Can ID be disproven?

Can you truly say that there are no recognizable 'patterns' to evolution? Please try!

I would never, ever, say that there are no recognizable patterns to evolution. Such a statement would be ridiculous. And I have never said it.

I don't know how much of this conversation you've followed, kuroyume, so I don't know if you realize how pathetic it truly is. Skimming through the recent posts, it would be easy to assume that I am making some ridiculous argument, because you might assume that Pat, Paul, or some of the other folks are responding to an argument I have actually made, but they aren't. They are responding to some other argument that they read somewhere else that happened to use some of the same words in my argument.

To help clarify the issue, an answer to one question would be helpful.

Bill's off for the weekend, apparently, so I'll ask you.

Kuroyume,
Does "random", imply a uniform distribution? A related question. If a process is random, does that imply that all possible outcomes of a process are equally likely?

Edited to add: Damn!

I was going to delete this, after I saw that Paul and I were in agreement. We both agree that evolution is random, with constraints. Unfortunately, Pat had already posted a response to this message, and he even quoted it, so it can't disappear.

This truly is ridiculous.
 
Last edited:
I would never, ever, say that there are no recognizable patterns to evolution. Such a statement would be ridiculous. And I have never said it.

I don't know how much of this conversation you've followed, kuroyume, so I don't know if you realize how pathetic it truly is. Skimming through the recent posts, it would be easy to assume that I am making some ridiculous argument, because you might assume that Pat, Paul, or some of the other folks are responding to an argument I have actually made, but they aren't. They are responding to some other argument that they read somewhere else that happened to use some of the same words in my argument.

To help clarify the issue, an answer to one question would be helpful.

Bill's off for the weekend, apparently, so I'll ask you.

Kuroyume,
Does "random", imply a uniform distribution? A related question. If a process is random, does that imply that all possible outcomes of a process are equally likely?
To shorten it still further, Kuroyume, Meadmaker is fishing for an opinion that agrees with his own. Just give him the answer he wants, and the thread can end with him successful in his skewering of modern evolutionary theory with a single word.
 
Taffer: Evolution is random with contraints.

I agree, wholeheartedly!

Now, in case there is some confusion about my stance on this issue, if anyone wants to go back to anything I said and try to seek clarification on what I meant, please do so. I don't think you will find anything I said that contradicts this. If so, it was an offhand remark that could easily be clarified, and almost certainly has been clarified, repeatedly.

Hear, oh world. Paul and I agree that evolution is random, with constraints.
 
Does "random", imply a uniform distribution? A related question. If a process is random, does that imply that all possible outcomes of a process are equally likely?
Though not addressed to me, I'll give you my conception of it.

An "event" is random if all possible outcomes are equally likely. At the risk of "going Yahtzee" on you again, consider the roll of a single die to be one event. 1,2,3,4,5 & 6 are equally likely outcomes. But when you combine events, the "combined outcomes" are not equally likely. Roll two dice and you will see that an outcome of 7 is six times more likely than an outcome of 2. But this is two events.

Now think of mutations. A mutation is not a single event, but a series of events. Think even of the kinds of mutations induced by bombardment by particles. You may consider the event of being hit by a particle is the same for every point along the DNA chain to be random, in that every point has the same possibility of being hit. (This is a crude assumption, but it is just for the sake of illustration). But the mutation requires several "events", such as the position of the DNA chain when it strikes, the susceptibility of the point on the DNA to mutation and probably many many others. Not all of these events are random, but even if they were, the probability of every possibility would not be the same.
 
I agree, wholeheartedly!

Now, in case there is some confusion about my stance on this issue, if anyone wants to go back to anything I said and try to seek clarification on what I meant, please do so. I don't think you will find anything I said that contradicts this. If so, it was an offhand remark that could easily be clarified, and almost certainly has been clarified, repeatedly.

Hear, oh world. Paul and I agree that evolution is random, with constraints.
Did I not predict this very same thing? Fishing for someone who will agree with him; person found, argument over. Facts notwithstanding.


I'll be applying for my million dollars next week...
Oh, wait. Predicting human behavior based on previous examples of behavior doesn't count?
 
Oh, I get it. Geez, you're opaque.

Sorry for the opacity, Paul. I plead that part of the opacity is not my own, but a consequence of the absurdity of the overall conversation.

About 4 pages back, I described the ID argument, and I used the phrase "by chance" in the description.

Here's how it looked:

Meadmaker No. Behe et. al. say the world looks like it was designed. They further say that the probability of it arising in that way by chance is virtually 0. Can you prove them wrong? No.


PatKelly]If it were completely random, it might be so; however, the changes in evolution are not random in the sense of all probabilities being equal; there are some that are more likely than others, and evolution does not argue that an organism arises ex nihilo in an instant. This is what is commonly known as a "straw man" - stating that another viewpoint maintains a position which it does not.


So, it all began when Pat described the use of "by chance" as being related to "all probabilities being equal". He went on to describe that use as a "straw man". (And somehow, he worked in organisms arising "ex nihilo in an instant". God only knows what he meant by that or how it related to "by chance", and since I don't believe in God, it isn't likely that He is going to tell me anytime soon.)

The rest followed from there, in a weird, zigzagging fashion. My clarifications, specifically that "random" didn't imply that all probabilities were equal were met with discussion that involved my lack of education, an awful lot of "you don't seem to understand", "you still don't get it" and, my favorite, a comparison to McCarthy because I used the phrase "my dictionary" without quoting a complete bibliographical citation.

It's very strange.



ETA: There could easily be a time in the future when I appear equally opaque. To anyone who thinks that is the case, I suggest, "What do you mean by that?" or, "Are you saying.....?" Starting off with "that's a straw man" and following up with "you don't get it" aren't likely to lead to further understanding, on my part or anybody else's.
 
Last edited:
Really? So is ID required for water molecules to appear? How about long organic molecules? No? So why is it any different for proteins?

The ID argument is that water molecules happen if you throw oxygen and hydrogen together under very common circumstances.

Amino acids happen if you also throw in some carbon and nitrogen. You get the "primordial soup".

To the best of my knowledge, that's about as complex as it has ever been observed without intelligent guidance.

You asked about a problem that evolution can't explain, and I said proteins.

I believe that someday, there will be a good explanation for how cells, proteins, DNA, and even bacterial flagella came about. Today, though, those explanations don't exist.
 
But why is Meadmaker so bent on us agreeing that evolution is random? There must be a punchline, no?

~~ Paul

What I'm bent on is the participants understanding what the ID argument really is. ID supporters do use the word "random" to describe evolution. So do evolutionists. Neither is erecting a straw man.

Pat can surely claim the million, but not based on the fact that he found someone, you, to agree with me. It is based on his psychic ability to discern thoughts in other peoples' heads, even when they specifically disclaim those thoughts.

So, I guess what I am "bent on", is not being accused of erecting a straw man. I'm not. I am not saying that "random" means "without pattern". I am not saying random means "uniformly". I'm not saying any of that stuff. I will continue to use the word "random" occaisionally, because all of the ID arguments are statistical in nature, and I don't know how to describe statistical arguments without using the word "random".
 
But why is Meadmaker so bent on us agreeing that evolution is random? There must be a punchline, no?

~~ Paul
The punchline is that ID proponents are then free to point at unconstrained probability matrices as "proof" of the unlikelihood of evolution without the observation that they are burning a straw-man. The stipulation, from the ID proponents themselves, that the probability of a gene "randomly" coming together is "impossible."

It is a false argument, and does nothing to bolster the case for ID as it is ID arguing with a straw man.
 
The ID argument is that water molecules happen if you throw oxygen and hydrogen together under very common circumstances.

Amino acids happen if you also throw in some carbon and nitrogen. You get the "primordial soup".

To the best of my knowledge, that's about as complex as it has ever been observed without intelligent guidance.

You asked about a problem that evolution can't explain, and I said proteins.

I believe that someday, there will be a good explanation for how cells, proteins, DNA, and even bacterial flagella came about. Today, though, those explanations don't exist.
They still won't exist under ID. Instead of "unknown" it will instead be painted "intelligent design."
 
Sorry for the opacity, Paul. I plead that part of the opacity is not my own, but a consequence of the absurdity of the overall conversation.

About 4 pages back, I described the ID argument, and I used the phrase "by chance" in the description.

Here's how it looked:




So, it all began when Pat described the use of "by chance" as being related to "all probabilities being equal". He went on to describe that use as a "straw man". (And somehow, he worked in organisms arising "ex nihilo in an instant". God only knows what he meant by that or how it related to "by chance", and since I don't believe in God, it isn't likely that He is going to tell me anytime soon.)

The rest followed from there, in a weird, zigzagging fashion. My clarifications, specifically that "random" didn't imply that all probabilities were equal were met with discussion that involved my lack of education, an awful lot of "you don't seem to understand", "you still don't get it" and, my favorite, a comparison to McCarthy because I used the phrase "my dictionary" without quoting a complete bibliographical citation.

It's very strange.
A persecution complex, ignoring refuting arguments, and misstatement of opposing positions. You are well on your way to being an ID proponent.
ETA: There could easily be a time in the future when I appear equally opaque. To anyone who thinks that is the case, I suggest, "What do you mean by that?" or, "Are you saying.....?" Starting off with "that's a straw man" and following up with "you don't get it" aren't likely to lead to further understanding, on my part or anybody else's.
Ah, so my initial questions to get you to clarify your misstatements are, to you, tantamount to persecution? Using your own statements to attempt to clarify is forbidden? Going to the sources you quote is also forbidden?

I see.


Everyone, simply take it on authority that Meadmaker is infallable, and we'll have no more arguments, okay?

I expect there will be no further argument, and please feel free to ignore me, as I've been painted as a persecuting naysayer. Good day, all.
 
I've taken Pat's advice to heart, but if anyone else wants to understand either my position, or that of ID, I would be happy to continue from here.

My apologies for stubbornly insisting on a single, mostly irrelevant, point.
 
The ID argument is that water molecules happen if you throw oxygen and hydrogen together under very common circumstances.

Amino acids happen if you also throw in some carbon and nitrogen. You get the "primordial soup".

To the best of my knowledge, that's about as complex as it has ever been observed without intelligent guidance.

Nonsense. It happens thousands of times a day in your cells. Are you saying that God still has to guide the process?

You asked about a problem that evolution can't explain, and I said proteins.

We haven't observed (directly) Black Holes. Do you deny that they exist, or our use of them as an explanation for various phenomenon? No one has every directly observed water molecules being made, either. Do they need a god to happen? Don't you see how silly this is? We have theories, oh Meadmaker, which is a great deal more then ID has.

I believe that someday, there will be a good explanation for how cells, proteins, DNA, and even bacterial flagella came about. Today, though, those explanations don't exist.

Yes, they do exist, unless you deny the last 20 years of molecular biology.
 
Nonsense. It happens thousands of times a day in your cells. Are you saying that God still has to guide the process?

Even as we speak, car parts are being assembled using software I wrote, manipulated by robots. Neither I nor God must guide the robots, but I told the robots what to do.

DNA and RNA put together those proteins over and over again, every day. But did God provide the blueprint, or did the blueprint come together by itself, constrained by natural law?



Yes, they do exist, unless you deny the last 20 years of molecular biology.

I'm at least that far behind on my molecular biology, now that you mention it.

How far do we get? I'm pretty darned certain we don't have any model for the formation of a cell, unless you start from on or two other cells. I'm pretty darned certain we don't have any experimental evidence of DNA being created. I'm not sure about protein, and I'm absolutely certain about bacterial flagella. I know we can make amino acids from nothing but basic components in the lab. What else can we do?
 
Even as we speak, car parts are being assembled using software I wrote, manipulated by robots. Neither I nor God must guide the robots, but I told the robots what to do.

DNA and RNA put together those proteins over and over again, every day. But did God provide the blueprint, or did the blueprint come together by itself, constrained by natural law?

The assembly of molecules in a cell is a natural process using chemical and physical laws we understand. Why, suddenly, are proteins, which are compiled in the exact same way as amino acids, made by God?

I'm at least that far behind on my molecular biology, now that you mention it.

How far do we get? I'm pretty darned certain we don't have any model for the formation of a cell, unless you start from on or two other cells.

There are hypotheses for various mechanisms for cell formation. Sure, they may not be theories yet, but it's more then "goddidit". For interest's sake, one of them I read about recently involves something as a surface, like the surface of small air pockets in ice. Another I can remember include a virus like particle getting a phosolipid layer, which then turned into a cell. It's all very interesting. But demanding direct evidence is silly, since we don't exactly have millions of years to sit around and observe it, do we?

I'm pretty darned certain we don't have any experimental evidence of DNA being created.

Again, if you are willing to sit for millions of years to observe this, be my guest. Myself, I'm happy to have my 'just so' story. What makes you think that RNA (which would have been the first nucleic acid, not DNA) could not form by natural processes? Because we've not observed it? Need I point out black holes to you again?

I'm not sure about protein, and I'm absolutely certain about bacterial flagella. I know we can make amino acids from nothing but basic components in the lab. What else can we do?

We don't need to, to understand or have hypotheses for their formation. (And yes, we can make proteins from smaller molecules in the lab. I've done it, Mead.) Science has hypotheses for all of this. What does ID have? "Goddidit"? How is that an answer? It neither predicts nor explains, both of which need to be done for something to be scientific.
 
Meadmaker said:
Hear, oh world. Paul and I agree that evolution is random, with constraints.
Although we may not agree on what that actually means.

What I'm bent on is the participants understanding what the ID argument really is. ID supporters do use the word "random" to describe evolution. So do evolutionists. Neither is erecting a straw man.
The ID elite do not use the term random, but instead say by chance. They have at least two definitions for that latter term, making many of their arguments incoherent. Any ID supporters who use the word "random" are probably confused. I would recommend against it.

~~ Paul
 
But demanding direct evidence is silly, since we don't exactly have millions of years to sit around and observe it, do we?

If their hypothesis is correct, you'll have direct evidence in less than 100 years, unless you are very, very, lucky.

We don't need to, to understand or have hypotheses for their formation. (And yes, we can make proteins from smaller molecules in the lab. I've done it, Mead.)

So what can we do? You know what I'm getting at. How much do we know about abiogenesis? In 1980, I read about the "primordial sandwich (open face)" model for abiogenesis. It sounded briefly like the first thing you presented. Has there been any significant advance in understanding the problem since then?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom