Can a CharlieHebdo-type attack happen in the US?

Don't you realize that small groups of zealots change the course of history? That they can sometimes set the tone for how millions or billions of people will live their lives for centuries to come?

The great advantage Islamic civilization has right now is belief in itself. It has people who are prepared to risk everything and do anything to see their vision for what the world should be like come to fruition.

You should really be grateful any time you find out or are reminded that you may still have a few such people on your side, whether you want to acknowledge having a side or not, who are just as passionate about preventing that vision from coming to pass.

You would not like for that vision to come true.

But I don't care for Christianity either. Are you suggesting I start attacking Baptists?

I don't think that works. If you kill all the people whose views differ from yours, what's to prevent someone from changing their previously approved views?
 
These sentiments of "why needlessly offend?" are the precursors of an electorate willingly passing religious offense laws infringing on the First Amendment.

Western civilization has lost almost all of its masculinity. Islam retains 100% of theirs.

Wrong. Under no circumstances can that collection of letters and punctuation ever be construed approaching accuracy.

F- for trolling.
 
These sentiments of "why needlessly offend?" are the precursors of an electorate willingly passing religious offense laws infringing on the First Amendment.

Western civilization has lost almost all of its masculinity. Islam retains 100% of theirs.

What has that to do with race?
 
Is there some suppressed urge to draw Mohammed cartoons among the general population I am unaware of? Is it the case that posters here are cowering in fear, lest Muslims discover they have made doodles on a napkin?

This very forum is chock-full of criticisms of Islam. If that doesn't make us afraid because of the violent Muslim Jihadis, I am left to wonder at the hypocrisy. Surely we feel extremely comfortable expressing our views, despite all the supposed fear of the Islamist boogy man.
 
But I don't care for Christianity either. Are you suggesting I start attacking Baptists?

I don't think that works. If you kill all the people whose views differ from yours, what's to prevent someone from changing their previously approved views?

Asserting our right to free speech and our right to offensive speech is not an "attack" on Islam it is a defensive act of flexing rights which were in danger of atrophy to assert for any who doubted or forgot that those rights are still there to be used, and still have people who don't intend to see them go away.

Nobody said anything about killing all those who disagree with views, either.

A world of difference between that and saying "you know what? you already have a huge portion of the globe, we think we'll keep this area over here to ourselves, thanks."

A multiculturalist would run into a paint store and mix all the paints into one big brown vat and then joyously proclaim "diversity!"

Diversity dies without borders and spheres of influence. In order to limit Islam's sphere of influence, there must be areas willing to say "no Islam here, or very little."
 
One of the suspects in the shooting in Garland, Texas, late Sunday has been identified as Elton Simpson, an Arizona man who was previously the subject of a terror investigation, according to a senior FBI official...

Officials believe Simpson is the person who sent out several Twitter messages prior to the attack on Sunday, in the last one using the hashtag #TexasAttack about half an hour before the shooting...

Simpson was well known to the FBI. Five years ago he was convicted for lying to federal agents about his plans to travel to Africa, but a judge ruled the government did not adequately prove he was going to join a terror group there. https://gma.yahoo.com/official-one-texas-shooting-suspects-ided-111112719--abc-news-topstories.html

Not looking too Lutheran.
 
To make things even more complicated, the group sponsoring it,the American Freedom Defense Initiative, has been called a hate group by the SPLC. Not surprising, I guess, given the guest list.

That's at least according to both NPR and CNN. A search on the SPLC site shows that they are called anti-muslim, but I didn't see the actual phrase "hate group". Maybe I'm splittling hairs, though.

And yet once again it wasn't one of the $PLC's "hate groups" attacking civilians with rifles and bombs.
 
How is the right to critique religion involved?

Did you mean some fictitious right to critique religion without consequences?.

Yeah!

You know who I blame for all the heretics getting burnt in medaeval Europe? The heretics!

Everyone from sir Thomas moore, galileo, on down should have just shut the hell up.
 
Okay, so if you don't want to get shot at by loonies, don't draw pictures of Mahomet then if you don't want to get raped, don't get drunk, give out lapdances, take your top off and pass out in a house full of strangers?
 
And yet once again it wasn't one of the $PLC's "hate groups" attacking civilians with rifles and bombs.

Quite right. The SPLC has been exposed as a greedy, fraudulent organization and was recently disavowed by the FBI, I believe it was, or at least they indicated they would no longer be utilizing the SPLC's list.

All you have to tell most people these days is that you're "anti-racist and pro diversity" and their brains will shut off completely. From that point on you can essentially do no wrong in their eyes.

Oh and ain't diversity grand? This event is another which we owe to diversity. Couldn't have happened without trying to get people of distinct groups to live within one nation.

It isn't very dangerous to offend Muslims when they're all in Muslim nations.

Okay, so if you don't want to get shot at by loonies, don't draw pictures of Mahomet then if you don't want to get raped, don't get drunk, give out lapdances, take your top off and pass out in a house full of strangers?

Another good strategy for avoiding rape is to not be a 13 year old native English white girl in Rotheram or the many other cities where Pakistani Muslim grooming gangs raped them left and right while multiculturalists obligingly turned the other way and pretended not to see it.
 
Last edited:
And yet once again it wasn't one of the $PLC's "hate groups" attacking civilians with rifles and bombs.

To quote Otto von Bismark, "better pointed words than pointed bullets".

Sad when Bismark has a better idea of civil society than the SPLC.
 
Oh and ain't diversity grand? This event is another which we owe to diversity. Couldn't have happened without trying to get people of distinct groups to live within one nation.


Have you considered that maybe you're doing diversity wrong? Other places have the diversity you seem to be disparaging and yet don't have the kinds of incidents and problems to which you refer.
 
Listen, I know all about the "Free Speech" touted as the reason we should be able to draw pictures of whoever we want, but lets be frank here. This was about being an a-hole.

Is there any way we can prevent incidents like this by simply not being an a-hole?

Yes, it was about being an a-hole. And they most certainly are a-holes. But free speech is for a-holes too and not just for those nice people whose opinions we don't disagree with.

The ONLY reason for an event like this is to provoke the very reaction they got. Now they get to say "See- gotcha! Muslims = baaaad"

I'm sorry. I can't for the life of me feel one iota of sympathy for any of those people at that event.

There should not really be any law protecting people's rights based on whether or not we have "sympathy" for them. In fact, whenever you find your morals being based on "sympathy" you should probably re-evaluate them as they are probably not actual principles.

I said nothing about law. I'm simply asking why we have to be jerks. We don't. This was 100% preventable, simply by not being a jerk. Feeding the trolls so to speak.

Nope. We don't have to be jerks. But if someone behaves like a jerk we should still draw the line at people strapping AK-47s to themselves and blowing away the jerks.

Rational people weren't in attendance at that event.

Protection is not only for rational people, but also for douchebag, unsympathetic a-hole jerks too. It is only when unsympathetic, douchebag, a-hole jerks also have protection that we know the law is right.
 
A modern guilt strategy for current events:
Step 1: Identify the party with the most privilege.
Step 2: Place blame on that party.
 
Yeah!

You know who I blame for all the heretics getting burnt in medaeval Europe? The heretics!

Everyone from sir Thomas moore, galileo, on down should have just shut the hell up.

Jeepers, you were born centuries too late. They could have used the advice.

But there's still hope. You can advise Egyptians not to import or make pornography, and tip off the Iranians not to diss Mohammed in public. Or, if you are in the US, let people know that it's unwise to taunt a Crip while wearing the colors of the Bloods.

There are lives to be saved!
 
Have any of those who are asserting that this gathering was a bunch of irrational idiots actually taken the time to listen to the speech by Geert Wilders at said event? Or put any effort into assessing, rather than just assuming, whether they are like that or not?
 
This was a suicide attack, technically. Texas police is probably better armed than most national armies. It's certainly more willing to shoot to kill than most armies.

McHrozni
Armies not trained to shoot to kill are generally trying to force more of the opposition's personnel into hospitals and food prep for the wounded - as well as transport for them. It is a good idea IF those on the other side are not trained to always shoot to kill and how to still fight though injured and to continue fighting rather than losing time to help the wounded who are damaged too badly to fight...
 
Have any of those who are asserting that this gathering was a bunch of irrational idiots actually taken the time to listen to the speech by Geert Wilders at said event? Or put any effort into assessing, rather than just assuming, whether they are like that or not?

I looked over their website. Do I get partial credit?

I also read the SPLC's entry on Pamela Geller.
 
Last edited:
This is the second time you've mentioned your avatar to me but it isn't clear to me what you're getting at.

I can tell it's a child. Care to make your point more clear?

Congratulations on the child regardless.

ETA: the picture isn't great quality and I'm on a very small screen. I'm assuming she(? Looks like a young girl from what I can tell) is a multiracial child? Is that your meaning?
I think you are correct. Possibly the problem is the bird she is letting sit on her hand instead of roasting it for dinner... It does not help that the picture seems to be on it's side.....
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom