Black Swan Event Under Way

I put all my retirement funds into cash in March and avoided a lot of losses. I’ve now moved it back into a “balanced“ fund which is a mixture of shares, bonds, property and cash. Riskier than cash, but I think it will return 3-5% over the next couple of years, where cash, after fees, will have a negative return.

As I’ve said many times, my wife and I can get by well enough on the Aged Pension (about $A35k per year) and only need our retirement savings to add $A25-30k a year to live very comfortably. This looks doable as the world economy recovers. If not, the equity on our house is always there.
 
It's been interesting to see the way stock indexes have recovered. Even travel/entertainments sectors are showing signs of life though they have a long ways to go. Much stronger at this point than I expected.

I suspect much of this is a build up of cash from two sources. People not spending as much and the multi trillion injections by the Fed.

One of the things I monitor is consumer credit and Equifax, a consumer credit reporting company, has an interesting blog post:

https://insight.equifax.com/let-the-data-tell-the-story/?intcmp=blog_QA_DA_blog

But despite the economic downturn, between the CARES Act and accommodations from creditors, we discovered 30+ day delinquency rates steadily declined in April. Additionally, bankcard utilization declined over 8% in the last two months versus a 16% increase in 2010.

When I see numbers like this, I find myself asking more questions. I want to study the data and understand how people are reacting.

Basically, while some are getting hit hard, overall people are seeing increased savings and lower debt.

How this shakes out over then next year or so should be interesting. Tax revenue v spending will be skewed more strongly. Its impact is lessoned by very low interest rates which will have to be maintained at a very low level as the debt has grown exponentially. This may not be the problem it seems since pretty much all countries are in the same boat. Rates could be low for quite a while but it is increasingly vulnerable and will require larger Fed actions to control. Similar issues are faced by other country's central banks.
 
I can't help but feel there's some irrational exuberance going on here. The economy is in pretty bad shape, it seems to me. I see increased cost for products, and decreased demand, for some time to come.



I didn't let go of my stocks, but I did put in a lot of "stop" orders at about 10%-20% below current prices.

I was very pleased that the Planet Fitness stock I bought during the lockdown rose 30% since I bought it. If it drops 10% from its current, I'm dumping it. It just seems like revenues will end up being way, way, down for a very long time. The potential down side is bigger than the potential up side, it seems to me. I have a few stocks like that, and they all just got stop orders.

I am surprised by the way it has recovered, but I didn't expect it to crash much worse than it did. On this thread I predicted 18,000 dow, and I think it got to 19,000 before it recovered.

I expected it to go a little bit lower before an anemic recovery. I guess that's why I program computers for a living, instead of trading stocks.

I haven't looked into it, but I know that at one point the FAANGs stocks were driving the indices. (Facebook, Apple, Amazon, Netflix, Google.) I suppose all of those have probably done well. I haven't looked. One thing that has happened in this plague driven market is that the big got bigger. It was waitresses and the remainder of the independent retailers that got totally screwed by the virus. That wouldn't drive the stock market down very much.
 
Last edited:
I suspect much of this is a build up of cash from two sources. People not spending as much and the multi trillion injections by the Fed.

Yep - pretty easy to see where the stimulus is going.

I haven't looked at all, so if you know how much QE (4? 5?) the Fed's done since 31 March, let me know. I bet it's plenty.

Quite amazing to have a Ponzi scheme printing its own money.

I can't help but feel there's some irrational exuberance going on here. The economy is in pretty bad shape, it seems to me. I see increased cost for products, and decreased demand, for some time to come.

Yes to all that.

I haven't looked into it, but I know that at one point the FAANGs stocks were driving the indices. (Facebook, Apple, Amazon, Netflix, Google.) I suppose all of those have probably done well. I haven't looked.

I have. Amazon & Netflix have made money, while Apple has lost a lot of sales and production. They may recover, but they may not, too.

Farcebook and Google have been savaged by reduced advertising, but their share prices have never been driven by profits, unlike Apple, which is.

One thing that has happened in this plague driven market is that the big got bigger. It was waitresses and the remainder of the independent retailers that got totally screwed by the virus. That wouldn't drive the stock market down very much.

No, but the effect of those people not earning and not paying taxes will be huge. There are also a lot of high-profile jobs lost: airline crew, tourist operators, travel agencies, the cruise industry, professional services (recruiting, management consulting) etc.
 
Still not seeing a true Black Swan event here, as I said long ago.

https://theconversation.com/coronavirus-is-significant-but-is-it-a-true-black-swan-event-136675

The subtitle of Taleb’s book is “The impact of the highly improbable.” But an event like COVID-19 is not all that rare. Indeed, history is replete with such events, there have been numerous warnings from many sources, and the mathematical odds of an occurrence are not all that remote. With pandemics, it is not really a question of if, but usually when.

Indeed, Taleb recently weighed in on the question of whether COVID-19 is or isn’t a black swan.

Spoiler alert: it isn’t.

Yes, a large market correction. Higher unemployment, but not so bad (8% predicted in Australia down from 10%).

Just like The Atheist’s predictions about the world death toll, this prediction also looks highly exaggerated.

Thankfully.
 
My post on 29 February:

Can I just add that, regardless of how many people use the term, this is not a “Black Swan Event” at all? Not only have we been here before many times, but governments know how to respond.

Hmmmm.
 
I can't help but feel there's some irrational exuberance going on here.

Here's why: It's all retail buyers.

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/arti...cks-is-fervid-retail-buying?srnd=premium-asia

Still not seeing a true Black Swan event here, as I said long ago.

Worldwide recession, negative 8-10% for the June quarter - sure as hell looks like one to me.

Just like The Atheist’s predictions about the world death toll, this prediction also looks highly exaggerated.

Thankfully.

You're making the same mistake as many others - thinking the worst is behind us, when in reality, we're less than 10% of the way through.

My post on 29 February:

Not only have we been here before many times, but governments know how to respond.

Hmmmm.

If it weren't for half a million corpses and millions of lives devastated, I'd find that hilarious. Yeah, governments know what to do...

Print money frantically. I'm sure I've heard of that somewhere in the past.

Check back again in six months and we'll compare notes.

I hope you're right, but I don't live on hope. I deal with facts & evidence.
 
Here's why: It's all retail buyers.

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/arti...cks-is-fervid-retail-buying?srnd=premium-asia



Worldwide recession, negative 8-10% for the June quarter - sure as hell looks like one to me.



You're making the same mistake as many others - thinking the worst is behind us, when in reality, we're less than 10% of the way through.



If it weren't for half a million corpses and millions of lives devastated, I'd find that hilarious. Yeah, governments know what to do...

Print money frantically. I'm sure I've heard of that somewhere in the past.

Check back again in six months and we'll compare notes.

I hope you're right, but I don't live on hope. I deal with facts & evidence.

See, I didn’t come up with the Black Swan Theory, Taleb did.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_swan_theory

Have you read him? Perhaps you should.

The link I posted (here it is again https://theconversation.com/coronavirus-is-significant-but-is-it-a-true-black-swan-event-136675) makes it clear that Covid-19 is not a Black Swan Event and Taleb agrees. I’ll take their facts and evidence over yours every day of the week.
 
The link I posted (here it is again https://theconversation.com/coronavirus-is-significant-but-is-it-a-true-black-swan-event-136675) makes it clear that Covid-19 is not a Black Swan Event and Taleb agrees. I’ll take their facts and evidence over yours every day of the week.

That's hilarious - they do not make it clear it's not a Black Swan.

I quote their three requirements:

Attribute one: Is the COVID pandemic an outlier?

They claim it isn't, because we've had other pandemics.

I say it is, and the proof is in the pudding - no other pandemic has caused the type of worldwide shutdown we're seeing with Covid. It is unquestionably an outlier.

Attribute two: Does COVID-19 carry an extreme impact?

They agree with me that it has.

Attribute three: Is it, or will it be, normalized after the fact?

They say "don't know"

Looks to me fairly non-committal, also pointing at your pal's "analysis".

So, you're taking the word of one bloke, because he agrees with you, when he was asked about it on about 20 April, which is a fair while and 250,000 deaths ago.

Even better, I wonder whether you actually read your own links, because Taleb doesn't give a single piece of evidence that it's not a Black Swan and says he's irritated by the description and goes on to pntificate on his pet subject.

But feel free to continue to screech into the wind, against the statements of the world's central banks and economists, all of whom have recognised a recession deeper than anything in the past 100 years.

If once a century doesn't qualify as a Black swan event, please do share what you think one would look like.
 
Have you read him? Perhaps you should.

The link I posted (here it is again https://theconversation.com/coronavirus-is-significant-but-is-it-a-true-black-swan-event-136675)
The theory was developed by Nassim Nicholas Taleb to explain:

1. The disproportionate role of high-profile, hard-to-predict, and rare events that are beyond the realm of normal expectations in history, science, finance, and technology.

2. The non-computability of the probability of the consequential rare events using scientific methods (owing to the very nature of small probabilities).

3. The psychological biases that blind people, both individually and collectively, to uncertainty and to a rare event's massive role in historical affairs.

I think we can all agree that Covid-19 is a rare event which has had a disproportionate role (compared to the numerous other recent virus outbreaks that had little impact). The last time we had something this big was the Spanish flu in 1918, so it is by far the most significant event of its type in our lifetimes.

If someone told you last December that this year an event would occur that closed down most businesses World wide, forced everyone to stay home and prevented international trade and tourism for months, that crashed the oil price to below zero, and has so far killed more people in the US than all wars combined since WWII (and almost as many as WWI), and caused states to defy the federal government and have to call out their own troops to protect essential supplies - would you have believed them?

One could say that an event of this type is predictable using scientific methods, but predicting the scale isn't. Previous epidemics were much less of a problem, which is why most countries were not prepared for the severity of this one. If this isn't an example of the 'non-computability owing to the very nature of small probabilities' then I don't know what is. A massive earthquake, or a large asteroid hitting the Earth? But they too are 'predictable'.

Then we come to the "psychological biases that blind people to a rare event's massive role in historical affairs". This event isn't anywhere near over, yet we have already seen plenty of blindness - ironically it seems even from the guy who developed the theory!

Perhaps living in Australia you are not aware of the true impact this event is having. It is certainly to soon to call it while death tolls are still rising and the long-term economic impact is yet to hit us. I bet that when it is all over the World's economic and political landscape will be rather different from what we were expecting.
 
That's hilarious - they do not make it clear it's not a Black Swan.

I quote their three requirements:

Attribute one: Is the COVID pandemic an outlier?

They claim it isn't, because we've had other pandemics.

I say it is, and the proof is in the pudding - no other pandemic has caused the type of worldwide shutdown we're seeing with Covid. It is unquestionably an outlier.

Attribute two: Does COVID-19 carry an extreme impact?

They agree with me that it has.

Attribute three: Is it, or will it be, normalized after the fact?

They say "don't know"

Looks to me fairly non-committal, also pointing at your pal's "analysis".

So, you're taking the word of one bloke, because he agrees with you, when he was asked about it on about 20 April, which is a fair while and 250,000 deaths ago.

Even better, I wonder whether you actually read your own links, because Taleb doesn't give a single piece of evidence that it's not a Black Swan and says he's irritated by the description and goes on to pntificate on his pet subject.

But feel free to continue to screech into the wind, against the statements of the world's central banks and economists, all of whom have recognised a recession deeper than anything in the past 100 years.

If once a century doesn't qualify as a Black swan event, please do share what you think one would look like.

The GFC. Nobody predicted that. Many people, notably Bill Gates, predicted this one. Bloody hell, even Hollywood. Did you watch “Contagion”?

Of course this event is serious and is not over. It’s just not a Black Swan, despite your screeching “but it is because I called it”.
 
Here's why: It's all retail buyers.

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/arti...cks-is-fervid-retail-buying?srnd=premium-asia



Worldwide recession, negative 8-10% for the June quarter - sure as hell looks like one to me.



You're making the same mistake as many others - thinking the worst is behind us, when in reality, we're less than 10% of the way through.



If it weren't for half a million corpses and millions of lives devastated, I'd find that hilarious. Yeah, governments know what to do...

Print money frantically. I'm sure I've heard of that somewhere in the past.

Check back again in six months and we'll compare notes.

I hope you're right, but I don't live on hope. I deal with facts & evidence.

I was going to let this one go.

But yes. Governments printed money. It works. It’s what got the world, belatedly, out of the Great Depression, it’s how the world coped with then recovered from the GFC.

What would your response be? Maintaining a balanced budget or aiming for a surplus?

Thank goodness you are nowhere near managing national economies.
 
The GFC. Nobody predicted that.

Utter nonsense, again.

Many people, notably Bill Gates, predicted this one.

I'm not sure whether you're being deliberately obtuse, or just have no idea what you're talking about. Pandemics happen all the time and Gates was one of many voices predicting another.

Nobody predicted one that would cause the destruction this one has.

As noted, the last pandemic of this scale was 100 years ago. You're talking about the Blue Mountains against Everest.

Bloody hell, even Hollywood. Did you watch “Contagion”?

Srsly?

It's not anywhere near the fist pandemic movie or story. Heck, there was a Pommy program on TV so long ago I was a teenager - Survivor.

That's like saying that if a UFO landed in Hyde Park it wouldn't be an unusual event because HG Wells wrote about a century ago.

Of course this event is serious and is not over. It’s just not a Black Swan, despite your screeching “but it is because I called it”.

Holy crap, you're just copying my words now.

It's not just me, mate.

Try Jerome Powell, talking about the US economy shrinking by 20-30%: https://kslnewsradio.com/1925424/the-recovery-from-coronavirus-could-take-years/

Or even Nasdaq itself:

You know what happened next. COVID-19 went from a minor news story to a full-blow black swan event.

Business Insider?

And if you look up the thread a little, I've quoted several major traders who have also identified it as a Black Swan.

I can give you as many expert opinions as you like.

Against your one bloke, who doesn't offer any evidence. But I guess he's probably smarter than the Chairman of the Federal Reserve...

I was going to let this one go.

Oh, I'm glad you didn't - you know me, the more bulldust you post, the more I'll dump on it.

But yes. Governments printed money. It works. It’s what got the world, belatedly, out of the Great Depression, it’s how the world coped with then recovered from the GFC.

As a short-term strategy, it can help, but the Fed has now been "easing" for 12 years and they have an awful lot of it to do yet.

US borrowing is currently sitting at 107% of GDP and is set to rise to 125% in the next 12 months: https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/government-debt-to-gdp

During the Great Depression, borrowing never exceeded 50% of GDp, and the only other time it exceeded 100% was during WWII.

It peaked at 112.7% during that period.

This will be the biggest deficit in 220 years of the US republic.

But it's not a Black Swan...

It's already at

What would your response be? Maintaining a balanced budget or aiming for a surplus?

What on earth does that have to do with the subject? You're arguing this isn't a Black Swan event, not asking whether I'd have done a better job.

(the answer to that is yes, though - see below)

Thank goodness you are nowhere near managing national economies.

I'll just point you gently towards the start of thread, where you can once again enjoy the fact that I was on top of this before anyone, and put my money where my mouth is.

I think my record on this situation speaks for itself.

Love forums - it's all there in black & white & grey.
 
There’s just so much wrong here, but 6 economists in the world (sort of) predicted the GFC? Close enough to zero.

The last large-scale pandemic the Spanish Flu? One hit in the 1980s, infected 75m and killed 39m, 37m still living with it and 770,000 deaths in 2017. Stacks up against this one I would have thought.

One thing you got right is that many did predict more pandemics and with great confidence. Which was my point. There was nothing greatly surprising about Covid-19, which alone makes this not a Black Swan.

And I see you have backed away from your “printing money” nonsense. Baby steps.
 
There’s just so much wrong here, but 6 economists in the world (sort of) predicted the GFC? Close enough to zero.

I gave you six, which doesn't mean there were only six - you're verging on being dishonest now. JP Morgan's hedge fund was limit short on the day of Lehman's collapse, which is quite ironic.

The last large-scale pandemic the Spanish Flu? One hit in the 1980s, infected 75m and killed 39m, 37m still living with it and 770,000 deaths in 2017. Stacks up against this one I would have thought.

Holy crap, now you're really clutching at straws.

Aside from the fact that HIV isn't classed as a pandemic, trying to compare a disease which is 100% avoidable with one that's highly contagious is just absurd.

I'm not even going to mention that even in the worst-case scenario, a million people a year died of AIDs, while Covid's knocked over half that in two months.

But nice try at comparing a 40-year-old STD with a disease that's existed for six months.

One thing you got right is that many did predict more pandemics and with great confidence. Which was my point. There was nothing greatly surprising about Covid-19, which alone makes this not a Black Swan.

Showing that you actually have no idea what the term means.

It's about the impact and the likelihood. I showed you how rare the current situation is, but you've ignored that because you know you're wrong.

Either that or you know more than the Chairman of the US Federal Reserve, and I seriously doubt that.

And I see you have backed away from your “printing money” nonsense. Baby steps.

Sorry mate, you'll need to hold onto those booties - I did not back away from it at all - I said it's a useful short-term mechanism. Jesus, I even gave you the numbers of why it's a bad idea, but maybe you think borrowing at levels higher than WWII is a good plan. You know little enough about economics that it wouldn't surprise me a bit if you did.
 
I gave you six, which doesn't mean there were only six - you're verging on being dishonest now. JP Morgan's hedge fund was limit short on the day of Lehman's collapse, which is quite ironic.



Holy crap, now you're really clutching at straws.

Aside from the fact that HIV isn't classed as a pandemic, trying to compare a disease which is 100% avoidable with one that's highly contagious is just absurd.

I'm not even going to mention that even in the worst-case scenario, a million people a year died of AIDs, while Covid's knocked over half that in two months.

But nice try at comparing a 40-year-old STD with a disease that's existed for six months.



Showing that you actually have no idea what the term means.

It's about the impact and the likelihood. I showed you how rare the current situation is, but you've ignored that because you know you're wrong.

Either that or you know more than the Chairman of the US Federal Reserve, and I seriously doubt that.



Sorry mate, you'll need to hold onto those booties - I did not back away from it at all - I said it's a useful short-term mechanism. Jesus, I even gave you the numbers of why it's a bad idea, but maybe you think borrowing at levels higher than WWII is a good plan. You know little enough about economics that it wouldn't surprise me a bit if you did.

Yeah, funny. What is a pandemic other than a global epidemic? It wouldn't surprise me if you declared AIDS not to be a global epidemic though. You are re-defining things all over this thread, most particularly "Black Swan", so coming up with your own definitions is no surprise.

Nonetheless, you described the Spanish Flu as the last great pandemic. It wasn't.
 
This month's update.

Date|% */-
5.18|1.3
8.18|3.4
11.18|-3.1
2.19|-0.8
5.19|1.9
8.19|7.4
11.19|6.6
2.20|10.3
3.20|3.7
4.20|-4.9
5.20|0.3
6.20|5.8

That's an increase of £633 in the value.

I have £15000 in premium bonds, and when one comes up I often treat myself to something with the prize money. I don't do that when the ISA jumps up like that, because I know it might go down again next month and I'd have to take my present back. :D
 
Yeah, funny. What is a pandemic other than a global epidemic?

Nice to see you're not trying to revisit the destruction of your sillier points and have move on the just nit-picking.

The WHO doesn't class HIV as a pandemic. And even if it did, the point of comparison, as noted, is absurd.

I will never get HIV - it is 100% avoidable. There were a few early cases of transmission by blood transfusion, which is unlucky, but outside of the very rare extreme stiff-up by medics, or rape, HIV is not a consideration for anyone.

Covid, you can catch by going to the shops, or hugging a grandchild.

Nonetheless, you described the Spanish Flu as the last great pandemic. It wasn't.

Yeah, just go straight for the dishonesty. This is what I actually typed:

Pandemics happen all the time and Gates was one of many voices predicting another.

Nobody predicted one that would cause the destruction this one has.

As noted, the last pandemic of this scale was 100 years ago. You're talking about the Blue Mountains against Everest.

The best thing about this very one-sided argument is that time will prove one of us utterly correct.

Let's check back in six months, and if the world's economy is smelling of roses, I will change my sig to state that I was completely wrong and should have listened to the amazing lionking and his superior analysis of the event from an economic perspective.

If I'm right, you can just slink off and ignore the thread, like you had been until the Fed's money got tipped into sharemarkets on the back of no fundamentals at all.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom