Black Swan Event Under Way

I've been trying to figure out what it is exactly that the world has spent $20T on so far. Europe shows a 7.5% contraction for the March quarter, and it will be a lot worse for Q2. USA has spent up to $5T.

And for what?

None of the major countries have done more than slow the spread, so the number of deaths will be pretty much the same as they would have been from the start.

Did we just create the worst recession in 90 years for the sake of it?

I did hear that if we did nothing then about 60% of the population would have it at the same time. Even if the actual number is a bit lower it would still mean the country would be barely functional for a few weeks. By this I mean supermarkets not having enough staff to take your money and put new goods on the shelf. If you call emergency services you are told they will come tomorrow. Worse, you will not be able to get into hospital. And for sometime before or after that they will be turning away certain people because they have no room.

But then I wonder what is the difference between nearly everyone having four weeks or so off sick and the current situation?

Maybe the point of it is that it showed what Australia and New Zealand needed to do to avoid what was happening in these places. I think in these countries most people will not get the virus.
 
I did hear that if we did nothing then about 60% of the population would have it at the same time. Even if the actual number is a bit lower it would still mean the country would be barely functional for a few weeks.

Yeah, I said all that way back at the start of the pandemic. The big difference since then is we now know a hell of a lot of cases are so mild you either don't notice, or have a sore throat that wouldn't keep you at home.

There's no doubt hospitals would be crushed for a time, but is that more or less preferable to having a year-long high?

(That is a rhetorical question - I sure as hell don't know)

But then I wonder what is the difference between nearly everyone having four weeks or so off sick and the current situation?

Economically, we'd have been vastly better to have done nothing and let it run. I said what seems like years ago that a pragmatic approach of letting the virus run would save hundreds of billions, because most of the people dying are those who take up 80% of healthcare time and budgets and are mainly in receipt of pensions. As it turns out, those savings would be in addition to the ~$20T the virus has cost the global economy already.

In NZ, the expected death toll from an unchecked virus is 18,000 people. Of that, if we subtract the aged & infirm, we'd probably have fewer deaths among the healthy than the roads claim every year.

Maybe the point of it is that it showed what Australia and New Zealand needed to do to avoid what was happening in these places. I think in these countries most people will not get the virus.

Yeah, I agree - we seem to have squashed it, but our economy is going to suffer for decades as a result.

I think if you can squash the disease, it's money well spent, but I am certain USA will have spent $5T for nothing, because they're going to see no difference in the final numbers.
 
We've done wonders for the environment from lockdown at least.

I didn't "prescribe" that.

As for the economy, it was a typical rollercoaster over a short year due to fear and panic.

We are animals, tribesmen afraid of hidden dangers in the bushes.

We fight to be top dog, too.

Instinct.

Calm and/or logical investors hold on for the ride and eventual rise (in sustainable things) and contrarily buy artificially low things.
 
Hey, I'm going to call plagiarism!

The biggest names in finance are coming around to a view that seemed unlikely a few weeks ago: Stocks are vastly overvalued.

It’s a notion catching on among Wall Street money managers. And it’s coming as investors start to suspect that the Federal Reserve’s support, as well as $3 trillion in Treasury stimulus, may not be enough to compensate for soaring unemployment, a wave of bankruptcies and no end in sight to the pandemic.

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/arti...ng-alarm-about-stock-prices?srnd=premium-asia

I rest my case.
 
Calm and/or logical investors hold on for the ride and eventual rise (in sustainable things) and contrarily buy artificially low things.


To be fair, typical investors also hold on to things, including stocks, long after they ought to realize that they are overvalued.

Eugene Fama got the economics Nobel prize for research quantifying that tendency.

A truly rational and well informed investor would recognize when economic or business conditions have changed, resulting in a company's real value changing, and they would sell shares until the price dropped to the new, more realistic, value that reflected current economic conditions. However, that doesn't happen. People tend to overvalue things that they already own. When applied to stocks, that means people tend to stick with a stock that they already own, even when it ought to be apparent that the true value of the company has dropped, which ought to make the stock price drop.

The result is that when something bad happens to a company, or in the current case to a whole lot of companies simultaneously, there tends to be a delay between the bad thing happening and the drop in stock price that the bad thing causes.

ETA: That still doesn't mean that I know whether current stock prices are overvalued. For companies that do not go bankrupt, many will recover, so their current really bad year shouldn't mean that their stock prices ought to reflect this year's awful performance.
 
Last edited:
To be fair, typical investors also hold on to things, including stocks, long after they ought to realize that they are overvalued.

Exactly the same as a gambler who bets right down to the last fifty cents.

I used to have a regular punter at the races who arrived every time in a neat suit & tie, and bet $20-50 a race, always in crisp $50 notes.

By the end of the day, he'd come up for the last race and have every last cent in bets. He'd scrape his pockets for 20 cent coins to get to the last dollar.

Long time ago, when $50 was worth $50.

A truly rational and well informed investor would recognize when economic or business conditions have changed, resulting in a company's real value changing, and they would sell shares until the price dropped to the new, more realistic, value that reflected current economic conditions.

Correct!

Holy crap, someone finally got there.

Right now, that rational investor would be selling. The market's made a spectacular and totally illogical reverse from a massive drop. The time to sell is today. Even if it goes up another 10%, there's at least 25% down left in it at the current level.

ETA: That still doesn't mean that I know whether current stock prices are overvalued.

Well, I don't expect anyone to listen to me, but those boys on Bloomberg I quoted seemed pretty clear. They're seriously heavyweight investors and they can see that light at the end of the tunnel is actually an iron ore train.

Maybe you're a victim of thee exact syndrome you describe?

If you think logically - what's the worst than can happen if you sell? Price goes up how far? Given the massive recession that is already happening, how much upside do you think there is today? Couple of percent?

If you get out and it does go up, you might cost yourself a percent or two of future profit. Buy back in, no capital lost.

If you hold and it goes down 25% you've lost 25% of your capital that may take decades to get back.

Add up the risk & reward and get back to me.

For companies that do not go bankrupt, many will recover, so their current really bad year shouldn't mean that their stock prices ought to reflect this year's awful performance.

Like the Bloomberg article noted, placing your wealth (for very small returns) on a bet that the economy will recover is a very dodgy proposition. A global recession of massive proportions does not create a good climate for company profits anywhere.

And remember, it's only just started. It feels like we've been doing Covid forever, when the reality is, the number of confirmed cases so far is under 5 million, so even if we think the real total might be 50,000,000, that is all of 1% of the total number of cases we'll ultimately have.

And if you want to be really disturbed about all this, check out the global supply chain and see how it's doing.
 
Like the Bloomberg article noted, placing your wealth (for very small returns) on a bet that the economy will recover is a very dodgy proposition.

The economy will recover. It's a question of whether it will recover in one year, or ten. The effects on company value will, or at least ought to, depend on that answer.

This year is going to suck, for sure.
 
Here's a scenario that I think is actually fairly likely.

Eventually we give up, open up the economy, and a lot of people die. This will be good for stock prices. My heirs will then be fortunate if I don't sell all of my stock.
 
The economy will recover. It's a question of whether it will recover in one year, or ten.

I'd be towards ten than one.

Here's a scenario that I think is actually fairly likely.

Eventually we give up, open up the economy, and a lot of people die. This will be good for stock prices. My heirs will then be fortunate if I don't sell all of my stock.

A million deaths (or more) won't be good for share prices. Insurance companies will be wiped out, premiums will skyrocket and the knock-on effects will cost trillions. Health systems will be crushed and hundreds of thousands of people will die from not being able to access healthcare.

Looks good on paper, but completely wrong.
 
I'd be towards ten than one.



A million deaths (or more) won't be good for share prices. Insurance companies will be wiped out, premiums will skyrocket and the knock-on effects will cost trillions. Health systems will be crushed and hundreds of thousands of people will die from not being able to access healthcare.

Looks good on paper, but completely wrong.

But think of the Medicare savings.
 
One of the underexplored aspects of our economy that this situation is demonstrating is that a huge part of the economy can go away completely, and it wouldn't matter.

I miss restaurants. I want to book a vacation because I like travel. All that junk that I don't need in a whole lot of retail stores? Yeah, whatever. I would like it, and yet, somehow, I'm not really suffering for the lack of it. That's bad news for a lot of companies that manufacture all that stuff or that provide the non-essential services.

In my fantasy head, I'm imagining that what comes out of this is more vacation time and earlier retirement, as we decide that it just isn't worth it to work so much so that I can have marble countertops or a convenient flight to Machu Picchu.
 
One of the underexplored aspects of our economy that this situation is demonstrating is that a huge part of the economy can go away completely, and it wouldn't matter.

Yeah, a lot of people are finding that, I think.

Whether they go back to their dark ways or not, time will tell.

Would be? Or already have?

I got out of TVIX at $400. It's down to $180 now. I had some thoughts about getting back in for a few at $140 last week, but I'm quite happy to sit on the sidelines and watch now.

The shares I own are locked in pension funds and not easily sellable, or they'd be gone today.

Boomer Remover

I started using "Boomer Hoover" until it stopped being funny. A Hoover being a brand name that generically means vacuum cleaner in the British Commonwealth.
 
One of the underexplored aspects of our economy that this situation is demonstrating is that a huge part of the economy can go away completely, and it wouldn't matter.
Except it can't, because people need money to buy the stuff they actually need - and to do that they have to sell stuff nobody needs.

I miss restaurants. I want to book a vacation because I like travel. All that junk that I don't need in a whole lot of retail stores? Yeah, whatever. I would like it, and yet, somehow, I'm not really suffering for the lack of it. That's bad news for a lot of companies that manufacture all that stuff or that provide the non-essential services.
I am the same, and it started before Covid-19.

But for many others the withdrawal symptoms from not shopping were too much to bear, and they will compensate by overdosing. I expect the economy to bounce back until people are once again drowning in junk.

In my fantasy head, I'm imagining that what comes out of this is more vacation time and earlier retirement, as we decide that it just isn't worth it to work so much so that I can have marble countertops or a convenient flight to Machu Picchu.
It's a nice fantasy, but I'm afraid it will just be 'business as usual' with everybody going back to old habits. Maybe when the next wave hits...
 
Except it can't, because people need money to buy the stuff they actually need - and to do that they have to sell stuff nobody needs.

I am the same, and it started before Covid-19.

But for many others the withdrawal symptoms from not shopping were too much to bear, and they will compensate by overdosing. I expect the economy to bounce back until people are once again drowning in junk.

It's a nice fantasy, but I'm afraid it will just be 'business as usual' with everybody going back to old habits. Maybe when the next wave hits...

All true.
 
Here's a scenario that I think is actually fairly likely.

Eventually we give up, open up the economy, and a lot of people die. This will be good for stock prices. My heirs will then be fortunate if I don't sell all of my stock.

It's not entirely clear that ending lockdowns opens up the economy and gets things rolling again. Some of the economic slowdown is mandatory, but some is voluntary. People are still worried about getting infected, and changing their behavior because of those fears. That doesn't change just because lockdown ends.
 
It's not entirely clear that ending lockdowns opens up the economy and gets things rolling again. Some of the economic slowdown is mandatory, but some is voluntary. People are still worried about getting infected, and changing their behavior because of those fears. That doesn't change just because lockdown ends.
New Zealand is functionally covid free yet the restaurants are open and deserted.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom