hankalme
Student
- Joined
- Sep 7, 2005
- Messages
- 36
Hello, Hank. Welcome.
hankalme said:As a way to better understand our world, ID is worthless. It is surrender to ignorance and mysticism.
Someone asked why I was spending so much effort defending ID. It's a fair question, and it relates a little bit to this comment. First, you probably haven't read the whole thread (I hope, for your sake), and I don't know if you know that I'm an atheist, and that I don't believe ID. That must make some people, perhaps you as well, even more confused as to why I would be starting a thread which seemed to support ID, and participating so much.
Examining the argument of the other side -- even trying to support it -- is a fine exercise. It is a great way to come to understand the opposing argument and to see how best to answer it. It helps expose flaws in the "good guy's" arguments tha need adressing. Empathy makes a thinker more effective, and less likely to spout nonsense.
So by all means we need to listen and understand. That does not lend any weight to the ID arguments. A bald assertion, listened to and well understood, is still bollocks as an argument.
I got interested in the topic during the Dover trial. I think the statement read in Dover was a bad idea, but I had mixed feelings about banning it. I just thought it was silly, but harmless.
To read the statement in the biology class is to teach students something that is not true. The statement proposed suggests that there is doubt about the ToE's ability to explain the variety of life we see: that is simply not so. There are arguments about details, but the overarching idea is as solid as any theory science uses.
The actions of the board are also odd, in that they single out a specific theory that coincidentally happens to contradict the worldview of a certain hard-line literalist group of Christians. Clearly there is a religious motivation.
The statement also suggests that the proper way to address a scientific idea you do not like is to pursue a political solution. Giving students in a science class the idea that science works like a legislature is harming their intellectual development.
My primary motive was just what the initial post said it was. I wanted to know whether there was any real evidence that disproved ID. I'm not a biologist, so I was a bit behind in my knowledge of real evolution and its observations in the lab. I though someone might provide some info.
You have the burden of proof backwards. The burden falls on the propoenents of ID to demonstrate any reason to think their explanation has any basis in reality. There are myriad things that could be so, including ID. The question ID proponents remain silent on is, what of it?
Until the ID camp produces some reason for the scientific community to care about their ramblings, they will remain in the hinterlands of pseudoscience.
However, there was another motive, and that other motive has proven more of a driver in the actual thread. Reading the coverage of the trial in forums like this one, among others, I started noticing some patterns. First, it seemed like there was incredible hostility toward ID, far more than it deserved, really, and that hostility seemed to me not directed at it because it was pseudoscience, but much of that hostility seemed to be directed at it because it was religious.
The hostility comes not from ID's being religious but from the disingenuous assertion on the part of its proponents that it is not. Religion is not science, and to assert it is is to do violence to both. To insult the intelligence of thinking people by saying that something clearly religious is 1) not religious, and 2) scientific, should reasonable be expected to provoke the reaction from scientifically literate people that it did.
That hostility worries me, frankly. I'm not a religious man, but my wife and son are religious. My parents are religious. I, myself, go to Jewish temples and even though I don't believe what they say, I go along with it, and don't feel guilty.
I wouldn't have you feel guilty. I go along on the rare occasions I find myself back at mass (weddings and funerals). I see no problem with that.
I am currently reading the Bible, I like the novels of Chaim Potok because of their exmainations of the Judaism. I read and enjoy the mystery novels of Andrew Greely (the Bishop Blackie Ryan series) and Harry Kemelman (Rabbi Small series) more for the theological discussions than for the minor detail of a murder mystery (Kemelman is very clever about bringing in lessons on judaism through Rabbi Small's discussions with many of the machers in the congregation whoh seem quite ignornant about thier faith).
What of it? Religion is a way to think about the why kinds of questions, which are important. It runs into difficulties when it -- or more accurately, it's practitioners -- try to use it to answer [i[how[/i] kinds of questions.
Even if I don't believe in God, I find myself getting increasingly comfortable with the idea of God and the language of God and religion. After fourtysomething years of observation of human behavior, I have reached the tentative conclusion that religion, though frequently abused, is on balance a good thing. So, hostility toward it worries me.
Speaking only for myself, I have no a priori hostility to religion. It does not seem to be an issue in my mind -- hostility to non-religion is the more common problem in the USA today. As an alleged critical thinker, I know that science has nothing to say one way or the other about any particular faith's assertions of the existence of god(s). The strongest statement I can make is that there is no reason to believe in god(s), so I don't. That is not the same as denying their existance.
When a person inserts their religious belief into a discussion, however, there is no reason to defer to it simply because it is an article of faith for them. So, when a religious dogma is held up as an explanation for a natural phenomena (for example, ID), it gets no special treatment. Claims are made, they must be supported.
Thus far, Behe and company have made a lot of assertions that boil down to "the natural pathway to <foo> is not obvious, so it must be designed." This is a statement that inspires my "surrender" comment. It is insulting to humanity to suggest that because something is not immediately obvious, we should then simply give up on thrying to find a natural explanation. This is what Id's proponenents would have us do. This is a religious statement made in a scientific discussion, and is thus properly attacked as non-scientific. That it is also religious is coincidence: that simply makes it easier to attack in a scientific context.
<snip: Behe's not an idiot, not proven wrong -- addressed above>
Now to your comments. You have lumped mysticism and ignorance, and characterized acceptance of ID as "surrender" to them. I won't argue that you are wrong, but only that it exposes unwarranted hostility.
I discussed this in more detail above. In a scientific context, ID represents a surrender to unreason by the insertion of a non-falsifiable supernatural agent.
It represents a surrender to ignorance by asserting that something we may be currently ignorant of -- the exact evolutionary pathway to obtain some structure -- is something we cannot know. Science is in the business of attempting to decrease lack of knowledge -- ignorance -- and ID would have us revel in it, ceasing any attempt to remove the veil. That is not a positive thing.
The hostility I feel toward ID has nothing to do with it being a religious idea. Were I to accept as true the risible assertion of its proponents that ID is not a religious concept, my hostility would be the same. The only possible way that the religious aspect of ID could be provoking me is in Behe, et. al insulting my intelligence by asserting that they are not pushing a religious concept. That hostility would not be directed at any religion, however, but at the people making such insulting arguments.
I don't know how to prove that God exists or God does not exist. I don't know how to prove that the experience of mystics is genuinely supernatural or not.
[\quote]
Neither can be proved or disproved, hence the term "supernatural". Science has nothing to say about the existence of God. Either there is a natural phenomenon to study, or there is no science. Once we go supernatural, we have left the realm of logic and science, and should admit as much.
I know I believe it's a trick of brain chemistry, but who am I to say that it is only brain chemistry? If there really is a God, then "surrender" and "ignorance" would be unfortunate terms, and ID, or even mysticism, may, in fact, tell us a great deal about understanding our world.
Such things can tell us nothing about the natural world. They may hold great truths about what is good and valuable, and how one should act, and how the world should be, but as a way to understand how nature works, they are worse than useless. One should use the correct tool for the job.
Cheers,
Hank