else.
Bullpucky. I don't care what "you" say; the burden of proof in skepticism and science is the same. Must we add this to the growing roster of "things Meadmaker doesn't get"? Hope not.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom